Year 10 science · Physical sciences · AC9S10U05
How do force and mass change an object’s motion?
1Ranking task 1
Newton’s first law
What happens to a moving object when there is no net force on it?
On every screen of this lesson you do a ranking task. You put a few cases in order and check your ranking. Then you test each case in a simulation, and you change your ranking if the results disagree with it. On this screen the cases are pucks on an air table, which is nearly frictionless when the air is on (OpenStax).
On this screen
- Rank the four pucks and check your ranking.
- In the simulation, flick the puck with the air on and with the air off, then flick the heavy puck.
- Test each puck, change your ranking if you need to, and choose the reason for it.
- Answer the questions.
Four pucks
Ranking taskThe ranking task loads here.
An air table
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
OpenStax describes an air hockey table. “When the air is turned off, the puck slides only a short distance before friction slows it to a stop.” But “when the air is turned on, it creates a nearly frictionless surface, and the puck glides long distances without slowing down.” In the simulation, the striker pushes the puck only while it touches it. After that, nothing pushes the puck forward, and with the air on nothing slows it down either.
Newton’s first law
“A body at rest remains at rest, or, if in motion, remains in motion at a constant velocity unless acted on by a net external force.” (OpenStax). A moving object doesn’t need a force to keep it moving. It needs a net force to speed up, slow down or change direction.
“The property of a body to remain at rest or to remain in motion with constant velocity is called inertia.” and “The inertia of an object is measured by its mass.” (OpenStax). The same flick changes the heavy puck’s speed less than the light puck’s, because the heavy puck has more inertia.
A puck glides across an air table at a steady 3 m/s in a straight line. What is the net force on it?
With the air off, a flicked puck slows down and stops. Why?
The same flick sends a light puck off fast and a heavy puck off slowly. What does this show?
2Ranking task 2
Speed and acceleration
How can you tell from an object’s motion whether it is accelerating?
Average speed is the distance an object travels divided by the time it takes (OpenStax). Speed and velocity are different, and OpenStax says “One major difference is that speed has no direction.” Velocity gives the direction as well as the speed. Acceleration is “the rate at which velocity changes” (OpenStax), so an object accelerates when it speeds up, slows down or changes direction. On this screen each car leaves a dot on the road every second.
On this screen
- Rank the four cars and check your ranking.
- In the simulation, drive at a steady speed, then speed up, then slow down, and watch the dots and the graph.
- Test each car, change your ranking if you need to, and choose the reason for it.
- Answer the questions.
Four cars
Ranking taskThe ranking task loads here.
A straight road
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
The dots and the graph show the same motion in two ways. Evenly spaced dots and a flat line on the speed–time graph mean a steady speed. Dots that spread out and a line that slopes up mean the car is speeding up. Dots that bunch up and a line that slopes down mean it is slowing down. The steeper the line, the bigger the acceleration.
Acceleration
Acceleration = change in velocity ÷ time taken, or a = Δv ÷ Δt, in metres per second per second (m/s²) (OpenStax). Car C goes from 0 to 24 m/s in 8 s, so its acceleration is 24 ÷ 8 = 3 m/s².
Slowing down is an acceleration too. “When an object slows down, its acceleration is opposite to the direction of its motion.” (OpenStax). Car D slows down by 2 m/s every second, so the size of its acceleration is 2 m/s².
A car leaves a dot every second, and the gaps between the dots get bigger. What is the car doing?
A cyclist riding east slows down. Which way is the cyclist’s acceleration?
3Ranking task 3
Newton’s second law
How do force and mass change an object’s acceleration?
Newton’s second law links the net force on an object, its mass and its acceleration: a = Fnet ÷ m, which is the same as Fnet = m × a (OpenStax). Forces are measured in newtons (N), and a newton is “the force needed to accelerate a 1-kg system at the rate of 1 m/s²” (OpenStax). On this screen a fan on each cart pushes it along a smooth track.
On this screen
- Rank the five carts and check your ranking.
- In the simulation, try three forces on the same mass, then three masses with the same force, and look at the table and the graph.
- Test each cart, change your ranking if you need to, and choose the reason for it.
- Answer the questions.
Five fan carts
Ranking taskThe ranking task loads here.
A fan cart
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
The light gates time the cart over 1.0 m from rest. OpenStax gives the distance travelled with a steady acceleration as x = x0 + v0t + ½at². The cart starts from rest at the first gate, so 1.0 m = ½at², which gives a = 2 × 1.0 m ÷ t². You can use the same method with a real trolley on the printable sheet.
Newton’s second law
a = Fnet ÷ m. “The acceleration of a system is directly proportional to and in the same direction as the net external force acting on the system, and inversely proportional to its mass.” (OpenStax).
Double the force and the acceleration doubles. Double the mass and the acceleration halves: “the larger the mass (the inertia), the smaller the acceleration produced by a given force” (OpenStax). On the graph, each mass gives a straight line through zero, and the bigger the mass, the less steep its line.
