AusSci

Year 2 science · Chemical sciences · AC9S2U03

Is it still the same material?

1Change and compare

Change the paper

If you change the shape of paper, is it still paper?

Paper is a material. You can change its shape in lots of ways. In this lesson you change materials, then compare them before and after.

How this lesson works. On every screen you change a material. Then you compare: what is the same, and what is different? Your teacher may show the screen to the class while you and a partner talk about what you see.

On this screen

  1. Change a sheet of paper in five ways.
  2. Do the three tasks.
  3. Read the key idea.
  4. Change a real sheet of paper.

Compare: before and after

A new sheet of paper is on the left. Change the sheet on the right, then compare the two. What is the same? What is different?

Press a button to change the sheet on the right. You can fold it, scrunch it, twist it, tear it or cut it. The sheet on the left stays as it was, so that you can compare the two. The table writes down the new shape and how many pieces there are.

After each change, look at the paper. In the table, press what material it is now. A change to the shape of a material is called a physical change.

One sheet of paper, changed five ways

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Change the paper in all five ways.

    Need a hint?

    Press each of the five buttons above the picture: Fold it, Scrunch it, Twist it, Tear it and Cut it.

  2. After each change, say what material it is now.

    Need a hint?

    In the table, each change has two buttons. Look at the picture, then press Paper or A new material.

  3. Find which changes made more pieces.

    Need a hint?

    Read down the Pieces column of your table. Then answer the question under it.

Talk about it. You scrunch a sheet of paper, then smooth it flat again. Is it the same as it was before? What is the same, and what is different?

Still paper

You folded, scrunched, twisted, tore and cut the paper. Each change gave the paper a new shape. Tearing and cutting made more pieces.

After every change it was still paper. It was still thin and white, and you could still write on it.

A change like this is called a physical change. The shape changes. The material stays the same.

Now for real

Change a real sheet of paper

Do this with real things. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • Five sheets of white paper
  • Scissors with round ends

What to do

  1. Keep one sheet flat. Fold one. Scrunch one. Twist one. Tear one, then cut it.
  2. Put them in a row. What is the same about all of them?
  3. Open out the scrunched sheet and the twisted sheet. Write your name on every sheet. Can you still write on it?

Take care. Carry scissors with the points down, and cut away from your fingers. Put the scraps in the paper recycling.

My notebook

You tear a sheet of paper into small pieces. What are the pieces made of?

Which of these changes the shape of paper and keeps it in one piece?

2Change and compare

Bend, twist, stretch

What happens to a material when you bend, twist or stretch it?

You can bend, twist and stretch some materials. Some spring back to their old shape when you let go. Some stay in their new shape.

On this screen

  1. Bend, twist and stretch four things.
  2. Do the three tasks.
  3. Read the key idea.
  4. Test real things.

Compare: before and after you let go

Bend, twist and stretch four things. Compare each one before you change it and after you let go. Does it spring back, or stay in its new shape?

Choose a thing. Before you press a button, say what you think will happen when you let go. Then press the button to bend it, twist it or stretch it. Was it what you thought? The table writes down each result.

Four things to bend, twist and stretch

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Bend, twist and stretch all four things.

    Need a hint?

    Choose a thing, then press Bend it, Twist it and Stretch it. Do the same for the other three. Your table shows which tests are left.

  2. Find a thing that stays in its new shape.

    Need a hint?

    Read across your table for a row that says Stays in its new shape. Then answer the first question under it.

  3. Say what the play dough is after you stretch it.

    Need a hint?

    Stretch the play dough and look at the picture. Its shape is new. Is its material new? Then answer the last question.

Talk about it. Think of something at home that springs back when you squash it, and something that stays squashed. What is each one made of?

A new shape, the same material

Bending, twisting and stretching change the shape of a material.

The rubber band sprang back every time. The play dough stayed in its new shape every time. The pipe cleaner stayed bent and twisted, and it did not stretch. The plastic ruler sprang back, and it did not stretch.

After every test, each thing was still made of the same material. The long, thin play dough was still play dough.

Now for real

Bend, twist and stretch real things

Do this with real things. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • A thick rubber band
  • A ball of play dough
  • A pipe cleaner
  • A plastic ruler

What to do

  1. Before each test, tell your partner what you think will happen.
  2. Bend each thing gently, then let go. What happens?
  3. Twist each thing gently, then let go.
  4. Pull gently on the ends of each thing, then let go.
  5. Sort them: which spring back, and which stay in a new shape?

