AusSci

Year 6 science · Chemical sciences · AC9S6U04

Can you get it back?

1Get ready

Changes all around

When a material changes, can you get it back?

Ice melts, salt dissolves, eggs cook and nails rust. You can undo some of these changes, and some you can’t. In this lesson you find out which ones, and why.

How this lesson works

This lesson borrows its steps from a way of teaching called cognitive acceleration, which researchers at King’s College London in England developed. Its puzzles are meant to be hard enough to make you think, and you solve them with help from a partner and your teacher.

  1. On this screen you try some changes and learn the words you need.
  2. On screens 2 to 4 you solve three puzzles. For each one, you predict, test, then talk with a partner about what you saw.
  3. On screen 5 you use your ideas on changes that people use.
  4. On screen 6 you sort changes, then think about how you decided.

On this screen

  1. Choose each material in the lab and make the change.
  2. Try to get each material back.
  3. Read about the two kinds of change, then answer the questions.

A material is what something is made of, such as wax, iron or water. In the lab, you change six materials. Then you try to get each one back as it was.

The change lab

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Two kinds of change

In a reversible change, no new substance is made, so you can get the material you started with back, even if its shape is different. Melting, freezing and dissolving are reversible.

In an irreversible change, new substances are made, so you can’t get the material you started with back. Cooking and rusting are irreversible.

What we are learning

Which changes can be undone and which can’t, how to tell when a new substance has been made, and how people use both kinds of change.

I can

  • 1explain what makes a change reversible or irreversible, using everyday examples.
  • 2describe what happens to salt when it dissolves, and how to get it back.
  • 3explain how the amount of heat a material gets can decide whether it changes state or turns into new substances.
  • 4choose tubes that make a fair test of what makes iron rust, and explain why rust is a new substance.
  • 5explain how people use reversible and irreversible changes, including First Nations Australians’ use of resin and fire.
  • 6sort changes into reversible and irreversible, and explain how I decided.

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 6, AC9S6U04: “compare reversible changes, including dissolving and changes of state, and irreversible changes, including cooking and rusting that produce new substances”. The teacher notes at the end show which screen covers each part.

My notebook

Which of these changes is reversible?

What happens in an irreversible change, such as cooking or rusting?

Some ice cubes melt. You freeze the water in a flat tray, so the ice is now one flat piece. Was the change reversible?

2Puzzle 1 of 3

Where did the salt go?

When salt dissolves, is it gone? Can you get it back?

Stir salt into water and the crystals disappear. Is the salt still there? And does hot water dissolve a lot more salt than cold water?

On this screen

  1. Make your prediction. Then add salt until some stays on the bottom.
  2. Find out how much salt dissolves at 0 °C and at 100 °C.
  3. Let the water evaporate to get the salt back.
  4. Talk with your partner, then answer the questions.

When salt dissolves in water, it makes a solution. Water can only hold so much salt. Once it holds all it can, any more salt you add stays on the bottom. The magnifier shows the water and salt particles in the glass.

Salt in a glass of water

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Talk with a partner

Was your prediction right? What surprised you?

Compare your prediction with what happened in the glass. Then agree on one sentence that describes how much more salt hot water dissolves.

Dissolving is reversible

The dissolved salt is still in the water, spread through it as particles far too small to see. When the water evaporates, the salt is left behind as crystals, so you get the salt back.

Hot water dissolves only a little more salt than cold water. 100 g of water holds about 36 g of salt at 0 °C and about 39 g at 100 °C (Sigma-Aldrich). Salt is unusual: OpenStax says that for most solids, more dissolves as the water gets hotter.

Salt is made this way at Dampier in Western Australia. Seawater is spread across shallow flats, and the sun and wind evaporate the water. Over months, salt crystals form a crust, which is harvested and washed. Rio Tinto, which makes salt there, says: “We export millions of tonnes of salt every year.”

My notebook

Salt dissolves in a glass of water, and you can’t see it any more. Where is the salt?