A net force of 10 N acts on a cart. What happens to the cart’s acceleration if the net force doubles to 20 N?
The same net force acts on a 2 kg cart and a 4 kg cart. How does the 4 kg cart’s acceleration compare with the 2 kg cart’s?
4Ranking task 4
Adding up forces
What happens when more than one force acts on an object?
Most objects have more than one force on them at once. “The net external force is the vector sum of all external forces” (OpenStax), so you add forces that point the same way and subtract forces that point in opposite directions. A free-body diagram shows an object as a dot, with an arrow for each force on it.
On this screen
- Rank the five boxes and check your ranking.
- In the simulation, make the box speed up, keep it sliding at a steady speed with friction on, and make it slow down while you still push it.
- Test each box, change your ranking if you need to, and choose the reason for it.
- Answer the questions.
Five boxes
Ranking taskThe ranking task loads here.
Pushing a box
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
The free-body diagram also shows the box’s weight, which is the force of gravity on it, and the support force from the floor. The weight of a 1.0 kg object on Earth is 9.8 N (OpenStax), so the 10 kg box weighs 98 N. Up and down, these two forces balance, so the box doesn’t move up or down. OpenStax warns that “Mass and weight are often used interchangeably in everyday language.” “However, in science, these terms are distinctly different from one another.”
Net force
Add up the forces, taking their directions into account, to get the net force. When the forces are balanced, the net force is zero and the velocity doesn’t change, so the object stays at rest or keeps moving at a steady speed in a straight line.
When the forces don’t balance, the object accelerates in the direction of the net force, with a = Fnet ÷ m. Box D’s net force is 40 N − 10 N = 30 N, so its acceleration is 30 N ÷ 10 kg = 3 m/s².
You push a heavy box across a floor at a steady speed. How does your push compare with the friction on the box?
A 50 N push to the right and 20 N of friction to the left act on a box. What is the net force on it?
5Ranking task 5
Newton’s third law
When two objects push on each other, how do the forces compare?
Newton’s third law says that forces come in pairs: “Whenever one body exerts a force on a second body, the first body experiences a force that is equal in magnitude and opposite in direction to the force that it exerts.” (OpenStax). On this screen two people on skateboards push off each other.
On this screen
- Rank the four people and check your ranking.
- In the simulation, push off with two people of different masses, then push off a wall.
- Test each person, change your ranking if you need to, and choose the reason for it.
- Answer the questions.
Four people on skateboards
Ranking taskThe ranking task loads here.
Push off
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
OpenStax gives a swimmer as an example. She “pushes against the pool wall with her feet and accelerates in the direction opposite to that of her push.” “The wall has exerted an equal and opposite force back on the swimmer.” In the same way, “a car accelerates because the ground pushes forward on the drive wheels”, and “rockets move forward by expelling gas backward at high velocity.” (OpenStax).
Newton’s third law
The two forces in a pair are equal in size and opposite in direction, and they act on different objects, so they don’t cancel. “You might think that two equal and opposite forces would cancel, but they do not because they act on different systems.” (OpenStax).
Each force accelerates the object it acts on. With forces of the same size, the object with less mass gets the bigger acceleration (a = F ÷ m), which is why the child moves off faster than the adult.
A truck and a small car collide head on. How does the force on the car compare with the force on the truck?
If the two forces in a pair are equal and opposite, why don’t they cancel each other out?
How does a rocket speed up in space, where there is no air to push against?
6Ranking task 6
Seatbelts, airbags and crumple zones
How do safety features reduce the force on people in a crash?
In a crash, everyone in the car has to stop. Their mass and their change in speed are set by the crash. From a = Δv ÷ Δt and F = m × a, the average force that stops a person is F = m × Δv ÷ Δt, so the longer the stop takes, the smaller the force. On this screen you crash-test cars with a dummy inside.
On this screen
- Rank the five crashes and check your ranking.
- In the simulation, crash with no seatbelt, then with the seatbelt and the crumple zone, then with the seatbelt and a rigid front.
- Test each crash, change your ranking if you need to, and choose the reason for it.
- Answer the questions.
Five crash tests
Ranking taskThe ranking task loads here.
A crash test
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
OpenStax explains that “The dashboard padding in a car, and certainly the airbags, allow the net force on the occupants in the car to act over a much longer time when there is a sudden stop.” A crumple zone works the same way for the whole car: “A longer collision time means the force on the car will be less.” OpenStax adds that “Deaths during car races decreased dramatically when the rigid frames of racing cars were replaced with parts that could crumple or collapse in the event of an accident.” With a seatbelt and an airbag, “(In effect, the driver collides with the seatbelt and airbag and not with the building.)” (OpenStax University Physics).
Making the stop take longer
Seatbelts, airbags and crumple zones don’t change how much a person’s speed changes in a crash. They make the stop take longer, so the average force needed to stop the person is smaller. OpenStax says of an airbag that the force “will be much less if it acts over a larger time”.