Take care. Stretch the rubber band slowly, pointing down at the table. Never flick it. Bend the ruler only a little, so that it does not snap. The ends of a pipe cleaner are sharp wire. Play dough is not for eating. Tell your teacher if you have an allergy to wheat, rubber or latex.

My notebook

You stretch a rubber band, then let go. What happens?

You roll a ball of play dough into a long snake. What has changed?

3Change and compare

Crush the chalk

Is chalk powder still chalk?

You can break a material into smaller pieces. If you crush it, the pieces get so tiny that they make a powder. Is the powder still the same material?

On this screen

  1. Crush a stick of chalk on the screen.
  2. Compare the stick and the powder.
  3. Do the three tasks.
  4. Read the key idea.
  5. Crush real chalk in a sealed bag.

Compare: the stick and the powder

There are two sticks of chalk. Keep one. Crush the other into a powder. Then compare the stick and the powder, one property at a time.

There are two sticks of chalk. Break one, then crush it. It stays inside a sealed bag, so that no dust gets into the air. Then test the stick and the powder. Each test compares one property.

In each row of the table, press Same or Different.

A stick of chalk and its powder

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Break one stick of chalk, then crush it.

    Need a hint?

    Press Break the stick, then Crush the pieces. The chalk stays inside the bag.

  2. Compare the stick and the powder in four ways.

    Need a hint?

    Press the three test buttons. Then, in each row of the table, press Same or Different.

  3. Decide what the powder is.

    Need a hint?

    Look at the rows where you pressed Same. Then answer the question under the table.

Talk about it. Sugar comes as cubes, as grains and as a fine powder. Are they all still sugar? How could you tell?

Still chalk

The stick and the powder have different shapes. The stick is one long piece. The powder is lots of tiny pieces, so it pours.

The stick and the powder are the same colour, and both make a white mark on a board.

The powder is still chalk. Crushing is a physical change. It changes the shape and the size of the pieces. It does not change the material.

A powder pours, but it is not a liquid. Each tiny piece is a solid.

Now for real

Crush a real stick of chalk

Do this with real things. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • Two sticks of white chalk
  • A strong zip bag that seals
  • A metal spoon
  • A sheet of dark paper

What to do

  1. Put one stick in the bag and seal it. Keep the other stick.
  2. Break the stick inside the bag. Then press on the pieces with the back of the spoon.
  3. Compare the stick and the powder through the bag. What is the same? What is different?
  4. Your teacher opens the bag and rubs a little powder on the dark paper. What do you see?

Take care. Keep the bag sealed, so that no dust gets into the air. Do not open the bag yourself, and do not blow or sniff the powder. Chalk dust can make it hard for some people to breathe. Wash your hands afterwards.

My notebook

You crush a stick of chalk into a powder. What is the powder made of?

What is different about the stick and the powder?

4Change and compare

Change it for a job

How can a new shape make a material more useful?

People change the shape of a material to make it do a job. Twisting makes wool into thread. Folding makes paper into a plane.

On this screen

  1. Twist wool and pull on it.
  2. Fold paper and throw it.
  3. Do the three tasks.
  4. Read the key idea.
  5. Twist a real thread and fold a real plane.

Compare: changed and not changed

People change the shape of a material to make it do a job. Compare wool that is twisted with wool that is not. Then compare paper that is folded with paper that is flat.

Wool is made of thin fibres. Choose Twist wool. Pick how much the fibres are twisted, then press Pull.

Then choose Fold paper. Pick a flat sheet or a folded plane, then press Throw. The tables write down what happens.

Twist wool, fold paper

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Pull on wool with no twist, a little twist and a lot of twist.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Twist wool. Choose each kind of wool in turn, and press Pull each time.

  2. Throw a flat sheet of paper and a paper plane.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Fold paper. Choose the flat sheet and press Throw. Then choose the plane and press Throw.

  3. Say what folding changed.

    Need a hint?

    Look at the Material column in the second table. Did the material change, or the shape? Then answer the question.

Talk about it. A rope is made of many thin strands twisted together. Why do you think it is made that way?

