AusSci

Year 7 science · Biological sciences · AC9S7U01

Who’s who in the schoolyard?

1A survey

What lives in the schoolyard?

How can you tell who’s who in the schoolyard?

In science, classification is defining and naming groups of living and non-living things by the characteristics they share (ACARA). ACARA gives identification and communication as reasons for classifying living things. Even a small schoolyard holds a diversity of life to identify and talk about.

How this lesson works. You will practise telling groups of living things apart, and the practice mixes the groups together instead of taking one group at a time. In one study, people learning to recognise bird families did better when the families were mixed than when they saw one family at a time (Wahlheim and colleagues). In another, with paintings, most people thought that seeing one artist’s paintings together had worked better, even after their own test results showed the opposite (Kornell and Bjork). So expect the mixed practice to feel harder. On screen 8 you come back to the schoolyard and answer this screen’s question.

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Explain it.
  3. Read the key idea, then write your first answer in My notebook.

The simulation is a schoolyard after rain. Survey all ten places, then look closely at what you find. The words under the picture describe each living thing, with its source in brackets.

A schoolyard survey

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

If you survey your own schoolyard, look but don’t touch. Leave spiders where they are, and don’t touch or eat wild mushrooms: children shouldn’t touch wild mushrooms with their bare hands, eating them can make you very sick or even kill you, and there is no easy way to tell which ones are poisonous (Victorian Department of Health; NSW Health). Leave logs where they are and keep out of long grass, because snakes hide in places such as fallen logs and long grass (NSW National Parks). Wash your hands when you come back inside.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain what happened. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Survey all ten places in the schoolyard.

    Need a hint?

    Tap each place in the picture, or choose a place in the list and press Look here.

  2. Look closely at the mushroom and the lichen, and find out why neither is a plant.

    Need a hint?

    The mushroom is in the lawn and the lichen is on the old log. Tap each one, or choose it under Look closely at.

  3. Look closely at the magpie and the magpie-lark, and find out whether the magpie-lark is a kind of magpie.

    Need a hint?

    Both are on the oval. Tap each one, or choose it under Look closely at.

Talk about it. How many kinds of living things did you find? How would you tell someone at another school exactly which bird you saw?

Classification brings order to many kinds of living things

The survey found 19 kinds of living things in one schoolyard: birds, mammals, invertebrates, plants, a fungus and a lichen. Some look alike but are in different families, such as the magpie and the magpie-lark, and some look like plants but aren’t, such as the lichen. Classification sorts living things into groups by the features they share and names them, so that people can identify a living thing and tell others exactly which one they mean (ACARA).

My notebook

Which reasons for classifying living things does ACARA give?

What is a lichen?

2Features

Sort them by their features

Which features put living things in the same group?

Living things in a group share features. Feathers set birds apart from other living vertebrates, mammals have hair or fur, and invertebrates are animals without a backbone. Nearly 97 percent of animal species are invertebrates (OpenStax). Almost all plants make their own food by photosynthesis (OpenStax). Fungi can’t, and they are more closely related to animals than to plants (OpenStax).

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Explain it.
  3. Read the key idea.

In the simulation, the survey’s living things come to the tray one at a time. Press the group each one belongs to. In the mixed order the group changes every time, so you have to look for the features that tell the groups apart. Try one group at a time as well, and compare your scores.

Sorting the survey

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain what happened. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Sort all 19 living things from the survey in the mixed order.

    Need a hint?

    Look at the living thing in the tray, then press the group it belongs to. If you’re wrong, read why and try again.

  2. Sort them again one group at a time, and compare your score.

    Need a hint?

    Choose One group at a time under Order, then sort all 19 again.

  3. Sort four living things that weren’t in the survey.

    Need a hint?

    After a full sort, press Four new living things.

Talk about it. Which order felt easier? Which living things were the hardest to sort, and why?

The members of a group share features

The members of a group can look very different: an earthworm and a spider are both invertebrates. Living things in different groups can look alike: a lichen can look like a plant, but it is a fungus living with an alga or a cyanobacterium (OpenStax). Fungi were once thought of as plant-like, but they can’t photosynthesise, and they are more closely related to animals than to plants (OpenStax).

My notebook

Which of these is an invertebrate?

Why aren’t fungi plants?

3Keys

Use a key

How does a dichotomous key work?

A dichotomous key is a set of questions, each with two answers. Each answer leads to another question or to a name. The key in the simulation identifies the six invertebrates found in the schoolyard survey.

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Explain it.
  3. Read the key idea.

Animals A to F are drawn so that you can count their legs. Choose an animal, count its legs on both sides, and answer each question. When the key gives a name, check its description against the animal.

