AusSci

Year 4 science · Chemical sciences · AC9S4U04

Why is it made of that?

1Ask

What is it made of?

What are the things around you made of?

A jar, a ruler and a window are objects. Every object is made of a material. A spoon is an object. Metal is its material.

On this screen

  1. Read the design brief.
  2. Name what eight objects are made of.
  3. Do the three tasks.
  4. Read the key idea.
  5. Go on a materials hunt in your classroom.

Design step 1: Ask

The design brief: by screen 5 you will design a small tent. An engineer starts by asking questions. The first question is: what materials are there to choose from?

Choose an object, then press the material it is made of. Two of the objects are made of two materials, so they need two presses. The table under the picture puts each object into its groups.

Wool and cotton are fibres. Steel and aluminium are metals. When you have named all eight objects, sort six materials in the second table: is each one a natural material or a made material?

Eight objects in a classroom

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Name what all eight objects are made of.

    Need a hint?

    Choose an object, then press a material. The scissors and the window need two materials each.

  2. Sort the six materials: natural or made.

    Need a hint?

    Read where each material comes from. If it grows, or is cut from a tree, it is natural.

  3. Answer the question about the drink can.

    Need a hint?

    The object is the thing. The material is what the thing is made of.

Talk about it. Which material is used most in your classroom? Tell your partner why you think so.

Objects and materials

An object is a thing, such as a jar or a ruler. A material is what the object is made of, such as glass or wood. The scissors and the window are each made of two materials.

Natural materials come from plants, animals or the ground, and are changed only a little. Wool, cotton and wood are natural materials.

Made materials are made by people. Glass is made from sand. Plastic is made from oil and gas. Steel is made from iron, which comes from a rock called iron ore.

Fibres, metals, glass and plastics are four big groups of materials. Wool and cotton are natural fibres. Nylon is a made fibre.

Now for real

A materials hunt

Do this with real things. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • A pencil and paper
  • Your classroom

What to do

  1. Find ten objects in your classroom.
  2. Write each object and the material it is made of.
  3. Put a star next to any object made of two materials or more.
  4. Group the objects by material. Which group is the biggest?

Take care. Look at glass things, such as windows, without pushing on them. Leave power points, cables, heaters and sharp tools alone. Ask before you pick up anything that is not yours.

My notebook

A drink can is made of aluminium. Which word names the material?

Which of these is a natural material?

2Ask

Test the properties

What can each material do?

A property is something you can say about a material: how it looks, how it feels, or what it does in a test. Scientists and engineers test materials to find their properties.

On this screen

  1. Read the design step.
  2. Test six samples on the screen.
  3. Do the three tasks.
  4. Read the key idea.
  5. Test real things.

Design step 1: Ask

A tent cover must keep the rain out. Tent poles must hold the tent up. The next question to ask is: what can each material do?

Choose a sample, then press a test. There are five tests, and each result goes into the table. The words in the table are the science words for the result: flexible or stiff; transparent, translucent or opaque; waterproof or absorbent; magnetic; and brittle.

The steel, the aluminium, the glass and the hard plastic are flat pieces as thick as a ruler. The soft plastic is a clear bag, and the cotton is a cloth. Glass is dropped on the screen only, never for real.

Six samples and five tests

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Find the sample that soaks up water. Do the water test on all six.

    Need a hint?

    Choose each sample in turn, and press Drip water on it.

  2. Test both metals with the magnet, then answer the magnet question.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Steel and press Hold a magnet over it. Then do the same with Aluminium.

  3. Do the light test and the drop test on glass and on hard plastic. Then answer the last question.

    Need a hint?

    Look along the rows for Glass and Hard plastic. Which results are the same, and which are different?

Talk about it. Glass is brittle. Why are the windows of a house still made of glass? Tell your partner.

Properties of materials

Each material has its own set of properties. Glass is transparent, stiff and waterproof, and it is brittle. Hard plastic is transparent and waterproof too, but it does not break when it is dropped.

Both metals are stiff, waterproof and opaque. A magnet pulls steel. It does not pull aluminium. Only some metals are magnetic.

Cotton cloth is flexible and absorbent. Soft plastic is flexible and waterproof.

How easily a piece bends also depends on how thick it is. Thin aluminium foil folds easily. A thick aluminium rod is stiff.

Now for real

Test real things

Do this with real things. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • A torch
  • A cup of water and a spoon
  • A fridge magnet
  • A steel can, an aluminium can, a plastic bottle and a plastic bag
  • Three pieces of cloth: cotton, wool and nylon

What to do

  1. Shine the torch at each thing. Does light get through?
  2. Put one drop of water on each thing. Does it soak in or stay on top?
  3. Hold the magnet against each thing. Does it pull?
  4. Write your results in a table like the one on the screen. Do the three kinds of cloth give the same results?