Speed matters too. The force is in proportion to the change in speed, so a crash at half the speed, with the same stopping time, needs half the force.
How does an airbag reduce the force on a driver in a crash?
Why are cars built with crumple zones that fold up in a crash?
7Ranking task 7
Stopping in time
How does a car’s speed change the distance it needs to stop?
A driver who sees a hazard takes time to react before they brake, and the car keeps going at full speed while they react. Then the brakes slow the car down. The stopping distance is the distance the car travels during the driver’s reaction time plus its braking distance.
On this screen
- Rank the five cars and check your ranking.
- In the simulation, drive at 40 km/h and at 60 km/h on a dry road, then drive on a wet road.
- Test each car, change your ranking if you need to, and choose the reason for it.
- Answer the questions.
Five cars
Ranking taskThe ranking task loads here.
A school crossing
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
The model gives the stopping distances that the Queensland Government publishes for “an average family car”, for example 45 m at 60 km/h on a dry road and 54 m on a wet road. Transport for NSW gives longer distances: “At 60km/h, that distance jumps to 56 metres.” Neither page says what reaction time or braking it assumes. Both agree that the distance grows quickly with speed.
Speed also changes what happens when a car can’t stop in time. Transport for NSW says that “there’s a 90% chance a pedestrian will survive if the car was travelling at 30km/h.” “There’s a 60% chance if the car was travelling at 40km/h, and a 10% chance at 50km/h.” In the Northern Territory, “You must drive at 40km/h or less in a school zone.” “This speed limit only applies on school days and during the times shown on the sign.” (NT Government). OpenStax also mentions school zones. Straight after explaining that a car going twice as fast needs much more than twice the distance to stop, it adds “(This is why we have reduced speed zones near schools.)”
Stopping in time
Stopping distance = reaction distance + braking distance. The reaction distance goes up in proportion to the speed. The braking distance goes up with the speed squared, because for a car that brakes to a stop, braking distance = v² ÷ (2 × deceleration), from v² = v0² + 2a(x − x0) (OpenStax).
So when the speed doubles, the braking distance goes up four times: “a car that is going twice as fast doesn’t simply stop in twice the distance” (OpenStax). On a wet road the brakes slow the car less quickly, so the braking distance is longer again.
On the same road, a car doubles its speed. What happens to its braking distance?
What happens to the car during the driver’s reaction time?
Which argument for a 40 km/h limit near schools does the simulation support?
8Ranking task 8
Spear-throwers
How does a spear-thrower make a spear go faster?
“Across mainland Australia and islands of the Torres Strait, a range of tools to increase the velocity and accuracy of projectiles was developed or produced by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples” (ACARA). On much of the mainland these included spear-throwers, and in the Torres Strait and nearby parts of northern Queensland, bows and arrows were used alongside spear-throwers (ACARA). On this screen you model a spear-thrower as a lever.
On this screen
- Rank the four throws and check your ranking.
- In the simulation, throw with the hand alone, then with a spear-thrower at least 50 cm long.
- Test each throw, change your ranking if you need to, and choose the reason for it.
- Answer the questions, then look at your results for the whole lesson.
Four throws
Ranking taskThe ranking task loads here.
A spear-thrower as a lever
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
ACARA’s background notes for teachers explain how a spear-thrower works. “Spear-throwers were effective as they provided an extension to the human thrower’s arm.” “A spear-thrower is an example of a lever”, and “as the farther end of the spear-thrower moves through a much greater distance than the nearer end but in the same amount of time, it moves at a much greater speed.” The peg at the far end pushes on the end of the spear, “allowing it to be propelled at a higher velocity than can be achieved by hand alone.”
In ACARA’s description the hand turns the spear-thrower about the wrist: “The effort force exerted by the thrower’s hand pivots around the wrist, acting as the fulcrum to move the spear positioned at the longer end of the thrower.” The simulation uses a simpler lever of its own. The arm and the spear-thrower turn together about the shoulder, so the spear-thrower makes the arm longer. The speeds in the simulation and the ranking task come from this model, and ACARA gives no speeds.
The extra speed has a cost: “The spear-thrower acts as a speed multiplier, which comes at a cost to the mass of the projectile that can be propelled in this way.” “Spears thrown with the aid of longer spear-throwers are therefore typically lighter” (ACARA). The notes describe spear-throwers made of hardwoods such as mulga, from about 50 cm to 100 cm long, and say that “Spear-thrower design, including its dimensions, was carefully refined and optimised for each individual user and carefully matched to the projectile type used.” A spear-thrower could also serve as a shield, a fire saw, a digging stick, a dish for mixing ochre, a carrying dish or a percussion instrument in ceremonies, and “Many examples of spear-throwers are elaborately decorated indicating their cultural significance.” (ACARA).
Newton’s laws and the spear
“The unbalanced force applied to a spear by the spear-thrower causes it to accelerate from rest.” (ACARA). That is the second law. The spear pushes back on the peg with a force of the same size, which is the third law.
