AusSci

Year 5 science · Biological sciences · AC9S5U01

How does it survive there?

1Claim, evidence, reasoning

Can the bird find it?

How does it survive there?

Every living thing has a habitat: the place where it lives. Its body and the things it does help it survive there. In this lesson you find out how, and you explain what you find the way scientists do.

How this lesson works. On each screen you investigate in the picture with your partner. Then you explain what you found in three parts. Your claim answers the question. Your evidence is what you saw or measured. Your reasoning says why your evidence shows your claim is right, using a science idea. On the first screens you choose the parts. On later screens you write more of them yourselves.

On this screen

  1. Investigate in the picture with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Choose your claim, your evidence and your reasoning.
  3. Read the key idea.

Twelve moths rest in a gum tree: six green and six brown. A bird hunts for them. Choose where the moths rest, then let the bird hunt. The table under the picture counts the moths it finds.

The bird hunts

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Let the bird hunt three times on the gum tree bark.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Gum tree bark, then press Let the bird hunt, three times.

  2. Let the bird hunt three times on the green leaves.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Green leaves, then press Let the bird hunt, three times.

  3. Find the bird hiding in the gum tree.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Gum tree bark, then press Where is the hidden bird?

Talk about it. On the green leaves, which moths did the bird find most often? Why do you think that was?

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Do the first try-it task in the picture, then come back here to explain what you found.

Question: Which moths survive better on gum tree bark, and why?

Claim Choose the claim that answers the question.

Evidence Choose the evidence that backs up your claim.

Reasoning Choose the reasoning: the science idea that links your evidence to your claim.

In your book. Write your claim, your evidence and your reasoning, in that order.

Camouflage helps animals hide

Many animals have a colour or shape that matches their habitat, so predators find it hard to see them. This is camouflage: hiding by blending in with the background.

Colour is a structural feature: part of an animal’s body. A behaviour is something it does. The tawny frogmouth has both. Its feathers are mottled grey, brown and white. During the day it perches on a tree branch, often low down, and it often stretches its neck out, so it looks like part of the branch. It hunts at night: it is nocturnal.

What we are learning

How the structural features and behaviours of living things help them survive in their habitats, and how to explain it with a claim, evidence and reasoning.

I can

  • 1explain how camouflage helps an animal hide from predators.
  • 2explain how the shape of a beak helps a bird get its food.
  • 3explain how fur helps an animal keep warm.
  • 4name a behaviour and a structural feature that help the water-holding frog survive the dry.
  • 5describe how First Nations Peoples have used the features of living things.
  • 6write a claim, evidence and reasoning about how a living thing survives.

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 5, AC9S5U01: “examine how particular structural features and behaviours of living things enable their survival in specific habitats”. The teacher notes at the end show which screen covers each part.

My notebook

A grey moth rests on grey tree bark. Why is it hard for a bird to find?

During the day, a tawny frogmouth perches on a branch with its neck stretched out. How does this help it?

2Claim, evidence, reasoning

The right beak

How does the shape of a beak help a bird find food?

A bird can only eat the food its beak can get. Birds have beaks of many shapes. Here you test three of them on three foods.

On this screen

  1. Test the beaks in the picture, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Choose your claim and your evidence. Write your reasoning.
  3. Read the key idea.

Choose a beak and a food, then let the bird feed for 20 seconds. The table under the picture fills in as you go.

Feed the bird

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Try all three beaks on the nectar.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Nectar in long flowers, then choose each beak in turn and press Feed for 20 seconds.

  2. Fill in the whole table: every beak on every food.

    Need a hint?

    Try each beak on the seeds and on the shrimps too. The table under the picture fills in as you go.

  3. Meet the real birds that have these beaks.

    Need a hint?

    Press Meet the real birds.

Talk about it. If a bird could only eat seeds, which beak would help it most? Use the table to explain.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Do the first try-it task in the picture, then come back here to explain what you found.

Question: Which beak is best for getting nectar from long flowers, and why?

Claim Choose the claim that answers the question.

Evidence Choose the evidence that backs up your claim.

Reasoning Write your reasoning: why your evidence shows your claim is right. Use a science idea.