Take care. Do not test glass, and do not drop or bend anything hard. Use cans with no sharp edges. Use a fridge magnet, not small loose magnets. Do not shine the torch into anyone’s eyes. Keep plastic bags away from your face. Wipe up spilt water.

My notebook

A magnet is held over a steel can and an aluminium can. What happens?

Water soaks into a cotton cloth. Which word describes the cotton?

3Imagine

A material for each part

Why is each part of a backpack made of a different material?

Many objects, such as backpacks and shoes, are made of more than one material. Each part has a job to do, and its material is chosen for the properties that the job needs.

On this screen

  1. Read the design step.
  2. Look at a backpack on the screen.
  3. Do the three tasks.
  4. Read the key idea.
  5. Look at a real backpack or shoe.

Design step 2: Imagine

Before engineers design something new, they look at how other people have solved the same kind of problem. Look at how a backpack is made, part by part.

Choose a part of the backpack to find what it is made of. In the table, press the properties that make the material right for that part. Then swap the material for another one, and read what happens.

A backpack, part by part

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Find what each of the three parts is made of.

    Need a hint?

    Press The body, The zip and The buckle in turn.

  2. Choose the properties that explain each material.

    Need a hint?

    In the table, press the properties that the part needs for its job.

  3. Swap the material of the body three times. Then answer the question.

    Need a hint?

    Choose The body, then press each material under Swap the material.

Talk about it. Look at your own backpack or one of your shoes. How many materials can you find in it?

The right material for each part

The body is nylon cloth because nylon cloth is light, strong and flexible. The zip is metal because metal is hard and strong. The buckle is hard plastic because hard plastic is light and hard.

A different material changes what the object can do. A cotton body soaks up the rain. A glass body cannot fold, and it breaks.

To find why a thing is made of a material, look at the properties of the material and the job the thing has to do.

Now for real

Look at a real backpack or shoe

Do this with real things. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • Your backpack, or one of your shoes
  • A pencil and paper

What to do

  1. Draw the backpack or the shoe.
  2. Label each part with the material you think it is made of.
  3. Next to each label, write one property that the part needs.
  4. Compare your drawing with your partner’s.

Take care. Wash your hands after you handle shoes.

My notebook

Why are the teeth of a zip made of metal or hard plastic, and not of cotton?

Which property would be a problem in a raincoat?

4Imagine

Chosen for their properties

How do First Nations Australians choose materials for tools, clothing and shelter?

For thousands of years, First Nations Australians have chosen and used natural materials from their Country or Place for many different purposes. Each material is chosen for its properties.

On this screen

  1. Read the design step.
  2. Match five natural materials to their uses.
  3. Do the three tasks.
  4. Read the key idea.

ACARA, the group that writes the Australian Curriculum, calls these “longstanding scientific knowledges of the properties of materials”. ACARA says that they have informed, and continue to inform, the choice of natural and made materials for particular jobs.

What this screen says comes from ACARA’s notes for teachers. The pictures show plain samples of five materials, drawn simply. No tools, shelters, clothing or people are drawn. ACARA’s notes say that the region where a People lived determined the resources that were available. Ask your teacher who your class could ask about the materials of the Country or Place you live on.

Design step 2: Imagine

Choosing a material for its properties is knowledge that is thousands of years old, and it is still used today. Match five natural materials to their uses.

Choose a material and read its properties. Then press the use that those properties fit. The table keeps each match. Three words to know: a durable material lasts a long time, a buoyant material floats, and to insulate is to slow down the heat moving in or out.

Five natural materials

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Match all five materials to their uses.

    Need a hint?

    Read the properties of the material. Then look for the use that needs those properties.

  2. Answer the question about the fishing spear.

    Need a hint?

    Buoyant means that it floats.

  3. Answer the last question, about all five choices.

    Need a hint?

    Look down the Properties column of your table.

Talk about it. Which natural materials grow or are found near where you live? What are their properties?

Chosen for their properties

Tools for striking and digging need to be hard, heavy and durable, so dense woods are used to make them.

A fishing spear needs a material that is lightweight, buoyant and flexible, so that the spear floats to the surface of the water and can be picked up again. The Meriam Peoples of the eastern Torres Strait Islands use lightweight bamboo to make baur, which are fishing spears with more than one prong.

Sandstone has long been widely used as a grindstone across Australia, because its rough surface grinds seeds well.

The Yir Yoront Peoples of the Kowanyama region of Cape York Peninsula use the strong, flexible stem of lawyer cane to tie roofing onto shelters.

Aboriginal Peoples whose Country has cool, wet climates made clothing from the furs of a variety of animals. The fur gave thermal insulation, and water did not pass through it.

In each of these, the properties of the material fit the use.

My notebook

ACARA’s notes say that a fishing spear needs a material that is lightweight, buoyant and flexible. Why buoyant?

Which property makes sandstone a good grindstone for seeds?