A key to six invertebrates

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain what happened. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Use the key to identify one of the six animals.

    Need a hint?

    Choose an animal, then answer each question with Yes or No. Count the legs on both sides.

  2. Identify all six animals.

    Need a hint?

    When the key gives a name, check its description against the animal. If they don’t match, start that animal again.

  3. Find the two animals that end at the same name.

    Need a hint?

    Identify every animal, and look for a name that comes up twice.

Talk about it. Why does the key ask about legs and a shell, not about colour or size? What should you do if the name at the end doesn’t match the animal?

A key is a chain of two-way questions

Each question in a dichotomous key has two answers, and each answer leads to another question or to a name. Good questions ask about features you can see or count, so that everyone gets the same answer. A key can end at a group as well as at a species: the ant and the ladybird both end at Insect, a group with many kinds in it. At the end, check the description against the living thing. If they don’t match, go back to the question you may have answered wrongly.

My notebook

How many answers does each question in a dichotomous key have?

The key says Spider, but the animal has fourteen legs. What should you do?

4Keys

Make a key for six birds

How do you make a key?

Three of the birds in the schoolyard are black and white: the Australian magpie, the magpie-lark and the willie wagtail. They look alike, but they are in three different families: Artamidae, Monarchidae and Rhipiduridae (Australian Museum; Atlas of Living Australia). The magpie-lark has no link with the magpies or the larks (Birds in Backyards).

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Explain it.
  3. Read the key idea.

To make a key, start with all the living things and choose a question that splits them into two groups. Then split each group again, until every group holds one living thing. In the simulation, choose a question for the group shown and press Split this group. The lengths on the cards come from the Australian Museum (magpie, willie wagtail, welcome swallow and cockatoo), Birds in Backyards (magpie-lark), Museums Victoria (galah) and the Victorian Government (crested pigeon).

A key for six birds

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain what happened. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Build a key that ends with one bird at each end.

    Need a hint?

    Choose a question for the group shown and press Split this group. Keep going until every group has one bird.

  2. Try a question that doesn’t work, and find out why.

    Need a hint?

    Try Is it a beautiful bird?, or Is it longer than 35 cm? on a group with the galah in it.

  3. A sulphur-crested cockatoo lands. Add it to your key.

    Need a hint?

    When your key is finished, press A seventh bird lands, then split the group the cockatoo ends up in.

Talk about it. How many questions did your key need? Did your partner’s key use the same questions?

A key is built from features that split groups

Each two-way question splits one group into two, so any dichotomous key for six birds has five questions, and adding a seventh bird adds one more. Good questions ask about features you can see or measure, with a clear yes or no for every bird in the group. A question about length doesn’t work for the galah, whose body is up to 40 cm long (Museums Victoria), because some galahs are longer than 35 cm and some aren’t.

My notebook

How many questions does a dichotomous key need to separate eight living things?

Which is the best question for a key to birds?

5Naming

One name for every species

Why do scientists use scientific names?

In 1735 Carolus Linnaeus published Systema Naturae, which set out a standard way of categorising and naming organisms, so that scientists could discuss them using consistent terms (OpenStax). Its 1758 edition was the first to use two-part names all the way through (University of California Museum of Paleontology). Each species has a two-part scientific name: its genus, which starts with a capital letter, then a second word, which doesn’t. Both parts are written in italics (OpenStax). The galah is Eolophus roseicapilla.

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Explain it.
  3. Read the key idea.

Common names can mislead, and they change from place to place. In the simulation, look up some common names, and find which living thing each one names and the family or other group it belongs to.

Common names and scientific names

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain what happened. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Look up both magpies, and find out whether they are in the same family.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Australian magpie and press Look it up, then do the same for Magpie (in Britain).

  2. Find the animals with four common names.

    Need a hint?

    Look up the animals you found under the old log.

  3. Choose the correctly written scientific name of the galah.

    Need a hint?

    The genus starts with a capital letter, the second word doesn’t, and both are in italics.

Talk about it. Why might people in different places give the same bird different names? Which name would a scientist in another country understand?

One species, one scientific name

A common name can belong to more than one living thing. The magpie of Britain, Pica pica, is in the crow family, Corvidae (BTO), and the Australian magpie, Gymnorhina tibicen, is in Artamidae (Australian Museum). One living thing can also have several common names: slaters are also called woodlice, butcher-boys or pillbugs (Australian Faunal Directory). A scientific name belongs to one species only, so scientists everywhere know which living thing is meant.

My notebook

Which is the cat’s scientific name, written correctly?

Why can common names cause mix-ups?

6The hierarchy

Groups within groups

How are the groups arranged?

