AusSci

Year 3 science · Physical sciences · AC9S3U03

Where does heat come from, and where does it go?

1For real, then on the screen

Sources of heat

Where does heat come from?

You can sense heat with your skin. You feel it when you stand in the sunshine, or when you hold your hands near a fire. Something that gives out heat is called a source of heat.

On this screen

  1. Feel for heat outside.
  2. Test eight things on the screen.
  3. Do the three tasks.
  4. Read the key idea.

First, for real

Feel for heat

Do this test with real things first. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • A sunny spot and a shady spot outside
  • A hat

What to do

  1. Stand in the shade. Hold your hands out. Then stand in the sunshine and do the same.
  2. Put a hand flat on a wall or a path in the shade. Then try one in the sun.
  3. Which felt warmer each time?

Take care. Never look at the Sun. If a wall or a path in the sun is too hot, take your hand off straight away. Do not touch heaters, kettles, toasters, stoves or fires.

Which felt warmer?

Then, on the screen

Now test eight things with a thermometer on the screen. Which ones are sources of heat?

Choose a thing, then press Test it. The thermometer starts at 20 °C, the same as the air. If it goes up, the thing is giving out heat. The table under the picture keeps each result. One of the things is an electrical device, and one is a hot spring.

Eight things and a thermometer

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Test all eight things with the thermometer.

    Need a hint?

    Which rows of your results table still have gaps? Choose that thing, then press Test it.

  2. Sort all eight things: source of heat, or not a source.

    Need a hint?

    Look at your results. Near a source of heat, the thermometer goes up.

  3. Use your results: why do you feel warm under a blanket?

    Need a hint?

    What did the thermometer read inside the blanket? Where could the heat under a blanket come from?

Talk about it. What sources of heat are there at your home? Tell your partner.

Sources of heat

The Sun, a fire, an electric heater and a hot spring are sources of heat. Near each one, the thermometer went up.

A blanket, a jumper, an esky and a wooden spoon are not sources of heat. With each one, the thermometer stayed at 20 °C.

Your body is a source of heat too. You feel warm under a blanket because your body makes heat, and the blanket keeps that heat in. You will test this on screens 5 and 6.

My notebook

Which of these is a source of heat?

A thermometer is wrapped in a blanket in a room at 20 °C. What does it read an hour later?

2For real, then on the screen

How hot is it?

Can you trust your hand to tell you how hot something is?

The temperature of a thing is how hot or cold it is. Your hand can tell you that something is warm. To measure temperature you use a thermometer, which gives a number in degrees Celsius (°C).

On this screen

  1. Do the three bowls test for real.
  2. Measure three bowls on the screen.
  3. Do the three tasks.
  4. Read the key idea.

First, for real

Three bowls

Do this test with real things first. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • 3 bowls
  • Cool water, and warm water that your teacher has checked
  • Water that has been in the room all day
  • A thermometer, if you have one
  • A towel

What to do

  1. Put the bowl of room water in the middle.
  2. Put one hand in the cool water and the other hand in the warm water. Count to 60.
  3. Put both hands in the middle bowl. How does it feel to each hand?
  4. If you have a thermometer, measure the three bowls.

Take care. Your teacher makes the warm water and checks that it is no hotter than a bath. Wipe up spills straight away, so that nobody slips.

How did the middle bowl feel?

Then, on the screen

Now measure the three bowls with a thermometer on the screen. Then do the test with two hands.

Choose a bowl to put the thermometer in. The red line moves, then stops. Read the number at the top of the red line. When you have measured all three bowls, press Hands in the cool and warm bowls. Then press Both hands in the middle bowl.

Three bowls of water

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Measure all three bowls with the thermometer.

    Need a hint?

    Choose a bowl to put the thermometer in. Wait until the red line stops moving, then read the number at its top.

  2. Do the test with two hands.

    Need a hint?

    Press Hands in the cool and warm bowls. Then press Both hands in the middle bowl.

  3. Use your results: what is the temperature of the middle bowl?

    Need a hint?

    Look at your results table. What did the thermometer read in the middle bowl?

Talk about it. When is your hand good enough, and when do you need a thermometer? Tell your partner.

Measuring temperature

The middle bowl felt warm to one hand and cool to the other. The thermometer read 25 °C both times. The water had one temperature.

Heat moving into your skin warms it, and heat moving out cools it. Your skin feels that. Heat moved from the water into the cool hand, so the water felt warm. Heat moved out of the warm hand into the water, so the same water felt cool.

A thermometer measures temperature, and it reads the same whichever hand has been in the water. Leave it in until the red line stops moving, then read the number.

My notebook

What does a thermometer measure?

One hand has been in cool water and the other in warm water. Both hands go into the same bowl. What happens?

3For real, then on the screen

Warm meets cold

What happens when a warm thing touches a cold thing?