A new shape for a job

Wool fibres that are not twisted slide apart. Twisting holds the fibres together. More twist makes the thread harder to pull apart, up to a point.

A flat sheet of paper is floppy. Folding gives the paper a new shape. The folds make it stiff and put its weight in the right place, so the plane can glide.

Twisting and folding are physical changes. The thread is still wool. The plane is still paper.

Now for real

Twist a thread and fold a plane

Do this with real things. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • A ball of cotton wool, which is made of cotton fibres
  • Two sheets of paper
  • A clear space to throw in

What to do

  1. Pull a small tuft from the cotton wool ball. Pull its ends. What happens?
  2. Pull out another tuft. This time, twist it between your fingers as you pull, to make a thread. Pull the ends of the thread.
  3. Throw a flat sheet of paper. Then fold a sheet into a plane and throw it the same way.
  4. Which change made the thread stronger? Which change made the paper fly?

Take care. Keep cotton wool away from your mouth, nose and ears. Throw the plane only in the clear space, away from faces. Wait until no one is in front of you.

My notebook

Why are wool fibres twisted together to make thread?

You fold a sheet of paper into a plane. What is the plane made of?

5Change and compare

Twisting and bending

How do First Nations Australians change natural materials to make things?

For thousands of years, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples have taken natural materials from their environment. They have changed the materials to make things such as shelters, fishing nets, baskets and canoes.

On this screen

  1. Match five natural materials to the change that is made to each.
  2. Do the three tasks.
  3. Read the key idea.

Bending and twisting are physical changes. ACARA is the group that writes the Australian Curriculum. ACARA says that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples have long used bending and twisting to make things. ACARA says that cultural practices are ongoing, so these knowledges continue.

What this screen says comes from ACARA’s notes for teachers. The pictures show only plain materials changing shape. No people, shelters, canoes or baskets are drawn. ACARA’s notes say that the natural materials used to make string differ from region to region. Ask your teacher who your class could ask about the Country or Place you live on.

Compare: five changes

First Nations Australians change natural materials by twisting and bending them. These knowledges are thousands of years old, and they are used today. Match five materials to the change that is made to each.

Choose a material and read about it under the picture. Then press the change: Twist or Bend. The table keeps each match. A strand is one long, thin piece of string. A sapling is a young tree.

Five natural materials, two changes

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Match all five materials to their change.

    Need a hint?

    Choose a material and read about it under the picture. Then press Twist or Bend.

  2. Name the two changes on this screen.

    Need a hint?

    Read down the Change column of your table. Then answer the first question under it.

  3. Say what the bent saplings are made of.

    Need a hint?

    Bending changes the shape of a sapling. Does it change the material? Then answer the last question.

Talk about it. Which natural materials near where you live could be twisted or bent? Who could your class ask about them?

Twisted and bent

Twisting changes strands of string into two-ply string and three-ply rope. The Guugu Yimithirr Peoples of far north Queensland form two-ply string. The Yolŋu Peoples of north eastern Arnhem Land in the Northern Territory make three-ply rope.

Bending changes the shape of saplings, bark and lawyer cane. The Bama Peoples of the rainforest region in far north Queensland make arched shelters from saplings that are bent towards each other. The Wik Mungkan Peoples of the Cape York Peninsula region in Queensland make bark canoes from bark that is bent into shape.

Twisting and bending are physical changes. The string, the saplings, the bark and the cane each have a new shape. Each is still the same material.

My notebook

The Yolŋu Peoples make three-ply rope from three strands of string. Which change makes the strands into rope?

A sheet of bark is held over a fire until it can be bent into shape. After it is bent, what is it made of?

6Change and compare

Odd one out

Which one is made of a different material?

A material can look very different after its shape is changed. In this game, three things are the same material in different shapes. One is a different material. Can you find it?

On this screen

  1. Play four rounds of odd one out.
  2. Do the three tasks.
  3. Read the key idea.
  4. Make your own game.
  5. Answer the last two questions and look at your results.

Compare: four things at a time

In each round, three things are the same material, changed in different ways. One is a different material. Compare all four and find the odd one out.

Look at the four things in the round. Press the letter of the odd one out. Then press why it is the odd one. The table keeps your answers.

Odd one out: four rounds

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Find the odd one out in all four rounds.

    Need a hint?

