Story time
The pond in the park, pages 1 and 2 of 11
Year 1 science · Biological sciences · AC9S1U01
1Story, then try it
What does a plant need to stay alive?
Every living thing has needs: things it must have to stay alive. Your teacher will read you a story about a pond, two pages at a time. After each part you try things out.
How this lesson works. Each screen starts with part of a story: two pages, or one on the last screen. Your teacher reads them aloud while you look at the pictures. Then you and your partner work the picture under the story: change things and see what happens. Then you talk about what you found.
On this screen
Story time
The pond in the park, pages 1 and 2 of 11
There are two bean plants in pots. You choose what each one gets: water every day or no water, and a place in the window or in a dark cupboard. Then press Next day and watch them for two weeks. Look at their leaves and stems.
The simulation loads here.
Try it
Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Find out what happens to a plant with no water.
Which plant could you stop watering? What happens after a few days?
Find out what happens to a plant with no light.
Where is it dark? What happens to a plant there after a week?
Make a fair test: change only one thing between the two plants, then grow them for a week.
What is different about the two plants now? Is it only one thing?
Talk about it. Which plant was healthiest? What did it have that the other plant didn’t?
Plants need light, air and water
A plant needs light, air and water. Its roots take in water from the ground, and air goes into its leaves through tiny holes. The leaves use light to make the plant’s food.
With no water, a plant wilts, and if it stays dry it can die. In the dark it grows long, thin and pale, and it gets weak. Your test was a fair test when only one thing was different between the two plants.
What we are learning
What plants and animals need to stay alive, how they find what they need where they live, and how people care for living things.
I can
Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 1, AC9S1U01: “identify the basic needs of plants and animals, including air, water, food or shelter, and describe how the places they live meet those needs”. The teacher notes at the end show which screen covers each part.
What does a plant need to make its own food?
A bean plant is watered every day but kept in a dark cupboard for two weeks. What happens?
2Story, then try it
What does an animal need to stay alive?
Animals have needs too. You are an animal, so you have them as well.
On this screen
Story time
The pond in the park, pages 3 and 4 of 11
Choose an animal, then choose a need. The picture shows how the animal gets it, and the words under it tell you.
The simulation loads here.
Try it
Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Find out how every animal gets water.
Which animals have you not looked at for water yet?
Find out how the fish gets air.
Can the fish leave the water? What does it breathe with?
Find all four needs for one animal.
Pick one animal. Which needs have you not looked at for it yet?
Talk about it. What do you and the dog both need? How do you each get it?
Animals need air, water, food and shelter
Animals need air, water and food, and most need a shelter. They get them in different ways. You and the dog breathe air through your noses and mouths, but the fish’s gills take air from the water. The frog soaks up water through its skin.
An animal can’t make its own food, so it eats plants, or other animals, or both.
Which of these does a dog need to stay alive?
How does a fish get the air it needs?
3Story, then try it
Where does each animal at the pond find what it needs?
The duck, the frog and the fish all live at the pond. Each one finds what it needs there, in its own spots.
On this screen
Story time
The pond in the park, pages 5 and 6 of 11
Choose an animal and a need. Then tap the place in the picture where the animal gets it. You can also choose the place from the list under the buttons.
The simulation loads here.
Try it
Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Find where the frog gets water, food and shelter.
Where is the ground damp? Where are the insects?
Find where the fish gets air, food and shelter.
Can the fish leave the water? What is under the water with it?
Find where the duck gets food and shelter.
What did the story say the duck eats? Where is its nest?
Talk about it. Which place in the pond do two animals both use? What does each one use it for?
Each animal finds what it needs here
All three animals need the pond’s water, and each finds the rest in its own spots. The duck eats seeds and water plants, and its nest is in a hollow in the old gum tree. The frog eats insects and shelters under the log, where the ground is damp. The fish eats tiny water animals and hides among the water plants.
The plants at the pond find what they need there too. They get water from the pond and the wet ground, and light from the sun.
Where could a frog find shelter at the pond?
Where is the duck’s nest in the story?
4Story, then try it
What happens when living things can’t find what they need?
Places change. In a long, dry summer a pond can get smaller and smaller.
On this screen
Story time
The pond in the park, pages 7 and 8 of 11
Press A week with no rain and watch the pond, the grass and the animals. Then press A week of rain.
The simulation loads here.
Try it
Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Let the weeks go by with no rain until the ducks fly away.
What happens to the pond each week with no rain?