How can you get dissolved salt back from salty water?

How much more salt dissolves in 100 g of water at 100 °C than at 0 °C?

g

3Puzzle 2 of 3

A little heat or a lot?

Does heating always make a change you can undo?

Heat melts ice and wax, and both set again when they cool. But heat also cooks food and burns candles. In this puzzle you find out when heating makes new substances.

On this screen

  1. Boil the water, then cool it until it is ice again.
  2. Melt the wax in the dish and let it set. Then light the candle and let it burn for a while.
  3. Predict what heat will do to the egg white. Then cook the egg and cool it.
  4. Talk with your partner, then answer the questions.

Water freezes at 0 °C and boils at 100 °C (OpenStax). Melting, freezing, boiling and condensing are changes of state. While ice is melting, its temperature stops rising and stays the same “until all of the solid is melted” (OpenStax). Watch the thermometer to see it.

The hot plate

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Talk with a partner

Melting wax and burning wax both use heat. Why can you get the wax back after one, but not after the other?

Then talk about the egg. Did it do what you predicted?

How much heat?

Heat can make either kind of change. The gentle heat of the hot plate melts wax, and the wax sets again as it cools. In a candle flame the wax burns, making new substances such as carbon dioxide and water vapour, so you can’t get that wax back.

Heat also cooks an egg, and cooling doesn’t undo it. Water changes state when you heat it or cool it, but it is still water.

My notebook

°C

Gentle heat melts wax. A candle flame burns wax. Which change is irreversible?

You cook an egg, then put it in the fridge. What happens to the egg?

4Puzzle 3 of 3

What makes iron rust?

What does iron need to rust? Does drying a rusty nail bring the iron back?

An iron nail left outside goes rusty. Is it the water, the air, or both? You can only tell with a fair test.

On this screen

  1. Predict which nails will rust. Then run the test for a week.
  2. Choose what you want to test. Then choose two tubes that test it fairly.
  3. Do this for air, then for water.
  4. Talk with your partner, then answer the questions.

In a fair test you change only one variable and keep all the other variables the same. Then you know that any difference in the results comes from the variable you changed. Each tube holds an iron nail. Tube A has a drying agent to keep the air dry. In tube B the water has been boiled to remove the oxygen dissolved in it, and oil on top stops air dissolving into the water again.

Four nails for a week

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Talk with a partner

Why can’t tubes A and D tell you whether iron needs water to rust?

List the ways tube A and tube D are different. Then decide which pair of tubes does test it.

Rusting makes a new substance

Iron rusts when it has both oxygen, from the air, and water (OpenStax). Salt makes it rust faster (Royal Society of Chemistry).

Rust is a new substance. OpenStax explains that it is a different kind of matter from the iron, oxygen and water it formed from. Rust flakes off the iron, and drying the nail doesn’t turn it back into iron, so rusting is irreversible.

My notebook

What does iron need to rust?

To test whether iron needs water to rust, which two nails should you compare?

Why is rusting an irreversible change?

5Use it somewhere else

Using changes

How do people use reversible and irreversible changes?

People use both kinds of change: to recycle metal, to make and repair tools, and to carry fire. Use what you found out in the puzzles to decide which kind each one is.

On this screen

  1. Run the recycling plant. Then say which kind of change melting the cans is.
  2. Warm the grasstree resin, let it set, and say which kind of change that is. Then see what happens if it is heated too quickly.
  3. Light the torch, and say which kind of change burning is.
  4. Answer the questions.

To recycle aluminium cans, Planet Ark explains, “the cans are crushed and then melted in a furnace.” The liquid metal is shaped in moulds and made into new products, “primarily new aluminium cans”. Planet Ark adds: “Aluminium is infinitely recyclable, meaning it can be recycled repeatedly without any decrease in quality.”