    Look at what each thing is like: shiny or dull, soft or hard, smooth or fuzzy. Three are alike. Press the one that is made of something else.

  2. Give the reason each time.

    Need a hint?

    Three of the things have different shapes, but they are the same material. What makes the odd one different from all three?

  3. Say what was different about the three that match.

    Need a hint?

    Read the Three the same column of your table. They are the same material. What did the changes do to them?

Talk about it. Could a different one be the odd one out for another reason? Tell your partner your reason.

Look past the shape

In every round, three things were the same material. They had been changed in different ways, so they had different shapes.

The odd one out was made of a different material. To find it, look past the shape. The paper ball and the foil ball were both balls, but they were different materials. Look at what each thing is like: shiny or dull, soft or hard, smooth or fuzzy. In round 4 all four things were red, so colour did not help.

Bending, twisting, stretching, scrunching, tearing, cutting and crushing are physical changes. They change the shape of a material. They do not change what the material is.

Now for real

Make your own odd one out game

Do this with real things. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • One material to change, such as paper, play dough or wool
  • A little of a different material
  • The printable game sheet

What to do

  1. Change your material in three different ways. Choose changes that stay when you let go. You could fold, scrunch, twist, stretch, tear or cut it.
  2. Add one thing made of a different material.
  3. Put all four in a row. Ask a partner to find the odd one out and to say why.
  4. Swap, and play your partner’s game.

Take care. Use scissors with round ends, and carry them with the points down. Do not use chalk powder, sand, glass or anything sharp in your game.

My notebook

Here are four things: a flat sheet of paper, a scrunched paper ball, torn pieces of paper and a ball of foil. Which one is made of a different material?

A rubber band is stretched, twisted and then let go. What stays the same the whole time?

Printable activity

My odd one out game

Two pages for making and playing a real odd one out game. Page 1 is for planning your game: one material changed in three ways, and one different material. Page 2 is for playing a partner’s game and saying what you found out.

For teachers

Curriculum

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 2, Science understanding, Chemical sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:

AC9S2U03 recognise that materials can be changed physically without changing their material composition and explore the effect of different actions on materials including bending, twisting, stretching and breaking into smaller pieces

  • exploring how materials can be physically changed to suit a particular purpose, such as twisting strands of cotton or wool together to make the thread stronger, or folding paper to make it fly
  • manipulating materials such as paper or fabric, and determining ways they can be physically changed by scrunching, twisting or bending, or broken into smaller pieces by cutting, tearing or crushing
  • crushing a stick of chalk into a powder, comparing the properties of the stick and the powder, and discussing whether it is still the same material
  • exploring how First Nations Australians make physical changes to natural materials to produce objects such as bowls, baskets and various fibre crafts
  • creating an ‘odd one out’ game by providing samples of the same material that has been physically changed in different ways, and one sample of a different material, and challenging other students to identify the odd one out

The second quote gives all five of ACARA’s elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each one has a screen:

  • Changing a material to suit a purpose, with thread and a paper plane as the examples: screen 4 pulls on wool that is twisted and not twisted, and throws paper that is folded and flat; q-thread and q-plane.
  • Scrunching, twisting and bending, and breaking into smaller pieces by cutting, tearing or crushing: screen 1 changes a sheet of paper in five ways, and screen 2 bends, twists and stretches four things; q-torn, q-fold, q-spring and q-dough. The lesson uses paper and not fabric.
  • Crushing a stick of chalk, comparing the stick with the powder and discussing whether it is still the same material: screen 3; q-powder and q-pour.
  • How First Nations Australians make physical changes to natural materials: screen 5; q-rope and q-bark. The elaboration gives bowls, baskets and fibre crafts as its examples. ACARA’s background page for it has no sentence about bowls, so the screen has none. It has string, rope and a basket frame, and the shelters and canoes that the same page describes.
  • The odd one out game: students play four rounds on screen 6, and the elaboration asks them to create a game, which the real activity and the printable sheet are for; q-odd and q-three.

The lesson also works on parts of these content descriptions. On screen 2 students say what they think will happen before each test and then check, which is the prediction half of AC9S2I01 and the comparison with predictions in AC9S2I05. They do not pose their own questions, and nothing in the lesson asks whether a test is fair. They follow the steps of each real activity with its care line, which is the ‘follow’ half of AC9S2I02: the lesson does not ask them to suggest a procedure. They record in the notebook boxes and on the printable sheet, but the lesson has no informal measurements (AC9S2I03). Every screen has a results table to read and use, and the real activity on screen 2 ends with a sort (AC9S2I04). Screens 4 and 5 describe people changing the shape of a material to make it do a job, which is part of AC9S2H01. The lesson does not use patterns to make predictions.