“Once launched, the unbalanced forces acting on the spear are air resistance, causing it to slow down, and the Earth’s gravitational attraction, causing it to fall.” (ACARA). Nothing pushes the spear forward once it has left the spear-thrower. With no net force it would keep a constant velocity (first law), but air resistance and gravity give it a net force, so it slows down and falls.
Newton’s three laws
- First law. An object stays at rest, or keeps moving at a constant velocity, unless a net force acts on it.
- Second law. A net force makes an object accelerate in the direction of the force, with a = Fnet ÷ m.
- Third law. When two objects push or pull on each other, the two forces are equal in size, opposite in direction and act on different objects.
Why does a spear leave a spear-thrower faster than it leaves the hand alone?
Which forces act on a spear once it has left the spear-thrower?
While a spear-thrower pushes a spear forward, which statement is true?
Newton’s laws: ranking tasks and a trolley practical
Two pages: two ranking tasks on paper, with room to explain each ranking, and a practical that times a trolley pulled by a falling mass hanger over 0.50 m, with a results table, a graph grid and questions.
For teachers
Curriculum
Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 10, Science understanding, Physical sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:
AC9S10U05 investigate Newton’s laws of motion and quantitatively analyse the relationship between force, mass and acceleration of objects
- investigating a moving object to analyse and propose relationships between distance and time, speed, force and acceleration
- using mathematical representations including graphs and algebraic formulas to quantitatively relate force, speed, acceleration and mass
- investigating how First Nations Australians achieve an increase in speed and subsequent impact force through the use of spearthrowers and bows
- modelling how a change in net force acting on an object affects its motion and relating to the purpose of safety features such as seatbelts, airbags and crumple zones in vehicles
- investigating the application of Newton’s laws in sport and how these are applied to improve an athlete’s performance or safety
- constructing an argument, supported by data, to support lower speed limits near schools or for trucks in urban environments
- investigating how driverless vehicles apply Newton’s laws of motion to brake in time
The second quote gives ACARA’s seven elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each part of the content description is covered on these screens:
- Investigate Newton’s laws of motion: the first law on screen 1 (the air table), the second law on screens 3 and 4 (the fan cart and the box), the third law on screen 5 (the skateboarders), and all three on screen 8 (the spear); q-first, q-friction, q-inertia, q-double-force, q-double-mass, q-steady, q-truck, q-cancel, q-rocket, q-launch, q-laws.
- Quantitatively analyse the relationship between force, mass and acceleration: screen 2 (a = Δv ÷ Δt from dots and a speed–time graph), screen 3 (a table and a graph of acceleration against force for each mass, and a = F ÷ m), screen 4 (net force, then a = Fnet ÷ m), screen 5 (a = F ÷ m for each person) and screen 6 (F = m × Δv ÷ Δt); n-accel, n-fma, n-net, n-crash.
- The elaborations: a moving object’s distance, time, speed, force and acceleration on screens 1 to 3 (dots, the speed–time graph and the light gates); graphs and algebraic formulas on screens 2, 3, 6 and 7 (the speed–time graph, the acceleration graph, a = F ÷ m, F = m × Δv ÷ Δt, the stopping-distance graph and braking distance = v² ÷ (2 × deceleration)); spear-throwers on screen 8, with bows mentioned there; net force and seatbelts, airbags and crumple zones on screens 4 and 6; an argument with data for lower speed limits near schools on screen 7 (q-school). The lesson has no sport example, though the skateboarders on screen 5 and the throw on screen 8 come close, and it doesn’t cover driverless vehicles. Screen 7 splits stopping into a reaction phase and a braking phase, which gives students a way into discussing what a driverless car would need to detect and do.
The lesson also works on these content descriptions. Each ranking task asks students to predict before they test. Students can use the crash simulation to ask questions and write a hypothesis, as in ACARA’s example “asking questions about the relationship between crash impact force and speed and developing a hypothesis which can then be tested” (AC9S10I01). The model’s stopping times are the same at every speed, so its speed setting only shows the model’s own assumption, and testing the hypothesis needs real crash data. Students record runs in a table and read the graphs on screens 2, 3 and 7, and use the relationships a = F ÷ m and F = m × Δv ÷ Δt (AC9S10I04), which matches ACARA’s example “representing speed and acceleration data from investigations or simulations in tables and graphs and comparing how these facilitate the identification of relationships” (AC9S10I05). Screen 7 builds an argument for lower speed limits from the model and from published data (AC9S10I07). ACARA’s example “examining how the recent use of female crash test dummies has shown women are at greater risk of injury in a car accident and considering implications for changing car safety features” (AC9S10H02) can follow screen 6, with care. The model gives every person the same stopping time, so its force is in proportion to mass and a lighter person gets a smaller force. The model can’t explain the greater risk, so ask students what it leaves out.
