AusSci

Year 3 science · Biological sciences · AC9S3U01

Is it alive?

1Talk, try it, talk again

Living, once living or non-living

How can you tell if something is alive?

Some things are living. Some things were alive once, or were part of a living thing, but aren’t alive now. Some things were never alive. How can you tell which is which? In this lesson you talk about it in a group, try it out in a simulation, then talk again.

How this lesson works

You work in a group of three. Scientists work out hard questions by talking. They share ideas, give reasons, listen to each other, and change their minds when they hear a better reason. Researchers in England taught classes of 9 and 10 year olds to talk like this. Those classes improved more in science tests than classes that hadn’t learnt it. On every screen:

  1. Talk about the question before you try the simulation. Choose an answer together and write your reason.
  2. Work the simulation together, and take turns at the controls.
  3. Talk about the question again. Did the simulation change your minds? Choose an answer together again, with a reason.
  4. Then, on your own, answer the notebook question and the quiz questions.

Our talk rules

Read the rules together and talk about why each one matters. Then agree to use them for the whole lesson.

  1. Everyone shares what they think.
  2. We give reasons: ‘I think … because …’.
  3. We ask each other: ‘Why do you think that?’
  4. We listen to every idea and think about it.
  5. We try to agree before we choose.

On this screen

  1. Agree to your talk rules.
  2. Talk about whether a seed is alive, before you try the simulation.
  3. In the simulation, ask the four questions about some of the things. Then sort all twelve things and check your sort.
  4. Talk again, then read the key idea.

Talk first

Is a seed alive?

Talk about it in your group before you try the simulation. Take turns, and say why you think so.

  • I think … because …
  • Why do you think that?
  • I agree, because …
  • I disagree, because …
Our group thinks

Here are four questions to test whether something is alive. Does it grow? Does it make young or seeds? Does it need food and water? Does it react to things around it? Pick a thing and ask the four questions. Then put it in a group. Once living things were alive once, or were part of a living thing, like a dead plant or a feather. Non-living things were never alive.

Test it, then sort it

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Talk again

Is a seed alive?

Now talk about the question again. What did the simulation show you? Keep talking until your group agrees, and say why.

Now our group thinks

How did our talk go?

Living, once living and non-living

Living things grow, make young or seeds, need food and water, and react to things around them. A seed is living. There is a tiny young plant inside it, with a store of food. A seed can wait for months, even years, and when it gets water, and it is warm enough, it starts to grow.

Once living things were alive once, or were part of a living thing: a dead plant was alive, a feather grew on a bird, and wood grew as part of a tree. Non-living things were never alive. A robot dog moves and reacts, but it doesn’t grow, have young, or need food and water, so it is non-living. Water moves and changes, but it was never alive either.

What we are learning

How to tell living, once living and non-living things apart, how plants and animals grow up and make young, and how to work out science questions by talking in a group.

I can

  • 1sort things into living, once living and non-living, and give a reason for each.
  • 2describe the life cycle of a flowering plant, from seed to plant to new seeds.
  • 3describe how a frog and a moth change shape as they grow, and what they do at each stage.
  • 4compare animals that change shape as they grow with animals that don’t, including humans.
  • 5explain how the magpie goose’s life cycle fits the Kakadu seasons, and how Bininj and Mungguy people use that knowledge.
  • 6talk about a science question in a group: give reasons, listen and try to agree.

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 3, AC9S3U01: “compare characteristics of living and non-living things and examine the differences between the life cycles of plants and animals”. The teacher notes at the end show which screen covers each part.

My notebook

Which of these is living?

A puddle gets bigger when it rains. Is the puddle alive?

2Talk, try it, talk again

A seed grows into a plant

How does a plant make new plants?

A bean seed is small and dry, but there is a tiny young plant inside it. Give it water and keep it warm, and it grows. A grass tree grows too, but very slowly. Here you grow both, and watch how each one makes new seeds.

On this screen

  1. Talk about which comes first, the seed or the plant.
  2. Grow a bean until it makes new seeds, then plant one of them. Try a seed with no water too.
  3. Grow a grass tree until it can flower, then make it flower.
  4. Talk again, then read the key idea.

Talk first

Which comes first, the seed or the plant?