AC9S2H01 describe how people use science in their daily lives, including using patterns to make scientific predictions

AC9S2I01 pose questions to explore observed simple patterns and relationships and make predictions based on experiences

AC9S2I02 suggest and follow safe procedures to investigate questions and test predictions

AC9S2I03 make and record observations, including informal measurements, using digital tools as appropriate

AC9S2I04 sort and order data and information and represent patterns, including with provided tables and visual or physical models

AC9S2I05 compare observations with predictions and others’ observations, consider if investigations are fair and identify further questions with guidance

Melting, freezing and dissolving are also physical changes, and they are left for later years. The site’s Year 3 lesson on solids and liquids takes up melting, and has a screen on why sand is a solid.

How the lesson is taught

The method is comparing cases. On every screen students change a material and then put two or more cases side by side: a sheet of paper before and after, a thing before it is bent and after they let go, a stick of chalk and its powder, wool that is twisted and wool that is not, and four things in each round of the game. Each time they say what is the same and what is different. The lesson ends with an odd one out game because ACARA’s fifth elaboration is one. At Year 2 the lesson is meant to be led by the teacher, with a screen shown to the class or shared by a pair, and with the real activities done by hand.

The research. Gentner and colleagues (2016) worked with 110 children aged six to eight at the Chicago Children’s Museum, each assigned at random to compare an easy-to-match pair of model buildings, to compare a harder-to-match pair, or to have no training. The children who compared the easy pair were more likely to succeed afterwards at repairing a building, where the answer was a diagonal brace, and the authors conclude that “even a single brief analogical comparison can confer insight”. Hardy and colleagues (2020) ran two experiments with 59 and 99 children aged four to seven in Germany and Switzerland. Children who were shown two objects of a material, not one, were better at predicting whether a new object would float or sink, and the authors read this as showing that “children successfully induced the relevance of material kind by comparison”. That is close to what this lesson asks for: seeing past the shape of a thing to what it is made of. Alfieri, Nokes-Malach and Schunn (2013) pooled the studies of case comparison: “we conducted a meta-analysis of 57 experiments with 336 tests”. The average effect was moderate (d = .50), and children gained about as much as adults.

The limits. Gentner’s study was one museum visit, with two or three minutes of comparison, about bracing a model building and not about materials, and the children were tested the same day. On the repair task only the easy-to-match pair did better than no training; on the building task both comparison groups did. Hardy’s children were mostly younger than Year 2, the task was floating and sinking, the authors call the effect of two objects over one small, and no condition gave a specific transfer effect. Alfieri’s review covers all ages and subjects. It found that asking for similarities alone worked better than asking for similarities and differences together, and this lesson asks for both. None of the three tested an odd one out game, a simulation, or the idea that a material stays the same when its shape changes. No trial of odd one out games as a way of learning science was found. Explorify, a British primary science site, describes the activity for classrooms, and its version differs from ACARA’s (see below).

The site’s Year 7 lesson on the Sun, Earth and Moon also compares cases and cites Alfieri’s review. The activities, contexts and simulations here are new.