A cup of warm water is standing in a bowl of cold water. The two lots of water do not mix, but the cup touches both. A drawing with arrows is a model of where the heat goes.

On this screen

  1. Do the test for real, and draw your arrows.
  2. Do the test on the screen.
  3. Do the three tasks.
  4. Read the key idea.

First, for real

A warm cup in a cold bowl

Do this test with real things first. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • A metal cup or a thin plastic cup
  • Warm water that your teacher has checked, for the cup
  • A bowl of cold water
  • 2 thermometers
  • A clock or a timer

What to do

  1. Read both thermometers. Write the numbers down.
  2. Stand the cup in the bowl. Keep the two lots of water apart.
  3. Read both thermometers every 2 minutes for 10 minutes.
  4. Draw the cup and the bowl. Draw arrows to show which way you think the heat moved.

Take care. Your teacher makes the warm water and checks that it is no hotter than a bath. Hold a thermometer by its top and do not stir with it. Wipe up spills straight away.

What did the two temperatures do?

Then, on the screen

Now put a cup of warm water in a bowl of cold water on the screen, and read both thermometers every 2 minutes.

First predict: choose which way the heat moves, under the picture. Then press Wait 2 minutes and read both thermometers. The table keeps each reading. Keep waiting until the two temperatures stop changing.

A warm cup in a cold bowl

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Draw the heat: choose which way it moves.

    Need a hint?

    Which water is warmer at the start? Heat moves out of the warmer thing.

  2. Wait until both temperatures stop changing.

    Need a hint?

    Press Wait 2 minutes until two rows of your results table are the same.

  3. Use your results: why did the temperatures stop changing?

    Need a hint?

    Look at the last rows of your table. What do you notice about the two temperatures?

Talk about it. Does cold move into the warm water, or does heat move out of it? Tell your partner what you think and why.

Heat moves from warm to cold

Heat moved from the warm water into the cold water. The warm water cooled down, and the cold water warmed up.

When both were 25 °C, they stopped changing. Two things at the same temperature do not pass heat to each other.

Cold does not move. When something feels cold, heat is moving out of your hand and into it.

My notebook

A cold can of drink is standing in warm water. Which way does heat move?

Warm water at 40 °C touches cold water at 10 °C. When do their temperatures stop changing?

4For real, then on the screen

Fast and slow materials

Does heat move through every material at the same speed?

Things are made of different materials. A spoon can be metal, ceramic or plastic. Heat moves through some materials quickly and through others slowly.

On this screen

  1. Do the touch test for real.
  2. Test three spoons on the screen.
  3. Do the three tasks.
  4. Read the key idea.

First, for real

The touch test

Do this test with real things first. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • A metal spoon
  • A ceramic mug or plate
  • A plastic spoon or cup
  • A thermometer to tape on to each thing, if you have one

What to do

  1. Leave all the things in the same room for an hour.
  2. If you have a thermometer, measure each thing before anyone touches it.
  3. Touch each one once, with your fingers flat. Which feels coldest? Let it cool before the next person has a turn.
  4. Put them in order, from the one that feels coldest to the one that feels warmest.

Take care. Use things with no sharp edges or chips. Put the mug or plate where it cannot fall.

Which felt coldest?

Then, on the screen

Now test a metal spoon, a ceramic spoon and a plastic spoon on the screen: measure each one, touch it, and stand it in hot water.

Choose a spoon. Press Measure it to put a thermometer on it. Press Touch it to touch it with a warm finger. Press Stand it in hot water, and a thermometer on the handle shows what happens in 2 minutes. The hot water is 60 °C, which is hot enough to burn skin, so this test stays on the screen.

Three spoons

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Do all three tests on all three spoons.

    Need a hint?

    Which boxes of your results table are still empty? Choose that spoon, then press the button for that test.

  2. Use your results: why did the metal spoon feel coldest?

    Need a hint?

    Look at the first column of your table. Were the spoons at different temperatures?

  3. Use your results: choose a material for the handle of a cooking pot.

    Need a hint?

    Which handle stayed cool in the hot water?

Talk about it. Why do many cooking pots have metal bottoms and plastic handles? Tell your partner.

Conductors and insulators

All three spoons were 20 °C on the bench. The metal spoon felt coldest because heat moved out of your warm finger and into the metal fastest.

A material that heat moves through quickly is a conductor. Metals are good conductors. A material that heat moves through slowly is an insulator. Plastic and wood are insulators. Ceramic is in between.

Many cooking pots are metal, so that heat from the stove gets to the food quickly. Their handles are often plastic or wood, so that they stay cool enough to hold.

My notebook

A metal spoon and a plastic spoon have been in the same room all day. The metal one feels colder. Why?

Which material is best for the handle of a hot cooking pot?

5For real, then on the screen

Keep it hot, keep it cold

What does a woolly sock do to an ice cube?

On a cold day you put on a jumper to keep warm. What would a woolly sock do to an ice cube? Would the ice melt faster, or would it last longer?

