AusSci

Year 7 science · Chemical sciences · AC9S7U05

How does particle theory explain the properties of substances?

1Model 1

Two levels

What is a substance like at the level of its particles?

Particle theory describes how the particles in a substance are arranged, how they move and how they attract each other, and relates this to the properties of the substance (ACARA). On this screen you look at a substance at two levels: what you would see, and its particles, magnified. The model is an agent-based model. Every particle follows the same three rules, and you can change rules 1 and 3.

On this screen

  1. Try each speed with the attraction on, and look at both views each time.
  2. Switch the attraction off and watch what the particles do.
  3. Answer the questions.

The three rules every particle follows

  1. Keep moving. Each particle has a speed, and you can make them faster or slower.
  2. Push away from a particle that comes too close, and bounce off the walls.
  3. Attract the particles nearby. You can switch this rule off.

The box also has gravity, which pulls every particle down a little.

One substance, two levels

Agent-based model

The model loads here.

Nothing in the model says “be a solid” or “be a gas”. The rules are only about single particles, and the solid, the liquid and the gas come from what all the particles do together. Researchers who build models like this one for teaching call this thinking in levels, and they point out that many mistakes come from mixing up the levels (Wilensky and Resnick).

Same particles, different states

A solid, a liquid and a gas of the same substance are made of the same particles. What changes is how the particles move and how close together they are. Particles in a solid vibrate about fixed positions; in a liquid they move past each other but stay in contact; in a gas they move independently, except when they collide (OpenStax).

In particle theory, what is the difference between ice and liquid water?

Which of these can you see only in the particle view?

You switched off the attraction rule. What happened?

2Model 2

How fast the particles move

How does the speed of the particles change how far apart they are?

Rule 1 says every particle keeps moving. When something gets hotter, the energy of motion of its particles goes up (OpenStax). So the higher the temperature, the faster the particles move on average. Change the speed and record how far apart the particles are.

On this screen

  1. Move the speed slider slowly from one end to the other and watch both views.
  2. Record the spacing at least once in a solid, once in a liquid and once in a gas.
  3. Answer the questions.

Speed and spacing

Change rule 1

The model loads here.

Particles in a solid are tightly packed and often arranged in a regular pattern, and they vibrate about fixed positions. In a liquid they are close together with no regular arrangement, and they move past each other. In a gas they are far apart with no regular arrangement, and they move on their own except when they collide (OpenStax).

Faster particles spread out

Slow particles stay touching their neighbours, so the spacing hardly changes between the solid and the liquid. When the particles move fast enough to break away from each other, the substance becomes a gas and the spacing grows a lot. Real gas particles are much further apart than the model’s: they are tiny compared with the distances between them (OpenStax).

How do the particles in a solid move?

In which state are the particles furthest apart?

The particles of a liquid move faster and faster. What happens in the end?

3Model 3

How strongly the particles attract

How does the attraction between particles help decide the state?

Rule 3 says particles attract the particles near them. Fluorine, chlorine, bromine and iodine are halogens. At room temperature fluorine and chlorine are gases, bromine is a liquid and iodine is a solid, and the attraction between their particles gets stronger in that order (OpenStax). Keep the speed at the model’s room temperature and change only the attraction.

On this screen

  1. Make a gas, a liquid and a solid by changing only the attraction. Give each change time to happen.
  2. Try the four halogen buttons and compare them with the table.
  3. Answer the questions.

Attraction and state

Change rule 3

The model loads here.

Chemists use a substance’s melting point and boiling point as signs of how strongly its particles attract each other (OpenStax). Bromine boils at 59 °C and chlorine at −35 °C (OpenStax), so bromine’s particles attract each other more strongly than chlorine’s.

Speed against attraction

The state of a substance depends on how strongly its particles attract each other compared with how much energy of motion they have. The energy of motion is what lets particles overcome the attraction (OpenStax). At the same temperature, weak attraction gives a gas, and strong attraction gives a solid.

Which halogen’s particles attract each other most strongly?

Substance A boils at 59 °C and substance B boils at −35 °C. Which has the stronger attraction between its particles?

Why is chlorine a gas at room temperature?

4Model 4

Heating and cooling

What happens to the particles when a substance is heated or cooled?