Handle with care

  • Risk assessment. Run the real activities under your school’s or system’s risk assessment process. Apart from the quotations below, the safety advice in these notes and on the screens is the lesson’s own.
  • Chalk dust. Students crush the chalk only inside a sealed zip bag, and they compare the stick and the powder through the bag. Use a strong bag, or one bag inside another, and check the seal before students press on it. The Allergy & Asthma Network says that “Chalk dust is an immediate irritant to anyone who breathes it in”, and more so for people with asthma. If you open the bag for the rubbing test, do it yourself, slowly, away from students, and seat students with asthma well back. You can leave that step out: the screen shows it. Seal the bag again before it goes in the bin, and wipe the desks with a damp cloth.
  • Chalk and milk allergy. A news release from the American College of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology says that “Casein, a milk protein, is often used in low-powder chalk.” and that milk-allergic children who breathe in such chalk dust can have life-threatening asthma attacks. It advises that a milk-allergic child be seated at the back of the classroom, and that a plan for allergy and asthma emergencies be shared with teachers. Check the box if you use dustless chalk. If a student has a milk allergy, use chalk with no casein in it, or leave out the step where the bag is opened. The study behind the release was not read for this lesson.
  • Rubber bands. Students stretch a band slowly, pointing down at the table, and never flick it. Throw out old bands, which snap. The Australasian Society of Clinical Immunology and Allergy says that many commercial products contain natural rubber latex, and rubber bands are on its list. Use latex-free bands if a student has a latex allergy.
  • Plastic rulers. Students bend and twist a ruler only a little. A ruler that snaps has sharp edges, so use flexible rulers, and take cracked ones away.
  • Pipe cleaners. The cut ends are sharp wire. Fold each end over before you hand them out.
  • Play dough. It is not for eating. Bought play dough can contain wheat: Poison Control, a poison centre in the United States, says that one well-known brand is “made mostly of water, salt, and flour” and that its wheat can set off a reaction in people with a wheat gluten allergy. Its play dough page adds that borax, if it is used to keep home-made dough, can be toxic if a large amount is swallowed. In another article Poison Control says not to make home-made play dough with raw flour, because flour can carry bacteria from the field and young children may put the dough in their mouths or lick their fingers. The lesson adds its own caution about salt: home-made dough usually has a lot of it, which can harm a child who eats much of the dough. Check the label, and check for wheat allergy and coeliac disease before you use any play dough. Students wash their hands afterwards.
  • Cotton wool. Use cotton wool whose pack says it is cotton. Students keep tufts away from mouths, noses and ears.
  • Scissors and paper. Use scissors with round ends. Students carry them with the points down.
  • Paper planes. Students throw only in a clear space, away from faces, and wait until no one is in front of them.
  • Fire. On screen 5 bark and cane are bent over a fire. Nothing is heated in this lesson.
  • The First Nations content. Screen 5, its key idea, q-rope and q-bark use only ACARA’s teacher background information for this elaboration, the fourth for AC9S2U03. The screen names the Peoples as ACARA names them and keeps ACARA’s tenses, which are present tense for all four. It says ‘make’ where ACARA’s verbs are construct and manufacture, ‘taken’ and ‘changed’ where they are sourced and manipulated, and ‘tied’ where ACARA has the saplings fastened in place by tying. For two-ply string it keeps ACARA’s own verb, form. ACARA says the three-ply rope is prepared by three people sitting together. The screen says so in words, and no people are drawn. The pictures show only strands, saplings, bark and cane changing shape, with no shelter, canoe or basket. The label ‘Still the same material’ is the lesson’s own science, applied to ACARA’s statement that bending and twisting are physical changes.
  • What has not been checked. This content has not been checked with the Guugu Yimithirr, Yolŋu, Bama or Wik Mungkan Peoples, or with any other People. ACARA’s page gives no protocol for working with a community. Its notice about the works it consulted does say that written records are often based on non-Indigenous interpretations, that such works may contain cultural breaches and offend the Peoples concerned, and that using them calls for careful selection, evaluation and community consultation. Screen 5 is written from ACARA’s summary of those records, so the same caution applies to it. The lesson’s own advice is to follow your school system’s guidance on working with local communities, to ask your school’s Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander education staff, or the local community, who can speak for the Country or Place your school is on, and to invite them to teach this part if they wish to.
  • Do not generalise. ACARA’s page says that before European arrival there were “more than 500 distinct Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Nations”, and that the region a People occupied determined the resources available to them. It gives its own example of the difference: the Gunai Peoples of Gippsland have long prepared kangaroo grass to make string for nets, while the Mabuaig Peoples of Mabuaig Island process coconut husk. What one People does should not be taught as what all First Nations Australians do.
  • The basket. ACARA’s page names the basket whose cane frame is bent over a fire, says it is unique to the north Queensland region, and names the Girramay Elder who shares some of the knowledges to make it. The screen says ‘a Girramay Elder of rainforest Country in far north Queensland’ and ‘one kind of basket’. His name is left off the screen because the lesson could not ask him or his family whether it should be used there. Read ACARA’s page before you say more.
  • ACARA’s consulted works. ACARA lists the works it consulted behind a notice that some may contain material considered culturally offensive or inappropriate, and that they are not provided or recommended as classroom resources. This lesson uses none of them. It also leaves out the paragraph on First Nations peoples in the James Cook University guide for parents.
  • Children’s ideas. Oak National Academy’s notes for this topic say pupils may think that everything that can be squashed, bent, twisted or stretched “will return to their previous shape”. Screen 2 is built around that: the play dough and the pipe cleaner do not. In the Inquiry Project’s research, over half of the students in its treatment group, at the start of grade 3, consistently judged that wood ground to sawdust was still wood. The same page reports that “only 38% went on to say that the sawdust would burn”, without saying of which group. So a child can say ‘it is still chalk’ without expecting the powder to behave like chalk, which is why screen 3 tests the stick and the powder side by side. Harden and Waller (2025) report that “One misconception found was thinking that a powder is a liquid”, and screen 3 has that as a wrong answer with feedback.
  • ‘You can change it back’ is not the test. Torn paper and crushed chalk cannot be put back as they were, and they are still paper and chalk. Steer talk towards what the material is like afterwards, not towards whether the change can be undone. This lesson shows only changes that leave the material the same, so say that some changes, such as burning and cooking, do make a new material. Reversible and irreversible changes come in Year 6.
  • Colour. A colour belongs to one sample, not to a material: paper, play dough and wool come in many colours. In three rounds of the game the odd one out is a different colour from the rest. In round 4 all four things are red, so students have to look at what each thing is like.
  • Reduced motion. When a device is set to show less movement, each change jumps to its end. The words under each picture still say what happened.