AC9S10I01 develop investigable questions, reasoned predictions and hypotheses to test relationships and develop explanatory models
AC9S10I04 select and construct appropriate representations, including tables, graphs, descriptive statistics, models and mathematical relationships, to organise and process data and information
AC9S10I05 analyse and connect a variety of data and information to identify and explain patterns, trends, relationships and anomalies
AC9S10I07 construct arguments based on analysis of a variety of evidence to support conclusions or evaluate claims, and consider any ethical issues and cultural protocols associated with accessing, using or citing secondary data or information
AC9S10H02 investigate how advances in technologies enable advances in science, and how science has contributed to developments in technologies and engineering
How the lesson is taught
The lesson uses ranking tasks. On each screen students rank four or five cases that differ in one or two ways, check their ranking and keep their first one. Then they test each case in the screen’s simulation, which shows the measurement on the case’s card, change their ranking if they need to, and choose the reason for it from three or four. Most wrong reasons are built on a wrong idea about force, such as a force that keeps a puck moving, or a person who pushes getting less force than the person pushed. The screen’s key ideas open when the ranking is right, the reason is right and the simulation’s tasks are done.
PhysPort names Thomas O’Kuma, David Maloney and Curtis Hieggelke as the developers of ranking tasks, whose collection is Ranking Task Exercises in Physics (2000). PhysPort describes ranking tasks as designed to bring out students’ own ideas about how physical systems behave, rather than an answer they have learned by heart. Hudgins and colleagues (2006) write that ranking tasks were “first described in the field of physics education research by David Maloney (1987)” and then developed as classroom material in that book. They add that “Typically, ranking tasks present learners with a series of four to eight pictures or diagrams that describe several slightly different variations of a basic physical situation.” Cox, Belloni and Christian (2005) combined ranking tasks with simulations “to enhance students’ interactive engagement in introductory physics”, which is the approach on every screen here.
The evidence is limited. PhysPort rates ranking tasks as research-based, which it calls “the lowest level of research validation”, and says that “there is no research on the impact of the final collection on student learning.” Hudgins and colleagues studied 253 students in an introductory astronomy course for non-science majors at the University of Arizona, where “average scores on multiple-choice tests across the eight astronomy topics increased from 32% before instruction, to 61% after traditional instruction, to 77% after the ranking-task exercises.” The 77% came from “a second bank of 28 multiple-choice questions”, which “were carefully designed to be conceptually similar” to the first. The normalised gains were 0.42 for traditional instruction and 0.41 for the ranking tasks. The authors note that “in this one-group design, we cannot say conclusively that the gains reported here are due strictly to incorporating a program of ranking tasks”, and that “We recognize that perhaps some gains might result from simply extending the lecture.” They also report that “83% of students believed that ranking tasks contributed positively to their learning”. Those students were older than Year 10, and the topic was astronomy, not mechanics.
The tasks work best with talk. Before students check a ranking, ask them to explain it to a partner, and after testing, ask what made them change it. Plan for about two lessons of 50 to 60 minutes: screens 1 to 4, then screens 5 to 8. The trolley practical on the printable sheet needs about 30 minutes more.
Handle with care
- Clement (1982) found that “many physics students have a stable, alternative view of the relationship between force and acceleration”, which he traces to “a deep-seated preconception that makes a full understanding of Newton’s first and second laws very difficult.” Ranking task 1 and the reasons on screens 1 and 8 test the idea that a moving object needs a force to keep it moving. Robertson and colleagues (2022) are more cautious. They write that “Perhaps the most commonly cited student idea about forces in the literature is the notion of an impetus force”, but among the 644 students who answered their coin toss question, in introductory physics courses at six universities in the United States, “the frequency of impetus-like drawings in our study both (a) is consistently less than reported in previous studies and (b) varies across samples”. The students answered “after relevant instruction about forces and motion”, in courses the authors describe as “PER-informed” (informed by physics education research), and Year 10 students may differ. So don’t assume every student holds the idea; the first rankings show who does.
- Mass and weight: OpenStax notes that “Mass and weight are often used interchangeably in everyday language.” “However, in science, these terms are distinctly different from one another.” The lesson gives mass in kilograms and weight in newtons, with the weight of a 1.0 kg object on Earth as 9.8 N (OpenStax). The printable practical uses this to work out the force from the hanging masses.
- The first law is about constant velocity, which includes direction. The lesson’s examples all move in straight lines, but the word list says that changing direction is also an acceleration.
- The crash simulation’s stopping times are the lesson’s own values, chosen to show what each safety feature does, and so are the forces they give. They are not measurements of real crashes, and they are the same at every speed.
- Some students may have been affected by a road crash. The school crossing screen uses a ball, not a person, and gives Transport for NSW’s pedestrian survival figures in words.