Linnaeus grouped organisms in a hierarchy of increasingly specific levels, based on their similarities (OpenStax). In his original system, genera were grouped into orders, orders into classes and classes into kingdoms, and later biologists added more levels between these (University of California Museum of Paleontology). Today the system has eight main levels, from domain and kingdom down to genus and species. For the dog they are the domain Eukarya (OpenStax), then Animalia, Chordata, Mammalia, Carnivora, Canidae, Canis and Canis familiaris (Australian Faunal Directory).

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Explain it.
  3. Read the key idea.

In the simulation, step down the levels with the dog and another living thing from the schoolyard, and find the level where the two part ways.

From domain to species

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain what happened. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Step down the levels with the dog and the cat, and find where they part ways.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Cat under Compare the dog with, then press Next level down until the two groups differ.

  2. Do the same with the dog and the magpie.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Australian magpie, then press Next level down.

  3. Find a living thing that shares only the domain with the dog.

    Need a hint?

    Try the gum tree or the mushroom.

Talk about it. The dog shares more levels with the cat than with the magpie. What does that tell you about how alike they are?

Each level is a group inside the one above

The levels are groups within groups: each one is a smaller group inside the level above it. The dog and the cat share five levels, down to the order Carnivora (OpenStax), and part ways at family: Canidae and Felidae (Australian Faunal Directory). The dog shares three levels with the magpie, two with the ant, and only the domain, Eukarya, with the gum tree and the mushroom. All dogs, from a Chihuahua to a Great Dane, belong to one species, Canis familiaris (Australian Faunal Directory), though dogs vary in body size more than any other species of mammal (National Institutes of Health).

My notebook

Which list puts the levels in order, from the biggest group to the smallest?

How many species do a Chihuahua and a Great Dane belong to?

7Microscopes

A drop of pond water

How did microscopes change classification?

In 1675 Antonie van Leeuwenhoek, a Dutch cloth merchant, used a simple but powerful microscope to see single-celled organisms swimming in a drop of rain water. He called them “animalcules” (OpenStax). Linnaeus’s system, published in 1735, had two kingdoms of living things: animals and plants (OpenStax).

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Explain it.
  3. Read the key idea.

In the simulation, turn the microscope up to high power and identify the four living things in a drop of pond water. Then place them in the kingdoms of four classification systems, from Linnaeus to Woese and Fox.

A drop of pond water

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain what happened. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Find and identify all four living things in the drop of pond water.

    Need a hint?

    Choose High power, then tap each living thing, or choose it under Look at and press Look closely.

  2. Try to put Euglena in one of Linnaeus’s two kingdoms.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Linnaeus (1735) under Kingdoms, choose Euglena, then press a kingdom.

  3. Switch to Haeckel’s kingdoms, and place all four living things.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Haeckel (1866), then place each living thing in a kingdom.

Talk about it. Euglena makes food in the light and swims. Where would you have put it before Haeckel? Why does the rotifer go with the animals, even though it is microscopic?

New evidence changes classification

Microscopes showed that a drop of water holds living things too small to see, many of them unicellular. Euglena photosynthesises in the light, as plants do, but it swims with a flagellum and takes in food in the dark (OpenStax), so it is hard to place in either of Linnaeus’s two kingdoms. In 1866 Ernst Haeckel proposed the kingdom Protista for unicellular organisms, and later Monera for those whose cells lack a nucleus. Robert Whittaker added Fungi in 1969, and from the 1970s Carl Woese and George Fox used genes to build a tree of life with three domains: Bacteria, Archaea and Eukarya (OpenStax).

Today the word protist is used informally, because molecular genetics has shown that some protists are more closely related to animals, plants or fungi than they are to other protists (OpenStax).

My notebook

Which kingdom did Haeckel propose in 1866 for unicellular organisms?

A rotifer is microscopic. Which group does it belong to?

8Explain it

Back to the schoolyard

Why classify living things?

On screen 1 you surveyed the schoolyard. Now use a key to the whole schoolyard to identify what you found, then compare the Linnaean system with other ways of classifying living things.

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Explain it.
  3. Read ACARA’s background information, then the key idea.
  4. Write your answer to the lesson’s question in My notebook.
  5. Answer the last two questions and look at your results.

The schoolyard key has ten questions and eleven ends, from Bird to Fungus. Choose a living thing from the survey, answer each question, and check the description at the end. Try the Paramecium from the pond as well.

The schoolyard key

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain what happened. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Use the schoolyard key to identify three living things from the survey.

    Need a hint?

    Choose a living thing, press Start, and answer each question with Yes or No.

  2. Identify the moss and the lichen, and find the question that separates them.

    Need a hint?

    Key out the moss, then the lichen, and look for where their paths go different ways.