In your book. Write your claim, your evidence and your reasoning, in that order.

A beak’s shape suits the food

A beak’s shape is a structural feature. It helps a bird get some foods and not others.

The eastern spinebill has a very long, fine, down-curved beak, and it feeds on nectar and insects. Cockatoos have strong bills: they can crack open the tough cones and gumnuts of eucalypts, banksias and hakeas to get the seeds. The royal spoonbill sweeps its spoon-shaped bill from side to side through shallow water to find food, mainly fish and shrimps.

My notebook

A bird has a long, thin, curved beak. Which food is it best at getting?

Why does a royal spoonbill sweep its bill from side to side in shallow water?

3Claim, evidence, reasoning

A warm coat

How does fur help an animal keep warm?

A furry animal’s body is warm, and it loses heat to the cooler air around it. Here you test whether a coat of fur slows that down, with jars of warm water standing in for animals.

On this screen

  1. Test the jars in the picture, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Choose your claim. Write your evidence. Choose your reasoning.
  3. Read the key idea.

Three jars hold the same amount of warm water, at 40 °C, in a cool room at 15 °C. One has no coat, one has a thin cotton coat and one has a thick fur coat. Wait 20 minutes, and watch the thermometers and the graph.

Three jars cool down

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Test all three jars for 20 minutes.

    Need a hint?

    Press Wait 20 minutes. All three jars cool at the same time.

  2. Find each jar’s temperature after 10 minutes.

    Need a hint?

    Test all three jars first, then move the Time slider to 10 minutes.

  3. Look at the fur up close.

    Need a hint?

    Press Look at the fur up close.

Talk about it. Why did the test use the same amount of water, at the same temperature, in every jar?

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Do the first try-it task in the picture, then come back here to explain what you found.

Question: Does a fur coat keep a warm jar warm for longer?

Claim Choose the claim that answers the question.

Evidence Write your evidence: what you saw or measured, with numbers if you have them.

Reasoning Choose the reasoning: the science idea that links your evidence to your claim.

In your book. Write your claim, your evidence and your reasoning, in that order.

Fur traps air

Fur is filled with air, broken up into many small pockets. The air in the pockets can hardly move, and air that can’t move about is poor at carrying heat, so fur slows the heat escaping from an animal’s body. A layer like this is called insulation. Thick fur and feathers both trap a layer of air.

A possum’s fur fibres are hollow, and they trap air too.

My notebook

Which coat would keep an animal warmest on a cold night?

Two jars of warm water cool on a cold day. One is wrapped in a woolly sock. What happens?

4Claim, evidence, reasoning

Waiting for rain

How does the water-holding frog survive when its swamp dries up?

The water-holding frog lives in Australia’s dry inland, in swamps, claypans and creeks that fill with water and then dry up. Here you test one thing it does in the dry, with sponges standing in for frogs.

On this screen

  1. Test the sponge frogs in the picture, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Choose your claim. Write your evidence and your reasoning.
  3. Read the key idea.

Two wet sponges, cut like frogs, each weigh 60 g. One lies on top of a tray of sand, and one is buried under the sand. Leave them in the sun and weigh them.

Sponge frogs in the sun

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Leave both sponge frogs in the sun for 6 hours.

    Need a hint?

    Press Leave them in the sun for 6 hours.

  2. Find both masses after 3 hours.

    Need a hint?

    Leave the sponges in the sun first, then move the Time slider to 3 hours.

  3. Look inside the real frog’s burrow.

    Need a hint?

    Press Show the real frog.

Talk about it. How is a buried sponge like a frog in its burrow? How is it different?

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Do the first try-it task in the picture, then come back here to explain what you found.

Question: How does burrowing help the water-holding frog survive the dry?

Claim Choose the claim that answers the question.

Evidence Write your evidence: what you saw or measured, with numbers if you have them.

Reasoning Write your reasoning: why your evidence shows your claim is right. Use a science idea.

In your book. Write your claim, your evidence and your reasoning, in that order.