When a solid is heated, its particles gain energy and it gets hotter (OpenStax). A solid melts at its melting point, and a liquid boils at its boiling point. Water melts at 0 °C and, at normal air pressure, boils at 100 °C (OpenStax). Heat the model from a solid until it is a gas, and watch the temperature and where the heat energy goes.

On this screen

  1. Press Heat and keep heating until the solid has melted and the liquid has become a gas.
  2. Watch the chart and the two energy bars while each change happens.
  3. Press Cool and watch the gas turn back into a liquid. Then answer the questions.

Heating and cooling

Add or remove energy

The model loads here.

On a heating curve of a real substance, the temperature stays the same while it melts and while it boils, which makes flat parts on the curve (OpenStax). While it changes state, the heat goes into overcoming the attraction between the particles instead of making them move faster (OpenStax). When a gas is cooled enough, the attraction between its particles can hold them together, and it turns into a liquid (OpenStax). This change is called condensation. A liquid freezes at the same temperature as its solid melts, so a melting point is also a freezing point (OpenStax).

Where the heat goes

Heat can make particles move faster, which raises the temperature, or it can pull particles apart against their attraction. When enough heat has gone into pulling them apart, the state changes. In the model, more of the heat goes into pulling particles apart while the substance is a liquid, so the temperature rises more slowly then than while it is a solid. In a real substance, the temperature stays the same while it melts and while it boils (OpenStax).

When a solid is heated, what happens to its particles?

While water boils at normal air pressure, its temperature stays at 100 °C even though it is still being heated. Where does the heat go?

What is the change from a gas to a liquid called?

5Model 5

Shape, flow and squeezing

How do particles explain the shape, flow and squashing of solids, liquids and gases?

A solid keeps its own shape. A liquid flows and takes the shape of its container, with a flat or slightly curved top. A gas takes the shape and the volume of its container (OpenStax). Pushing in a syringe squashes the gas inside into a smaller space (OpenStax), but solids and liquids hardly change their volume when you push on them (OpenStax). Tilt the box and push on the piston for each state.

On this screen

  1. For each state, tilt the box well over, then push hard on the piston, and watch the space the substance takes up.
  2. Sort the statements into solid, liquid and gas.
  3. Answer the questions.

Tilt and squeeze

Three states

The model loads here.

Solid, liquid or gas?

Sort the statements

The statements load here.

Density is the mass of a sample divided by its volume (OpenStax). Water has a density of 1.0 grams per cubic centimetre and dry air 1.20 grams per litre (OpenStax). A litre is 1000 cubic centimetres, so the density of air is 0.0012 grams per cubic centimetre. A gas has a low density because its particles are far apart.

Space and movement explain the properties

A solid keeps its shape because its particles stay in their places. A liquid flows because its particles can slide past each other, and it keeps its volume because they stay close together. A gas fills its container because its particles move freely, and it can be squashed because there is space between them.

Why can you squash a gas into a smaller space but hardly squash a liquid?

times

Why can a liquid flow but a solid can’t?

6Model 6

Why a heated gas expands

How does the volume of a balloon change as it is heated and cooled?

When a gas is heated and the push on it stays the same, its volume increases, and when it is cooled its volume decreases (OpenStax). A balloon put in a fridge shrinks, and it expands again as it warms up (OpenStax). In the model, the gas is trapped under a piston that slides up and down. The weight of the piston keeps the push on the gas the same, so the gas can expand and shrink as the gas in a balloon does.

On this screen

  1. Heat the gas all the way and wait for the piston to settle, then cool it all the way and wait again.
  2. Watch the particles: how fast they move, how hard they hit the piston, and their size.
  3. Answer the questions.

A gas under a piston

Heat and cool

The model loads here.

Thermal expansion is the change in size or volume of something when its temperature changes (OpenStax). Solids and liquids expand too. Railway tracks and bridges have expansion joints, and the liquid in a thermometer expands as it warms (OpenStax). In a heated solid, the particles vibrate more and push their neighbours further apart (OpenStax). Some students think the particles themselves get bigger when they are heated (Kind), but in particle theory they stay the same size and move further apart.