About the models

  • Screen 1: each change starts from a new flat sheet, so the changes do not add up. ‘Still thin and white, and you can still write on it’ are the lesson’s own checks. The James Cook University guide for parents puts the idea in four words: “Torn paper is still paper.”
  • Screen 2: the twelve results are the lesson’s own model of four typical things handled gently. OpenStax College Physics gives the general pattern for a solid. For small deformations, which it puts at under about 0.1%, an object goes back to its original shape when the force is removed. With larger forces the deformation can still be elastic, and “Still greater forces permanently deform the object until it finally fractures”. The gently bent ruler goes back, and the pipe cleaner and the play dough are permanently deformed. OpenStax does not discuss rubber stretched a long way, so the rubber band’s results are the lesson’s own. Real things differ. A thin rubber band is floppy and shows bending poorly, so the real activity asks for a thick one. Old bands and rulers snap, and play dough pulls apart, which is breaking into pieces of the same material. A ruler or a pipe cleaner pulled by hand does stretch, by too little to see: ‘No change’ means none that a student can see.
  • Screen 3: the chalk is white, and the results are the lesson’s own. OpenStax Chemistry lists “grinding solids into powders” among physical changes, and adds that grinding can sometimes change the colour noticeably. With coloured chalk the powder can look paler than the stick, so use white chalk. On the screen a little powder is out of the bag for the three tests. In the real activity it stays in the sealed bag unless you open the bag for the rubbing test, which is the last step and can be left out.
  • Screen 4: the wool follows a report in the American Physical Society’s magazine Physics (Schirber, 2022), which says that twisting turns loose fibres into “a single strand of yarn that is hard to break”. The experiments it reports used cotton and flax fibres, and simulated ones; the report names wool only in general. The three amounts of twist and what happens to each are the lesson’s own model. The real activity uses cotton wool, and ACARA’s elaboration names cotton or wool. For the plane, the Exploratorium says “By itself, a sheet of paper is not very stiff.” and that the folds give a plane its shape, control where its mass is and add stiffness. The two flight paths are the lesson’s own drawings. How a real plane flies depends on the folds and the throw.
  • Screen 5: everything is from ACARA’s page, in plainer words (see Handle with care). The two-ply string is drawn as two strands twined together, and the screen leaves out ACARA’s names for the two directions of twist.
  • Screen 6: the four rounds are the lesson’s own: paper with aluminium foil, chalk with sand, play dough with wood, and rubber with wool. In round 4 the rubber is a band, a band cut open and a band cut into pieces, because a band that is stretched or twisted springs back as soon as it is let go. The words under each thing describe it without naming its material.