5Plan, create, improve

Design, test, improve

Which materials would you choose for a tent?

Now design the tent. An engineer plans, builds and tests, and then improves the design. When a test fails, it shows you what to change.

On this screen

  1. Read the brief.
  2. Design and test a tent on the screen.
  3. Do the three tasks.
  4. Read the key idea.
  5. Build and test a model tent for real.

Design steps 3, 4 and 5: Plan, create, improve

The brief: a small tent that stays dry inside in the rain, stands up in the wind, and weighs 700 g or less. Choose a cover and poles. Test your design. Then change one thing and test again.

Choose a material for the cover and a material for the poles. Press each of the three tests. The table keeps every design you test. If a test fails, read why, change one part and test again.

Waxed cotton cloth is cotton cloth with wax rubbed into it. The wax helps to keep water out of the cloth.

Design and test a tent

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Test your first design with all three tests.

    Need a hint?

    Choose a cover and poles. Then press Rain test, Wind test and Pack and carry test.

  2. Improve your design until it passes all three tests.

    Need a hint?

    Read why a test failed. Change the cover or the poles, not both, and test again.

  3. Answer the question about the poles.

    Need a hint?

    Compare the rows for steel rods and aluminium rods in your table.

Talk about it. Two different tents pass all three tests. Which would you take camping, and why?

Design, test, improve

The cover must be waterproof. The soft plastic sheet and the waxed cotton cloth passed the rain test. Plain cotton cloth is absorbent, so the rain soaked through it.

The poles must be stiff, light and not brittle. The aluminium rods passed every test. The steel rods are stiff but heavy. The glass rods are stiff and light but brittle. The thin plastic rods bend.

No material is best at everything. A designer chooses the material whose properties fit the job, tests the design, and improves it.

Treating a material can change its properties. Wax rubbed into cotton cloth helps to keep water out.

Now for real

Build and test a model tent

Do this with real things. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • Straws, blunt sticks or pipe cleaners for the poles
  • Pieces of cloth, pieces cut from a plastic bag, paper and foil for the cover
  • Tape or string
  • A clean spray bottle of water and a tray
  • A small toy
  • The printable design sheet

What to do

  1. Plan: choose a cover and poles, and write why on your design sheet.
  2. Create: build your tent over the toy, on the tray.
  3. Test: spray the tent with water ten times, then wave a book beside it five times. Is the toy dry? Is the tent still standing?
  4. Improve: change one thing, and test again.

Take care. Your teacher cuts anything that needs cutting, and bends over the sharp ends of pipe cleaners. Use blunt sticks only. Keep plastic bags away from your face. Wipe up spilt water straight away.

My notebook

A tent cover made of plain cotton cloth fails the rain test. Why?

Your tent passes the rain test and the wind test, but it is too heavy. What do you do next?

6Improve

After it is used

What happens to a material when we have finished with it?

Designers also think about what happens to a thing after it has been used. Some materials can be recycled: they are collected, sorted and made into new things. A single-use plastic is made to be used once and then thrown away.

On this screen

  1. Read the design step.
  2. Sort eight things for recycling.
  3. Swap three single-use plastics.
  4. Do the three tasks.
  5. Read the key idea.
  6. Check your own bins.
  7. Answer the last two questions and look at your results.

Design step 5: Improve

Improve the things we use every day. Sort eight things for recycling. Then find a material that can be used again and again in place of a single-use plastic.

Recycling rules are different from council to council. This screen uses the list of one council, the City of Darwin, for its yellow recycling bin. Find out what your own council takes.

Choose Sort for recycling. For each thing, press where it goes. Then choose Swap a single-use plastic, and find a material that can be reused again and again.

Sort it, then swap it

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Sort all eight things: the yellow recycling bin, or not.

    Need a hint?

    Hard plastic containers go in. Soft plastics, such as bags, do not.

  2. Find a material to use again and again in place of each single-use plastic.

    Need a hint?

    Think of the properties the thing needs. A bottle must be waterproof. A fork must be hard.

  3. Answer the last question, about the steel bottle.

    Need a hint?

    Look at the properties of steel in your results on screen 2.

Talk about it. Which single-use plastics could your class stop using? What would you use in their place?

Recycle, and use again

In the City of Darwin, glass bottles and jars, aluminium and steel cans, cardboard and paper, and hard plastic containers go in the yellow recycling bin. They are sorted. The plastics, metals, paper and cardboard are then sent away to be made into new things.

Plastic bags and other soft plastics, old clothing and mirrors do not go in the yellow bin. Your council may have a different list.

At a sorting centre, the properties of the materials help to sort them. At one centre, in Brisbane, a rotating magnet separates the steel cans from everything else.

A single-use plastic is made to be used once and then thrown away. A material that can be washed and used again and again, such as steel or cotton cloth, can take its place.