On this screen

  1. Do the ice in the sock test for real.
  2. Test three wraps on the screen.
  3. Do the three tasks.
  4. Read the key idea.

First, for real

The ice in the sock

Do this test with real things first. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • 2 ice cubes of the same size
  • A woolly sock, a glove or a tea towel
  • 2 plates
  • A clock or a timer

What to do

  1. Predict: which ice cube will melt first, the one in the sock or the one with no wrap?
  2. Put one ice cube inside the sock, on a plate. Put the other on a plate with no wrap.
  3. Look at both every 10 minutes. Which melts first?

Take care. Do not eat the ice. Wipe up any water on the floor.

Which ice cube melted first?

Then, on the screen

Now test ice cubes and cups of warm water on the screen: one with no wrap, one in a woolly sock and one in a foam box.

Choose Ice cubes or Cups of warm water. There are three of each: one with no wrap, one in a woolly sock and one in a foam box. First predict, under the picture. Then press Wait 30 minutes four times, and watch the table. The room is 20 °C.

Three wraps

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Predict: will the ice cube in the woolly sock melt faster or slower?

    Need a hint?

    Is a sock a source of heat? Think back to the blanket on screen 1.

  2. Wait 2 hours with the ice cubes, and 2 hours with the cups of warm water.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Ice cubes and press Wait 30 minutes four times. Then choose Cups of warm water and do the same.

  3. Use your results: what does the woolly sock do?

    Need a hint?

    Look at both tables. The sock kept the ice cold for longer. What did it do to the warm water?

Talk about it. What would you pack around cold drinks to keep them cold on a hot day? Tell your partner why.

Insulators slow heat down

The ice cube in the sock lasted longer. The sock made no heat. It slowed down the heat moving from the warm room into the ice.

The same sock kept the warm water warm for longer. It slowed down the heat moving out of the water into the room.

Wool and foam are insulators. They are full of tiny pockets of air, and heat moves through air slowly. An insulator keeps hot things hot and cold things cold for longer.

A jumper keeps you warm in the same way. It keeps in the heat your body makes.

My notebook

An ice cube is put inside a woolly sock in a warm room. What happens?

Why does a foam box keep cold drinks cold?

6For real, then on the screen

Fur that traps heat

How does a fur cloak keep a person warm?

Possum skin cloaks have long been a culturally important item of clothing, especially for Peoples whose Country is in the colder south east of Australia. The fur of a cloak traps heat close to the body.

On this screen

  1. Do the sock test for real.
  2. Look at fur on the screen.
  3. Do the three tasks.
  4. Read the key idea.
  5. Answer the last two questions and look at your results.

In cool, dry weather the Gunditjmara Peoples of western Victoria wore possum furs with the fur side inwards. The Noongar Peoples of south-west Western Australia made buka, which are kangaroo skin cloaks, and wore them with the fur facing inwards for warmth too. In wet weather the Wiradjuri Peoples of central New South Wales wore animal furs with the fur side to the rain.

After European colonisation, making possum skin cloaks was prohibited. Bringing back the making of these cloaks is helping many Aboriginal Peoples, including the Gunditjmara and Yorta Yorta Peoples of Victoria, to reconnect with their cultures and to restore them.

We read about this on the website of ACARA, the group that writes the Australian Curriculum. The picture below shows a small piece of fur from the side, drawn very simply. No people and no cloaks are drawn. Ask your teacher who your class could ask to find out more.

First, for real

Trap the heat

Do this test with real things first. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • A woolly sock or a glove
  • A clock or a timer

What to do

  1. Put one hand inside the sock. Leave the other hand bare.
  2. Wait 2 minutes.
  3. Which hand feels warmer?

Take care. Use a clean sock. If your hand gets too hot, take it out.

Which hand felt warmer?

Then, on the screen

Now look at how fur was worn in cool, dry weather and in wet weather, and at one possum fibre up close.

Choose the weather. Then choose which way the fur side faces, and read the words under the picture. Press Look at one possum fibre to see one fibre up close. It is hollow.

A piece of fur, from the side

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Find which way the fur faced in cool, dry weather, and in wet weather.

    Need a hint?

    Choose the weather. Then turn the fur side inwards or outwards, and read the words under the picture.

  2. Look at one possum fibre up close.

    Need a hint?

    Press Look at one possum fibre.

  3. Use your results: what was trapped between the fibres?

    Need a hint?

    Look at the first row of your results table.

Talk about it. What do you wear to trap heat close to your body? Tell your partner how it works.

Trapping heat close to the body

In cool, dry weather the Gunditjmara Peoples wore possum furs with the fur side inwards. Warm air was trapped between the fibres of the fur, and heat moves through trapped air slowly. So heat stayed close to the body.

In wet weather the Wiradjuri Peoples wore animal furs with the fur side to the rain, and the fur protected the wearer from water.