Faster, not bigger

When the gas is heated, its particles move faster and hit the piston harder, so the piston rises. Once it has risen, the particles have further to travel, so they hit the piston less often, but each hit is harder, and their push balances the weight of the piston again (OpenStax). The gas takes up more space, but every particle is the same size as before.

Why does the gas take up more space when it is heated?

A student says that a heated gas expands because its particles get bigger. What does particle theory say?

Why do railway tracks have small gaps between lengths of rail?

7Model 7

Spreading out

How do particles spread through a liquid and a gas?

The smell of a hot pizza spreads through a room, and a drop of food colouring placed carefully in still water slowly spreads through it (OpenStax). Spreading like this is called diffusion. In the model, the dye particles follow the same rules as all the other particles. They are coloured pink only so you can follow them.

On this screen

  1. Add a drop of dye to the liquid and wait until its line reaches the right-hand edge of the chart. Then do the same in the gas.
  2. Run the liquid cold and then hot, and compare the lines on the chart.
  3. Answer the questions.

A drop of dye

Liquid and gas, cold and hot

The model loads here.

Diffusion is the movement of a substance caused by the random motion of its particles (OpenStax). Nothing pushes the particles in one direction: they move at random, and over time they spread out from where there are many of them to where there are few (OpenStax). Diffusion is faster at higher temperatures (OpenStax). When a drop of food colouring is put into hot water and another into cold water, the drop in the hot water spreads much faster (University of Iowa).

Scientists describe how fast a substance diffuses with a number called its diffusion constant. For oxygen at 20 °C, it is 1.8 × 10−5 square metres per second in air and 1.0 × 10−9 square metres per second in water (OpenStax). That makes it 18,000 times bigger in air than in water.

Random motion spreads particles out

Each dye particle moves at random and keeps colliding with the particles around it, so the dye slowly spreads through the whole box. When it is hot, the particles move faster and the dye spreads faster (OpenStax). In a gas, the particles are far apart, so a particle travels further before it hits another one, and the dye spreads much faster than in a liquid.

What makes the dye spread through the liquid?

A drop of food colouring is put into a glass of hot water and another into a glass of cold water. What happens?

Why does dye spread faster through a gas than through a liquid?

8Model 8

Explain it with particles

How does particle theory explain the properties of substances?

On this screen you change two rules at once, speed and attraction, to make each state in turn. Then you match everyday observations with the part of particle theory that explains them.

On this screen

  1. Do the three challenges with the speed and attraction sliders, in order.
  2. Sort each observation under the idea that explains it.
  3. Answer the questions, then look at your results for the whole lesson.

Three challenges

Rules 1 and 3 together

The model loads here.

Which idea explains it?

Everyday observations

The observations load here.

The whole theory in three rules

Every substance is made of particles that are always moving, that push away from a particle that comes too close, and that attract the particles near them. Faster particles break away from each other more easily, stronger attraction holds them together, and the push stops a solid or a liquid being squashed. With the space between the particles of a gas, these rules explain the states of a substance, its shape, flow, squashing and density, why it expands when heated and how it diffuses.

Which statement is part of particle theory?

Nothing in the model’s rules says “be a liquid”. Where does the liquid come from?

Why does a gas turn into a liquid when it is cooled enough?

Printable activity

Particles: draw the particles and watch diffusion

Two pages: boxes to draw the particles in a solid, a liquid and a gas, and before and after heating and squeezing, and a practical to time food colouring spreading through cold and hot water, with a results table and questions.

For teachers

Curriculum

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 7, Science understanding, Chemical sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:

AC9S7U05 use particle theory to describe the arrangement of particles in a substance, including the motion of and attraction between particles, and relate this to the properties of the substance

  • using and constructing models, diagrams or virtual simulations to represent changes in particle arrangement as substances change state
  • relating motion and energy of particles to distances between particles of the same substance in different states
  • comparing attractive forces in the solid, liquid and gaseous states of the same substance and relating this to relative position and movement of particles
  • examining how the changing motion and energy of particles is affected by the amount of heat energy absorbed or released
  • comparing the properties of different states of matter and explaining differences using particle theory
  • investigating properties of materials such as density, melting point and compressibility and explaining these in terms of particle arrangement
  • explaining the process of diffusion in a liquid and a gas in terms of particles