- Screen 8 uses only ACARA’s background notes for teachers about spear-throwers (Version 8.4). That page says its consulted works are “not provided or recommended by ACARA as classroom resources”, that “they can also be problematic as they are often based on non-Indigenous interpretations”, and that “some of the sources listed in the consulted works may contain material that is considered culturally offensive or inappropriate”. The lesson uses the general term spear-thrower, and its drawing is a plain lever with no decoration. Where you can, invite local Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people to share their own knowledge of spear-throwers or bows, and follow your school’s and community’s protocols.
- ACARA classes the spear-thrower as “a first-order lever” when the arm and wrist action are included, with the hand pivoting about the wrist, and notes that “Since the spear-throwing process involves a series of levers, defining which class of lever applies is often debated.” The simulation is a simpler lever of the lesson’s own: the arm and spear-thrower turn together about the shoulder, so the spear-thrower makes the arm longer. It also keeps the same spear and the same swing time for every spear-thrower length. A real thrower uses the whole body, and a longer, heavier spear-thrower is harder to swing. ACARA notes that the extra speed comes at a cost to the mass of the spear, that “Spears thrown with the aid of longer spear-throwers are therefore typically lighter”, and that “spears thrown by spear-throwers need to be lighter than spears thrown by hand”.
About the models
- Screen 1: an air table 2 m long. With the air on there is no friction. With the air off, friction slows a sliding puck by 3 m/s every second, which is 0.3 N on the light puck (0.1 kg) and 1.2 N on the heavy puck (0.4 kg), and holds a puck at rest against a smaller push. A flick pushes with 0.8 N for 0.25 s, which sends the light puck off at 2 m/s and the heavy puck at 0.5 m/s. The cushions push the puck back like stiff springs, so it bounces off at the same speed. The tests start each puck at 0.25 m and measure the net force for up to 0.6 s, before it reaches a cushion. These are the model’s own values.
- Screen 2: each run lasts 8 s and plays at twice real speed. The car’s speed changes by the chosen amount every second, and a car that slows to a stop stays stopped. The graph keeps the last five runs. The ranking task’s dots, on the cards, are worked out the same way.
- Screen 3: a = F ÷ m, with no friction. The light gates’ time is √(2 × 1.0 m ÷ a), given to 0.001 s, and the acceleration in the table is 2 × 1.0 m ÷ t², worked out from that time. The cart is 1 kg and each block adds 1 kg. Each mass’s dashed line on the graph goes through zero with a slope of 1 ÷ mass, and every run for that mass lies on it, because the model has no measurement error. The table keeps 12 runs, and a run with no force is recorded with an acceleration of 0.
- Screen 4: friction has the chosen size while the box slides. A box at rest stays at rest until the push is bigger than that size, and until then friction matches the push; the model uses one friction value for a box at rest and a sliding box. The weight is the mass × 9.8 N/kg. A run lasts 3 s, or less if the box reaches 10 m/s. The free-body diagram draws all four forces to the same scale. The tests start each box sliding at 1 m/s and measure its change in speed over 2 s.
- Screen 5: the people are 40, 60 and 80 kg, and the push lasts 0.5 s, played at 0.3 times real speed so the pair of forces can be seen. There is no friction, and the wall is fixed to the ground. The tests use a 120 N push, as in the ranking task.
- Screen 6: the dummy is 75 kg. With a rigid front the car stops in 0.04 s, and with a crumple zone in 0.10 s. With a seatbelt the dummy stops 0.03 s after the car, and an airbag adds another 0.03 s. Without a seatbelt the model treats the dummy as stopping from the car’s full speed in 0.01 s (0.04 s against an airbag), whether or not the car has a crumple zone. The stopping times are the same at every speed. The average force is 75 kg × the car’s speed ÷ the dummy’s stopping time, with the speed in m/s given to 4 significant figures, so in the ranking task it is about 8,010 N (A), 3,260 N (B), 104,000 N (C), 6,510 N (D) and 14,900 N (E). The drawing isn’t to scale. It stretches or shrinks the dummy’s movement so that the head ends against the airbag or the windscreen. The crash plays 20 times slower than real time.
- Screen 7: the driver takes 1.5 s to react, then the brakes slow the car by 6.9 m/s every second on a dry road and 4.75 m/s every second on a wet road. These values give Queensland’s published stopping distances to within 1 m at every speed in its table from 40 km/h to 100 km/h, and about 1.1 m more at 110 km/h on a wet road. The readings round each part to a whole metre and add the parts, so the sum adds up as written; at 40, 50, 60 and 70 km/h they give Queensland’s figures exactly. The driver sees the ball when the car is 40 m from the crossing, and a run plays at 1.5 times real speed.
- Screen 8: ACARA’s lever pivots at the wrist, and the model is a simpler lever that turns about the shoulder. The arm is 0.7 m from the shoulder to the hand, every throw uses the same spear, and the arm and the spear-thrower turn through 90° in 0.2 s, or in two thirds of that time with the faster swing. The peg’s speed is the rate of turning × its distance from the shoulder, so a 50 cm spear-thrower gives 1.2 ÷ 0.7, about 1.7 times the hand’s speed, and a 100 cm one 1.7 ÷ 0.7, about 2.4 times. In 90° of turning the hand moves 1.1 m and the peg of a 100 cm spear-thrower moves 2.7 m. The spear leaves at 20° above the horizontal, and in flight gravity and an air resistance that grows with its speed act on it. The swing plays 8 times slower and the flight 3 times slower than real time. The model gives speeds as multiples of the hand alone, not in metres per second. These are the model’s own values, and ACARA gives no speeds.