Waiting underground for rain

When the water dries up, the water-holding frog burrows into the ground, where less water evaporates from it. It makes a round chamber of packed soil and wraps itself in a cocoon of skin it has shed. It stores water in its bladder and in pockets under its skin, and this stored water can make up as much as sixty per cent of its weight. After floods, it lays its eggs in still water.

Burrowing is a behaviour. Pockets that store water are a structural feature. Many desert animals burrow, and many are nocturnal.

My notebook

Why does the water-holding frog burrow into the ground when its swamp dries up?

Which of these is a structural feature of the water-holding frog, not a behaviour?

5Claim, evidence, reasoning

Knowing a feature

How have First Nations Australians used the features of living things?

First Nations Australians have long observed how the structural features of living things help them survive, and have used those features in many parts of life. Here you look at four of them up close.

On this screen

  1. Look at each feature in the picture, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Write your claim, your evidence and your reasoning, with a start for each.
  3. Read the key idea.

Choose a living thing to look at its feature in the magnifier. The words under the picture say what the feature does for it, and how Peoples have used it.

Four features up close

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Look at all four features up close.

    Need a hint?

    Choose the stingray, the possum, the lawyer cane and the water-holding frog in turn.

  2. Find the feature that traps air.

    Need a hint?

    Look at all four features up close. Then answer Which feature traps air? under the picture.

  3. Find the feature that helps a plant climb.

    Need a hint?

    Look at all four features up close. Then answer Which feature helps a plant climb? under the picture.

Talk about it. How has knowing about a feature helped people? Give one example from the picture.

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Do the first try-it task in the picture, then come back here to explain what you found.

Question: Why do possum skin cloaks keep people warm?

Claim Write your claim: one sentence that answers the question.

Evidence Write your evidence: what you saw or measured, with numbers if you have them.

Reasoning Write your reasoning: why your evidence shows your claim is right. Use a science idea.

In your book. Write your claim, your evidence and your reasoning, in that order.

Knowing a feature, and using it

A stingray’s barb defends it when predators threaten it, and several Peoples used stingray barbs as spear tips. Possum fur fibres are hollow and trap air, and possum skin cloaks have long been important to Peoples in the colder south-east of Australia. Lawyer cane has curved hooks that help it climb, and the Kuku-Yalanji Peoples used its spikes to make fishing hooks. The water-holding frog stores water under its skin, and Aboriginal Peoples of desert Country found the frogs by looking for markings on the ground or by tapping the ground with the butt of a spear.

My notebook

Why do possum skin cloaks keep people warm?

How does a stingray’s barb help the stingray survive?

6Claim, evidence, reasoning

Your turn: the boab

How does the boab survive the long dry season?

Plants have features that help them survive too. The boab grows in the Kimberley and the western edge of the Northern Territory, in the north-west of Australia, where a wet season comes each summer and the winter months are dry. This time you write the whole explanation yourselves.

On this screen

  1. Move through the year in the picture, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Write your claim, your evidence and your reasoning, with no starts this time.
  3. Read the key idea.
  4. Answer the last two questions and look at your results.

Play the year, or move the Month slider, and watch the rain and the boab’s leaves.

A year for a boab

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Play a whole year.

    Need a hint?

    Press Play the year.

  2. Find a month when the boab has no leaves.

    Need a hint?

    Move the Month slider to July, August or September, in the dry season.

  3. Find the month when its new leaves appear.

    Need a hint?

    Move the Month slider to the start of the wet season.

Talk about it. The water-holding frog and the boab both get through the dry season. How are their ways the same, and how are they different?

Claim, evidence, reasoning

Do the first try-it task in the picture, then come back here to explain what you found.

Question: How does the boab survive the long dry season?

Claim Write your claim.

Evidence Write your evidence.

Reasoning Write your reasoning.

In your book. Write your claim, your evidence and your reasoning, in that order.

Plants have features for dry seasons too

The boab has a short, wide trunk that stores water, with soft, spongy wood. It is deciduous: in the drier winter months it loses its leaves, and new leaves appear at the start of the wet season. Many desert plants have tiny leaves or no leaves at all, which cuts down the water they lose.

Features and behaviours like these, passed on from parents, that help a living thing survive and have young in its habitat are called adaptations.

