Year 10 science · Biological sciences · AC9S10U02
Do living things evolve because they need to?
Cane toads were released in North Queensland in 1935. They now live in Queensland, New South Wales, the Northern Territory and Western Australia. They are poisonous, and a red-bellied black snake can die quickly after eating one, or even just mouthing it. Many people would say that snakes living with toads change because they need to. In this lesson you test that idea, and five other common ideas about evolution, against what scientists have found.
The snakes and the toads
Ben Phillips and Richard Shine measured snakes that had been collected over more than 80 years and kept as specimens at the Queensland Museum. All of the snakes came from places that cane toads have since reached. The researchers used a map of the toads’ spread to work out how long toads had been in each snake’s area when the snake was collected. Choose a time below to see how a snake collected then compares with one collected before toads arrived.
Red-bellied black snakes
DiagramThe diagram loads here.
What the measurements showed
Two kinds of snake that toads can kill are the red-bellied black snake and the common tree snake. For these two, Phillips and Shine found “a steady reduction in gape size and a steady increase in body length with time since exposure to toads”. A snake’s gape is how wide it can open its mouth. The study measured each snake’s head, including its gape, and compared head size with body length, so the change was a smaller head for the length of the body. Two other kinds of snake, which are at low risk from toads, showed no consistent change (Phillips and Shine, 2004).
My notebook
What do you think now?
Say whether you agree or disagree with each statement. Nobody expects you to know yet. Screens 2 to 8 come back to every one of them.
How the lesson works
1 · Meet a common idea
Each of screens 2 to 7 starts with an idea about evolution that many people hold.
2 · Read why it’s wrong
Then read why scientists reject the idea, and what they have found instead.
3 · Test it
Use the simulation to check what you read, then answer the questions.
Why the lesson starts with wrong ideas
A text that states a common wrong idea, says that it is wrong and then gives the scientific explanation is called a refutation text. Across many studies, people who read refutation texts held more accurate ideas afterwards than people who read ordinary texts (Danielson and others, 2025).
What we are learning
How natural selection changes a population over generations, why some common ideas about evolution are wrong, how new species form, and what evidence shows that living things share common ancestors.
I can
- 1explain how natural selection changes a population, using variation, inheritance and selection.
- 2explain why changes an animal gets during its life are not passed on to its young.
- 3explain why mutation is random and natural selection is not.
- 4explain what fitness means in biology, and why it depends on the environment.
- 5explain how isolation can lead to new species.
- 6use evidence from bones, DNA and where species live to show that living things share common ancestors.
- 7say what a piece of evidence shows and what it can’t show.
Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 10, AC9S10U02: “use the theory of evolution by natural selection to explain past and present diversity and analyse the scientific evidence supporting the theory”. The teacher notes at the end show which screen covers each part.
In biology, which of these is evolution?
Evolution: be the bird
Three pages: a practical in which students hunt paper dots on fabric for three generations, a page to record and graph the results, and a page for writing a refutation text and explaining the snakes.
2Common idea 1 of 6
Who changes?
Does an animal change because it needs to?
A fire has turned the ground black. Beetles live there, and some of them are pale and some are dark. Birds eat beetles. What happens to the beetles over the generations?
A common idea
Living things evolve because they need to.
Why it’s wrong
A beetle on black ground might be safer if it were dark, but needing a dark shell can’t give it one. Natural selection has no intentions and can’t sense what an individual or a species needs. Each beetle keeps the genes it hatched with for the rest of its life.
What scientists have found
The members of a population already differ, and some of the differences are inherited. Individuals with differences that suit their surroundings are more likely to survive and have young, and they pass those differences on. Over many generations the differences become more common in the population, while each individual keeps the genes it was born with. “Populations, not individual organisms, evolve.”
From Understanding Evolution, Misconceptions about evolution, and Concepts of Biology, sections 11.1 and 11.5.
On this screen
- Read the common idea, then why it’s wrong.
- Be the bird. Catch 12 beetles by tapping the first ones you see, or let the bird hunt.
- Make the next generation and hunt again. Run at least three generations.
Be the bird
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
What changed
No beetle changed colour during its life. The bird caught more of the beetles it could see easily, so more of the hard-to-see dark beetles survived, and they had young like themselves. The population changed over the generations. None of the beetles in it did.
My notebook
In the simulation, how many beetles changed colour during their lives?
Which of these evolves?
3Common idea 2 of 6
Passed on or not?
Are changes during an animal’s life passed on to its young?
During its life an animal can lose a leg, build up its muscles or get a scar. Do its young start life with these changes?
A common idea
Changes an animal gets during its life, like bigger muscles, are passed on to its young.
Why it’s wrong
Young get their genes from their parents. A weightlifter’s training builds up their muscles but doesn’t change their genes, so their children aren’t born with bigger muscles. Physical changes that happen during an organism’s lifetime are not passed on to its offspring.