- With reduced motion, each run is worked out at once and the drawing shows how it ends. On screen 1, where the puck keeps moving, each change runs the model on for 1.5 s and the Run on button runs it further.
Where sources disagree and what to check
- Stopping distances: Transport for NSW gives 27 m at 40 km/h, 37 m at 50 km/h and 56 m at 60 km/h, longer than Queensland’s 26 m, 35 m and 45 m on a dry road. NSW’s 56 m is close to Queensland’s 54 m on a wet road. Neither page says what reaction time or braking it assumes. The lesson follows Queensland’s table.
- OpenStax’s worked example (College Physics 2e, Example 2.12) uses a reaction time of 0.500 s and decelerations of 7.00 m/s² on dry concrete and 5.00 m/s² on wet concrete. Queensland’s table fits a reaction time of about 1.5 s and decelerations of about 6.9 and 4.75 m/s².
- OpenStax University Physics’s worked example on a crash has much longer times than the lesson’s model. It says that “The collision with the building causes the car to come to a stop in approximately 1 second.” With a seatbelt and airbag the driver “comes to a stop in approximately 2.5 s”, and “Without the seatbelt and airbag, his collision time (with the steering wheel) would have been approximately 0.20 s.” The lesson’s model uses its own values of 0.10 s for a car with a crumple zone, 0.16 s for a dummy with a seatbelt and airbag, and 0.01 s without a seatbelt.
- ACARA’s spear-thrower notes are from the Version 8.4 teacher background information for a Year 7 elaboration on simple machines. Version 9 has a similar Year 7 elaboration (AC9S7U04) as well as this Year 10 one.
- A measured result is smaller than the model’s multiples. Bebber and colleagues (2023) asked 108 volunteers from a university community in the United States, none of whom had used either before, to throw darts with a spear-thrower (an atlatl) 66.5 cm long and javelins by hand: “Mean dart velocity (x̅ = 16.2 m/s) is 65% faster than mean javelin velocity (x̅ = 9.8 m/s).” For a spear-thrower of that length the model gives about 1.95 times the hand’s speed, with the same spear and the same swing.
Answers at a glance
- Screen 1: the ranking is A = B = C = D, because each puck is at rest or moving at a constant velocity, so the net force on each is zero. q-first zero; q-friction friction acts on it, against its motion; q-inertia the heavy puck has more inertia, because it has more mass.
- Screen 2: C > D > B > A (3, 2, 1 and 0 m/s²), ranking by the change in speed each second, whether up or down. q-trail speeding up; q-decel west, opposite to the motion; n-accel 20 ÷ 8 = 2.5 m/s².
- Screen 3: B > A = D = E > C (10, 5, 5, 5 and 2.5 m/s²), dividing each force by its mass. q-double-force it doubles; q-double-mass it is half as big; n-fma 1500 × 2 = 3000 N.
- Screen 4: D > A = C = E > B (3, 2, 2, 2 and 0 m/s²), subtracting the friction from the push and dividing by the mass. q-steady they are equal in size; q-net 30 N to the right; n-net (60 − 15) ÷ 5 = 9 m/s².
- Screen 5: A = D > C > B (3, 3, 2 and 1.5 m/s²), because each person in a pair gets a force of the same size. q-truck they are equal in size; q-cancel they act on different objects; q-rocket it pushes gas backwards, and the gas pushes the rocket forwards.
- Screen 6: C > E > A > D > B, because each safety feature makes the stop take longer, and half the speed, with the same stopping time, needs half the force. q-airbag it makes the driver’s stop take longer; q-crumple so the car takes longer to stop, which reduces the force; n-crash 70 × 14 ÷ 0.1 = 9800 N.
- Screen 7: D > B > C > E > A (54, 45, 41, 35 and 26 m), because speed matters most and a wet road makes the braking distance longer. q-double-speed it goes up four times; q-reaction it keeps going at the same speed; q-school a car at 40 km/h stops in a much shorter distance, and if it can’t stop in time it hits more slowly.
- Screen 8: C > B > D > A (2.4, 1.7, 1.5 and 1 times the hand alone), because the far end of a longer lever moves through a bigger distance in the same time. q-lever the far end of the spear-thrower moves through a bigger distance in the same time; q-launch air resistance and gravity; q-laws the spear pushes back on the peg with a force of the same size.