  3. Try the key on a Paramecium from the pond.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Paramecium (from the pond). Answer each question for the Paramecium, then check the description at the end.

Talk about it. What can a key do, and what can’t it do? Why might different people sort the same living things into different groups?

From ACARA’s background information

ACARA describes the classification systems of First Nations Australians as diverse and complex. They differ in many respects from Linnaean taxonomy, and at times they parallel it. Many living things are grouped by First Nations Australians based on their use. Living things are at times grouped by features such as form and function, and these groupings are not always based on relatedness, as the Linnaean system is.

For example, some First Nations Australians classify turtles, barramundi and dugong into the same group, “based on the observation that they are all aquatic and have fins or flippers”. The Linnaean system categorises turtles as reptiles, barramundi as fish and dugong as mammals.

Yanyuwa peoples in the Northern Territory have two broad categories, which distinguish living things as coastal and marine, or inland, and certain animals and plants can move between them depending on circumstance. The Yanyuwa language has one term, walya, for all dugong and sea turtles, and this category breaks down into at least 16 names for dugong. The names vary with a dugong’s age, size and gender, and even with its status within its herd.

ACARA says that all classification systems serve a purpose of relevance and importance to the user, and that they can also reflect the knowledge, values, behaviours and worldviews of the peoples who construct them.

Classification orders the diversity of life

The schoolyard key sorted the survey’s 19 living things into eleven groups by features you can see, and the Linnaean levels place each kind in groups within groups, from domain to species. A key works only for the living things it was made for: it ended at Earthworm for the Paramecium. Biologists work to make the Linnaean system reflect how living things are related through evolution (OpenStax). First Nations Australians’ systems are diverse, and many living things are grouped by their use (ACARA). ACARA says that all classification systems serve a purpose of relevance and importance to the user.

My notebook

In ACARA’s example, why do some First Nations Australians classify turtles, barramundi and dugong in the same group?

The schoolyard key ended at Earthworm for a Paramecium. What does that show?

Printable activity

Use and make a dichotomous key

Two pages. Page 1 has six invertebrates to identify with a key. Page 2 has six birds to build your own key for, and the levels from domain to species for the dog and the cat.

For teachers

Curriculum

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 7, Science understanding, Biological sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:

AC9S7U01 investigate the role of classification in ordering and organising the diversity of life on Earth and use and develop classification tools including dichotomous keys

  • observing and identifying the similarities and differences of particular features within and between groups of organisms
  • creating and modifying a dichotomous key to classify organisms into groups and groups within groups
  • naming and classifying species using scientific conventions from the Linnaean hierarchical classification system, such as kingdom, phylum, class, order, family, genus, species
  • considering the reasons for classifying living things, such as identification and communication
  • examining how biological classification has changed over time through improvements in microscopy
  • using provided dichotomous keys to identify organisms surveyed on a field trip
  • investigating First Nations Australians’ systems of classifying living things and how these systems differ from those used by contemporary science

The second quote gives all seven of ACARA’s elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each part of the content description is covered on these screens:

  • The role of classification in ordering and organising the diversity of life: the survey on screen 1, the sorting on screen 2, the levels on screen 6 and the schoolyard key on screen 8; q-reason, q-invert, q-order and q-limit.
  • Using and developing classification tools, including dichotomous keys: the invertebrate key on screen 3, building and changing a key for six birds on screen 4, and the schoolyard key on screen 8; q-dich, q-check, q-count and q-goodq.
  • The elaborations, in ACARA’s order. Similarities and differences of features within and between groups are screens 1 and 2. Creating and modifying a dichotomous key is screen 4, where the cockatoo is added to a finished key, with groups within groups on screens 3 and 6. Naming and classifying species with the Linnaean conventions is screens 5 and 6. The reasons for classifying, such as identification and communication, are screens 1 and 5. How classification has changed through improvements in microscopy is screen 7. Using provided keys on organisms surveyed on a field trip is screens 3 and 8, with the survey on screen 1 standing in for the field trip. First Nations Australians’ systems of classifying living things are screen 8, from ACARA’s background information for AC9S7H02 elaboration 1.

The lesson also works on these content descriptions. Screens 5 and 7 show classification changing as evidence changes: Linnaeus’s two kingdoms giving way to Haeckel’s, Whittaker’s and Woese and Fox’s, the word protist now used informally, and the dog’s two scientific names. Screen 5 also says that sources can disagree about families, and Where sources disagree gives the magpie-lark as an example. Screen 8 gives ACARA’s account of First Nations Australians’ classification systems. The keys on screens 3, 4 and 8 are representations that organise information, and screen 4 asks students to design one.