First Nations Australians use both kinds of change. “Resins were, and continue to be, widely used as adhesives” (ACARA), for example to attach spear points to shafts and stone hatchet heads to handles. Aboriginal Peoples most often get resin from spinifex and grasstrees. Warm resin is soft and easy to shape, and when the heat is taken away, “the resin cools and hardens again”, holding the point on. Because that change can be reversed, a tool can be reshaped or repaired by warming its resin again. Makers “carefully control the application of heat”, ACARA explains. Grasstree resin heated too quickly froths and crumbles, and heating it for a long time or many times makes it brittle and less sticky. Those changes are irreversible.

In the Torres Strait, heat is used to soften turtle shell so that it can be bent into fish hooks, and the shell hardens again as it cools (ACARA). Spinifex is used to carry fire: “Spinifex is highly flammable and burns intensely for a long period of time, making it useful as a torch to transport fire.” In the Torres Strait, coconut fronds are used as torches, and the peoples of Mer Island use them for spear fishing at night.

Changes at work

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Changes at work

Recycling works because melting is reversible. Aluminium is still aluminium after it melts and sets, so it can be made into new cans.

Gentle warming softens resin, and it hardens again as it cools, so a tool can be repaired. Too much heat changes resin for good. Burning is irreversible too, so a torch uses up its spinifex.

My notebook

Why can aluminium cans be recycled again and again?

Resin is warmed to fix a stone point onto a spear. Why does this work?

A spinifex torch burns. What kind of change is that?

6Think about your thinking

Sort the changes

When a material changes, can you get it back?

Sort ten everyday changes into two bins. Then write down how you decided.

On this screen

  1. Sort the ten changes.
  2. Write down how you decided.
  3. Answer the questions, then look at your results for the whole lesson.

Two bins

Card sort

The card sort loads here.

How to decide

To decide, ask whether you can get the material you started with back. If you can, the change is reversible. If new substances have been made, it is irreversible.

Some signs can mean that a change is irreversible: “a change in colour, release of odour, gas, light or sound”, or a change in temperature (ACARA). A sign is only a clue, so check by asking whether you can get the material back.

My notebook

Which question is the best test of whether a change is reversible?

When something changes, it gives out light and heat, and its colour changes. What does that suggest?

A puddle dries up on a sunny day. What kind of change is that?

Printable activity

Reversible and irreversible changes: a card sort and a rusting test

Two pages: twelve everyday changes to cut out and sort, with a box for how you decided, and a fair test of what makes iron rust, with four jars to set up, a results table and questions.

For teachers

Curriculum

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 6, Science understanding, Chemical sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:

AC9S6U04 compare reversible changes, including dissolving and changes of state, and irreversible changes, including cooking and rusting that produce new substances

  • discussing what makes a change reversible or irreversible, using everyday examples
  • examining the substances produced in cooking and rusting and comparing them with the original substances
  • comparing how the amount of heat energy added affects whether a change in state or an irreversible change occurs
  • describing how dissolved substances are reclaimed from solutions
  • exploring how reversible changes can be used to recycle materials
  • investigating First Nations Australians’ knowledges of reversible processes such as the application of adhesives and of irreversible processes such as the use of fuels for torches

The second quote gives ACARA’s six elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each part of the content description is covered on these screens:

  • Compare reversible changes: every screen asks whether the material can be got back; screen 1 makes and tries to undo six changes, and screen 6 sorts ten; q-rev, q-shape, q-best and q-puddle.
  • Including dissolving: screen 2 dissolves salt, finds how much 100 g of water holds from 0 °C to 100 °C, and gets the salt back by evaporating the water; q-where, q-back, q-hot and n-left.
  • And changes of state: ice and wax on screen 1; ice to water to steam and back, and wax melting and setting, on screen 3; aluminium melting and setting on screen 5; n-boil and q-recycle.
  • And irreversible changes, including cooking and rusting that produce new substances: the egg, toast and nail on screen 1; the egg and the candle on screen 3; rusting on screen 4; the spinifex torch and overheated resin on screen 5; q-newsub, q-wax, q-egg, q-needs, q-rustnew and q-torch.
  • The elaborations: what makes a change reversible or irreversible, with everyday examples, on screens 1 and 6; the substances produced in cooking and rusting compared with the original substances on screens 3 and 4 (the egg white before and after, and rust beside iron in the magnifier); how the amount of heat decides between a change of state and an irreversible change on screen 3 (the hot plate melts wax and the flame burns it) and screen 5 (resin heated too quickly or too often); dissolved substances reclaimed from solutions on screen 2 (evaporating the water, and the salt fields at Dampier); recycling on screen 5 (aluminium cans); and First Nations Australians’ knowledges of resin and torches on screen 5, which also includes Torres Strait turtle shell.