My notebook

Why does losing its leaves in the dry season help the boab?

Which of these is evidence, not a claim or an opinion?

Printable activity

Claim, evidence, reasoning: two survival tests

Two pages for pairs. Page 1 has two real tests, each with boxes for a claim, evidence and reasoning: a warm jar in a woolly coat, and a sponge frog under the sand. Page 2 has a camouflage hunt outside, and space to write your own claim, evidence and reasoning about a living thing.

For teachers

Curriculum

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 5, Science understanding, Biological sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:

AC9S5U01 examine how particular structural features and behaviours of living things enable their survival in specific habitats

  • identify physical and behavioural characteristics that enable a plant or animal to survive, such as being able to see in dim light and being nocturnal
  • exploring features of plants and animals that enable them to survive in Australia’s desert environments, such as bottle (or boab) trees and the water-holding frog
  • investigating how camouflage is used by animals to hide from predators and to ambush prey
  • using physical or digital simulations to explore how the shape of animals’ body parts, such as the beak of a particular bird species, influence their ability to find food and survive in a given environment
  • investigating First Nations Australians’ knowledges of the structural features of certain species and how those features can be exploited

The second quote gives ACARA’s five elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each part of the content description is covered on these screens:

  • Structural features: colour on screen 1, beaks on screen 2, fur on screen 3, the water-holding frog’s water pockets on screen 4, the barb, fur, hooks and stored water on screen 5, and the boab’s trunk and leaves on screen 6; q-camo, q-beak, q-fur, q-jar, q-store, q-cloak, q-barb and q-boab.
  • Behaviours: the tawny frogmouth perching with its neck stretched out on screen 1, the royal spoonbill sweeping its bill on screen 2 and the frog burrowing on screen 4; q-frogmouth, q-spoon and q-burrow.
  • Enable their survival in specific habitats: the claim, evidence and reasoning cards on screens 1, 2, 4 and 6 link a feature or a behaviour to living somewhere (gum tree bark, long flowers, Australia’s dry inland and the Kimberley). The card on screen 3 is about a model, a warm jar standing in for a warm body, and the card on screen 5 is about possum skin cloaks keeping people warm.
  • The elaborations: being nocturnal is the tawny frogmouth on screen 1 and the key idea on screen 4 (the lesson doesn’t model seeing in dim light); desert features, with the boab and the water-holding frog, are screens 4 and 6 (ACARA groups the boab with desert plants; the Kimberley, where it grows, has a wet season and a long dry season, which is how screen 6 shows it); camouflage to hide from predators is screen 1 (the lesson doesn’t show camouflage used to ambush prey); a digital simulation of how beak shape affects finding food is screen 2; and First Nations Australians’ knowledges of structural features, and how they can be exploited, is screen 5.

The lesson also works on these content descriptions. The fur and sponge tests change one thing and keep the rest the same, as in AC9S5I02; the tables and the graph organise the data and show its patterns, as in AC9S5I04; choosing evidence to back a claim is what AC9S5I05 means by “select evidence to draw reasoned conclusions”; and a written claim, evidence and reasoning is a text that communicates findings, as in AC9S5I06.

AC9S5I02 plan and conduct repeatable investigations to answer questions, including, as appropriate, deciding the variables to be changed, measured and controlled in fair tests; describing potential risks; planning for the safe use of equipment and materials; and identifying required permissions to conduct investigations on Country/Place

AC9S5I04 construct and use appropriate representations, including tables, graphs and visual or physical models, to organise and process data and information and describe patterns, trends and relationships

AC9S5I05 compare methods and findings with those of others, recognise possible sources of error, pose questions for further investigation and select evidence to draw reasoned conclusions

AC9S5I06 write and create texts to communicate ideas and findings for specific purposes and audiences, including selection of language features, using digital tools as appropriate

It builds on Year 4’s AC9S4U01, “explain the roles and interactions of consumers, producers and decomposers within a habitat and how food chains represent feeding relationships”, and leads to Year 6’s AC9S6U01, “investigate the physical conditions of a habitat and analyse how the growth and survival of living things is affected by changing physical conditions”.