AC9S7H01 explain how new evidence or different perspectives can lead to changes in scientific knowledge

AC9S7H02 investigate how cultural perspectives and world views influence the development of scientific knowledge

AC9S7I04 select and construct appropriate representations, including tables, graphs, models and mathematical relationships, to organise and process data and information

AC9S7I08 write and create texts to communicate ideas, findings and arguments for specific purposes and audiences, including selection of appropriate language and text features, using digital tools as appropriate

It builds on Year 3’s AC9S3U01, “compare characteristics of living and non-living things and examine the differences between the life cycles of plants and animals”, which the site’s Year 3 living things lesson teaches. It leads to Year 10’s AC9S10U02, “use the theory of evolution by natural selection to explain past and present diversity and analyse the scientific evidence supporting the theory”, which the site’s Year 10 evolution lesson teaches.

Elaboration 7 asks students to investigate First Nations Australians’ systems of classifying living things. No ACARA teacher background information page was found for that elaboration. Its page for AC9S7H02 elaboration 1 covers the same topic, and screen 8’s box gives students its main points. If students are to investigate further, follow it with local sources that the community has approved.

How the lesson is taught

The method is interleaved practice: students practise sorting and identifying living things from different groups mixed together, rather than one group at a time. Brunmair and Richter’s meta-analysis of 59 studies found “a moderate overall interleaving effect” (Hedges’ g = 0.42), and “stronger interleaving effects for learning material more similar between categories, for learning material less similar within categories, and for more complex learning material”. With bird families, Wahlheim, Dunlosky and Jacoby found that “spacing enhanced learning beyond massed study”. Kornell and Bjork, who mixed paintings by different artists, found that “Participants rated massing as more effective than spacing, even after their own test performance had demonstrated the opposite”. Screen 1 tells students this, so that they expect the mixed practice to feel harder.

Screen 1’s survey and screen 2’s sorting present living things from all five groups mixed together. On screen 2, students sort the survey in a mixed order, where the group changes every time, then one group at a time, and compare their first-try scores; four living things they haven’t seen then test whether they have learned the groups. The one-group order usually scores better, because the answer is usually the same as the last one and the living things have been seen once already, so the two scores show how each order feels, not which one teaches better. Screen 4’s six birds include three black and white birds from three families, so students have to look past colour. Screens 3 and 4 use keys with six living things at a time (seven once the cockatoo lands), as Randler recommends: teaching and learning “should make use of a small selection of species (6-8)”. Screen 8’s key brings all 19 together. Each screen then has an Explain it card that asks first what students found and then why or how, with a reply to each wrong option.

These studies have limits. Brunmair and Richter found “An advantage of blocking compared with interleaving” for studies based on words (g = −0.39), and say that interleaving “should be used with caution in certain conditions, especially for expository texts and words”, so the reading and the explanations on each screen are not interleaved. Kornell and Bjork’s participants were at the University of California, Los Angeles, and Wahlheim and colleagues’ study also looked at ageing, so none of these studies tested school students, and the meta-analysis’s abstract doesn’t say who its learners were. With keys, Randler and Zehender taught 71 Grade 6 students to identify six reptile species with either an identification book or a dichotomous key. Both groups improved, straight after the lesson and four weeks later, and they found “no differences in achievement between both groups”, so the key itself did no better than the book. The simulations and the keys are the lesson’s own. Run the lesson in pairs. After screen 2, ask which order felt easier and why the one-group order scored better, then point out that the studies tested learning with new examples, as the four new living things do. On screen 4, compare keys between pairs: different keys can all work.