The lesson also touches on these content descriptions. Screen 2’s prediction adapts ACARA’s example question for AC9S6I01, “‘Will more salt dissolve in warm water than in cold water?’”; screen 4 asks students to choose pairs of tubes that make a fair test (AC9S6I02); and students could turn their sort on screen 6 into the poster or slideshow suggested for AC9S6I06, “comparing everyday examples of reversible and irreversible change”.

AC9S6I01 pose investigable questions to identify patterns and test relationships and make reasoned predictions

AC9S6I02 plan and conduct repeatable investigations to answer questions including, as appropriate, deciding the variables to be changed, measured and controlled in fair tests; describing potential risks; planning for the safe use of equipment and materials; and identifying required permissions to conduct investigations on Country/Place

AC9S6I06 write and create texts to communicate ideas and findings for specific purposes and audiences, including selection of language features, using digital tools as appropriate

It builds on Year 3’s AC9S3U04, “investigate the observable properties of solids and liquids and how adding or removing heat energy leads to a change of state”, and Year 5’s AC9S5U04, “explain observable properties of solids, liquids and gases by modelling the motion and arrangement of particles”, which the magnifier on screen 2 draws on. In Year 8, AC9S8U07 asks students to “compare physical and chemical changes and identify indicators of energy change in chemical reactions”.

How the lesson is taught

The lesson uses cognitive acceleration, developed at King’s College London as Cognitive Acceleration through Science Education (CASE). It was first written for secondary science and was later extended to primary science at Key Stage 2 and to the early years. Oliver, Venville and Adey (2012) list six principles behind it: schema theory; concrete preparation, in which the teacher sets up a problem and works through the ideas and words it needs; cognitive conflict, “intellectual challenges of moderate difficulty that must be accompanied by support”; social construction, in which students work out explanations together; metacognition, in which students reflect on their thinking and explain how they approached a problem; and bridging, in which they apply the ideas to other problems, including real-world ones.

The screens follow those principles, and each screen names its part in plain words. Screen 1 is the concrete preparation: students make six changes, try to undo them and meet the words reversible, irreversible and new substance. Screens 2 to 4 each pose a cognitive conflict. On screen 2 students predict whether hot water dissolves more salt, then find it dissolves only a little more. On screen 3 heat turns the egg white solid instead of melting it, and the same wax changes reversibly in the dish and irreversibly in the flame. On screen 4 they predict which nails will rust, then work out which pairs of tubes make a fair test. Each puzzle has a talk box for social construction and a notebook question for metacognition. Screen 5 is the bridging, to recycling, resin and torches, and screen 6 comes back to the lesson’s question with a sort and three notebook questions about how students decided. The reasoning patterns are among those listed in King’s College London’s case study: controlling variables on screen 4, and determining criteria for classification on screens 1 and 6.