What scientists have found
Natural selection can change the next generation only if the differences between individuals have some genetic basis. In the early nineteenth century Jean-Baptiste Lamarck proposed that changes caused by the environment, or by using or not using a part of the body, could be inherited. His idea is called inheritance of acquired characteristics, and it was discredited.
From Gregory (2009) and Concepts of Biology, section 11.1.
On this screen
- Read the common idea, then why it’s wrong.
- Choose what happens to the parent beetle during its life, then show its young.
- Try all three, and compare the young each time.
A beetle and its young
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Changes during life aren’t inherited
The mud made the parent look dark, but its genes were still for a pale shell, so its young hatched pale. Losing a leg didn’t change its genes either. Natural selection can act only on differences that are inherited.
My notebook
A weightlifter builds big muscles before having children. Will the children be born with bigger muscles because of the training?
A pale beetle gets covered in dark mud, so birds don’t see it, and it survives to have young. What colour are its young when they hatch?
For natural selection to change a population, the differences between its members must be…
4Common idea 3 of 6
Bacteria and antibiotics
Does an antibiotic cause the mutations that make bacteria resistant?
An antibiotic is a medicine that kills bacteria or stops them from growing. Bacteria that survive an antibiotic are resistant to it. Where does the resistance come from?
A common idea
Bacteria become resistant because the antibiotic causes the mutations they need.
Why it’s wrong
A mutation is a change in an organism’s DNA. Many mutations are mistakes made when a cell copies its DNA. They happen by chance, whether or not they help. In 1952 Esther and Joshua Lederberg helped to show that resistant bacteria are already in a population before it meets the antibiotic.
What scientists have found
The process of mutation is random, but selection is not. When an antibiotic is used, some bacteria die, but resistant bacteria can survive and multiply. Bacteria can also get genes for resistance from other bacteria.
From Understanding Evolution (The Lederberg experiment, and Misconceptions about evolution), Microbiology, section 11.5, and the Australian Government’s page What causes AMR?
In an experiment like the Lederbergs’, bacteria grow on a plate that has no penicillin, and each bacterium multiplies into a spot called a colony. A piece of velvet is pressed onto the plate. It picks up some bacteria from every colony, in the same arrangement, and is then pressed onto fresh plates that contain penicillin.
On this screen
- Read the common idea, then why it’s wrong.
- Copy the first plate onto three plates that contain penicillin, and see where colonies grow.
- Mark the same places on the first plate, then wash the first plate with penicillin.
- Switch to what the common idea predicts, and compare.
Copying a plate of bacteria
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
The resistance came first
Colonies X and Y were resistant before they ever met penicillin. Penicillin didn’t make them resistant. It killed the colonies around them, so only the resistant ones were left to grow.
An infection treated with an antibiotic
DiagramThe diagram loads here.
My notebook
On every penicillin plate, the resistant colonies grew in the same places. What does that show?
Which statement about mutation and natural selection is right?
A person with an infection takes an antibiotic. A few of the bacteria are already resistant. What happens to the bacteria?
5Common idea 4 of 6
Survival of the fittest
Do the strongest survive?
People often sum up natural selection as survival of the fittest. Charles Darwin used the phrase himself. So which individuals are the fittest?
A common idea
Survival of the fittest means the strongest survive.
Why it’s wrong
In biology, fitness does not refer to physical condition, strength or stamina. As Darwin used the word, fittest meant best suited to a particular environment, not most physically fit.
What scientists have found
Fitness is an individual’s ability to survive and reproduce compared with the rest of its population. Which individuals are fittest depends on the environment, and when the environment changes, different individuals can become the fittest. Evolution has no goal of making faster, bigger, more complex or smarter species. Understanding Evolution suggests that “survival of the fit enough” is more accurate.
From Gregory (2009), Biology 2e (chapter 19 key terms), Concepts of Biology, section 11.5, and Understanding Evolution, Misconceptions about evolution.
On this screen
- Read the common idea, then why it’s wrong.
- Run five generations and watch the share of dark beetles on each plot.
- Change the ground on one plot and run at least three more generations.
- Read the graph, or open the table under it.
Two plots of ground
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Fittest depends on the ground
On pale sand the pale beetles are the fittest, because birds see them less, so more of them survive to have young. On burnt ground the dark beetles are the fittest. Neither colour is fitter everywhere.
Evolution has no goal
When the ground changed, the share of dark beetles changed direction. The colour that left more young in the conditions of the time became more common.
My notebook
On the burnt ground in the simulation, which beetles are the fittest?
Wind blows pale sand over the burnt plot while some pale beetles are still there. What happens to the share of dark beetles over the next generations?
6Common idea 5 of 6
Where new species come from
Is every species a clear, separate kind of living thing?