Handle with care

  • A schoolyard survey. If students survey their own schoolyard, have them look but not touch. Few Australian spiders are harmful to humans, and those considered dangerous are female redback spiders, mouse spiders and funnel-web spiders (Australian Museum), so leave spiders where they are. NSW National Parks says that snakes hide in places that include fallen logs and long grass, so leave logs where they are and keep the survey out of long grass; on screen 1 the slater, the moss and the lichen are at the old log. NSW Health says “Do not eat wild mushrooms” and that there is no easy way to tell which wild mushrooms are poisonous, and the Victorian Department of Health says “Children should not touch wild mushrooms with their bare hands and animals should be kept away from them.” Have students wash their hands afterwards.
  • Magpies and magpie-larks. The Australian Museum says that only a small minority of Australian magpies swoop, and that their peak breeding season is August to November. Birds in Backyards says that magpie-larks can be aggressive during breeding season. Plan a survey around any swooping birds you know of.
  • Soil in the NT. Soil can carry the bacteria that cause melioidosis. The Northern Territory Government says that melioidosis is more common in the Top End, but that cases have also been reported as far south as Tennant Creek. It says the chance of getting sick is higher in the wet season, from October to April, and advises rubber gloves when handling soil, waterproof shoes or boots in wet and muddy conditions, and keeping cuts covered with a clean dressing when going outside.
  • Pond water. If students look at real pond water under a microscope, follow your school’s rules for handling water samples, and have them wash their hands afterwards.
  • The First Nations content. Screen 8’s box, its key idea, the second part of its Explain it card and q-acara use only ACARA’s teacher background information for AC9S7H02 elaboration 1. No people are drawn, and no First Nations classification is made into a simulation or a sorting task. ACARA’s page carries the same cautions as its other background information pages: some of its consulted works “may contain material that is considered culturally offensive or inappropriate”, and they “are not provided or recommended as classroom resources”. Written records are often “based on non-Indigenous interpretations of observations and records of First Nations Peoples’ behaviours, actions, comments and traditions”, and “Such interpretations privilege western paradigms of non-First Nations authors and include, at times, attitudes and language of the past.” ACARA adds that “These sources often lack the viewpoints of the people they discuss and can contain ideas based on outdated scientific theories”, that although they are public “they may contain cultural breaches and cause offence to the Peoples concerned”, and that with careful selection, evaluation and community consultation they “could be culturally audited, refined and adapted to construct culturally appropriate teaching and learning materials”. It says that “The ability to select and evaluate appropriate resources is an essential cultural capability skill for educators.” As ACARA does, the lesson describes these systems in the present tense. Screen 8 has not been checked with the Yanyuwa peoples or the other Peoples it refers to. Follow your school’s or system’s protocols for First Nations content, for example by asking Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander staff or education officers, and ask your local community for advice on teaching screen 8, bearing in mind that this knowledge belongs to the Peoples named.
  • Ideas worth listening for. Listen for the ideas that all small animals are insects (a spider has eight walking legs, and a slater has fourteen legs), that fungi and lichens are plants, that animals sharing a common name are related (the two magpies), that a key always gives the right answer (it can only name what it was made for), that very different sizes mean different species (all dogs are one species), and that animals that move the same way belong together: Cardak found that the way an animal moves was a key factor when the 316 primary school students in his study classified animals.

About the models

Screen 1. The schoolyard is the lesson’s own, with 19 kinds of living things in ten places, each drawn from the descriptions in the sources named in its words. The pond shows nothing until screen 7.

Screen 2. The groups are birds (feathers), mammals (hair or fur), invertebrates (animals without a backbone), plants (photosynthesis) and fungi (no photosynthesis), from OpenStax. The lichen is accepted with the fungi, with the reply that it is a fungus living with an alga or a cyanobacterium. In the mixed order no two living things from the same group come one after the other. In one group at a time, the six birds come first, then the two mammals, the six invertebrates, the three plants and the two fungi. The four new living things are a laughing kookaburra, a millipede, a fern and a brushtail possum.

Screen 3. The key has four questions: legs, then six legs, then eight legs, and for animals without legs, a shell. The ant and the ladybird end at Insect, the spider at Spider, the slater at Slater, the snail at Snail and the earthworm at Earthworm. A wrong answer leads to a wrong name, and the words then name the first question answered wrongly. The drawings show every animal’s legs, but a real ladybird’s legs are usually hidden beneath its body when it is viewed from above (CSIRO), so have students look at a real one from the side.

Screen 4. The questions and the birds that answer yes: black and white (magpie, magpie-lark, willie wagtail); longer than 35 cm (magpie, 36 to 44 cm, and cockatoo, 45 to 50 cm), which is unclear for the galah, 35 to 36 cm; shorter than 25 cm (willie wagtail, about 20 cm, and welcome swallow, 15 cm); a long forked tail (welcome swallow); a thin black crest (crested pigeon); a rose-pink head (galah); and a yellow crest (cockatoo). One key that works asks black and white, then longer than 35 cm, then shorter than 25 cm, and for the other three birds a rose-pink head, then a long forked tail. Three questions are refused: a beautiful bird (an opinion), big (no measure) and sings (it can’t be seen). The birds are drawn larger or smaller in the order of their lengths, but not to scale.

Screen 6. The levels for the dog and the cat are from the Australian Faunal Directory, through the Atlas of Living Australia, with the domain from OpenStax. The magpie’s class, Aves, is from the Australian Museum. The ant’s phylum, Arthropoda, is from OpenStax, which says ants are insects and describes insects in the phylum Arthropoda. The gum tree’s and the mushroom’s kingdoms are from OpenStax.