- Printable sheet, ranking task 1: C = D > A = E > B (4, 4, 3, 3 and 2 m/s²). Ranking task 2, by the size of the net force: A > E > C > D > B (8, 7, 6, 5 and 0 N). In the practical, the net forces on the trolley and hanger together are 0.98, 1.47, 1.96, 2.45 and 2.94 N, and the graph should be close to a straight line: twice the force gives about twice the acceleration. Moving masses from the trolley to the hanger keeps the total mass that is accelerated the same, so only the force changes (question 2). Friction makes every acceleration a little smaller, so a line through the points crosses the force axis to the right of zero, and the smallest force might not move the trolley at all (question 3). Light gates or more repeats make the times more precise (question 4).
Saved progress
Rankings, answers, records and settings are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere.
References
- Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) (2022). Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Years 7 to 10 curriculum content. Australian Curriculum website.
- Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) (n.d.). Teacher background information: investigating the effect of forces through the application of simple machines, such as the bow and arrows used by Torres Strait Islander Peoples or the spear throwers used by Aboriginal Peoples. Australian Curriculum, Version 8.4.
- Bebber, M. R., Buchanan, B., Eren, M. I., Walker, R. S. and Zirkle, D. (2023). Atlatl use equalizes female and male projectile weapon velocity. Scientific Reports, 13, 13349. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41598-023-40451-8.
- Clement, J. (1982). Students’ preconceptions in introductory mechanics. American Journal of Physics, 50(1), 66–71. https://doi.org/10.1119/1.12989.
- Cox, A. J., Belloni, M. and Christian, W. (2005). Teaching physics with Physlet-based ranking task exercises. The Physics Teacher, 43(9), 587–592. https://doi.org/10.1119/1.2136455.
- Hudgins, D. W., Prather, E. E., Grayson, D. J. and Smits, D. P. (2006). Effectiveness of collaborative ranking tasks on student understanding of key astronomy concepts. Astronomy Education Review, 5(1), 1–22. https://doi.org/10.3847/AER2006001.
- Ling, S. J., Sanny, J. and Moebs, W. (2016). University Physics Volume 1. OpenStax. Section 9.2 Impulse and collisions.
- Northern Territory Government (n.d.). Speed limits.
- O’Kuma, T. L., Maloney, D. P. and Hieggelke, C. J. (2000). Ranking Task Exercises in Physics. Upper Saddle River, NJ: Prentice Hall.
- PhysPort (n.d.). Ranking task exercises in physics.
- Queensland Government, Department of Transport and Main Roads (2016). Stopping distances on wet and dry roads. Last updated 14 November 2016.
- Robertson, A. D., Goodhew, L. M., Heron, P. R. L. and Scherr, R. E. (2022). Impetus-force-like drawings may be less common than you think. The Physics Teacher, 60(4), 254–257. https://doi.org/10.1119/5.0027858.
- Transport for NSW (n.d.). Speeding.
- Urone, P. P. and Hinrichs, R. (2022). College Physics 2e. OpenStax. Sections 2.3 Time, velocity, and speed, 2.4 Acceleration, 2.5 Motion equations for constant acceleration in one dimension, 4.2 Newton’s first law of motion: inertia, 4.3 Newton’s second law of motion: concept of a system, 4.4 Newton’s third law of motion: symmetry in forces and 8.2 Impulse.
Sources by screen
- Method: PhysPort; O’Kuma, Maloney and Hieggelke (2000), as described by PhysPort; Hudgins and colleagues (2006); Cox, Belloni and Christian (2005).
- Screen 1: OpenStax College Physics 2e, 4.2 (the first law, the air hockey table and inertia).
- Screen 2: OpenStax College Physics 2e, 2.3 (speed and velocity) and 2.4 (acceleration and slowing down).
- Screen 3: OpenStax College Physics 2e, 4.3 (the second law and the newton) and 2.5 (x = x0 + v0t + ½at²).
- Screen 4: OpenStax College Physics 2e, 4.3 (net external force, weight and the difference between mass and weight).
- Screen 5: OpenStax College Physics 2e, 4.4 (the third law, the swimmer, the car’s drive wheels and rockets).
- Screen 6: OpenStax College Physics 2e, 8.2 (padding, airbags, crumple zones and racing cars); OpenStax University Physics Volume 1, 9.2 (seatbelts and airbags).
- Screen 7: Queensland Government, Department of Transport and Main Roads (stopping distances); Transport for NSW (stopping distances and pedestrian survival); Northern Territory Government (school zones); OpenStax College Physics 2e, 2.5 (Example 2.12 and v² = v0² + 2a(x − x0)).
- Screen 8: ACARA, Version 8.4 teacher background information on spear-throwers and bows; Bebber and colleagues (2023), in Where sources disagree.
- Printable sheet: OpenStax College Physics 2e, 2.5 (the time over a distance from rest) and 4.3 (weight on Earth).
- Handle with care: Clement (1982); Robertson and colleagues (2022); OpenStax College Physics 2e, 4.3; ACARA, Version 8.4 teacher background information.
- Word list: the sources for the screen where each word is first used.