A new river channel splits a population of beetles into two groups. The east group lives on pale sand and the west group on dark soil. What happens to the two groups over many generations?
A common idea
Every species is a clear, separate kind of living thing.
Why it’s wrong
Biologists define a species as a group of organisms that interbreed and produce fertile, viable young. That definition is hard to apply to some organisms, such as bacteria and plants that form hybrids. People invented the idea of a species to help them grasp the diversity of the natural world, and the idea is a fuzzy one.
What scientists have found
When a population is split, the two groups can evolve in different ways. Over time, natural selection, mutation and chance are likely to make them diverge, unless they meet and interbreed again. They may stop breeding with each other, for example because they breed at different times of year. Biologists call that temporal isolation. While two groups are part way apart, it can be hard to say whether they are one species or two.
From Biology 2e, section 18.2, Concepts of Biology, section 11.4, and Understanding Evolution, Misconceptions about evolution.
On this screen
- Read the common idea, then why it’s wrong.
- Move through the four times and watch each group.
- At each time, let the river dry up and see whether the two groups still breed together.
- Decide when you think they became two species.
A river splits a population
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Isolation
The river kept the two groups apart. This is called geographic isolation. Each group changed in its own way. By the end, breeding at different times of year kept them apart even without the river. Anything that stops two groups breeding when they meet is called reproductive isolation.
My notebook
Which is the definition of a species used on this screen?
Why did the east and west groups end up different?
Two kinds of frog live in the same area. One breeds from January to March and the other from March to May. Why do they rarely breed with each other?
7Common idea 6 of 6
Did humans evolve from chimpanzees?
Who are our closest relatives, and how do we know?
Chimpanzees and bonobos are our closest living relatives. Does that mean humans evolved from them?
A common idea
Humans evolved from chimpanzees.
Why it’s wrong
Humans are not descended from chimpanzees, or from any other primate living today. Humans and chimpanzees share a common ancestor, which lived between 8 and 6 million years ago. Both lines have evolved since they split.
What scientists have found
On an evolutionary tree, ancestors are at the branch points, not at the tips. Body structures, DNA, fossils and the places where species live all give evidence that living things share common ancestors.
From the Smithsonian’s Human Origins Program (Frequently asked questions, and Genetics), Understanding Evolution, Misconceptions about evolution, and Concepts of Biology, section 11.3.
On this screen
- Read the common idea, then why it’s wrong.
- Choose each group of bones and find it in all four limbs.
- Compare the made-up DNA of four apes, two at a time, until you have compared every pair.
- On the tree, tap the common ancestor of humans and chimpanzees.
Same bones, different jobs
DiagramThe diagram loads here.
Homologous structures
A human arm, a dog’s front leg, a bird’s wing and a whale’s flipper do different jobs, but they share the same overall construction. Parts that are similar because they are descended from the same part in a common ancestor are called homologous structures.
Count the differences
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
DNA
The more closely two groups are related, the more alike their DNA sequences are. In the genes that humans and chimpanzees share, about 1.2% of the DNA letters differ. Counting other kinds of difference as well adds a further 4 to 5%.
Fossils and where species live
Fossils give solid evidence that organisms from the past are not the same as those living today. Where species live is evidence too. Australia has many species found nowhere else, and the great variety of its marsupials reflects the continent’s long isolation.
My notebook
On an evolutionary tree, where is the common ancestor of humans and chimpanzees?
A human arm, a bird’s wing and a whale’s flipper have the same pattern of bones. What is the best explanation?
Why does Australia have so many kinds of marsupial that live nowhere else?
8Explain
Back to the snakes
Why do red-bellied black snakes in places with cane toads now have smaller gapes for their body size?
You have tested six common ideas. Now use what you found to explain the snakes from screen 1.
A common idea
The snakes needed smaller mouths for their size, so their mouths got smaller.
Why it’s wrong
Needing a smaller mouth can’t change a snake’s genes. An explanation by natural selection has to say which snakes survived and had young, and what they passed on.
What scientists have found
Phillips and Shine point out that snakes are gape-limited predators: a snake can eat only prey that fits through its gape. A snake with a bigger head for its size is more likely to eat a toad large enough to kill it. On this reasoning, toads favour snakes with larger bodies and smaller heads for their size, and that is the direction in which the two kinds of snake at risk from toads changed.
From Phillips and Shine (2004).
On this screen
- Choose each snake and compare its head with the toad that would kill it.
- Sort each card into the part of the explanation it belongs to, or leave it out.
- Write the explanation in your own words.
- Look at your answers from screen 1, then answer the eight statements again.
How big a toad would kill each snake?
DiagramThe diagram loads here.
Build the explanation
DiagramThe cards load here.
Natural selection
The members of a population vary, and some of the variation is inherited. Some individuals survive and reproduce more than others because of the variation they inherited. Over many generations, the inherited characteristics of the more successful individuals become more common. That is natural selection.