The evidence is mixed, and the studies measured different things. In Adey, Robertson and Venville’s (2002) study of Year 1 pupils in a disadvantaged inner-city area, classes given a year of cognitive acceleration activities gained significantly more than classes in matched schools on direct and transfer tests, with effect sizes of 0.47 and 0.43. In one high school in regional Western Australia, Oliver, Venville and Adey (2012) found an effect size of 0.47 for cognitive gains over Years 8 and 9 (0.81 for boys and 0.15 for girls) and 0.21 for science achievement; theirs was an exploratory case study, compared with published control data from another time and place. The Education Endowment Foundation’s trial of Let’s Think Secondary Science, an adaptation of CASE cut from 30 lessons to 19, with over 8000 students in 53 schools, “provided no evidence that Let’s Think Secondary Science improved the science attainment” of students by the end of Year 8 (Hanley et al., 2016). That trial measured attainment only, because no suitable test of reasoning was found, and its report says “Many schools did not implement the programme as intended by the developer.” It also notes that earlier studies of CASE reported gains in GCSE results that showed up years later.

The programmes in those studies were series of lessons taught over one or two years: 29 activities over a year in Adey and colleagues’ study, and two school years in the EEF trial. This lesson uses the principles inside a single lesson about content, which is its own adaptation, so it shouldn’t be expected to give the gains those studies report. Have pairs talk before they read each key idea, which opens once the simulation’s tasks are done, so that they meet each puzzle before its answer.

Handle with care

  • Screen 5 follows ACARA’s Science Teacher Background Information for elaboration AC9S6U04_E6. ACARA explains that written records “are often based on non-Indigenous interpretations of observations and records of First Nations Peoples’ behaviours, actions, comments and traditions”, that “These sources often lack the viewpoints of the people they discuss”, and that “The consulted works are not provided or recommended as classroom resources.” It suggests that, “With careful selection, evaluation and community consultation”, they may help teachers build culturally appropriate materials. The drawings on screen 5 are simple and don’t show any one community’s tools or ways of working. The detail that resin heated too quickly froths and crumbles comes from early Europeans’ observation of the Wadjari Peoples in central Western Australia; the lesson gives the chemistry without the observation.
  • The lesson’s definitions match the physical and chemical changes students meet in Year 8 (AC9S8U07): a reversible change makes no new substance, even if the shape changes, and an irreversible change makes new substances, following ACARA’s wording about the changes “that produce new substances”. That definition is the lesson’s own reading of the content description. The everyday sense of undoing a change can differ. OpenStax gives grinding solids into powders as a physical change, but a powder can’t easily be made back into one piece.
  • ACARA also says that “prolonged and repeated heat applied to Xanthorrhoea spp. resin causes irreversible chemical changes to the cement; it becomes more brittle and lessens the adhesive properties of the resin”, and that First Nations Australians “carefully control the application of heat to utilise reversible changes” in resins. Screen 5 calls gentle warming reversible, and heating too quickly, too long or too often irreversible. The detail about frothing and crumbling is about grasstree resin, so the simulation’s resin is grasstree resin.
  • The tubes and jars differ in more than the one condition being tested: the stopper or lid, the drying agent, boiling and the oil are the ways water or air is taken away. A student who points this out is thinking well; ask whether those differences could change the result.
  • The signs ACARA lists for irreversible change, such as a change in colour or temperature, gas or light, suggest a new substance but don’t prove one. Melting ice takes in heat and boiling water gives off a gas, with no new substance made.
  • Some cards can be argued, for example how completely sugar can be got back from tea, and on the printable, a burning candle also melts some of its wax, and card J’s drops come from water vapour in the air, not through the glass. Treat arguments like these as good thinking, as long as students explain them with the test of getting the material back.
  • Screen 3’s question is about one material at a time: the hot plate melts wax and a flame burns it, and resin softens or froths depending on how it is heated. Across materials it differs: the egg cooks even on Low, and water boiling on High is still water. Salt is unusual too: OpenStax says that for “most, but not all, solid solutes” solubility increases with temperature, so screen 2’s result shouldn’t become a rule about all dissolving.
  • In the rusting practical, the teacher boils the water and pours it gently into jar B once it has cooled, and students add the oil straight away. The teacher also puts the calcium chloride, the drying agent, into jar A, wearing gloves and eye protection: Studyladder’s worksheet says “Use gloves when handling calcium Chloride.” The jar A nail hangs on string from the lid so that it doesn’t touch the drying agent, as in Studyladder’s jar version. Check your school’s safety advice and risk assessment before the practical. Nails can be sharp, and students wash their hands afterwards. Students don’t taste anything in a science lesson, including the salty water.