Now for real

Check your own bins

Do this with real things. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • Your council’s recycling list, which your teacher can find
  • Clean, empty packaging from home or the canteen
  • Gloves or tongs

What to do

  1. Read your council’s list. What goes in the recycling bin? What does it say about lids and bags?
  2. Sort the packaging into two piles: recycling and rubbish.
  3. Count the single-use plastics. Write down what each one is.
  4. For one of them, find out what could be used in its place.

Take care. Use only clean, empty packaging. Do not sort glass, or cans with sharp edges. Wash your hands afterwards.

My notebook

Which of these goes in the City of Darwin’s yellow recycling bin?

What is a single-use plastic?

Printable activity

My tent design

Two pages for building and testing a real model tent. Page 1 is the plan: the brief, your materials, your reasons and a drawing. Page 2 is the test table, what you changed, and your best design.

For teachers

Curriculum

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 4, Science understanding, Chemical sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:

AC9S4U04 examine the properties of natural and made materials including fibres, metals, glass and plastics and consider how these properties influence their use

  • identifying and naming materials in the classroom, and grouping objects made of similar materials or combinations of materials
  • exploring vocabulary for describing properties; observing different fibres, metals, glass and plastics; and using appropriate terms to describe, compare and contrast their properties
  • investigating familiar objects, such as shoes, drink containers or backpacks, examining the combination of materials from which they are made and suggesting reasons for those combinations based on properties of materials
  • considering how First Nations Australians use materials for different purposes, such as tools, clothing and shelter, based on their properties
  • designing, building and testing an object or structure for a specific purpose, such as a tent, lunchbox or bird feeder
  • investigating which materials can be recycled and researching alternatives for materials such as single use plastics

The second quote gives all six of ACARA’s elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each one has a screen:

  • Identifying and naming materials, and grouping objects by material: screen 1 names what eight objects are made of and sorts six materials into natural and made; q-object and q-natural.
  • Words for properties, and describing and comparing fibres, metals, glass and plastics: screen 2 tests six samples in five ways; q-magnet and q-words.
  • Familiar objects and the reasons for their combinations of materials: screen 3 takes a backpack part by part; q-zip and q-rain.
  • How First Nations Australians use materials for tools, clothing and shelter, based on their properties: screen 4; q-spear and q-grind.
  • Designing, building and testing an object for a purpose: screen 5 designs, tests and improves a tent, and the printable design sheet is for building a real model; q-cover and q-improve.
  • Which materials can be recycled, and alternatives for single-use plastics: screen 6; q-bin and q-single.

The lesson also works on parts of these content descriptions. Students follow a procedure and keep a results table on every screen, plan and carry out tests on screens 2 and 5, change one thing at a time when they improve the tent, and draw conclusions from their tables. Two parts are not done unless you add them. Students are given the safety rules, not asked to consider them, so before the build ask the class what could go wrong and how they will stay safe. And nothing is measured for real, because the weighing is on the screen only: to add a formal measurement, weigh the model tents on kitchen scales and set your own limit. Screens 3, 5 and 6 are where students consider how people use what science explains about materials to meet a need, which is AC9S4H02.

AC9S4H02 consider how people use scientific explanations to meet a need or solve a problem

AC9S4I02 use provided scaffolds to plan and conduct investigations to answer questions or test predictions, including identifying the elements of fair tests, and considering the safe use of materials and equipment

AC9S4I03 follow procedures to make and record observations, including making formal measurements using familiar scaled instruments and using digital tools as appropriate

AC9S4I04 construct and use representations, including tables, simple column graphs and visual or physical models, to organise data and information, show simple relationships and identify patterns

AC9S4I05 compare findings with those of others, consider if investigations were fair, identify questions for further investigation and draw conclusions

The site’s Year 3 heat lesson tests how quickly heat moves through metal, ceramic and plastic, so thermal conductors and insulators are not tested again here. Whether a material conducts electricity is left for Year 6.

How the lesson is taught

The method is engineering design. Students are given a design brief on screen 1 (a small tent), find out what they need to know to meet it, and then plan, build, test and improve. The step names on the screens are those of Engineering is Elementary, a primary curriculum from the Museum of Science in Boston, which describes “an age-appropriate five-step engineering design process: Ask, Imagine, Plan, Create, and Improve.” Screens 1 and 2 are Ask: what materials are there, and what can each one do? Screens 3 and 4 are Imagine: how have other people matched materials to jobs? Screen 5 is Plan, Create and Improve. Screen 6 improves everyday things by thinking about what happens after they are used. Every screen has a simulation with a results table and three tasks, and five of the six have a real activity to follow. The real build on screen 5, with the printable design sheet, is the centre of the method.