When the pond is small, find the frog. Tap where it is.
Where is the ground still damp?
Make it rain until the ducks come back.
How full does the pond need to be?
Talk about it. Why did the ducks fly away? Why couldn’t the fish leave too?
When a place changes
When the pond was nearly dry, the ducks flew to a pond that still had water. The fish couldn’t leave, so they crowded into the water that was left. The frog stayed under the log, where the ground was still damp. When the rain came, the pond filled up, the grass grew again and the ducks came back.
A living thing that can’t find what it needs can move, or someone can help it, or it can die.
The pond is drying up. What do the ducks do?
Why did the frog stay under the log when the pond was small?
5Story, then try it
How do people care for plants and animals?
Pets and garden plants can’t always find what they need by themselves. People look after them.
On this screen
Story time
The pond in the park, pages 9 and 10 of 11
There are seven jobs in this backyard. Do each job by tapping it in the picture or pressing its button. Then choose the need each job meets.
The simulation loads here.
Try it
Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Do all seven jobs.
Which jobs have no tick yet?
Put each job in its group: water, food, shelter or light.
What does the animal or plant get when you do this job?
Find out why the hens go in their house at night.
Which job is for the hens at night?
Talk about it. What jobs do you do for a pet or a plant at home? Which need does each job meet?
People care for living things
People look after their pets and plants by giving them what they need: water, food, shelter and light. Farmers look after the plants and animals that we eat, and they grow sheep and cotton plants for fibre to make clothes.
First Nations Australians have cared for the living things on their Country/Place for a very long time. Some Peoples have tamed dingoes and given them food, water and shelter.
You fill a dog’s bowl with fresh water. Which need does that job meet?
How have some First Nations Peoples cared for the dingoes they tamed?
6Story, then try it
Can you make a place where an animal finds everything it needs?
This is the last page of the story. Then you use what the story explained for two animals that weren’t in it.
On this screen
Story time
The pond in the park, page 11 of 11
This box is a diorama: a small model of a place. Choose an animal, then add things to the box. The list next to the box shows which needs the animal can find there.
The simulation loads here.
Try it
Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Make a place where the blue-tongue lizard can find everything it needs.
Look at the list under the box. Which need has no tick?
Make a place where the possum can find everything it needs.
Where does a possum sleep in the day? What does it eat?
Make one place that works for both animals.
Which things do both animals use? Which does only one of them use?
Talk about it. What did the lizard need that the possum didn’t? Why?
The same needs, different things
The lizard and the possum both need air, water, food and shelter, but they find them in different things. The blue-tongue lizard shelters under a log or in leaf litter, and eats snails, beetles, flowers and berries. It also needs a sunny place, because its body warms up with heat from the sun. The possum sleeps in a nest box or a hollow in the day, and eats leaves, flowers and fruit.
A good place for an animal has everything that animal needs.
A box has a log, leaf litter and a dish of water. What else does a blue-tongue lizard need there?
What did every plant and animal in the story need?
Two pages. Page 1 is a plant test: two bean plants, one in the window and one in a dark cupboard, drawn on four days over ten. Page 2 plans a diorama: choose an animal, draw its place in a box and show where it finds air, water, food and shelter.
Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 1, Science understanding, Biological sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:
AC9S1U01 identify the basic needs of plants and animals, including air, water, food or shelter, and describe how the places they live meet those needs
- identifying the places where plants and animals live, including in our homes, local areas such as ponds, national parks, gardens or zoos
- identifying what they do to look after pets or plants at home and grouping these activities
- identifying and comparing the needs of a variety of plants and animals, including humans, based on their own experiences
- creating dioramas of a place a plant or animal lives, and identifying the features that enable it to meet its needs
- recognising how First Nations Australians care for living things
- exploring why caring for plants and animals is important including as sources of food and fibre
The second quote gives all six of ACARA’s elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each part of the content description is covered on these screens:
The elaborations: places where plants and animals live, including ponds and gardens, are screens 3 to 6. Looking after pets or plants at home and grouping these activities is screen 5. Comparing the needs of plants and animals, including humans, is screens 1 and 2 and q-all. Creating dioramas of a place and the features that let a living thing meet its needs is screen 6 and page 2 of the printable. How First Nations Australians care for living things is page 10 of the story and q-dingo, drawn only from ACARA’s own teacher background information for this elaboration (reference below). Why caring for plants and animals is important, including as sources of food and fibre, is page 9 of the story and screen 5. The lesson touches Science inquiry too: following a safe procedure to test a prediction (AC9S1I02) and making and recording observations (AC9S1I03) are the printable’s plant test; sorting information in a provided table (AC9S1I04) is the job groups on screen 5; considering whether an investigation is fair (AC9S1I05) is the plant test on screen 1; and creating models of the place a plant or animal lives (an elaboration of AC9S1I06) is screen 6 and page 2 of the printable.