A possum fibre is hollow, and the hollow traps air too.

Fur is an insulator, like the woolly sock on screen 5. It makes no heat. It keeps in the heat the body makes.

My notebook

In cool, dry weather, which way did the Gunditjmara Peoples wear the fur side of a possum fur?

What does the hollow in a possum fibre trap?

Printable activity

For real: three heat tests

Two pages for the real tests. Page 1 is a warm cup in a cold bowl: read two thermometers every 2 minutes and draw the heat. Page 2 is the touch test on things made of different materials, and the ice in the sock.

For teachers

Curriculum

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 3, Science understanding, Physical sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:

AC9S3U03 identify sources of heat energy and examine how temperature changes when heat energy is transferred from one object to another

  • exploring how we sense heat and identifying sources of heat such as the sun, fire, electrical devices and geothermal springs
  • recognising that changes in heat energy can be measured using a thermometer
  • observing and, with assistance, measuring, what happens when a cold object is placed in direct contact with a warm object and proposing explanations
  • modelling the movement of heat from one object to another using drawing or role-play
  • investigating how well heat is transferred by different types of materials such as metals, plastics and ceramics and identifying how materials are used to keep things hot and cold
  • exploring how First Nations Australians developed clothing from animal skins such as possum furs and kangaroo skin cloaks that trap heat close to the body to stay warm

The second quote gives all six of ACARA’s elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each part of the content description is covered on these screens:

  • Sources of heat energy, and how we sense heat: screen 1 tests the Sun, a campfire, an electric heater and a hot spring with a thermometer, beside four things that make no heat; q-source and q-blanket. Its real test, and the three bowls on screen 2, are about sensing heat with the skin.
  • Measuring with a thermometer: screen 2; q-thermo and q-hands.
  • How temperature changes when heat is transferred from one object to another: screen 3 puts a cup of warm water in a bowl of cold water, reads both thermometers and draws the heat as arrows; q-way and q-stop.
  • How well different materials transfer heat, and how materials keep things hot and cold: screen 4 tests metal, ceramic and plastic spoons, and screen 5 tests a woolly sock and a foam box; q-metal, q-handle, q-sock and q-box.
  • Clothing from animal skins that traps heat close to the body: screen 6; q-fur and q-fibre.

The lesson also works on these content descriptions. Students predict on screens 3 and 5, follow a procedure and read real thermometers in the real tests on screens 2 and 3, keep a results table on every screen, and compare what they found for real with what the simulation shows. Screen 4’s pot handles and screen 5’s foam box are where students consider how people use what science explains about heat to meet a need, which is AC9S3H02. No screen asks whether a test was fair, which is part of AC9S3I05; the real tests on screens 4 and 5 are places to raise it.

AC9S3H02 consider how people use scientific explanations to meet a need or solve a problem

AC9S3I01 pose questions to explore observed patterns and relationships and make predictions based on observations

AC9S3I03 follow procedures to make and record observations, including making formal measurements using familiar scaled instruments and using digital tools as appropriate

AC9S3I04 construct and use representations, including tables, simple column graphs and visual or physical models, to organise data and information, show simple relationships and identify patterns

AC9S3I05 compare findings with those of others, consider if investigations were fair, identify questions for further investigation and draw conclusions

It goes with Year 3’s AC9S3U04, “investigate the observable properties of solids and liquids and how adding or removing heat energy leads to a change of state”, which the site’s Year 3 solids and liquids lesson teaches. The words conductor and insulator are used here for heat only; electrical conductors are left for Year 6.

How the lesson is taught

The method is the real thing first, then a simulation. Each screen opens with a box, ‘First, for real’, that lists what is needed for a short test with everyday things and asks what the student found. A simulation of the same thing follows. It shows what the real test cannot: a thermometer on everything, and arrows for the heat. A results table fills in as the simulation is used, three tasks use the table, and the key idea opens when the tasks are done.

The order comes from Tseng and colleagues (2023), who compared four ways of teaching heat and temperature to 205 primary school students: hands-on experiments only, simulations only, hands-on experiments followed by simulations, and simulations followed by hands-on experiments. Hands-on work followed by a simulation did better than the other order, and better than hands-on work alone. ERIC’s record of the paper gives the students as Grade 6, in Taiwan. The authors write that “virtual laboratories can effectively model abstract concepts.” Zacharia, Olympiou and Papaevripidou (2008) found the same direction with 62 undergraduates studying heat and temperature: real equipment followed by a simulation did better than real equipment alone.