The research. The closest study is Wendell and Lee (2010), in which nine third graders designed and built a model house, and in interviews before and after it “students significantly improved on both materials selection tasks”. Wendell and Rogers (2013) compared the classes of 12 teachers who taught science with their usual curriculum in one year and with engineering design units in the next, in four science topics. The gain in science content “was significantly greater” with the design units, and there was “minimal difference” in attitudes to science. The largest study is Cunningham and colleagues (2020), a randomised trial of Engineering is Elementary in 604 classrooms in 152 schools in three states, in which its students “outperformed students in the comparison group on outcome measures of both engineering and science content learning.”

The limits. Wendell and Lee’s is a case study of nine students with no comparison group. Wendell and Rogers’s comparison was not randomised: the same teachers taught the two curricula in successive years, so the classes were different and the teachers had a year’s more experience, and the units used LEGO kits. In Cunningham’s trial both groups did engineering. Schools were assigned “to either the treatment curriculum or to a comparison curriculum that addressed the same learning goals but did not include several critical components”, so the trial shows that one engineering curriculum did better than a plainer one, not that engineering design does better than ordinary science teaching. All three come from projects in the United States in which students built things: a model house, LEGO designs and the units of Engineering is Elementary. Only their abstracts were read, so how long the teaching lasted and whether any of it was on a screen were not checked. None of them tested these simulations. A simulated tent passes or fails cleanly and a real one does not, which is why the real build matters. Ausgeology, this site’s sister site for Earth science, already teaches lessons through design-based learning, so the method is a repeat in kind, with new activities.

Handle with care

  • Risk assessment. Run the real activities under your school’s or system’s risk assessment process. Apart from the two quotations below, the safety advice in these notes and on the screens is the lesson’s own.
  • Glass. No real glass is bent, dropped or tested in this lesson. Those tests are on the screen only, and the care line on screen 2 tells students not to test glass. Students look at windows and jars without handling them. If glass breaks, keep students away and follow your school’s procedure. This advice is the lesson’s own.
  • Magnets. Use fridge magnets or large bar magnets for the real tests, never small loose ones. The Australian Competition and Consumer Commission warns that “Small high-powered magnets are dangerous if children swallow more than one magnet as they can stick together.”
  • Cans, scissors and plastic bags. Use cans with no sharp edges, or tape their rims. Do the cutting for the model tents yourself. Keep plastic bags away from faces.
  • The model tents. The cut ends of pipe cleaners are sharp wire, so bend them over. Use blunt sticks such as craft sticks, not skewers. Foil can have sharp edges. Use a new spray bottle, or one that has only ever held water, never one that held a cleaning product.
  • The materials hunt and the torch. On screen 1 students leave power points, cables, heaters and sharp tools alone. On screen 2 they keep the torch out of each other’s eyes.
  • Water. The real tests use drops of water and a spray bottle. Work on trays, and wipe up spills straight away.
  • Wax. The waxed cloth is on the screen only. To try it for real, rub a cold candle or a wax crayon hard into a piece of cotton cloth. Do not melt wax with students. The RSC chapter that suggests waxing also warns that “Great care should be taken and children closely supervised when using hot wax.”
  • Sorting rubbish. For the real activity on screen 6, use only clean, empty packaging, with no glass and no cans with sharp edges. Leave out packaging that held a food any student is allergic to. Students use gloves or tongs and wash their hands afterwards. If a student has a latex allergy, use gloves that are not latex.
  • The First Nations content. Screen 4, its key idea, q-spear and q-grind use only ACARA’s teacher background information for this elaboration, the fourth for AC9S4U04. The screen names the Peoples as ACARA names them and keeps ACARA’s tenses: dense woods “are used”, the Meriam Peoples and the Yir Yoront Peoples “use”, sandstone “has long been widely used”, and the clothing made from furs is in the past. Only plain samples of the five materials are drawn, with no tools, no shelters, no clothing and no people. The screen has not been checked with the Meriam Peoples, the Yir Yoront Peoples or any other People. ACARA’s page says that the region where a People lived “determined the resources that were available”, so do not present these five examples as the materials of all First Nations Australians. The same page says that “Prior to European arrival in Australia, there were more than 500 distinct Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Nations, each occupying a specific geographical territory.” It gives its own example of a difference between regions: “The Jirrbal Peoples of the Atherton Tableland region in far north Queensland do not use sandstone grindstones for processing the toxic cycad nut, as the process may deposit toxic residue in the stone.”, and “In this region, cycad seeds are processed using slate grinding stones.” The screen’s sentence about sandstone is ACARA’s, but it is not true of every place. ACARA also says that communities throughout Australia “utilise their material science knowledge and understanding in the continuation of cultural practices”, so speak of this knowledge in the present. The two Peoples named on the screen live in the Torres Strait and on Cape York Peninsula. ACARA’s cautions about its own consulted works apply to anything you add: such sources are “often based on non-Indigenous interpretations”, they “often lack the viewpoints of the people they discuss”, they “may contain cultural breaches and cause offence to the Peoples concerned”, and they need “careful selection, evaluation and community consultation”. ACARA calls choosing resources “an essential cultural capability skill for educators.” The advice that follows is the lesson’s own, because ACARA’s page gives none beyond those words. Before the lesson, find your school’s or system’s document on working with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities and Elders, and follow it. Ask your local community, or your Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander education staff, which materials are used on the Country your school is on, and whether and how to share that with students. The talk prompt on screen 4 asks about natural materials near where students live, and it is a place for local knowledge only with that guidance.
  • Children’s ideas. The Victorian Department of Education’s notes on this topic say that students “tend to associate substances and materials with objects”, that they “broadly identify substances and materials by how they are used and generally can only identify one or two properties that make the material well suited to its application”, and that in one study “1 in 3” Year 3 students “could not identify that plastic wrap is waterproof.” Krnel, Watson and Glažar (2005) interviewed 84 children aged 3 to 13 in Slovenia and found a growing awareness with age of the difference between the properties of objects and the properties of matter. Screen 1’s question about the drink can and screen 3’s swaps are aimed at this. Many children expect a magnet to pull every metal, which screen 2 tests. In a survey in Turkey, Ürek and Çoramık (2021) found that “about half of the elementary, middle and high school students agreed on this misconception”; their elementary students were in fourth grade. Children of this age also mix up heavy and heavy for its size. Writing about Grade 4, Smith says that to tell the two apart students “need experiences where the object made of the heavier kind of material is not also absolutely heavier”. Screen 5 compares rods of the same size. On screens 3 and 6 and on the printable, ‘light’ and ‘heavy’ are said of things, so when students use the words of a material, ask ‘heavy for its size?’. Two cautions are the lesson’s own, with no source read. In everyday speech ‘material’ also means cloth, so say early that in science every object is made of a material. And ‘made’ has two jobs on screen 1: every object is ‘made of’ a material, but only some materials are ‘made materials’. A child may reason that a woollen jumper is made, so wool is a made material. Keep the two apart when you talk about the sort.
  • Where you are. Screen 6 uses the City of Darwin’s list for its yellow recycling bin. Councils differ, so find your own council’s list before the lesson. If your community has no recycling collection, the swap half of the screen and the real activity still work.
  • Reduced motion. When a device is set to show less movement, each test jumps to its end. The words under each picture still say what happened.