Screen 7. The drop holds a Paramecium, an Amoeba, a Euglena and a rotifer, drawn from OpenStax’s descriptions, at three powers that show specks, shapes and parts; the powers have no magnifications. Under Linnaeus the three single cells can go in either kingdom, with a reply on why neither fits well (the Paramecium swims with cilia and the Amoeba pulls itself along, and both take in food), and the rotifer goes with the animals. Under Haeckel and Whittaker the single cells go in Protista and the rotifer in Animalia, and under Woese and Fox all four go in Eukarya.

Screen 8. The schoolyard key has ten questions and eleven ends, and every living thing from the survey reaches its group. A Paramecium, answered truthfully, ends at Earthworm, because the key has no question about size or cells. Answered wrongly, it gets the usual reply naming the first question to look at again.

Where sources disagree and what to check

  • The dog’s name. OpenStax names the dog Canis lupus familiaris, “a subspecies of Canis lupus, which also includes the wolf and dingo”. The Australian Faunal Directory lists it as Canis familiaris and notes Freedman and colleagues (2014), “who demonstrate through molecular analyses that Canis lupus and C. familiaris are separate lineages”. It also says that the dingo “is variously referred to as Canis lupus, Canis lupus dingo, Canis familiaris and Canis familiaris dingo in the literature”. The lesson uses the Australian Faunal Directory’s name, says on screens 5 and 6 that some books use Canis lupus familiaris, and leaves the dingo out. OpenStax also says “Dogs and wolves are the same species because they can breed and produce viable offspring”, which is the word list’s test for a species, so a student who applies that test to dogs and wolves reaches OpenStax’s answer. The Australian Faunal Directory’s name follows Freedman and colleagues’ molecular analyses instead.
  • The magpie-lark’s family. The Atlas of Living Australia, from the Australian Faunal Directory, puts it in Monarchidae. Birds in Backyards says “it actually belongs in the Family Dicruridae (Monarchs, Fantails, and Drongos)”, which would put it in the same family as the willie wagtail, a fantail. The lesson uses Monarchidae.
  • The two magpies. No Australian source found says in so many words that the Australian magpie and the magpie of Britain are unrelated. The lesson gives only their families, Artamidae (Australian Museum) and Corvidae (BTO).
  • Protista. OpenStax’s microbiology text gives Haeckel’s Protista and Whittaker’s five kingdoms. Its biology text says that the term protist “still is used informally”, because some protists are more related to animals, plants or fungi than they are to other protists. Screen 7 gives both.
  • The galah’s length. The Australian Museum gives the galah’s size range as 35 cm to 36 cm, Museums Victoria gives a body “up to 40 cm long”, and BirdLife Australia puts the galah in its “Medium (30 to 45 cm, eg: pigeon)” size band. Screen 4 and the printable use the Australian Museum’s range, so longer than 35 cm is unclear for the galah.
  • Linnaeus’s levels. OpenStax’s microbiology text gives the levels of Linnaeus’s original taxonomy as kingdom, class, order, family, genus and species. The University of California Museum of Paleontology says that in Linnaeus’s original system genera were grouped into orders, orders into classes and classes into kingdoms, and that later biologists added more ranks. The lesson follows the museum.
  • Microscopes and the kingdoms. ACARA’s elaboration links changes in classification to improvements in microscopy. OpenStax gives Leeuwenhoek’s sight of single-celled organisms in 1675 and Haeckel’s kingdom for unicellular organisms in 1866, but no source found says that a better microscope caused a particular change, so screen 7 gives the dates and leaves students to place Euglena themselves.

Answers at a glance

Screen 1: 19 living things in ten places, with nothing visible in the pond; the mushroom is part of a fungus, and the lichen is a fungus living with an alga or a cyanobacterium; the magpie-lark has no link with the magpies; the card answers are animals, plants, a fungus and a lichen, and identification and communication; q-reason identification and communication, q-lichen a fungus living with an alga or a cyanobacterium. Screen 2: six birds, two mammals, six invertebrates, three plants and two fungi, with the lichen; the kookaburra is a bird, the millipede an invertebrate, the fern a plant and the possum a mammal; the card answers are no backbone, and fungi can’t photosynthesise; q-invert a snail, q-fungi they can’t photosynthesise. Screen 3: A is a slater, B an ant, C a snail, D a spider, E an earthworm and F a ladybird; the ant and the ladybird both end at Insect; the card answers are two answers each leading on, and features that can be seen and counted; q-dich two, q-check go back to the questions about legs. Screen 4: any working key has five questions for six birds and six for seven; the card answers are five, and a feature you can see or measure with a clear yes or no; q-count seven, q-goodq a long forked tail. Screen 5: the Australian magpie is Gymnorhina tibicen in Artamidae and the magpie of Britain Pica pica in Corvidae; slaters have four common names; the galah is Eolophus roseicapilla, in italics; the card answers are different families, and one scientific name for each species; q-binomial Felis catus, q-common the same common name can belong to different species. Screen 6: the dog shares five levels with the cat and parts at family, three with the magpie (class), two with the ant (phylum), and one with the gum tree and the mushroom (kingdom); the card answers are five, and each level is a smaller group inside the one above; q-order kingdom down to species, q-dogs one. Screen 7: the Paramecium, the Amoeba and the Euglena are single cells and the rotifer is an animal; under Haeckel the single cells go in Protista and the rotifer in Animalia; the card answers are four living things, three single cells and a tiny animal, and Protista for unicellular organisms; q-protista Protista, q-rotifer animals. Screen 8: each living thing from the survey ends at its group; the moss and the lichen part at question 8; the Paramecium ends at Earthworm; the card answers are groups through two-way questions, and each system serves a purpose that matters to the people who use it; q-acara they are all aquatic and have fins or flippers, q-limit a key can only identify the living things it was made for.