Talk about it in your group before you try the simulation. Take turns, and say why you think so.

  • I think … because …
  • Why do you think that?
  • I agree, because …
  • I disagree, because …
Our group thinks

The wheel beside the bean shows its life cycle. Watch the marker go round as the bean grows from a seed to a seedling and on to a plant with flowers and pods. When the new seeds fall, plant one, and the cycle starts again.

Grow a bean, and a grass tree

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Talk again

Which comes first, the seed or the plant?

Now talk about the question again. What did the simulation show you? Keep talking until your group agrees, and say why.

Now our group thinks

How did our talk go?

A plant’s life cycle

A plant’s life goes round in a cycle. A seed grows a root and a shoot. The shoot grows into a plant with leaves, and the plant makes flowers. New seeds form inside the flowers, and each seed can grow into a new plant. So which comes first? Every bean plant grew from a seed, and every bean seed came from a bean plant. The cycle goes round and round.

A seed needs water to start growing, and it must be warm enough. Without water it waits, still alive. A growing plant needs water and light, and without water it wilts and dies. Some plants go round their life cycle in a few months, like the bean. A grass tree grows only about one or two centimetres a year and can take over 20 years to flower for the first time. Then one flowering stem can make up to 10,000 seeds.

My notebook

What does a bean seed need to start growing?

Why is it called a life cycle?

3Talk, try it, talk again

Frogs and moths change shape

How does an animal change as it grows up?

A frog starts life as an egg in water or a wet place. An emperor gum moth starts as an egg on a gum leaf. Both of them change shape completely as they grow up. Scientists call this big change metamorphosis.

On this screen

  1. Talk about whether a tadpole is the same animal as a frog.
  2. Put the frog’s life cycle in order, then the moth’s.
  3. Tap each stage to see what its body is like and what it does.
  4. Talk again, then read the key idea.

Talk first

Is a tadpole the same animal as a frog?

Talk about it in your group before you try the simulation. Take turns, and say why you think so.

  • I think … because …
  • Why do you think that?
  • I agree, because …
  • I disagree, because …
Our group thinks

Tap the stage that comes first, then the next one, and so on round the wheel. Start with the eggs. When the wheel is full, tap each stage to see what its body is like and what it does. Look for the tadpole, and for the pupa inside the moth’s cocoon.

Put the stages in order

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Talk again

Is a tadpole the same animal as a frog?

Now talk about the question again. What did the simulation show you? Keep talking until your group agrees, and say why.

Now our group thinks

How did our talk go?

Metamorphosis

A tadpole is a young frog: the same animal at a different stage. Its body changes completely as it grows. A tadpole has gills and a tail and lives in water, and many tadpoles eat plants. A frog has lungs and four legs, can live on land, and catches small animals to eat. Each body suits what the animal does at that stage.

The emperor gum moth changes too. The caterpillar eats gum leaves and grows. Inside its cocoon, as a pupa, its body changes into a moth. The moth can’t eat at all: it flies, finds a mate and lays eggs, using energy stored up when it was a caterpillar. A big change of body shape like this is called metamorphosis. Beetles and butterflies go through it too.

My notebook

Which is true about a tadpole and a frog?

An emperor gum moth can’t eat at all. Where does it get the energy to fly and lay eggs?

4Talk, try it, talk again

Hatched or born?

Do all animals change shape as they grow up?

Not every animal changes shape. A magpie goose, a platypus, a red kangaroo and a human all grow up without changing into a new body shape. But they don’t all start life the same way.

On this screen

  1. Talk about whether all baby animals hatch out of eggs.
  2. Look at every stage of all four animals’ life cycles.
  3. Sort eight animals. Do they hatch or are they born? Do they change shape?
  4. Talk again, then read the key idea.

Talk first

Do all baby animals hatch out of eggs?

Talk about it in your group before you try the simulation. Take turns, and say why you think so.

  • I think … because …
  • Why do you think that?
  • I agree, because …
  • I disagree, because …
Our group thinks

Pick an animal and go round its life cycle, one stage at a time. Then choose ‘Sort them’ and put each animal in the box that fits it. The platypus and the kangaroo are both mammals, and a young kangaroo is called a joey.