About the models

  • Screen 1: the eight objects are made of typical materials, and real ones differ, which the note under the picture says. Where each material comes from is taken from Woolmark (“Wool is a natural fibre grown by sheep.”), PrimeZone (“Cotton is a natural fibre that grows on a plant.”), Logan City Council’s list of natural resources and what they give (trees for timber, “Silica, soda ash, limestone - glass”, “Oil, coal, natural gas, petroleum - plastic and fuel” and “Iron ore, coal, limestone - steel products”), and Geoscience Australia, for which iron “is the basic ingredient of steel (iron plus carbon).” Aluminium is left out of the natural or made sort on purpose; see ‘Natural and made’ below.
  • Screen 2: the results are the lesson’s own model, in line with these sources. The JCU guide for parents says “Glass is transparent, hard and waterproof.” and “Plastics are light, can be rigid or flexible, and are waterproof.” Britannica calls glass “hard, brittle”. PrimeZone calls cotton “soft, absorbent”. OpenStax says that “Only certain materials, such as iron, cobalt, nickel, and gadolinium, exhibit strong magnetic effects.”, and Geoscience Australia lists aluminium as “non-magnetic”. The bend results are for pieces as thick as a ruler. They follow OpenStax’s table of Young’s moduli, where a bigger number means a stiffer material: steel is 210, aluminium and glass are both 70, and nylon, a plastic, is 5. The table has no figure for the clear hard plastic of a drink bottle; nylon (5) and polystyrene (3), the two plastics it lists, stand in for it. A thin piece of any material bends more, and the Corning Museum of Glass says that thin glass “will only bend a little bit before it breaks.” The cotton cloth is called translucent because a little torchlight gets through a thin cloth; a thick cloth is opaque. On the screen a strong magnet lifts the piece of steel. A fridge magnet sticks to a steel can but will not lift a thick piece of steel, so in the real test students feel for a pull. The real test has three kinds of cloth, because the second elaboration asks students to compare fibres: a cotton cloth, a woollen sock and a piece of an old nylon bag or stocking will do.
  • Screen 3: the backpack is one made-up backpack. The JCU guide says that synthetic fibres “(nylon, polyester) are flexible, can be woven, and are used for clothing, rope and bags.” What each swap does is the lesson’s own reasoning from the results on screen 2. The same guide calls nylon “strong and waterproof”. A real nylon bag keeps out a shower, but in heavy rain water gets in at the seams and the zips; that remark is the lesson’s own.
  • Screen 4: everything is from ACARA’s page, in plainer words. The screen says ‘make’, ‘tools’ and ‘picked up’ where ACARA says “construct”, “implements” and “retrieved”, and it says that Country ‘has’ cool, wet climates where ACARA says “encompasses”. ACARA says that the fur “provided thermal insulation and impermeability to water”; the screen says that the fur gave thermal insulation and that water did not pass through it. The properties in the table are ACARA’s words for each material, except for fur, which is in the plainer words above, and the Purpose column uses the three words of the elaboration: tools, clothing and shelter.
  • Screen 5: the brief’s 700 g, the covers’ 300 g, 400 g and 100 g and the plastic rods’ 120 g are the lesson’s own numbers. The steel, aluminium and glass rods weigh 780 g, 270 g and 260 g, which is what 100 cubic centimetres of each weighs by OpenStax’s table of densities (iron or steel 7.8, aluminium 2.7 and common glass 2.6 grams per cubic centimetre). Two designs pass all three tests: aluminium rods with the soft plastic sheet (370 g), and aluminium rods with waxed cotton cloth (670 g). Waxing is from the RSC chapter: “Making the absorbent material ‘waterproof’ can then be tried with older children, by waxing it.” The same chapter says that “The property of a material can change according to how the material is treated”. The RSC puts its ‘waterproof’ in quotation marks, and its waxing uses hot wax. Cloth rubbed with a cold candle keeps out some water and may let some through, which is a result worth talking about; the screen’s waxed cloth, which keeps all the rain out, is a model. The steel, aluminium and glass rods are the same size. The plastic rods are thinner, and a thicker plastic rod would bend less. A real tent has more parts than a cover and poles, and the model leaves them out.