The second quote gives ACARA’s seven elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each part of the content description is covered on these screens:

  • Use particle theory to describe the arrangement of particles in a substance: screen 1 (the same particles as a solid, a liquid and a gas), screen 2 (the distance between particles in each state) and screen 5 (the sort of statements about each state); q-made, q-level, q-spacing, q-flow.
  • Including the motion of particles: screens 1 and 2 (the speed rule) and screen 4 (heating and cooling); q-vibrate, q-faster, q-heatup.
  • And the attraction between particles: screen 1 (switching the attraction rule off), screen 3 (the attraction rule and the halogens) and screen 8 (speed and attraction together); q-rules, q-strong, q-mp, q-room, q-explain.
  • Relate this to the properties of the substance: screen 3 (melting and boiling points), screen 4 (changes of state), screen 5 (shape, flow, compressibility and density), screen 6 (expansion), screen 7 (diffusion) and screen 8 (everyday observations); q-plateau, q-condense, q-squash, n-dense, q-expand, q-size, q-rail, q-diffusion, q-hot, q-gasliq, q-theory, q-model.
  • The elaborations: virtual simulations of changes of state on screens 1, 3, 4 and 8; motion, energy and distance between particles on screen 2; attractive forces in each state of the same substance on screen 1 (the attraction switch at each speed) and screen 4 (the energy bars while one substance is heated through its states); heat absorbed or released on screen 4; the properties of the states on screen 5; density, melting point and compressibility on screens 3 and 5; diffusion in a liquid and a gas on screen 7.

The lesson also works on these content descriptions. The lesson’s title is the question that ACARA gives as an example of an investigable question to explore scientific models, and screen 6 answers ACARA’s example question about a balloon that is heated and cooled (AC9S7I01). Students record the distance between particles in a table on screen 2, and the printable practical has them time food colouring spreading with a stopwatch (AC9S7I03). Students construct representations: the table and chart of their spacing records on screen 2, and the particle drawings and results table on the printable sheet (AC9S7I04). They read the patterns in the spacing, heating and diffusion charts, and q-spacing and q-gasliq ask about two of them (AC9S7I05).

AC9S7I01 develop investigable questions, reasoned predictions and hypotheses to explore scientific models, identify patterns and test relationships

AC9S7I03 select and use equipment to generate and record data with precision, using digital tools as appropriate

AC9S7I04 select and construct appropriate representations, including tables, graphs, models and mathematical relationships, to organise and process data and information

AC9S7I05 analyse data and information to describe patterns, trends and relationships and identify anomalies

How the lesson is taught

The lesson uses agent-based modelling. Each model is a box of particles, and every particle follows the same three rules: keep moving, push away from a particle that comes too close, and attract the particles nearby. Students change a rule, such as how fast the particles move or how strongly they attract, and watch what the whole substance does. Each model shows two levels side by side: the substance as you would see it, and its particles, magnified. Nothing in the rules says “be a solid” or “be a gas”. The states come from what all the particles do together.

Wilensky and Resnick (1999) write about emergent levels, “levels that arise from interactions of objects at lower levels”, and “argue for an expanded role for this concept of ‘levels’ in science education”. They see “confusion of levels (and ‘slippage’ between levels)” as “the source of many of people’s deep misunderstandings about patterns and phenomena in the world”, and they describe a teacher, Harry, who built a gas model and was excited that “the laws of the gas should emerge, automatically, from the simple rules he had written for the particles”. The models in this lesson are built the same way. On screen 6, students can see that the particles of a gas don’t get bigger when the gas expands. Saying that they do mixes up the levels.

Levy and Wilensky (2009) report on Connected Chemistry (CC1), “a computer-based environment for learning the topics of gas laws and kinetic molecular theory in chemistry”, built on NetLogo agent-based models. “In CC1, students explore prepared models.” With 904 students in 12 US high schools, mostly in grades 10 and 11, who did the seven activities, usually on consecutive school days, scores on a content questionnaire rose from 56% to 66% (d = 0.55). Scores on questions at the particle level rose from 45% to 60% (d = 0.51), and on questions linking the particles to what can be observed from 56% to 65% (d = 0.42). The authors note that there was no control group and no long-term follow-up, so the study shows what students learned with the models, not that the models worked better than another way of teaching. Those students were older than Year 7 and studied gases, so this lesson changes one or two rules at a time, says in words under each model what the particles are doing, and asks questions after each model.