How the lesson is taught

The method is claim, evidence and reasoning, with written support that fades. On each screen students investigate in a simulation, then explain what they found in three parts: a claim that answers the question, evidence from what they saw or measured, and reasoning that links the evidence to the claim with a science idea. On screen 1 students choose all three parts from options, and each wrong option gets its own reply. On screens 2 to 4 they write one or two parts, each with a sentence starter, an example to compare with and a short checklist. On screen 5 they write all three with starters, and on screen 6 with none.

Run it in pairs. Show the three parts on the board before screen 1, with a short example of your own, and expect the reasoning to be the hardest part. Have each pair say its claim and evidence aloud before anyone types or writes. Students write their final explanation in their books; the examples on the screens are there to compare with. As the written support fades, check on each pair and help where they are stuck. Martin and colleagues (2019) followed two teachers using the same written scaffolds as they faded: in the class whose teacher kept checking understanding and adding help, “her students maintained a high level of performance throughout the unit”, and in the other, “his students showed a significant decrease in performance over time”.

McNeill, Lizotte, Krajcik and Marx (2006) gave 331 seventh-grade students in an 8-week chemistry unit either detailed written support for every explanation or support that faded over the unit. Both groups improved on all three parts, and “on posttest items lacking scaffolds, the faded group gave stronger explanations in terms of their reasoning compared to the continuous group”. Songer and Gotwals (2012) used claim, evidence and reasoning with 939 fourth to sixth graders in Detroit, in 8-week units on biodiversity and ecology whose worksheets had fewer scaffolds as the units went on. They found that “Fifth graders had the most difficulty in generating reasoning that linked claims to evidence”, so this lesson keeps the reasoning to choose on screens 1 and 3. More widely, a meta-analysis of the experimental studies of argumentation in Turkey, 68% of them at what the paper calls primary level (its examples include grades 7 and 8), found a large effect on achievement (ES = 0.997; Çömek, Sarıçayır and Erdoğan, 2015).

McNeill’s students were older than Year 5 and studied chemistry, and the study compared two kinds of written support, not claim, evidence and reasoning against none. In Songer and Gotwals’ study the teachers chose how much of the units to use, and the findings on students’ errors come from 77 notebooks. Martin and colleagues followed two classes in one school; the drop they describe was in one class’s reports during the unit, and on their science practices test both classes improved. The meta-analysis covers argumentation in general, searched only studies from Turkey and gives no effect sizes for each school level; 17 of its 25 studies were postgraduate theses, and it reports no check for publication bias. The examples on these screens can be copied, which is one reason the final explanation goes in students’ books.

Handle with care

  • Warm water. The printable’s jar test uses warm tap water, not water from a kettle, and an adult pours it. Water from a hot tap can be hot enough to scald, so the adult checks it with a thermometer first; about 40 °C, as in the simulation, is enough.
  • Sand and sun. Use plain play sand, not coloured or craft sand. In November 2025 some imported coloured sands sold for children’s play and craft were recalled after testing found asbestos in them (WA Health, 2025). Wash hands after the sponge test. If it goes outside, follow your school’s sun-safety rules, and put the trays where they won’t be knocked over.
  • The camouflage hunt. Use pieces of coloured wool, count them out and count them back in, so none are left on the grass. Follow your school’s sun-safety rules, check the grass for bees before you start, and take any student’s anaphylaxis plan and adrenaline injector outside.
  • Frogs. Screen 5 says that in times of drought, squeezing a frog gently gave water to drink. Tell students not to pick up or squeeze frogs: FrogWatch SA advises against handling wild frogs at all.
  • The First Nations content. Screen 5, its key idea, the question the claim, evidence and reasoning card asks there, q-cloak and q-barb use only ACARA’s teacher background information for elaboration 5. No people are drawn, and the pictures are the lesson’s own. ACARA’s page warns that some of the sources in its consulted works “may contain material that is considered culturally offensive or inappropriate”, that they “are not provided or recommended as classroom resources”, and that written records can be problematic, as they are often “based on non-Indigenous interpretations of observations”. It adds that these sources “often lack the viewpoints of the people they discuss” and “can contain ideas based on outdated scientific theories”, and that with careful selection, evaluation and community consultation they could be “culturally audited, refined and adapted” into culturally appropriate teaching materials. Its consulted works run from 1897 to 2017. ACARA’s account of how Peoples found the water-holding frog comes from what early colonisers observed, which is the kind of written record these cautions are about. The page also records that “After European colonisation the manufacture of possum skin cloaks was prohibited.”, and that their revival is helping many Aboriginal Peoples, including the Gunditjmara and Yorta Yorta Peoples of Victoria, to reconnect with and restore their cultures. Screen 5 has not been checked with the Peoples it names. Follow your school’s or system’s protocols for First Nations content, for example by asking Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander staff or education officers, and ask your local community for advice on teaching screen 5, bearing in mind that this knowledge belongs to the Peoples named.
  • Ideas worth listening for. Some of the wrong options carry ideas students may bring with them: that a moth chose its colour in order to hide (screen 1), that fur makes its own heat, and that fur keeps the cold out (screen 3). Each one gets a reply. Two other ideas don’t get a reply on the screens, so listen for them: that a living thing grows a feature during its life because it needs it (the word list defines an adaptation as a feature or behaviour passed on from parents), and that insulation only keeps things warm (a woolly sock would also slow an ice block melting).