  • Screen 6: the sorting follows the City of Darwin’s lists as they stood on 20 November 2026. In the yellow bin: “Glass bottles and jars”, “Cardboard, magazines, paper and cartons”, “Aluminium and steel cans, trays and foil” and “All hard plastic containers”. Not in it, among other things: “Plastic bags and other soft plastics”, “Small plastic lids”, “Sheet glass and mirrors” and “Old bedding and clothing”. The yellow-bin list is headed “Loose, not in plastic bags!”. The City of Darwin says that “The contents of your yellow bin are taken to Darwin’s own Materials Recovery Facility in Berrimah”, where “items are sorted by hand and put through specialised machinery to separate them by material type”, and that “The separated plastics, metals, paper and cardboard are then baled up to be sent away for recycling into something new.” The page does not say what happens to the glass, so the key idea does not either. The line about the magnet is from Brisbane City Council’s fact sheet on its own sorting centre: “Rotating magnet separates steel cans and removes them to a separate container.” Darwin’s sorting centre may work differently. A single-use plastic is defined as the Business Recycling website defines it: “any plastic product that is designed to be used once and then thrown away.” The three swaps are the lesson’s own reasoning from the properties on screen 2. The same website says that compostable packaging is made of raw materials “like paper, wood, bamboo”.

Where sources disagree and what to check

  • Natural and made. ACARA’s Version 9 curriculum uses the two words without defining them. Its Version 8.4 glossary counted as natural materials those that “have undergone very little modification by humans”, and it included “minerals and metals that can be extracted from them (without further modification)”. By that reading a metal that is extracted without further modification counts as natural, while steel, which is iron with carbon added, is made. Aluminium is harder to place: Geoscience Australia says that the bauxite “is refined into alumina” and that “Large amounts of electricity are used to smelt the alumina into aluminium metal.” The lesson sorts steel as made and leaves aluminium out of the sort. The Victorian Department of Education says that the classification “should be seen as a continuum rather than an either/or classification”: timber is natural, and plywood and paper are more and more processed. A cotton cloth and a woollen jumper have been spun and woven or knitted, so they are part of the way along. If your school says ‘processed’ or ‘manufactured’ for ‘made’, tell your students that the words mean the same here.
  • Magnets and steel. Not every steel is pulled by a magnet. The Australian Stainless Steel Development Association says that one family of stainless steels, “such as 304 and 316, are generally regarded as non-magnetic in the annealed condition”, and that other stainless steels are strongly attracted to a magnet. Some spoons, sinks and drink bottles are stainless steel, so test your steel things with a magnet before the lesson.
  • Drink cans. Geoscience Australia says that “worldwide, four out of every five drink cans are made of aluminium”. Some are steel, and a magnet tells the two apart.
  • Recycling lists change. Check your council’s list close to the day.
  • Rules about single-use plastics. The Business Recycling website says that “States and territories have their own timeframe for phasing out these products.” The lesson does not say what is banned where. In the Territory, the Northern Territory Government says that retailers “must not give out lightweight, checkout-style plastic bags, including degradable bags”, and that “The NT plastic bag ban began on 1 September 2011.” Its list of bags that can still be used includes “heavy retail bags”, so a plastic shopping bag from a Darwin shop will be one of the heavier kind. A Northern Territory Government consultation page says that the Territory’s Circular Economy Strategy 2022-2027 proposed phasing out heavy plastic bags, plastic straws, plastic utensils and stirrers, and plastic bowls and plates, among other things. That page does not say that a ban on those things is in force, and no other source was found for that.
  • The word ‘fibre’. On screen 1 a jumper and a T-shirt are grouped as fibre. The cloth is the material students can see, and the fibre is what the cloth is made from. ACARA’s content description names “fibres” as one of its four groups, which is why the lesson uses the word.