About the models

  • Screen 1: each change takes 3 seconds, so the nail’s week in damp air is sped up. A change counts as reversible if the starting material comes back, even in a new shape.
  • Screen 2: the grams of salt 100 g of water can hold at 0, 20, 40, 60, 80 and 100 °C are Sigma-Aldrich’s values for sodium chloride, 35.6, 35.8, 36.42, 37.05, 38.05 and 39.2 g, with straight lines between them. Each spoonful is 5 g, a spoonful dissolves over a second or two (3 g a second, at every temperature: the model shows how much salt can dissolve, not how fast), and the water evaporates in 6 seconds. The magnifier shows far fewer particles than there would really be, with more salt particles for each water particle than in real salty water so that they can be seen, and draws each salt particle as a single dot.
  • Screen 3: ice melts and water freezes at 0 °C, and water boils at 100 °C (OpenStax), and its temperature stays the same while it melts and while it boils. The ice starts at −10 °C. Off the hot plate, hot water cools by itself to about 25 °C, and Cool it right down takes it to −10 °C. How much heat each stage needs, the hot plate’s three settings, and how fast wax melts, sets and burns and an egg cooks are the lesson’s own choices, sped up. The lid is cooler than the steam, so steam that touches it condenses, and with the hot plate off the water stops boiling at once. Steam and the candle’s gases are invisible; the drawings show them as faint wisps so that students can follow where they go. The candle task is done once a fifth of the candle has burnt.
  • Screen 4: students predict which nails will rust before the week runs. The four tubes follow Studyladder’s worksheet: air with no water (a drying agent keeps the air dry), cooled boiled water with oil on top (no air), water and air, and salty water and air. Over the model’s week the nail in water and air ends up with rust over 60% of it and the nail in salty water is covered; the nails without water or without air don’t rust. These amounts are the lesson’s own; real tubes are usually left for a week or two (Preproom).
  • Screen 5: the recycling plant follows Planet Ark’s description: the cans are crushed, melted in a furnace, and the liquid metal is shaped in moulds into new products, mainly new cans. The resin and the torch follow ACARA, and the resin is grasstree resin. The resin softens and sets in under 2 seconds each, and heated too quickly it froths in 2 seconds.
  • Screen 6: each card drops into the bin it is sorted into, and a cross marks a card in the wrong bin until it is moved.
  • With reduced motion, each run is worked out at once and the drawing shows how it ends.

Where sources disagree and what to check

  • Salt in hot water: ACARA’s example question for AC9S6I01 asks whether more salt will dissolve in warm water than in cold water. Sigma-Aldrich’s values show only a little more, 35.6 g per 100 g of water at 0 °C and 39.2 g at 100 °C. Its table doesn’t list sugar, so the lesson doesn’t compare salt with sugar. OpenStax gives “a general trend of increasing solubility with temperature, although there are exceptions”.
  • Cooking an egg: OpenStax Biology calls frying an egg an example of “irreversible protein denaturation”, in which the protein changes shape “without losing its primary sequence”. OpenStax Chemistry lists “food being cooked” among chemical changes, which produce different kinds of matter. For Year 6, the lesson follows ACARA, which describes cooking as producing new substances.
  • Burning wax: the lesson names carbon dioxide and water vapour as examples of the new substances. OpenStax says candle waxes are “composed of large hydrocarbon molecules” and that “The complete combustion of hydrocarbons, for example, will yield carbon dioxide and water as the only products.”
  • Rusting: OpenStax says “Iron will rust when it is exposed to oxygen and water.” The Royal Society of Chemistry gives “Salt speeds up rusting.” as prior knowledge for students aged 11 to 14.