The limits are these. Tseng and colleagues’ students were about three years older than Year 3 students, and the undergraduates were adults. In Tseng’s study, hands-on work followed by a simulation did no better than the simulation alone (“this effect is similar to that of virtual manipulatives alone”), so the gain may come mostly from the simulation, and the authors conclude that what matters is the kind of experiment more than the order. Zacharia and colleagues had no group that used the simulation first, and they name the simulation as the cause of the gain, so their study supports adding a simulation more than it supports the order. The only study here with children of Year 3’s age is Wang and Tseng (2018), with 208 third graders learning about evaporation and condensation, and it supports the other order: a simulation before the hands-on work “promoted students’ conceptual understanding most efficiently”, and hands-on work alone did least. Its three groups were hands-on only, simulation only, and simulation then hands-on, so it did not test this lesson’s order. The site’s solids and liquids lesson uses the simulation-first order. None of these studies used this lesson’s simulations.

The screens work without the real tests, and the questions about the real tests hold nothing back. But the method is the two together, with the real test first. If time is short, do the real tests for screens 2, 3 and 5 at least: the three bowls, the warm cup in the cold bowl, and the ice in the sock. The printable is the record sheet for the real tests on screens 3, 4 and 5.

ACARA’s fourth elaboration is modelling the movement of heat “using drawing or role-play”. Screen 3 asks for the drawing: the arrow on the screen, the arrows in the real test, and a drawing in the science book, which the notebook prompt asks for. A role-play is the lesson’s own suggestion: two groups stand for the warm water and the cold water, and a few students who are the heat walk from the warm group to the cold group until neither group is ‘warmer’.

Handle with care

  • Warm water. The real tests on screens 2 and 3 use warm water. Make it yourself, away from students, and check it with a thermometer, not with your hand. Raising Children Network gives “between 37°C and 38°C” as a safe bath temperature for babies and children, and says to “Check the bath temperature using a thermometer.” Water like that is warm enough for both tests. Water from a hot tap or a kettle can be far hotter. The same site says that “At 60°C it takes only one second to cause a full thickness burn.”, that “At 50°C it takes 5 minutes.”, and that “Hot water can scald up to half an hour after it has been boiled.” For a scald, Kidsafe Victoria’s first aid is to “Place the scald or burn under cool running water for a minimum of 20 minutes.” Follow your school’s first aid procedure as well. Screen 4’s hot water is 60 °C and is on the screen only; the page tells students so.
  • The Sun and hot surfaces. Screen 1’s real test is outdoors. Students must not look at the Sun: “it is extremely dangerous to look directly at the Sun: even a brief exposure can damage your eyes.” In hot weather, feel the wall or the path yourself before students do, and follow your school’s sun protection policy.
  • Sources of heat. Students use no heater, kettle, toaster, stove or fire in any real test, and screen 1’s care line tells them not to touch one. If you heat water for the warm bowls, do it away from students.
  • Thermometers. Use spirit-filled or digital thermometers. Show students how to hold one by its top, keep it still and read it with their eyes level with the number. A glass thermometer can roll off a desk and break, so lay it in a tray between readings, use plastic bowls for the water, and follow your school’s procedure for broken glass.
  • The touch test. On screen 4 and the printable, students measure each thing before anyone touches it, touch it once, and let it cool before the next turn. The Exploratorium gives the reason: “Materials will warm to above room temperature after just a few rounds of being touched.” It measures each surface with an infrared thermometer, and the RSC chapter tapes a thermometer to the material.
  • Ice and spills. The ice is not for eating, and water on a floor is a slip hazard. No food is used in this lesson.
  • The First Nations content. What screen 6, its key idea, q-fur and q-fibre say about the Peoples named, their clothing and possum fibres comes only from ACARA’s teacher background information. Two points in the key idea are physics and come from elsewhere: that heat moves through trapped air slowly (OpenStax College Physics 14.5 speaks of “air’s poor thermal conductivity”), and the comparison with the sock on screen 5. ACARA’s page for this lesson’s own elaboration, the sixth, could not be found when the lesson was written, so the screen draws on ACARA’s pages for three other elaborations that describe the same clothing: AC9S4U04 in Year 4, AC9S5U01 in Year 5 and AC9S9U04 in Year 9. Look for the Year 3 page before you teach. ACARA gives how the furs and cloaks were worn in the past tense, so the lesson does too. It gives in the present tense that possum skin cloaks “have long been a culturally important, essential item of clothing”, that they “are of great cultural significance to some Aboriginal peoples”, and that the revival of making them “is providing a significant way for many Aboriginal Peoples”, and the lesson keeps that tense. No people and no cloaks are drawn: the picture shows only a small piece of fur from the side, and one fibre. ACARA’s Year 9 page says that “the inner surface of each cloak was incised and painted with ochre”, and those designs are not the lesson’s to draw. Screen 6 has not been checked with the Gunditjmara, Noongar, Wiradjuri or Yorta Yorta Peoples. ACARA’s Year 4 page says that before colonisation clothing “varied greatly across the Australian continent”, so do not present these furs and cloaks as the clothing of all First Nations Australians; ACARA places the four Peoples named in Victoria, New South Wales and Western Australia. ACARA’s pages warn that written records “can also be problematic”, that “These sources often lack the viewpoints of the people they discuss”, and that, although they are in the public domain, “they may contain cultural breaches and cause offence to the Peoples concerned.” They warn that some of the sources listed in the consulted works “may contain material that is considered culturally offensive or inappropriate”, that “The consulted works are not provided or recommended as classroom resources.”, that “The ability to select and evaluate appropriate resources is an essential cultural capability skill for educators.”, and that, with careful selection, evaluation and community consultation, they may give teachers material that “could be culturally audited, refined and adapted to construct culturally appropriate teaching and learning materials.” The Year 9 page adds that “A more complete understanding of the topic may be found through community consultation and further research.” Follow your school’s or system’s protocols for First Nations content, for example by asking Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander staff or education officers, and ask your local community for advice on teaching screen 6.
  • Screen 6’s real test. A hand in a sock is a test of trapping heat. It is not a test of a cloak, and the lesson does not ask students to make or copy one.
  • Children’s ideas. Lewis and Linn (1994), as Thiam reports them, found that middle school students held ideas such as “wool warms things up” and “metals absorb, hold, or attract cold in cool environments”. Paik, Cho and Go (2007) interviewed 154 Korean children aged 4 to 11 about temperature, thermal insulation and heat equilibrium, and report that “Younger students displayed a greater tendency to view insulation as a material property”. The same abstract says that younger children tended to treat temperature as a size or as numbers to add up, and that “Most students did not have clear concepts of heat equilibrium regardless of age”. The RSC’s primary chapter says that things in a room being at the temperature of the room “is a difficult concept for children to comprehend”, and puts the snowman’s coat as a question of “whether the coat is an insulator or whether it actually generates heat.” Screens 1 and 5 test the blanket and the sock, screen 4 tests the cold metal, and screen 3 says that cold does not move. Screen 3 is also the place to talk about adding up: water at 40 °C and water at 10 °C end at 25 °C, not 50 °C.
  • Where you are. The model’s room is 20 °C. In a room near 30 °C the touch test on screen 4 is weak, because the things are close to the temperature of the skin. Cool them all in a fridge first; an hour is the lesson’s own suggestion. The RSC chapter does this with metal and wood: “Put a piece of metal and a piece of wood in the refrigerator, get the children to then feel them.” In a hot room ice also melts much faster than the model’s 2 hours, and water that has been in the room all day may feel warm.
  • Reduced motion. When a device is set to show less movement, each change jumps to its end. The words under each picture still say what moved and which way the heat went.