Answers at a glance

  • Screen 1: the jar is glass; the drink can is metal (aluminium); the scissors are metal (steel) and plastic; the water bottle is plastic; the jumper is a fibre (wool); the T-shirt is a fibre (cotton); the ruler is wood; the window is glass and metal (aluminium). Natural: wool, cotton and wood. Made: glass, plastic and steel. The drink can’s material is metal: aluminium. q-object aluminium; q-natural wool.
  • Screen 2: steel does not bend, lets no light through, is waterproof, is pulled by the magnet and does not break. Aluminium is the same, except that the magnet does not pull it. Glass does not bend, is see-through and waterproof, is not pulled, and breaks. Hard plastic bends a little, is see-through and waterproof, is not pulled and does not break. Soft plastic bends and folds, is see-through and waterproof, is not pulled and does not break. Cotton cloth bends and folds, lets a little light through, soaks up the water, is not pulled and does not break. A magnet pulls only some metals. The glass breaks when it is dropped and the hard plastic does not. q-magnet it pulls the steel can only; q-words absorbent.
  • Screen 3: the body is nylon cloth, which is light, strong and flexible; the zip is metal, which is hard and strong; the buckle is hard plastic, which is light and hard. A cotton body would soak up the rain. q-zip cotton is too soft to grip; q-rain absorbent.
  • Screen 4: dense wood, tools for striking and digging; lightweight bamboo, fishing spears; sandstone, grindstones for seeds; lawyer cane stem, tying roofing onto shelters; animal fur, clothing for cool, wet climates. A buoyant spear floats to the surface and can be picked up again. Each material is chosen for its properties. q-spear so that the spear floats to the surface and can be picked up again; q-grind its rough surface.
  • Screen 5: the designs that pass are aluminium rods with a soft plastic sheet, and aluminium rods with waxed cotton cloth. Cotton cloth fails the rain test. Thin plastic rods fail the wind test. Glass rods break in the pack and carry test. Steel rods make every tent heavier than 700 g. Aluminium is lighter than steel. q-cover cotton is absorbent, so the water soaks through; q-improve change one part for a lighter material and test again.
  • Screen 6: in the yellow recycling bin, the glass jar, the aluminium can, the steel can, the cardboard box and the hard plastic bottle. Not in it, the plastic bag, the old T-shirt and the mirror. The swaps: cotton cloth for the shopping bag, steel for the drink bottle and steel for the fork. A steel bottle is strong and waterproof, and it can be washed. q-bin a glass jar; q-single a plastic thing made to be used once and then thrown away.
  • The printable: answers vary. A good sheet gives a property as the reason for each material, and changes one thing between tests.

Saved progress

Answers, notes, results tables and settings are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere. If students share devices, clear the saved answers between them.

References

Sources by screen

  • Screen 1: Woolmark, PrimeZone, Logan City Council and Geoscience Australia (where the materials come from); George the Farmer (plant and animal fibres); ACARA’s Version 8.4 glossary and the Victorian Department of Education (natural and made).
  • Screen 2: the JCU guide for parents, Britannica and PrimeZone (properties); OpenStax College Physics 5.3 and 22.2 (stiffness and magnets); Geoscience Australia (aluminium); the Corning Museum of Glass (thin glass); the RSC chapter (the words for properties, and dropping water on materials); the Australian Stainless Steel Development Association (stainless steel).
  • Screen 3: the JCU guide for parents.
  • Screen 4: ACARA’s teacher background information for AC9S4U04, elaboration 4.
  • Screen 5: the RSC chapter (waxing, and treating a material); OpenStax College Physics 11.2 (densities); Engineering is Elementary (the steps).
  • Screen 6: the City of Darwin (the lists); Brisbane City Council (the magnet); the Business Recycling website (single-use plastics).
  • The method: Wendell and Lee (2010); Wendell and Rogers (2013); Cunningham and colleagues (2020); Engineering is Elementary.
  • Children’s ideas: the Victorian Department of Education; Krnel, Watson and Glažar (2005); Ürek and Çoramık (2021); Smith (heavy for its size).
  • These notes only: the Northern Territory Government (the plastic bag ban and the proposed phase-out); Geoscience Australia (how aluminium is made).
  • Safety: the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission (magnets); the RSC chapter (hot wax).
  • Printable: the sources for screen 5.

Word list