Fast enough to measure
Cane toads were released in 1935, and Phillips and Shine published their study in 2004, so the changes they measured took less than 70 years. Each generation of these snakes takes less than 3 years, so in some areas more than 20 generations had passed since the toads arrived. If the changes are inherited, these snakes evolved within a human lifetime. Biologists have also watched evolution happen within the past 50 years. Many microbes have evolved resistance to new drugs, for example. Evolution can be slow, but it can also be fast enough to measure.
My notebook
Your answers at the start and now
CompareYour answers from screen 1 load here.
Which explanation of the snakes uses natural selection correctly?
Two other kinds of snake, which are at low risk from toads, showed no consistent change. Why does that matter?
What else would biologists want to know before they say the change came from natural selection?
Evolution: be the bird
Three pages: a practical in which students hunt paper dots on fabric for three generations, a page to record and graph the results, and a page for writing a refutation text and explaining the snakes.
For teachers
Curriculum
Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 10, Science understanding, Biological sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:
AC9S10U02 use the theory of evolution by natural selection to explain past and present diversity and analyse the scientific evidence supporting the theory
- outlining processes involved in natural selection including variation, isolation and selection
- examining biodiversity as a function of evolution
- analysing evidence for the theory of evolution by natural selection including the fossil record, chemical and anatomical similarities, and geographical distribution of species
- investigating changes caused by natural selection in a particular population as a result of a specified selection pressure such as artificial selection in breeding for desired characteristics
- relating genetic characteristics to survival and reproductive rates
The second quote gives the first five of ACARA’s six elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. The lesson uses these five and leaves out the sixth, on the structural and physiological adaptations of First Nations Australians to the Australian environment. The fourth elaboration gives artificial selection in breeding as its example of a selection pressure. The lesson uses birds hunting beetles, an antibiotic and cane toads instead. Each part of the content description is covered on these screens:
- Use the theory of evolution by natural selection to explain past and present diversity: screens 2 and 5 (natural selection in a beetle population), screen 3 (only inherited differences are selected), screen 4 (mutation and selection in bacteria), screen 6 (isolation and new species) and screen 8 (the snakes and the cane toads); q-evo, q-change, n-young, q-evolves, q-muscles, q-mud, q-variation, q-random, q-amr, q-fittest, q-switch, n-survive, q-species, q-isolation, q-frogs, q-snakes.
- Analyse the scientific evidence supporting the theory: screen 4 (the copied plates of bacteria), screen 7 (homologous limbs, differences in DNA, an evolutionary tree, fossils and the marsupials of Australia) and screen 8 (the snake specimens, the size of toad that would kill each kind of snake, and the two kinds at low risk from toads); q-plates, q-ancestor, q-bones, n-dna, q-marsupials, q-control, q-inherit.
The lesson also works on these content descriptions. Students read trends from the generations of beetles on screen 2 and from the graph of the two plots on screen 5 (AC9S10I05). They judge claims about evolution against evidence when they answer the eight statements on screens 1 and 8, and on screen 8 they ask what the measurements of the snakes can and can’t show (AC9S10I06). They sort evidence and reasoning into an explanation of the snakes and write it in their own words (AC9S10I07). The simulated data have no anomalies to find.
AC9S10I05 analyse and connect a variety of data and information to identify and explain patterns, trends, relationships and anomalies
AC9S10I06 assess the validity and reproducibility of methods and evaluate the validity of conclusions and claims, including by identifying assumptions, conflicting evidence and areas of uncertainty
AC9S10I07 construct arguments based on analysis of a variety of evidence to support conclusions or evaluate claims, and consider any ethical issues and cultural protocols associated with accessing, using or citing secondary data or information
How the lesson is taught
The lesson uses refutation texts. A refutation text states a commonly held misconception, refutes it directly and gives the current scientific explanation (Sinatra and Broughton, 2011). Each of screens 2 to 7 opens with one, in three parts: the common idea, why it is wrong, and what scientists have found. Students then test what they read in a simulation, write in their notebook and answer the checks. Screen 1 asks students to agree or disagree with eight statements before any teaching, and each refutation shows the answer the student gave there. Screen 8 brings the ideas together to explain a real case, the snakes and the cane toads, and students answer the eight statements again beside their first answers.
The explanation is an essential part of a refutation text. In Kendeou and others (2014), a refutation with an explanation was sufficient to significantly reduce the disruption that a commonsense belief caused during reading, and it also produced long-term learning outcomes. A refutation alone reduced the disruption but did not eliminate it, and an explanation alone was as effective as a refutation with an explanation in reducing it. Every refutation in the lesson ends with the explanation.