The models work best with talk. Before students change a rule, ask them to predict what the substance will do and what its particles will do. Afterwards, ask them to describe what happened at both levels. Plan for about two lessons of 50 to 60 minutes: screens 1 to 4, then screens 5 to 8. The food colouring practical on the printable sheet needs about 20 minutes more.

Handle with care

  • Kind’s review of students’ ideas reports that “Students ascribe macroscopic properties to particles.” Some 16-year-olds think “that particles expand when they are heated”, and a small study that Kind reports (Griffiths and Preston, 1992) found that “about 50% of 18-year olds think water molecules in steam are larger than those in ice”. The models draw particles the same size at every temperature, screen 6 shows the size of one particle beside the gas, and q-made, q-size, q-gasliq, q-theory and q-explain have wrong answers built on these ideas.
  • Kind also writes that “Students of all ages find space difficult to imagine and intuitively ‘fill’ it with something.” One wrong answer in q-theory says there is air between the particles of a gas.
  • Kind reports a study in which about 20% of students aged 16 and over thought that “repulsive forces between the particles” stop gas particles falling to the bottom of a flask, and notes that “The attractive and repulsive force ideas imply static particles, confirming that particle movement in a gas is difficult to grasp.” In the models the particles never stop moving, and the particles of the solid vibrate in place, so students see the forces and the motion together.
  • Water is the most important exception to the rule that things expand when they are heated: between 4 °C and 0 °C it expands as it cools (OpenStax College Physics 2e, 13.2). Ice, at 0.92 g/cm³, is less dense than liquid water, at 1.0 g/cm³ (OpenStax Chemistry 2e, Table 1.4). Avoid using ice and water as an example of a solid that is denser than its liquid.
  • A real substance keeps the same temperature while it melts and while it boils, which gives the flat parts of a heating curve (OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 10.3). The model’s heating curve has no flat parts. Screen 4 says so, and its energy bars show where the heat goes.
  • In the model, particles leave the liquid gradually over a range of temperatures, so the change from a liquid to a gas is spread out instead of happening at one boiling point. The model is a closed box, and as a liquid gets hotter the pressure of its vapour rises (OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 10.3), so a closed box has no single boiling point.
  • Diffusion in a liquid is slow. OpenStax College Physics 2e (12.7) says that a drop of food colouring placed very carefully in a still glass of water “will slowly diffuse”, and works out that a glucose molecule takes about 21 hours to move 1 cm in water. Over the few minutes of the practical, much of the spreading students see comes from the drop sinking and from the water moving. Diffusion is still faster in hot water, because the particles move faster (12.7). Let the water stand for a few minutes before the drops go in, and accept moving water as part of the answer to question 2 on the sheet.
  • Hot water systems store water above 60 °C, and “At 68°C, it can take as little as one second to cause a full thickness scald” (Victorian Building Authority). A tempering valve lowers the temperature in a bathroom but not in a kitchen. The sheet asks the teacher to hand out the hot water, no hotter than about 50 °C.
  • The model is flat, its particles are round, and it has far fewer particles than any real sample. Its speeds and temperatures are in the model’s own units, so no screen gives the model’s temperature in degrees.
  • The halogen settings on screen 3 are chosen to give each halogen its state at room temperature. They are not measured attractions, and the model doesn’t calculate melting or boiling points.