Four life cycles, then sort them

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Talk again

Do all baby animals hatch out of eggs?

Now talk about the question again. What did the simulation show you? Keep talking until your group agrees, and say why.

Now our group thinks

How did our talk go?

Hatched or born, changing shape or not

Some baby animals hatch out of eggs and some are born. Magpie geese, platypuses, frogs and the insects here hatch out of eggs. Kangaroos and humans are born. The platypus is a mammal that lays eggs. The only other mammals that lay eggs are echidnas.

A frog, a moth, a beetle and a butterfly change into a new body shape as they grow up. A goose, a platypus, a kangaroo and a human don’t. Some of them start out very small and not fully formed, like a newborn joey the size of a jelly bean, but they keep the same body shape as they grow. All of them grow up and have young of their own, so every life cycle goes round.

My notebook

Which of these animals hatches out of an egg?

Which animal changes into a new body shape as it grows up?

5Talk, try it, talk again

Life cycles and the seasons

How do people use what they know about life cycles?

In Kakadu, in the Northern Territory, the Bininj and Mungguy people know six seasons in the year. They know when magpie geese nest, when the goslings hatch and when the geese are fat. They use what they know to decide when to collect eggs and when to hunt.

On this screen

  1. Talk about what would happen to the magpie geese if people took every egg, every year.
  2. Go round the six seasons. In each one, read what the weather, the geese and the people are doing.
  3. Answer the three find-it questions by choosing the right season.
  4. Talk again, then read the key idea.

Talk first

What would happen to the magpie geese if people took every egg, every year?

Talk about it in your group before you try the simulation. Take turns, and say why you think so.

  • I think … because …
  • Why do you think that?
  • I agree, because …
  • I disagree, because …
Our group thinks

Tap a season on the wheel, or use the buttons. The picture shows the floodplain in that season, and the words under it say what is happening. The season names and months are the knowledge of Kakadu’s Traditional Owners, as given on Parks Australia’s Kakadu website.

Six seasons in Kakadu

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Talk again

What would happen to the magpie geese if people took every egg, every year?

Now talk about the question again. What did the simulation show you? Keep talking until your group agrees, and say why.

Now our group thinks

How did our talk go?

Knowing a life cycle

Magpie geese breed in the wet season. They build nests from rushes and grasses in the flooded wetlands. The goslings hatch after about 25 days, and the young can fly at about 10 weeks old. By the cold weather season the geese are fat and heavy. Bininj and Mungguy people know this cycle and the seasons that go with it, so they know when there are eggs to collect and when to hunt the geese.

Collecting eggs every year only works if enough eggs hatch and grow into geese that lay eggs of their own. Bininj and Mungguy people use what they know about the geese’s life cycle to harvest the eggs in a way that can go on year after year. People read signs in nature too. Dry winds and the flowering Darwin woollybutt tell them when it is time to start patch burning.

My notebook

In which season do magpie geese start to nest in Kakadu?

In Yekke, what tells people that it is time to start patch burning?

6Talk it through, then look back

Talk it through

What is the same about every life cycle?

The last talk. Sixteen pictures from four life cycles are mixed up. Put each life cycle back together as a group, then talk about what all life cycles share.

On this screen

  1. Talk about what is the same about every life cycle.
  2. Put the sixteen cards back into their four life cycles, starting each one with the egg or the seed. Check, and fix any crosses.
  3. Talk again, then look back at how your group talked in this lesson.
  4. Answer the last two questions and look at your results.

Talk first

What is the same about every life cycle?

Talk about it in your group before you try the simulation. Take turns, and say why you think so.

  • I think … because …
  • Why do you think that?
  • I agree, because …
  • I disagree, because …
Our group thinks

Tap a card, then tap the life cycle it belongs to. It goes into the next empty space, so start with the egg or the seed and go round. Tap a card in a life cycle to send it back. Three of the cards are eggs: talk about how you can tell whose eggs they are.

Four life cycles, mixed up

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Talk again

What is the same about every life cycle?

Now talk about the question again. What did the simulation show you? Keep talking until your group agrees, and say why.

Now our group thinks

How did our talk go?