About the models

  • Screen 1: the air is 20 °C. The readings for the Sun (28 °C), the campfire (45 °C), the heater (40 °C) and the hot spring (34 °C) are the lesson’s own: a real thermometer reads more or less depending on how close it is and how long it is left, and real hot springs differ. The spring is not a real one; see ‘Hot springs’ below. The blanket, the jumper, the esky and the wooden spoon stay at 20 °C; the RSC chapter says that things in a room are at the temperature of the room “even if they appear to feel warmer or colder.” ‘Your body makes heat’ is the lesson’s wording for what the same chapter calls “the natural body warmth”.
  • Screen 2: the bowls are 15 °C, 25 °C and 35 °C, the lesson’s own numbers, and the bench is 20 °C. The middle bowl on the screen is 5 °C warmer than the room; a real bowl of water that has been in the room all day reads the same as the room. The red line moves and then stops because the thermometer has to warm up or cool down itself. OpenStax: “Thermometers actually take their own temperature, not the temperature of the object they are measuring.”, and “if enough time is allowed for this transfer of heat to run its course, the temperature a thermometer registers does represent the system with which it is in thermal equilibrium.” The two hands are from the RSC chapter: “The water will feel different to each hand.”
  • Screen 3: the cup and the bowl hold the same amount of water and no heat is lost to the room, so both end at 25 °C, half-way between 40 °C and 10 °C. The readings every 2 minutes (40 and 10, 34 and 16, 30 and 20, 27 and 23, 26 and 24, 25 and 25, 25 and 25) are the lesson’s own. In a real test the room warms or cools the water too. The screen’s warm water starts at 40 °C; real warm water for this test is no hotter than a bath, so the real numbers start lower. Use a metal cup or a thin plastic one for the real test. OpenStax gives the rate of heat transfer as “inversely proportional to the thickness”, and through a thick mug or a foam cup the two temperatures may hardly change in 10 minutes.
  • Screen 4: all three spoons are 20 °C on the bench. How each feels follows the Exploratorium’s account: “They do not feel equally cold because they carry heat away from your hand at different rates.” The handle readings after 2 minutes in 60 °C water (metal 44 °C, ceramic 27 °C, plastic 21 °C) are the lesson’s own. Their order is from OpenStax: metals “are also good heat conductors, whereas insulators of electricity (wood, plastic, and rubber) are poor heat conductors”, and one of the chapter’s conceptual questions describes ceramic as having “a conductivity less than that of a metal but greater than that of a good insulator”. OpenStax’s table of conductivities lists neither plastic nor ceramic, so the order rests on those two statements and not on measurements. A real stainless steel spoon is a poor conductor for a metal (OpenStax lists it at 14, against 220 for aluminium), so its handle warms slowly; that, and the hot water, are why the real test is the touch test.
  • Screen 5: the room is 20 °C. The ice is shown in quarters and the cups start at 50 °C; the amounts and the temperatures are the lesson’s own. The foam box slows heat more than the sock because OpenStax lists Styrofoam at 0.010 and wool at 0.04; real results depend on how thick each wrap is. The sock and the box are drawn cut open.
  • Screen 6: a small piece of fur from the side, not to scale. Three of the four ways round are from ACARA’s text. For the fourth, cool, dry weather with the fur side outwards, ACARA’s pages say nothing, and the screen says so.