Answers at a glance

  • Screen 1: ice, salt and wax come back, so those changes are reversible; the egg, the bread and the nail don’t, so those are irreversible. q-rev melting chocolate; q-newsub new substances are made; q-shape yes, it is the same material.
  • Screen 2: at 20 °C, 100 g of water holds 35.8 g of salt, so seven spoonfuls dissolve and the eighth leaves 4.2 g on the bottom; at 0 °C it holds 35.6 g and at 100 °C 39.2 g. q-where still in the water; q-back let the water evaporate; q-hot a little more; n-left 50 − 36 = 14 g.
  • Screen 3: the ice melts at 0 °C, the water boils at 100 °C, steam condenses on the cooler lid, and cooling turns the water back into ice; the wax melts and sets again, but the candle’s wax burns; the egg white turns white and solid and stays cooked when cooled. n-boil 100 °C; q-wax burning the wax; q-egg it stays cooked.
  • Screen 4: the nails in C and D rust, D most; A and B don’t, so the prediction C and D is right. Air: B and C. Water: A and C. Salt: C and D. q-needs oxygen and water; q-fair the nail in dry air and the nail in water with air; q-rustnew rust is a new substance.
  • Screen 5: melting cans and softening resin are reversible; resin heated too quickly and the burning torch are irreversible. q-recycle melting is reversible; q-resin warm resin is soft and hardens as it cools; q-torch irreversible.
  • Screen 6: reversible are the ice block melting, water freezing, sugar dissolving, the puddle drying and drops on the mirror; irreversible are bread toasting, the egg frying, the chain rusting, the banana turning brown and the match burning. q-best can I get the material back?; q-sign a new substance has probably been made; q-puddle reversible.
  • Printable sheet: cards A, C, E, H, J and L are reversible (chocolate melting, salt dissolving, water boiling into steam, melted wax setting, drops on a glass of iced water and butter melting); B, D, F, G, I and K are irreversible (a cake baking, paper burning, an egg boiling, a nail rusting, a banana turning brown and a candle burning). In the rusting test, the nails in jars C and D should rust, D most, and the nails in A and B should stay shiny or rust only a little. If a little rust appears in jar B, ask how well the air was kept out. Water: jars A and C. Air: jars B and C.

Saved progress

Answers, notes and settings are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere.

References

Sources by screen

  • Method: Oliver, Venville and Adey (2012); Adey, Robertson and Venville (2002); King’s College London (2014); Hanley et al. (2016); Education Endowment Foundation.
  • Screen 1: ACARA (AC9S6U04); OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 1.3 (physical and chemical changes); OpenStax Biology 2e, 3.4 (frying an egg).
  • Screen 2: Sigma-Aldrich (solubility of sodium chloride); OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 1.2 (mixtures separated by evaporation; sodium chloride as a white, crystalline solid) and 11.3 (solubility); Rio Tinto (Dampier salt); ACARA (AC9S6I01).
  • Screen 3: OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 1.3 (wax melting and steam condensing as physical changes), 1.4 (water freezes at 0 °C and boils at 100 °C), 4.2 (combustion), 4.5 (combustion of hydrocarbons), 10.3 (temperature during a change of state) and 10.5 (candle waxes); OpenStax Biology 2e, 3.4 (frying an egg).
  • Screen 4: OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 1.3 (rust as a different kind of matter) and 17.6 (corrosion); Royal Society of Chemistry (salt speeds up rusting); Studyladder (the four tubes); Preproom (a week or two).
  • Screen 5: Planet Ark (recycling aluminium cans); ACARA, Science Teacher Background Information, AC9S6U04_E6.
  • Screen 6: ACARA, Science Teacher Background Information, AC9S6U04_E6 (signs of irreversible change); OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 1.3 (a banana turning brown, a burning match, condensing).
  • Printable sheet: Studyladder (the four jars); Preproom (a week or two); OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 17.6 (rusting).
  • Word list: the sources for the screen where each word is first used.

Word list