Every life cycle goes round

Every life cycle goes round: the young grow up, and the grown-ups make young of their own. Flowering plants start as seeds. Animals hatch out of eggs or are born. Some animals change shape as they grow and some don’t. Some life cycles take weeks and some take years.

You worked all this out by talking: sharing ideas, giving reasons, listening and trying to agree. Researchers found that children who learnt to talk like this got better at working things out together, and on their own as well.

How your group talked

My notebook

What is the same about every life cycle?

Your group can’t agree whether a seed is alive. What is the best thing to do?

Printable activity

Living things and life cycles: talk, sort and grow

Two pages. Page 1 is for groups: the talk rules, eight things from around the school to sort into living, once living and non-living with a reason for each, and the life cycle of a frog to put in order. Page 2 is an investigation into whether a bean seed needs water to start growing, with a bean diary to keep for four weeks.

For teachers

Curriculum

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 3, Science understanding, Biological sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:

AC9S3U01 compare characteristics of living and non-living things and examine the differences between the life cycles of plants and animals

  • classifying a collection of objects as living, once living or non-living and explaining their reasoning
  • observing and describing differences between metamorphic (such as butterflies, beetles or frogs) and non-metamorphic life cycles of animals, including humans
  • comparing the physical characteristics of an animal such as a frog or moth with its activity at different stages of its life cycle
  • representing stages of a plant or animal’s life cycle using drawings, digital photographs, graphic organisers or concrete materials
  • investigating how First Nations Australians understand and utilise the life cycles of certain species

The second quote gives all five of ACARA’s elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each part of the content description is covered on these screens:

  • Compare characteristics of living and non-living things: screen 1, twelve things tested with four questions (does it grow, make young or seeds, need food and water, react to things around it) and sorted into living, once living and non-living; the dead bean plant on screen 2 becomes once living; q-alive and q-puddle.
  • Examine the differences between the life cycles of plants and animals: screen 2, a bean from seed to seed and a grass tree; screen 3, the frog and the emperor gum moth; screen 4, the magpie goose, the platypus, the red kangaroo and a human, and eight animals sorted by how they start and whether they change shape; screen 5, the magpie goose’s cycle through the Kakadu seasons; screen 6, a plant and three animals rebuilt side by side; q-seed, q-cycle, q-tadpole, q-moth, q-hatch, q-shape and q-same.

The elaborations: classifying living, once living and non-living things with reasons is screen 1. Metamorphic and non-metamorphic life cycles, including humans, are screens 3 and 4, and the grid on screen 4 includes the butterflies and beetles that ACARA names. The frog and moth at each stage, body against activity, is screen 3, where every stage card says what its body is like and what it does. Representing life cycle stages is the wheels on screens 2, 3, 4 and 6, the frog cards and the bean diary on the printable. How First Nations Australians understand and use life cycles is screen 5, drawn from ACARA’s own teacher background information for this elaboration (reference below), which also supplies the grass tree on screen 2. The lesson touches related content too: AC9S3H02’s elaboration on how First Nations Australians observe developmental changes “to make decisions about when to harvest certain resources” is screen 5; the fair test of a bean seed with and without water on the printable fits AC9S3I02; and comparing and agreeing on findings in groups fits AC9S3I05. AC9S3H01’s elaboration names Maria Sibylla Merian, “who was the first to record the nature of metamorphosis”, which makes a good extension after screen 3. The Natural History Museum in London calls her “one of the first to closely observe and record the process of insect metamorphosis”, and says she knew the work of Jan Goedaert, who “also painted insect life cycles”.

How the lesson is taught

The method is exploratory talk, from the Thinking Together research programme. Exploratory talk is talk in a group in which, in the words of Mercer, Dawes, Wegerif and Sams (2004): “All relevant information is shared”; “All members of the group are invited to contribute to the discussion”; “Opinions and ideas are respected and considered”; “Everyone is asked to make their reasons clear”; “Challenges and alternatives are made explicit and are negotiated”; and “The group seeks to reach agreement before taking a decision or acting.” Teachers first agree ground rules for talk with the class, such as, in the words of the programme’s Key Stage 2 page, “listening with respect, providing and seeking reasons for opinions, encouraging partners to give their views and trying to reach joint decisions.” Then groups work on activities that need a joint decision with reasons.