About the models

  • Screen 1. Twelve moths, six green and six brown. Each hunt the bird catches six, and the number it catches of each colour runs through a fixed cycle. On the bark, it catches 5 green and 1 brown, then 4 and 2, then 5 and 1, then 6 and 0, then 4 and 2, then round again; on the leaves the colours swap. So three hunts on one background always find 14 of the colour that doesn’t match and 4 of the colour that does. Where the moths rest, and which ones are caught, come from a seeded random sequence. The numbers are the lesson’s own; the pattern is camouflage, which Biology 2e 45.6 describes as “avoiding detection by blending in with the background”. The tawny frogmouth is drawn perched with its neck stretched out, as Museums Victoria describes it.
  • Screen 2. In 20 seconds the long, thin, curved beak gets 12 sips of nectar, no seeds and 2 shrimps; the short, strong beak 1 sip, 9 seeds and 1 shrimp; and the flat, spoon-shaped beak no nectar, no seeds and 10 shrimps. These numbers are the lesson’s own, set so that each beak gets the most of one food. The real birds come from the Australian Museum (the eastern spinebill and the royal spoonbill) and Bush Heritage Australia (cockatoos).
  • Screen 3. Each jar starts at 40 °C in a room at 15 °C and cools towards the room’s temperature: temperature = 15 + 25 × e^(−kt), with t in minutes and k = 0.0290 with no coat, 0.0223 in the thin coat and 0.0112 in the fur coat, so that after 20 minutes the jars read 29 °C, 31 °C and 35 °C. After 10 minutes they read 34 °C, 35 °C and 37 °C. The thermometers show whole degrees. The numbers are the lesson’s own. The pattern follows College Physics 2e 14.6, which says “Fur is filled with air, breaking it up into many small pockets.” and “The low conductivity of air makes fur a very good lightweight insulator.”
  • Screen 4. Each sponge is 10 g of sponge holding 50 g of water, 60 g on the scales. The water left after t hours is 50 × e^(−kt), with k = 0.153 an hour on top of the sand and 0.0139 an hour buried, so that after 6 hours the one on top weighs 30 g and the buried one 56 g; after 3 hours they weigh 42 g and 58 g. The scales show whole grams. The numbers are the lesson’s own. The sponges stand in for the frog’s body losing water: ACARA’s background information says the frog burrows underground to reduce evaporation, and van Beurden (1977) found that its cocoon of shed skin cuts evaporative water loss to as little as 1/44th.
  • Screen 5. The four living things, and every sentence about them, come from ACARA’s teacher background information for elaboration 5. The pictures and the close-ups are the lesson’s own.
  • Screen 6. The months follow Frederick and colleagues (2023): a wet season from October to April, leaves and flowers appearing at its start, and the leaves lost in the drier winter months. In the picture the boab is in full leaf from November to May, loses its leaves in June, is bare from July to September and puts out new leaves in October, and rain falls from October to April. That month-by-month detail is the lesson’s own. The picture doesn’t show how much water the trunk holds or when the tree uses it.