Two meta-analyses support the method. Schroeder and Kucera (2022) combined 44 comparisons with 3,869 participants and found a positive, moderate effect (g = 0.41). Most of the comparisons used post-secondary students, but the effects were robust and consistent regardless of the age of the learners. The studies were mainly one-off readings of short passages, and the authors say it is unclear whether the effect would persist in longer readings such as textbooks. Danielson and others (2025) combined 111 samples from 76 studies and found a consistent, statistically significant advantage for refutation texts, with effects in the small-to-medium range (g = 0.37 for accurate beliefs measured after reading). The effects were robust across education levels and across how long after reading they were measured. For secondary students the effect measured after reading was g = 0.61 (9 studies), and the change from before to after reading was g = 0.51 (7 studies), which was not statistically significant. These school estimates come from few studies. The authors argue that refutation texts should play only a limited role in school science, and they do not recommend teaching science through text alone. In this lesson each text comes with a simulation, a notebook question and checks.
Closer to this topic, Pickett and others (2022) gave readings about antibiotic resistance to 64 advanced biology majors. Significantly more students rejected a teleological statement, one that explains resistance by its purpose, after the reading intervention, and the authors conclude that readings which confront intuitive misconceptions can be more effective in reducing them. Misconceptions about natural selection are common. Gregory (2009) writes that a finding that less than 10% of those surveyed have a functional understanding of natural selection is not atypical.
Sinatra and Broughton (2011) note that the results of some later research have been mixed, and that refutation texts have shown two consistent advantages: the change in students’ ideas often lasts for weeks or months, and students like the texts. They also note that a reader may construct a coherent but incorrect understanding from a text, and that discussion can add to the effect of refutation texts. With a class, read each refutation together, then ask a student to put the common idea and the reason it is wrong into their own words before anyone runs the simulation. The notebook questions show you what each student has understood.
Plan for about two lessons of 50 to 60 minutes: screens 1 to 4, then screens 5 to 8. The printable practical needs a further lesson.
Handle with care
- Students can hold several of these ideas at once and keep them after teaching. Gregory (2009) groups them under headings that include teleology, use and disuse, soft inheritance, and typological and essentialist thinking. Listen for need, want, try and in order to in students’ explanations, and ask which individuals survived and had young.
- Each refutation states the common idea before correcting it. Read each one through to the explanation, and don’t leave a common idea written up on its own.
- In everyday speech a theory can mean a guess. In science, a theory is a concept that has been extensively tested and supported over time (Fowler, Roush and Wise, 2013, section 11.5). The word list gives the scientific meaning.
- Some students and families hold beliefs about the origins of living things that differ from the theory of evolution. The feedback on the eight statements says whether scientists agree, and the checks ask about the science.
- Screen 7 keeps to what the Smithsonian’s Human Origins Program says about human evolution: humans are not descended from any primate living today, and humans and chimpanzees share a common ancestor that lived between 8 and 6 million years ago.
- The snake case comes from Phillips and Shine (2004). They measured preserved snakes at the Queensland Museum, all from places that toads have since reached, and related each snake’s body length, and its head size for that length, to how long toads had been in its area when it was collected. For head size, they had no direct data to tell selection from a change in how the snakes grew, and no estimates were available of how strongly head size and body size are inherited in these snakes. Even so, they argue that the pattern across the four species points to the toads themselves rather than a change in the snakes’ prey, that features like head size are almost always partly inherited, and that more than 20 snake generations had passed in some areas. For the longer bodies they give three possible causes: toads killing many young snakes in each generation, faster growth in response to toads, and selection on the snakes’ life history towards larger young or young that grow faster. The first two would not necessarily be inherited changes. For that reason screen 8 doesn’t say the change was inherited, and q-inherit asks students what else biologists would want to know. The name common tree snake for Dendrelaphis punctulatus comes from Fearn and Trembath (2011). Phillips and Shine call it the green tree snake.
- On screen 8 the card saying that each snake’s mouth got smaller as it grew up near toads is left out of the explanation, because a change during life is development, not natural selection. It is also the alternative that the measurements can’t rule out, which is what q-inherit asks about.
- Screen 4 explains how antibiotic resistance spreads in a population of bacteria. It gives no advice about taking antibiotics.
- The printable practical follows the pattern of Survival of the flattest (Utah Education Network, 2018), which uses paper dots, fabric squares and tweezers. The procedure on the sheet was written for this lesson and hasn’t been tried with a class, so run one generation yourself first.
About the simulations and the numbers
- The beetles are a made-up model, not a real species. In each beetle model a surviving beetle has young of its own colour, so colour is inherited exactly and from one parent. Real beetles have two parents, and their young can differ from both. Real beetles also hatch as larvae. In the models a beetle has its colour from the start and keeps it.
- Screen 2 starts with 24 beetles, 18 pale and 6 dark, on burnt ground. The bird catches 12 beetles each generation. Students tap beetles or let the bird hunt. When the bird hunts, it picks beetles at random, with a pale beetle 4 times as likely to be picked as a dark one. Each survivor has 2 young and then dies, so every generation has 24 beetles. Students can run up to 6 generations, and the results differ from run to run.