Where sources disagree and what to check

  • Odd one out. Explorify says of its version that “there is no right or wrong answer”: any picture can be the odd one if a child gives a reason. ACARA’s game has three samples of one material and one of another, so it has an intended answer. The simulation marks the different material as right. The Talk prompt on screen 6 keeps Explorify’s open version: accept any reason a student can explain, then ask which one is made of something else.
  • What counts as a physical change. The James Cook University guide says a physical change alters the shape of a material and not what it is made of. OpenStax Chemistry defines it more widely, as a change in state or properties with no change in chemical composition, which takes in melting and dissolving. The lesson keeps to shape and the size of the pieces, which are the actions in the content description.
  • ‘Material composition’. The content description uses this phrase. The screens say ‘the same material’.
  • Springing back. Oak National Academy’s notes say that some materials do not change back on their own. OpenStax says that any solid pushed far enough is permanently deformed. A rubber band stretched too far or too often does not go all the way back either.
  • More twist is not always stronger. The Physics report says that binding strength rises with twist up to a critical amount, and that past it the fibres themselves break. The note under the simulation on screen 4 says this in plain words.
  • Heat and bending. ACARA’s page treats bark and cane bent over a fire as physically changed, and it describes steam bending as heat and moisture applied to wood or bark so that the material can be moulded. Burning is a different kind of change, and it is not part of this lesson.

Answers at a glance

  • Screen 1: after every change the answer is Paper. Folded, scrunched and twisted paper is one piece; torn paper is two pieces; cut paper is four. Tearing and cutting made more pieces. q-torn paper; q-fold folding it.
  • Screen 2: the rubber band springs back from all three; the play dough stays in its new shape after all three; the pipe cleaner stays bent and twisted and does not stretch; the plastic ruler springs back from bending and twisting and does not stretch. The play dough stayed in its new shape every time, and stretched play dough is play dough in a new shape. q-spring it springs back; q-dough its shape.
  • Screen 3: shape, different; colour, same; rubbed on a board, same; tipped from a dish, different. The powder is chalk in tiny pieces. q-powder chalk; q-pour the size of the pieces.
  • Screen 4: wool that is not twisted pulls apart easily; twisted a little, it holds for a moment and then pulls apart; twisted a lot, it holds. The flat sheet flutters down close by and the plane glides across the room. Folding changed the shape. q-thread twisting holds the fibres together; q-plane paper.
  • Screen 5: two strands of string, twist, two-ply string; three strands, twist, three-ply rope; saplings, bend, arched shelters; a sheet of bark, bend, bark canoes; lengths of lawyer cane, bend, the frame of a basket. The two changes are twisting and bending, and bent saplings are the same material as before. q-rope twisting them together; q-bark bark.
  • Screen 6: round 1, C (aluminium foil among paper); round 2, A (sand among chalk); round 3, D (wood among play dough); round 4, B (wool among rubber). The reason each time is a different material, and the three that match differ in shape. q-odd the ball of foil; q-three its material.
  • The printable: answers vary. A good game has three samples that are clearly one material, changed in three different ways, and a fourth that looks alike at first.

Saved progress

Answers, notes, results tables and settings are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere. If students share devices, clear the saved answers between them.

References

Sources by screen

  • Screen 1: the James Cook University guide for parents.
  • Screen 2: OpenStax College Physics 5.3 (springing back); Oak National Academy (not everything springs back); the James Cook University guide (the things to try).
  • Screen 3: OpenStax Chemistry 1.3 (grinding to a powder); Harden and Waller (2025) (a powder is not a liquid).
  • Screen 4: Schirber (2022) in Physics (twist); the Exploratorium (folds and stiffness).
  • Screen 5: ACARA’s teacher background information for AC9S2U03, elaboration 4.
  • Screen 6: ACARA’s fifth elaboration for AC9S2U03; Explorify (the classroom activity).
  • The method: Gentner and colleagues (2016); Hardy and colleagues (2020); Alfieri, Nokes-Malach and Schunn (2013).
  • Children’s ideas: Oak National Academy; the Inquiry Project; Harden and Waller (2025).
  • Safety: the Allergy & Asthma Network (chalk dust); the American College of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology (dustless chalk); the Australasian Society of Clinical Immunology and Allergy (latex); Poison Control (play dough, raw flour and borax).
  • Printable: ACARA’s fifth elaboration; Explorify (accepting any reason a student can give).

Word list