Where sources disagree and what to check

  • When the boab flowers. Florabase gives the flowers as “Dec or Jan to May”, and Frederick and colleagues have flowers and leaves appearing at the beginning of the wet season, which they give as October to April. The lesson doesn’t give flowering months.
  • The boab’s stored water. Florabase describes the trunk as “adapted for water storage”, with soft, spongy wood. The lesson says the trunk stores water and that a tree with no leaves loses less water; it doesn’t say how the boab uses its stored water through the dry season, which these sources don’t say.
  • Real tests give different numbers. The hunts, jars and sponges are models. Real jars and sponges cool and dry at rates that depend on their size, the room, the sun and the wind, and a class hunting wool pieces will find its own counts. In the sponge test, students weigh each tray with its sand and sponge, because dry sand soaks up some water from a sponge it touches, and weighing the sponge on its own would count that water as lost. The patterns should hold.
  • Calling it an adaptation. ACARA’s background information defines structural adaptations as “the physical features of an organism that have evolved to aid its survival”, and Concepts of Biology 11.1 says “A heritable trait that aids the survival and reproduction of an organism in its present environment is called an adaptation.” Year 5 doesn’t teach evolution, so the lesson uses the word only in screen 6’s key idea and the word list, where it means a feature or behaviour passed on from parents, and in the page’s title and web address. Natural selection comes in Year 10, in AC9S10U02.

Answers at a glance

Screen 1: the brown moths survive better on the bark; three hunts there find 14 green moths and 4 brown; brown moths match the bark, so the bird finds them harder to see. Screen 2: the long, thin, curved beak gets the most nectar, 12 sips against 1 and none, because it reaches deep into the long flowers. Screen 3: the jar in the fur coat cools the least, to 35 °C after 20 minutes against 31 °C and 29 °C, because fur traps air, which slows the heat escaping. Screen 4: the buried sponge keeps more water, 56 g after 6 hours against 30 g, because less water evaporates under the sand. Screen 5: possum fur fibres are hollow and trap air, so the cloaks slow heat escaping. Screen 6: the boab stores water in its trunk and loses its leaves in the dry season, so it loses less water. Questions: q-camo its colour matches the bark; q-frogmouth it looks like part of the branch; q-beak nectar; q-spoon to find food in the water; q-fur thick fur; q-jar it cools more slowly; q-burrow less water evaporates; q-store pockets under its skin; q-cloak hollow fibres trap air; q-barb it defends the stingray; q-boab without leaves it loses less water; q-evidence no leaves from July to September.

Saved progress

Claims, evidence, reasoning, answers, notes, settings and the try-it tasks are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere. If students share devices, clear the saved answers between them.

References

Sources by screen

  • Method: McNeill, Lizotte, Krajcik and Marx (2006); Songer and Gotwals (2012); Martin, Dornfeld Tissenbaum, Gnesdilow and Puntambekar (2019); Çömek, Sarıçayır and Erdoğan (2015).
  • Screen 1: Biology 2e 45.6 (camouflage); the Australian Museum and Museums Victoria (the tawny frogmouth).
  • Screen 2: the Australian Museum (the eastern spinebill and the royal spoonbill); Bush Heritage Australia (cockatoos).
  • Screen 3: College Physics 2e 14.1 and 14.6; Biology 2e 33.3; ACARA’s background information for elaboration 5 (possum fibres).
  • Screen 4: ACARA’s background information for elaboration 5; FrogWatch SA; van Beurden (1977); Biology 2e 44.3.
  • Screen 5: ACARA’s background information for elaboration 5.
  • Screen 6: Florabase (the boab); Frederick and colleagues (2023); Biology 2e 44.3; Concepts of Biology 11.1 (adaptation).
  • Word list: the sources for the screen where each word is first used.
  • Handle with care: WA Health (2025) for the sand; FrogWatch SA’s FAQs for handling frogs.

Word list