- Screen 5 works out expected numbers, so it gives the same result every time. A beetle that matches the ground survives the birds with a chance of 0.8, and one that stands out with a chance of 0.4. Every survivor has the same number of young, so the share of dark beetles in the next generation is (share dark × survival of dark) ÷ (share dark × survival of dark + share pale × survival of pale). Both plots start at 50% dark. On burnt ground the odds of a beetle being dark double each generation, so the share of dark beetles goes 50%, 66.7%, 80%, 88.9%, 94.1% and 97.0%. The pictures show 20 beetles, with the number of dark ones rounded from the share. When the dark or the pale beetles are down to less than half a beetle out of the 20 (a share under 2.5% or over 97.5%), the model counts that colour as gone and keeps the share at 0% or 100%. In a real population a colour that has gone could come back only through a new mutation or beetles moving in, which the model leaves out. Without a change of ground, the burnt plot reaches 100% dark at generation 6 and the sand plot 0%.
- On screen 3 the drawings show one parent and three of its young. The mud and the lost leg are made up.
- On screen 4 the plates are drawings, and the places of colonies X and Y were chosen for the picture. Understanding Evolution describes copying the plate with a cloth and testing with penicillin, and Parker and others (2016) describe replica plating with sterile velvet. The lesson uses velvet and penicillin. The infection diagram starts with 40 bacteria, 2 of them resistant, and 3 of the others survive the antibiotic. The numbers were chosen for the picture.
- On screen 6 the river, the colours, the breeding seasons and the four times are made up, and the four times have no stated number of generations. The months follow the example of temporal isolation in Clark, Douglas and Choi (2018), in which one kind of frog breeds from January to March and another from March to May.
- On screen 7 the limb drawings are simplified and show the bones in three groups. The DNA sequences are made up and 20 letters long, and they exaggerate the differences. Chimpanzee and bonobo differ at 2 places, human and either of them at 4, and gorilla and each of the other three at 6. That gives the tree the Smithsonian’s Human Origins Program describes: the bonobo is the close cousin of the chimpanzee, and chimpanzees, bonobos and humans all show the same amount of difference from gorillas.
- On screen 1 the snake drawings show only the direction of the change, not its size. Phillips and Shine report the changes as regression estimates, not as head or body sizes, and they report head size relative to body length, so the head is drawn the same size each time and only the body gets longer. The first drawing is a snake collected before toads reached its area, because every snake in the study came from a place that toads have since reached.
- On screen 8 the toad sizes come from Phillips and Shine (2004), who took them from Phillips, Brown and Shine (2003). A red-bellied black snake gets a fatal dose from a toad whose head is 43% as wide as its own, a common tree snake from 49%, a swamp snake from 108% and a keelback from 185%. Swamp snakes have unusually small heads, and keelbacks can take unusually large doses of toad poison. In the drawing the toad’s head is drawn at that percentage of the snake’s head width.
Where sources disagree, and what to check
- Both meta-analyses found that the learners’ age or education level made no significant difference to the effect, and both had few studies with school students. In Danielson and others (2025) the change from before to after reading for secondary students came from 7 studies and was not statistically significant. Read what your students write in their notebooks.
- Biology 2e gives two definitions of a species in section 18.2: a group of individual organisms that interbreed and produce fertile, viable offspring, and a group of actual or potential interbreeding individuals. Concepts of Biology uses one like the second (section 11.4). The lesson uses the first. Understanding Evolution notes that the definition is hard to apply to bacteria and to plants that hybridise.
- Understanding Evolution describes the Lederberg experiment with a cloth and penicillin, and Parker and others (2016) describe replica plating with sterile velvet. Screen 4 uses velvet and penicillin. The Lederbergs’ own 1952 paper wasn’t read for this lesson, so screen 4 doesn’t name the antibiotic they used.
- The Smithsonian’s Human Origins Program gives the difference between human and chimpanzee DNA as about 1.2% in the genes the two share, counting only substitutions, and an additional 4 to 5% when other differences are counted. Students may meet other figures elsewhere.
- Gregory (2009) says that Darwin began using the phrase survival of the fittest, which had been coined a few years earlier by Herbert Spencer, and calls it a poor descriptor of natural selection. Understanding Evolution suggests survival of the fit enough instead.
Answers at a glance
- Screen 1: q-evo, a change in the inherited characteristics of a population over generations. Of the eight statements, scientists agree that populations evolve but individual animals don’t, and that evolution can be fast enough to measure in a human lifetime. They disagree with the other six.
- Screen 2: the share of dark beetles usually rises over the generations, and no beetle changes colour. q-change, none; n-young 18; q-evolves, a population of beetles over many generations.