The main study is Mercer and colleagues (2004). Seven Year 5 classes of children aged 9 and 10 in Milton Keynes began with five lessons in which each class agreed ground rules for talk, then had seven Thinking Together lessons in science and maths, some built around computer activities; the tests were 23 weeks apart. Matched classes in similar local schools followed the normal curriculum. On science problems from the QCA’s optional Key Stage 2 tests, the target classes’ mean score rose from 3.97 to 5.70 and the control classes’ from 4.22 to 5.04 (effect size .29); on a concept-mapping task the effect size was .74. On a reasoning test (Raven’s matrices) the target children improved more when working in groups (effect size .55) and also when working alone (.27). The study has limits. The classes were matched, not assigned at random. Only 109 of the 196 target children completed the programme. The study was run by the Thinking Together team, and the authors say it cannot separate the effect of the teacher’s guidance from the effect of the group talk. They concluded that “if teachers provide children with an explicit, practical introduction to the use of language for collective reasoning”, then “children learn better ways of thinking collectively and better ways of thinking alone.”

Littleton and colleagues (2005) worked with Year 2 children in England. Six teachers in three schools taught twelve Thinking Together lessons, in mixed groups of three, and some talk lessons of their own. The study did not measure science learning. In a reasoning task, six recorded target groups used ‘because’ or ‘’cos’ 36 times after the lessons against 9 before, while three control groups went from 15 to 21. These are raw counts, with no statistical test. A larger trial of a related, teacher-led approach, the Education Endowment Foundation’s Dialogic Teaching evaluation with almost 5,000 Year 5 pupils in 76 schools, found two extra months’ progress in English and science and one in maths. A 2019 follow-up found no effect on the pupils’ national tests at the end of primary school, and the EEF says “it is likely that many schools did not implement the programme in Year 6, prior to the KS2 testing”. Larger trials of two other talk-based programmes found no effect. Thinking, Doing, Talking Science, which builds “deeper thinking and discussion” into Year 5 science lessons, added about three months’ progress in a first trial in 40 schools, but a trial in 205 schools with 8,966 pupils found “no evidence of an impact on pupils’ science attainment, on average”. A 2021 trial of Philosophy for Children in 198 schools found “no evidence that P4C had an impact on pupils’ reading or maths outcomes”.

So for Year 3 the evidence is promising but limited. The two Thinking Together studies are small and were run by the programme’s own team, and Year 3 children are older than those in the Year 2 study and younger than those in the Year 5 study. Whether the method lifts Year 3 science learning in this online form has not been tested. The talk boxes are this lesson’s own way of building in the method’s two parts. Screen 1 sets out five ground rules for the group to agree and adds a space for one of their own. Each screen then asks one question to talk about before the simulation and again after it, and each time the group must choose one answer together and write its reason. The hint under the reason box looks for words such as ‘because’, ‘if’ and ‘why’, three of the words Littleton and colleagues counted, and also accepts ‘so’ and ‘since’. Not agreeing yet is always a choice. The ‘How did our talk go?’ ticks and the tally on screen 6 are the lesson’s additions, so that the group looks back at how it talked as well as at what it decided.

Groups of three work well, as in the Year 2 study, and each group needs one device. Mercer and colleagues stress an “explicit, practical introduction” to talk, so model it first: think aloud with a volunteer, using ‘I think … because …’ and ‘Why do you think that?’, and let the class hear you change your mind. Then listen in and ask ‘Why?’ more than you answer. The notebook questions and the quiz are done alone, after the talk. The lesson also works with the whole class around one screen, the class talking in groups and you taking each group’s answer and reason.