Saved progress

Answers, choices, notes, settings and the try-it tasks are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere. If students share devices, clear the saved answers between them.

References

Sources by screen

  • Method: Brunmair and Richter (2019); Kornell and Bjork (2008); Wahlheim, Dunlosky and Jacoby (2011); Randler (2008); Randler and Zehender (2006).
  • Screen 1: ACARA (the definition of classification and the reasons for classifying); the Australian Museum (Australian magpie, willie wagtail, galah, welcome swallow, spiders); NSW National Parks (snakes); Birds in Backyards (magpie-lark); BirdLife Australia (crested pigeon, welcome swallow nests); the Australian Faunal Directory (cat); the National Institutes of Health (dog sizes); the NSW Department of Education (ladybird); Museums Victoria (slater); Concepts of Biology 14.1 (plants) and 15.3 (ants and insects); Biology 2e 24 Introduction and 24.1 (fungi and mushrooms), 24.3 (lichens), 25.3 (mosses) and 28.4 (earthworms and snails); the Victorian Department of Health and NSW Health (wild mushrooms).
  • Screen 2: Biology 2e 28 Introduction (invertebrates), 29.5 (birds), 29.6 (mammals), 24.1 (fungi) and 24.3 (lichens); Concepts of Biology 14.1 (plants and mosses); Museums Victoria (slater).
  • Screen 3: Concepts of Biology 15.3 (insects); the Australian Museum (spiders); Museums Victoria (slaters); Biology 2e 28.4 (earthworms and snails); the NSW Department of Education and CSIRO (ladybirds).
  • Screen 4: the Australian Museum (Australian magpie, willie wagtail, galah and its length, crested pigeon, welcome swallow, sulphur-crested cockatoo); Birds in Backyards (magpie-lark, crested pigeon); the Atlas of Living Australia (the magpie-lark’s family); Museums Victoria (galah, welcome swallow); BirdLife Australia (crested pigeon, galah); the Victorian Government’s Ecolinc (crested pigeon).
  • Screen 5: Microbiology 1.2 (Linnaeus and naming); the University of California Museum of Paleontology (the 1758 edition); Biology 2e 20.1 and Concepts of Biology 12.1 (writing scientific names); the Australian Museum, the BTO, the RSPB, Birds in Backyards, the Atlas of Living Australia and the Australian Faunal Directory (names and families).
  • Screen 6: Biology 2e 20.1 and Concepts of Biology 12.1 (the levels, the dog, and cats and dogs sharing five levels); Microbiology 1.2 (Linnaeus’s hierarchy, the kingdoms and the domains); the University of California Museum of Paleontology (Linnaeus’s original levels); the Australian Faunal Directory and the Atlas of Living Australia (the dog’s and the cat’s levels, and the dog as one species); the Australian Museum (the magpie’s class); Concepts of Biology 14.1 (plants) and 15.3 (arthropods); Biology 2e 24.1 (fungi); the National Institutes of Health (dog sizes).
  • Screen 7: Microbiology 1.1 (Leeuwenhoek) and 1.2 (the kingdoms and the domains); Biology 2e 23 Introduction, 23.2 and 23.3 (protists) and 28.3 (rotifers).
  • Screen 8: ACARA’s background information for AC9S7H02 elaboration 1; the sources for screens 1 to 3 for the schoolyard key.
  • Printable: the sources for screens 3, 4 and 6.
  • Handle with care: the Australian Museum (spiders and magpies); Birds in Backyards (magpie-larks); NSW National Parks (snakes); NSW Health and the Victorian Department of Health (wild mushrooms); the Northern Territory Government (melioidosis); Cardak (2009) (moving and classifying); ACARA (cautions on the consulted works).
  • Word list: the sources for the screen where each word is first used.

Word list