- Screen 3: after the lost leg and after the mud the young hatch pale with six legs, and when the parent hatched with genes for a dark shell they hatch dark. q-muscles, no; q-mud, pale; q-variation, passed from parents to their young in their genes.
- Screen 4: colonies X and Y grow in the same places on all three penicillin plates and survive when the first plate is washed with penicillin. q-plates, the resistant bacteria were there before they met penicillin; q-random, mutations happen by chance, but which ones become common depends on the environment; q-amr, most of the bacteria that aren’t resistant die, and the resistant ones survive and multiply.
- Screen 5: on burnt ground the share of dark beetles goes 50%, 66.7%, 80%, 88.9%, 94.1% and 97.0% over the first five generations, and on pale sand it falls through 33.3%, 20%, 11.1%, 5.9% and 3.0%. Without a change of ground, the burnt plot reaches 100% dark at generation 6, when the last pale beetle is gone, and the sand plot reaches 0%. q-fittest, the dark beetles; q-switch, it falls; n-survive 8.
- Screen 6: the two groups still breed together at the first two times, rarely at the third and never at the fourth. q-species, a group of organisms that interbreed and produce fertile, viable young; q-isolation, the river kept them apart and each group changed in its own way; q-frogs, they breed at different times of year.
- Screen 7: every limb has one upper arm bone, two forearm bones, and a group of wrist and hand bones. The differences are chimpanzee and bonobo 2, human and chimpanzee 4, human and bonobo 4, and gorilla and each of the others 6. The common ancestor of humans and chimpanzees is the branch point where the human line meets the line to chimpanzees and bonobos. q-ancestor, the branch point where their lines meet; q-bones, a common ancestor; n-dna 20%; q-marsupials, Australia’s long isolation.
- Screen 8: variation, some snakes had bigger mouths for their body size; inheritance, mouth size was passed on; selection, snakes with bigger mouths for their size were more likely to eat a toad large enough to kill them, and snakes with smaller mouths for their size were more likely to survive and have young; over generations, more and more snakes had small mouths for their size. The other five cards don’t belong in a natural selection explanation and are left out. q-snakes, snakes with smaller mouths for their size were more likely to survive and have young; q-control, it points to the toads as the cause; q-inherit, whether gape size is passed from parents to young.
- Printable sheet: the answers depend on the class’s results. Expect the dots that stand out against the fabric to be picked up first, so the colours that match the fabric become more common over the generations. No dot changes colour. On the other fabric, different colours would be picked up first. Each generation starts with 80 dots and has 40 survivors, so each colour’s number at the start of the next generation is twice its survivors.
Saved progress
Answers, notes and simulation records are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere.
References
- Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) (2022). Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Years 7 to 10 curriculum content. Australian Curriculum website.
- Australian Government (n.d.). What causes AMR? Antimicrobial resistance website.
- Australian Museum (n.d.). Red-bellied Black Snake.
- Clark, M. A., Douglas, M. and Choi, J. (2018). Biology 2e, sections 1.2 and 18.2, and the key terms for chapters 14 and 19. OpenStax.
- Danielson, R. W., Jacobson, N. G., Patall, E. A., Sinatra, G. M., Adesope, O. O., Kennedy, A. A. U., Bhat, B. H., Ramazan, O., Akinrotimi, B., Nketah, G., Jin, G. and Sunday, O. J. (2025). The effectiveness of refutation text in confronting scientific misconceptions: A meta-analysis. Educational Psychologist, 60(1), 23–47. https://doi.org/10.1080/00461520.2024.2365628
- Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water (2021). Cane toads (Bufo marinus). Last updated 10 October 2021.
- Fearn, S. and Trembath, D. F. (2011). Natural history of the common tree snake, Dendrelaphis punctulatus (Serpentes : Colubridae), in the wet–dry tropics of north Queensland. Australian Journal of Zoology, 58(6), 384–389.
- Fowler, S., Roush, R. and Wise, J. (2013). Concepts of Biology, sections 11.1, 11.3, 11.4 and 11.5, and the key terms for chapter 11. OpenStax.
- Gregory, T. R. (2009). Understanding natural selection: Essential concepts and common misconceptions. Evolution: Education and Outreach, 2(2), 156–175. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12052-009-0128-1
- Kendeou, P., Walsh, E. K., Smith, E. R. and O’Brien, E. J. (2014). Knowledge revision processes in refutation texts. Discourse Processes, 51(5–6), 374–397. https://doi.org/10.1080/0163853X.2014.913961
- Parker, N., Schneegurt, M., Thi Tu, A.-H., Lister, P. and Forster, B. M. (2016). Microbiology, section 11.5. OpenStax.