Handle with care

  • Children’s ideas about living things. The Primary SPACE Project’s report on processes of life (Osborne, Wadsworth and Black, 1992) asked children to sort objects into living, once living and never living, and gives the results through three children’s sorts and their reasons. Leah, aged nine and a half, put the apple and the seed in once living (of the apple, “It was alive when it was growing on a tree”), and said of the rock, “It was an animal once and it turned into a rock”. Jermaine, aged 5, judged by what he could see (the plastic box was not alive because “It hasn’t got a face”), and put the seed in once living. Arridet, aged 6, put the animal, the insect, the apple and the seed in never living. Across all the children, movement and growth were the reasons used most, and other processes of life were used “in a very small number of instances out of a total possibility of 675 opportunities to apply criteria”. The report also sets out Piaget’s stages, one of which is “Things that move by themselves are alive”, and Lucas and colleagues’ criticism that the ‘attributes of life’ used in earlier studies “are strongly biased towards humans and ignore plants”. Expect groups to argue about the seed, the gum tree, the robot dog and the glass of water: they are on screen 1 for these reasons.
  • Rocks. Some rocks did form from once living things: Geoscience Australia says “Coal is a sedimentary rock formed when abundant plant material is covered by sediments”. If a child argues that coal is once living, and gives that reason, accept it. The rock on screen 1 is an ordinary stone.
  • The words. ACARA’s elaboration uses living, once living and non-living, so the lesson does too, with non-living meaning never alive. Point out that a once living thing is not alive now either; the SPACE report uses ‘never living’ for the third group, which some children find clearer.
  • The four questions. They are a short version of the much longer list of shared features in the biology text (order, response to the environment, reproduction, adaptation, growth and development, regulation, energy processing and evolution), chosen because Year 3 students can check them. Not every single living thing has young, and a seed has not made seeds of its own yet, so the question is really whether that kind of living thing makes young or seeds. The text also notes that “it is not always easy to define life”.
  • Animals that don’t fit. A few frogs have no tadpole stage: the biology text says “the eggs of frogs in the genus Eleutherodactylus develop directly into little froglets”, so the lesson says ‘most frogs’. Not every moth makes a cocoon, so the lesson says a moth changes as a pupa, often inside a cocoon. In an ant nest the queens lay the eggs, and the workers are sterile.
  • Reproduction. The lesson says only that animals lay eggs or are born and that adults have young. SPACE avoided sexual reproduction in its research because it was hard to study with young children. Be ready for questions about how babies start, and answer them as your school’s policy says.
  • Live animals and plants. Growing beans is safe and easy. If you keep tadpoles or caterpillars, check your state’s rules first and return animals to the exact spot they came from. The emperor gum moth may stay in its cocoon, as a pupa, for a year or more.
  • The First Nations content. Screen 5 uses only ACARA’s teacher background information for elaboration 5 and Parks Australia’s Kakadu page on the six seasons. ACARA’s page says that written records can be problematic, because they are often based on non-Indigenous interpretations, and that they “may contain cultural breaches and cause offence to the Peoples concerned”. It says “The consulted works are not provided or recommended as classroom resources.”, and that, “With careful selection, evaluation and community consultation”, those works may give teachers reference material to adapt into culturally appropriate resources. The six Kakadu seasons are the knowledge of Kakadu’s Traditional Owners: Parks Australia says they “recognise six different seasons based on thousands of years of local knowledge.” ACARA names the Bininj and Mungguy Peoples as the people who manage the floodplain wetlands. Other Peoples have their own seasons (ACARA’s page mentions the Miriwoong calendar of three seasons and the D’harawal calendar of six), so if you want to bring in the seasons of your own area, work with your local community. ACARA’s page also describes moths: witjuri, a large wood moth whose larvae the Adnyamathanha Peoples of the Flinders Ranges harvest; moth pupae dug from the foot of gum trees by the Gunditjmara Peoples of western Victoria; and the bogong moths that gather in caves in the Snowy Mountains on Ngarigo lands.
  • Reduced motion. With the device’s reduce-motion setting on, each growing run jumps to its end, and the season pictures move only when a button is pressed.