Where sources disagree and what to check

  • ACARA’s page for this elaboration. See Handle with care. If you find it, compare screen 6 with it.
  • Scalds. Raising Children Network gives one second for a full thickness burn at 60 °C. The Sydney Children’s Hospitals Network gives “about five seconds” at 60 °C, and says that water at 65 °C can cause a full-thickness burn “in seconds”. The lesson uses the more cautious figure.
  • Heat. ACARA writes “heat energy”. OpenStax defines heat as “the spontaneous transfer of energy due to a temperature difference.” The lesson says heat ‘moves’ from a warmer thing to a cooler one; ACARA’s content description has “when heat energy is transferred from one object to another”, and an elaboration has “the movement of heat from one object to another”. The lesson uses ‘temperature’ for how hot a thing is and ‘heat’ for what moves, and goes no further.
  • When no more heat moves. OpenStax: “no further heat flow or changes in temperature will occur.” Screen 3’s key idea puts this as two things at the same temperature not passing heat to each other.
  • Hot springs. ACARA’s first elaboration names “geothermal springs”, and screen 1 says that the spring’s water is warmed by heat from under the ground. Resources Victoria describes geothermal energy as coming “from natural heat in hot rocks and groundwater below the earth’s surface.” The screen’s spring is not a real one. Its 34 °C was first taken from the Northern Territory Government’s page on Elsey National Park, where the thermal waters at Bitter Springs and Mataranka Thermal Pool “stay a warm 34°C year round”. Mataranka is a poor example of a geothermal spring, though. A fact sheet from the Geological and Bioregional Assessment Program says that the springs there “are warm due to high soil temperatures” when the groundwater went into the ground, “not from geothermal heating of groundwater.” If your students know Mataranka, it is a warm spring to talk about, but not one warmed by hot rocks.
  • Pot handles. A guide for parents from James Cook University says of insulators: “That is why pot handles are plastic or wood”. OpenStax says that “Cooking utensils are typically made from good conductors.”
  • Tseng and colleagues’ students. Grade 6 and Taiwan are from ERIC’s record, not from the paper’s abstract, and the paper itself was not read.

Answers at a glance

  • Screen 1: the Sun, the campfire, the electric heater and the hot spring are sources of heat; the blanket, the jumper, the esky and the wooden spoon are not. A blanket keeps in the heat your body makes. q-source a campfire; q-blanket 20 °C.
  • Screen 2: 15 °C, 25 °C and 35 °C. The middle bowl feels warm to the hand from the cool bowl and cool to the hand from the warm bowl, and it is 25 °C whichever hand is in it. q-thermo temperature; q-hands the water feels different to each hand.
  • Screen 3: heat moves from the warm water to the cold water; both end at 25 °C and stop changing because they are the same temperature. q-way from the warm water into the cold can; q-stop when both are the same temperature.
  • Screen 4: all three spoons read 20 °C; the metal feels cold, the ceramic cool and the plastic only a little cool; the handles read 44 °C, 27 °C and 21 °C. The metal felt coldest because heat moved out of the finger into it fastest; plastic for the handle. q-metal heat moves out of your hand into the metal faster; q-handle plastic.
  • Screen 5: after 2 hours the ice with no wrap has all melted, half is left in the sock and three quarters in the foam box; the cups are 22 °C, 32 °C and 38 °C. The sock slows down the heat moving in or out. q-sock it melts more slowly than an ice cube with no wrap; q-box heat from outside moves through the foam slowly.
  • Screen 6: in cool, dry weather the Gunditjmara Peoples wore the fur side inwards, and warm air was trapped between the fibres; in wet weather the Wiradjuri Peoples wore the fur side to the rain; a possum fibre is hollow, and the hollow traps air. q-fur inwards, towards the body; q-fibre air.

Saved progress

Answers, notes, results tables and settings are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere. If students share devices, clear the saved answers between them.