- Phillips, B. L. and Shine, R. (2004). Adapting to an invasive species: Toxic cane toads induce morphological change in Australian snakes. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 101(49), 17150–17155. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.0406440101
- Pickett, S. B., Nielson, C., Marshall, H., Tanner, K. D. and Coley, J. D. (2022). Effects of reading interventions on student understanding of and misconceptions about antibiotic resistance. Journal of Microbiology and Biology Education, 23(1). https://doi.org/10.1128/jmbe.00220-21
- Schroeder, N. L. and Kucera, A. C. (2022). Refutation text facilitates learning: A meta-analysis of between-subjects experiments. Educational Psychology Review, 34, 957–987. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-021-09656-z
- Sinatra, G. M. and Broughton, S. H. (2011). Bridging reading comprehension and conceptual change in science education: The promise of refutation text. Reading Research Quarterly, 46(4), 374–393. https://doi.org/10.1002/RRQ.005
- Smithsonian Institution’s Human Origins Program (n.d.). Frequently asked questions; Genetics (section last updated 28 August 2026).
- University of California Museum of Paleontology (n.d.). Understanding Evolution: Misconceptions about evolution; The Lederberg experiment.
- Utah Education Network (2018). Survival of the flattest. Designed by Jordan School District teachers and staff. Created 5 December 2014, updated 4 February 2018.
Curriculum attribution
© Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) 2010 to present, unless otherwise indicated. This material was downloaded from the Australian Curriculum website (Website) (accessed 10 November 2026) and was not modified. The material is licensed under CC BY 4.0 Attribution 4.0 International Deed. Version updates are tracked in the ‘Curriculum version history’ section on the ‘About the Australian Curriculum’ page of the Australian Curriculum website.
ACARA does not endorse any product that uses the Australian Curriculum or make any representations as to the quality of such products. Any product that uses material published on this website should not be taken to be affiliated with ACARA or have the sponsorship or approval of ACARA. It is up to each person to make their own assessment of the product, taking into account matters including, but not limited to, the version number and the degree to which the materials align with the content descriptions and achievement standards (where relevant). Where there is a claim of alignment, it is important to check that the materials align with the content descriptions and achievement standards (endorsed by all education Ministers), not the elaborations (examples provided by ACARA).
Sources by screen
- Screen 1: Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water (2021) (the release of cane toads in 1935 and where they live now); Australian Museum (red-bellied black snakes die from eating or mouthing cane toads); Phillips and Shine (2004) (the museum snakes); Fearn and Trembath (2011) (the name common tree snake); Danielson and others (2025) (refutation texts); Fowler, Roush and Wise (2013), sections 11.1 (evolution as a change in a population) and 11.5 (growing up is development).
- Screen 2: University of California Museum of Paleontology, Misconceptions about evolution (natural selection can’t sense needs; populations evolve); Fowler, Roush and Wise (2013), sections 11.1 and 11.5 (inherited variation; an individual’s genes don’t change as it ages).
- Screen 3: Gregory (2009) (changes during life aren’t passed on); Fowler, Roush and Wise (2013), section 11.1 (differences need a genetic basis; Lamarck).
- Screen 4: University of California Museum of Paleontology, The Lederberg experiment, and Misconceptions about evolution (mutation is random, selection is not); Parker and others (2016), section 11.5 (replica plating with velvet; mutations from mistakes in copying DNA); Australian Government, What causes AMR? (resistant bacteria survive and multiply; resistance genes from other bacteria).
- Screen 5: Gregory (2009) (what fitness means; Darwin and the phrase survival of the fittest); Clark, Douglas and Choi (2018), chapter 19 key terms (fitness); Fowler, Roush and Wise (2013), section 11.5 (evolution has no goal) and chapter 11 key terms (gene flow); University of California Museum of Paleontology, Misconceptions about evolution (survival of the fit enough; mutation produces new variation).
- Screen 6: Clark, Douglas and Choi (2018), section 18.2 (species; separated populations; temporal isolation); Fowler, Roush and Wise (2013), section 11.4 (geographic isolation; reproductive isolation; allopatric speciation); University of California Museum of Paleontology, Misconceptions about evolution (the idea of a species is fuzzy).
- Screen 7: Smithsonian Institution’s Human Origins Program, Frequently asked questions and Genetics (the common ancestor; closest living relatives; DNA differences); University of California Museum of Paleontology, Misconceptions about evolution (ancestors at branch points); Fowler, Roush and Wise (2013), section 11.3 (homologous structures; fossils; marsupials; DNA similarity).
- Screen 8: Phillips and Shine (2004) (the snakes, the toad sizes, which they took from Phillips, Brown and Shine (2003), and the number of generations); Department of Climate Change, Energy, the Environment and Water (2021) (the release of cane toads in 1935); University of California Museum of Paleontology, Misconceptions about evolution (evolution observed over the past 50 years).
- Word list: the sources for the screen where each word is first used, and Clark, Douglas and Choi (2018), section 1.2 (population) and chapter 14 key terms (mutation).