About the models

  • Screen 1: the answers to the four questions are written for each thing; there is no model. The check marks each sorted thing right or wrong, and the reason for a thing is shown when it is right or after it has been wrong twice, so that groups talk before they are told.
  • Screen 2: the bean grows 7 days a second. It comes up on day 7, opens its first leaves by day 12, flowers from about day 42, has green pods by day 56, ripe dry pods by day 77, and drops its seeds from day 84. The WA growing guide gives 5 to 14 days for beans to come up and 7 to 11 weeks to the first pods to pick, about two weeks after flowering; the later stages, when pods are left to ripen for seed, are the lesson’s own timing. With no water a seed waits and does not change. A plant that has started growing wilts after 4 days without water and dies after 10; these numbers are made up to show the idea. The grass tree grows 1.5 cm a year in the model, the middle of ACARA’s “one to two centimetres annually”, so its trunk is 1.5 m tall at 100 years old. It can flower from age 20 in the model, because an ecologist writing in The Conversation says “It can take over 20 years before a grass tree produces its first flowers.” ACARA says only that grass trees “may take several years to flower”. The same article says “Flowering is not dependent on fire, but it stimulates the process.” The model leaves fire out, and its flowering stem is drawn, not measured.
  • Screens 3, 4 and 6: the stage pictures are drawn to fit their cards and are not to scale.
  • Screen 5: the wheel shares out the year using Parks Australia’s months, with the change from Kunumeleng to Kudjewk put in late December, because Parks Australia gives Kunumeleng as mid-October to late December and Kudjewk as December to March. The goose stage shown in each season is the lesson’s own working from the sources. ACARA says nests are built in the wet season, laying starts about two months after nest building, goslings hatch after about 25 days and can fly at about 10 weeks. The Australian Museum gives the breeding season as “February to June”, and the Northern Territory Government says “Magpie geese usually breed late in the wet season.” That puts nests and the first eggs in Kudjewk, eggs and goslings in Bangkerreng, growing goslings in Yekke and most young geese flying in Wurrkeng, although real years vary. The fat geese in Wurrkeng, the egg collecting in Kudjewk and the patch burning in Yekke and Wurrkeng come straight from the sources.

Where sources disagree and what to check

  • Season names. Parks Australia spells the seasons Kudjewk, Bangkerreng, Yekke, Wurrkeng, Kurrung and Kunumeleng, and the lesson uses these spellings and Parks Australia’s headings, such as ‘Hot dry weather’ for Kurrung. ACARA’s page writes Gudjewg, wurrgeng and gurrung for three of them. It gives the same months as Parks Australia for Gudjewg (December to March), and whole months for the other two: wurrgeng June to August, and gurrung, which ACARA calls the hot, dry season, mid-August to October.
  • Magpie goose clutches. ACARA says “clutch size varies from a single egg up to 14 eggs per breeding cycle”; the Australian Museum says “Up to 16 eggs for 2 females, but 8 more common”. The lesson uses ACARA’s figure.
  • How fast grass trees grow. ACARA says the plant grows “approximately one to two centimetres annually”. The ecologist writing in The Conversation says “Most grow slowly (0.8–6 cm in height per year)”, faster after good rain. The model uses 1.5 cm a year.
  • How long joeys drink milk. The biology text says that in kangaroos “the young joeys continue to nurse for about a year and a half”; the Australian Museum says a red kangaroo joey suckles until about 12 months old. Kangaroo species differ, and the lesson uses the museum’s figures because it names the red kangaroo.
  • Platypus eggs. The Australian Museum says the mother incubates the eggs “for possibly 10 days”, so the lesson says ‘Scientists think’.
  • Moths that do not eat. The emperor gum moth cannot feed as an adult. The Australian Museum’s page on moths and butterflies says that adult moths and butterflies feed on nectar from flowers, and that “Some adults don’t even feed at all”, so the lesson does not say that all moths go without food.
  • Exploratory talk and age. The science gains come from one small study of Year 5 classes, run by the programme’s own team. The Year 2 study counted words, not learning, and larger trials of two related talk programmes found no effect. Treat the method as promising for Year 3 science, not proven for it.