The method is the explanatory storybook. Deborah Kelemen and her colleagues at Boston University write short picture storybooks that explain one cause-and-effect idea from start to finish. In their studies the books were read aloud, mostly by researchers, to children aged about 5 to 9. Each page adds one step to the explanation, the pictures are realistic and show only what the words say, and the narrative “avoided teleological or intentional language” (Kelemen 2019): no animal in the story talks, wears clothes, wants something or tries to do something. After the story, children apply the same explanation to animals the book never showed, which is how the studies tested whether the idea had transferred. This lesson’s story, The pond in the park, is written to those rules. It runs over all six screens, two pages at a time and one on the last screen, and explains what plants need, what animals need, how the animals at the pond find what they need, what happens when the pond dries up, how people care for living things, and finally the whole idea in one page. Screen 6 then asks students to make a place for a blue-tongue lizard and a possum, neither of which is in the story.
Read each screen’s pages aloud to the whole class before pairs start on the simulation. Kelemen describes the books as “read aloud in a joint attentional context”, so point to the part of the picture each sentence is about. In one classroom study the researcher read each book straight through (each reading was “entirely monological”), so keep questions until the pages are finished. Then pairs work the picture on one device, and the Talk about it question asks them to explain what they found in their own words, which Emmons, Smith and Kelemen (2016) suggest is likely to help children learn more deeply, though they say more research is needed. They also recommend explanations that are “simple but also cohesive and complete”. The Read this page aloud button under each page uses the device’s own voice, for pairs who want to hear a page again. Each screen suits a short session of its own. Grow or buy the two bean plants for the printable’s test before you start, so that they are young and the same size, and read the whole story again after screen 6, since Emmons, Smith and Kelemen also advise coming back to the ideas more than once.
The evidence is promising but narrow. In the first study each child heard a 10-page book read one to one: 28 children aged 5 to 6 and 33 aged 7 to 8. Before the story, 82% of the younger children didn’t have the basic facts; afterwards 11% didn’t, and the learning held three months later (Kelemen and colleagues 2014). A repeat with 32 children aged 5 to 8 in three after-school programmes, from a range of economic and educational backgrounds, found the same pattern, with the older children doing better (Emmons, Smith and Kelemen 2016). In two classrooms a researcher read two books a week apart to 20 kindergarten children and 17 second graders (average ages 6 years 2 months and 8 years 5 months), then led a class discussion; the kindergarten children learnt the facts, but carried the idea over to a different kind of problem far less well than the second graders (Emmons, Lees and Kelemen 2018). In the one study where classroom teachers ran it themselves, with 220 second and third graders (aged about 7 to 9), every teacher also added a hands-on simulation after the story, and one class of 19 watched an animated video of the book instead. The gains were large, but the paper describes no control group and the authors say the results “were not as marked as in prior researcher-led storybook interventions” (Brown, Ronfard and Kelemen 2020). A narrated animation of the book on a screen did about as well as the printed book read aloud, in a study of 33 second graders aged 7 to 8 (Ronfard and colleagues 2023).
So the limits for this lesson are real. Every study comes from one research group, and every one teaches natural selection, an idea far less intuitive than what living things need; none tested basic needs. The samples are small, 32 to 61 children, except the teacher-led study’s 220, and every study that says where it was done was in Massachusetts or elsewhere in New England. The studies read each book straight through, so children heard the whole explanation at once; this lesson splits the story into parts with activities in between, which the studies didn’t test. Year 1 students are at the younger end of the studies’ ages, where children learnt the facts but applied them to new cases less reliably. Kelemen calls the findings “preliminary”, and writes that “it would be naive to view this general approach as representing a panacea”. The simulations, the try-it tasks and the talk questions here are untested. The nearest things in the studies are the hands-on simulation the teachers added in Brown and colleagues’ study and the class discussion in Emmons and colleagues’ 2018 study, and neither was tested apart from the book. Whether this lesson teaches basic needs better than other approaches is not known.
Answers, notes, settings, the story pages read and the try-it tasks are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere. If students share devices, clear the saved answers between them.