References

  • Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) (2022). Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Foundation to Year 10 curriculum content. Australian Curriculum website.
  • Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) (n.d.). Science teacher background information: AC9S4U04, elaboration 4; AC9S5U01, elaboration 5; AC9S9U04, elaboration 5. Read 19 November 2026.
  • Exploratorium (n.d.). Cold Metal. Science Snacks.
  • Fraknoi, A., Morrison, D. and Wolff, S. (2022). Astronomy 2e. OpenStax. Section 4.7 Eclipses of the Sun and Moon.
  • Geological and Bioregional Assessment Program (2021). Groundwater sources to the Mataranka Springs Complex. Fact sheet 25. Australian Government.
  • James Cook University, Indigenous Education and Research Centre (2026, July). Year 3 Physics: Heat. A guide for parents.
  • Kidsafe Victoria (n.d.). Burns + scalds prevention. Brochure, read as the copy at cope.org.au.
  • Lewis, E. L. and Linn, M. C. (1994). Heat energy and temperature concepts of adolescents, adults, and experts: Implications for curricular improvements. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 31(6), 657–677. (read only as Thiam reports it)
  • Northern Territory Government (n.d.). Elsey National Park.
  • Paik, S.-H., Cho, B.-K. and Go, Y.-M. (2007). Korean 4- to 11-year-old student conceptions of heat and temperature. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 44(2), 284–302. (read only in its abstract)
  • Raising Children Network (n.d.). Safe bath temperature for babies and children: what you need to know.
  • Raising Children Network (n.d.). Scalds and scalding risks: what you need to know.
  • Rees, J. (Compiler) (n.d.). Insulation and conduction. In That’s Chemistry! Royal Society of Chemistry.
  • Resources Victoria (n.d.). Geothermal energy.
  • Sydney Children’s Hospitals Network (n.d.). Burns and scalds safety.
  • Thiam, M. (2021). Basic thermodynamics to save lives. Science Activities, 58(3), 89–97. (read as the copy at arXiv:2208.05513)
  • Tseng, Y.-K., Lin, F.-S., Tarng, W., Lu, Y.-L. and Wang, T.-L. (2023). Comparing the effects of physical, virtual, and hybrid labs on primary school students’ conceptual learning of heat and temperature. Journal of Baltic Science Education, 22(1), 153–166. (read only in its abstract)
  • Urone, P. P. and Hinrichs, R. (2022). College Physics 2e. OpenStax. Sections 13.1 Temperature, 14.1 Heat and 14.5 Conduction.
  • Wang, T.-L. and Tseng, Y.-K. (2018). The comparative effectiveness of physical, virtual, and virtual-physical manipulatives on third-grade students’ science achievement and conceptual understanding of evaporation and condensation. International Journal of Science and Mathematics Education, 16(2), 203–219. https://link.springer.com/doi/10.1007/s10763-016-9774-2
  • Zacharia, Z. C., Olympiou, G. and Papaevripidou, M. (2008). Effects of experimenting with physical and virtual manipulatives on students’ conceptual understanding in heat and temperature. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 45(9), 1021–1035. (read only in its abstract)

Sources by screen

  • Method: Tseng and colleagues (2023); Zacharia, Olympiou and Papaevripidou (2008); Wang and Tseng (2018).
  • Screen 1: ACARA’s first elaboration (the four sources of heat); Resources Victoria (heat from under the ground); the Northern Territory Government’s page on Elsey National Park and the Geological and Bioregional Assessment Program’s fact sheet (Mataranka, in the notes only); the RSC chapter (things in a room, and body warmth).
  • Screen 2: the RSC chapter (three bowls); the Exploratorium’s Cold Metal (the hand as a thermometer, and what the skin senses); OpenStax College Physics 13.1 (thermometers, and the Celsius scale).
  • Screen 3: OpenStax College Physics 13.1 and 14.1 (heat moves from hot to cold until the temperatures are the same); the RSC chapter (a related test, in which one very cold and one hot container of water are left in a room).
  • Screen 4: the Exploratorium’s Cold Metal; the RSC chapter (metal and wood, and mugs of plastic, metal and ceramic); OpenStax College Physics 14.5 (conductors, insulators and the table of conductivities); James Cook University’s guide for parents (pot handles); Raising Children Network (scalds).
  • Screen 5: the RSC chapter (the snowman’s coat, and ice in a sock or glove); OpenStax College Physics 14.5 (wool, foam and pockets of air).
  • Screen 6: ACARA’s teacher background information for AC9S4U04 elaboration 4, AC9S5U01 elaboration 5 and AC9S9U04 elaboration 5.
  • Children’s ideas: Lewis and Linn (1994), as Thiam reports them; Paik, Cho and Go (2007); the RSC chapter.
  • Safety: Raising Children Network (bath temperature, scalds); Kidsafe Victoria (first aid for a scald); the Sydney Children’s Hospitals Network (scalds); OpenStax Astronomy 4.7 (looking at the Sun).
  • Printable: the sources for screens 3, 4 and 5.

Word list