Answers at a glance

  • Screen 1: talk question, a seed is living. Living: dog, frog, ant, gum tree, bean seed. Once living: wooden spoon, feather, dead leaf. Non-living: rock, robot dog, metal spoon, glass of water. q-alive a bean seed; q-puddle no, the water was never alive.
  • Screen 2: talk question, neither: it goes round. q-seed water; q-cycle because it goes round, the seeds growing into plants that make new seeds.
  • Screen 3: talk question, yes, a tadpole is a young frog. Frog: eggs, tadpole, tadpole with legs, froglet, frog. Moth: eggs, caterpillar, cocoon, moth. q-tadpole the same animal at different stages; q-moth from the food it ate as a caterpillar.
  • Screen 4: talk question, no, some are born. Hatches and changes shape: frog, moth, beetle, butterfly. Hatches and keeps its shape: magpie goose, platypus. Born and keeps its shape: red kangaroo, human. None of the eight is born and then changes shape. q-hatch a platypus; q-shape a frog.
  • Screen 5: talk question, there would be fewer and fewer geese. Nests and first eggs: Kudjewk. Patch burning starts: Yekke. Fat geese on shrinking billabongs: Wurrkeng. q-season Kudjewk; q-sign dry winds and the flowering Darwin woollybutt.
  • Screen 6: talk question, they all go round. Bean: a seed, a shoot with two leaves, a plant with flowers, pods with seeds inside. Frog: eggs in jelly, a tadpole, a froglet, a frog. Moth: eggs on a gum leaf, a caterpillar, a cocoon, a moth. Magpie goose: eggs in a nest, a fluffy gosling, a young goose flying, a grown goose. q-same the young grow up and make young of their own; q-talk everyone gives their reason, then you talk and try to agree.
  • Printable: the answers are printed upside down at the foot of page 1. A pot plant and an earthworm are living; a pencil (its wood), a cotton T-shirt and a paper bag are once living; a steel paperclip, a stone and a glass of water are non-living. The frog pictures go eggs, tadpole, tadpole with legs, froglet, frog. In the bean test the seeds on damp paper grow roots and shoots and the dry ones do not change.

Saved progress

Answers, talk records, notes, ticks and settings are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere. If groups share devices, clear the saved answers between groups.

References

Sources by screen

  • Method: Mercer, Dawes, Wegerif and Sams (2004); Littleton and colleagues (2005); Thinking Together’s Key Stage 2 page; the Education Endowment Foundation’s Dialogic Teaching and Thinking, Doing, Talking Science evaluations; the National Foundation for Educational Research’s Philosophy for Children evaluation. Children’s ideas about living things: Osborne, Wadsworth and Black (1992). Coal: Geoscience Australia. Merian: the Natural History Museum.
  • Screen 1: Biology 2e, 1.2 (the shared features of living things; plants bend towards light; technology can regulate but is not alive) and 32.2 (a seed holds an embryo with stored food and can stay dormant until conditions suit it); the Western Australian growing guide (the soil temperature beans need to start growing); the Australian Museum’s page on ant colonies (the queens lay the eggs and feed the larvae; the workers are sterile).
  • Screen 2: Biology 2e, 32.2 (seed parts, the root first, the hooked shoot, dormancy, beans as fruit, and fruits such as pea pods that release their seeds); the Western Australian growing guide (days to come up, first pods, moist soil, soil temperature); ACARA’s background information for elaboration 5 (the grass tree’s growth, flowering and seeds); Patykowski in The Conversation (the grass tree’s first flowers, fire and growth).
  • Screen 3: Biology 2e, 29.3 (frog eggs, tadpoles, metamorphosis, adult frogs, frogs with no tadpole stage) and 28.6 (complete metamorphosis in beetles and butterflies; growth only in the young stages); the Australian Museum’s pages on the emperor gum moth and on moths and butterflies.
  • Screen 4: ACARA’s background information for elaboration 5 (the magpie goose’s nests, eggs, goslings and first flight); Biology 2e, 29.5 (newly hatched birds in down) and 29.6 (monotremes lay eggs; marsupial young finish growing in a pouch; mammals feed their young milk); the Australian Museum’s pages on the platypus and the red kangaroo (its birth, pouch life, body length and one joey at a time).
  • Screen 5: Parks Australia’s Kakadu seasons page; ACARA’s background information for elaboration 5 (the Bininj and Mungguy Peoples, the magpie goose’s cycle, the egg harvest and the hunting seasons); the Australian Museum’s magpie goose page (the breeding season and clutch size); the Northern Territory Government’s magpie goose page (breeding late in the wet season).
  • Screen 6 and the printable: the sources for screens 1 to 4, and the Western Australian growing guide (soil temperature, damp but not waterlogged, seed treated before planting).
  • Word list: the sources for the screen where each word is first used.

Word list