About the models

  • All screens: the force between two particles comes from the Lennard-Jones formula. They are pushed apart when they are closer than about 1.1 particle widths, and pulled together out to 2.5 widths, with the pull scaled by the attraction setting from 0 (rule 3 off) to 2.6. The model moves the particles in small steps of time. On most screens a thermostat brings the particles’ average energy of motion towards the speed setting, which is the model’s temperature. Gravity pulls every particle down a little, so a liquid settles at the bottom. Most models have 90 particles in a box 26 particle widths wide and 32 high.
  • How the model names the state: it counts the particles that have at least two neighbours within 1.5 particle widths. If fewer than 40% do, the substance is a gas. Otherwise the model compares the pairs of touching neighbours (closer than 1.4 widths) with the pairs about two time units earlier. If more than 90% are still neighbours, the particles are keeping their places and the substance is a solid; if not, it is a liquid. The words under the model change to a new state only once the model has named it at six readings in a row, so they don’t flicker while a substance is part way through a change. While the model can’t tell, they say the substance is changing state.
  • Screen 1: the three speeds set the model’s temperature to 0.12, 0.42 and 1.1, which give a solid, a liquid and a gas with the attraction on. Screen 2: for each particle, the model measures the average distance to its three nearest neighbours, and the screen gives the middle value of these for all the particles (the median), so a few particles that break away from a liquid hardly change it.
  • Screen 3: the speed stays at 0.5, the model’s room temperature. The halogen buttons set the attraction to 0.2 (fluorine), 0.45 (chlorine), 1.2 (bromine) and 2.4 (iodine). A gas can take a while to condense and a liquid a while to freeze, so the screen asks students to give each change time.
  • Screen 4: heat is added or taken away at a steady rate shared by all the particles, and the thermostat is off. The temperature line is smoothed a little. The first energy bar shows the particles’ average energy of motion, and the second shows the energy that has gone into pulling particles apart since the start. In eight test runs, about 60% to 80% of the heat went into pulling particles apart while the substance was a liquid, against about 40% to 60% while it was a solid, so the temperature rose more slowly while it was a liquid.
  • Screen 5: tilting the box turns the direction of gravity by up to 25°. Gravity is made stronger for the solid and the liquid (0.15) than on the other screens (0.04), so that the liquid settles into a pool while students watch; a gas with that gravity would crowd into the bottom of the box. The liquid is at a temperature of 0.44. The piston’s push goes from 0 to 8 in the model’s units, and with no push the piston is lifted back to the top. For a gas, the space it takes up is the space below the piston. For a solid or a liquid, each particle is given the space of a hexagon set by the average distance to its three nearest neighbours, and the spaces are added up, leaving out particles that have broken away. Both are in squares one particle width across.
  • Screen 6: 40 particles with the attraction at 0.2, under a piston of fixed weight, at temperatures from 0.5 to 1.5. A volume counts once the temperature has stayed the same for a moment, and the screen is complete when the hot volume is at least 25% bigger than the cool one.
  • Screen 7: the drop of dye is the particles in the left fifth of the box when the button is pressed. The chart shows how mixed the particles are: 1 minus the correlation between where each particle was across the box when the dye went in and where it is now. So 0 means every particle is still where it started, and 1 means the particles are completely mixed up. It uses every particle, not only the dye, because a line from the dye’s few particles jumps about too much to read. The liquid has 100 particles with the attraction at 1, at temperatures of 0.42 (cold) and 0.7 (hot). The gas is a different substance, 34 particles with the attraction at 0.3, at 0.5 (cold) and 1.4 (hot), so that it stays a gas when cold. Each run lasts 60 time units, and the screen is complete when the liquid has been run cold and hot and the gas has been run once. The model’s gas is packed far more closely than a real gas, so the difference between the gas and the liquid is far smaller than in real life.
  • Screen 8: a challenge counts once the model has named the state it asks for at eight readings in a row, taken a quarter of a unit of model time apart. The second challenge counts only if the speed hasn’t changed since the liquid was made, and the third needs a speed of 0.6 or more.
  • With reduced motion, the models don’t move on their own. Each change runs the model on for a moment and shows the result, and the Run on button runs it further. Short tails behind the magnified particles show how fast they are moving.

Where sources disagree and what to check

  • OpenStax gives the halogens’ melting and boiling points in kelvin (Chemistry 2e, Table 10.1). The lesson converts them to degrees Celsius by subtracting 273 and rounding to the nearest degree, so chlorine’s 172 K and 238 K become −101 °C and −35 °C.
  • Data tables round differently. OpenStax gives chlorine’s boiling point as 238 K, which is −35 °C; Jefferson Lab gives 239.11 K (−34.04 °C). Table 1.4 lists dry air at 1.20 g/L among gases at 25 °C and 1 atm, and air’s density changes with temperature and pressure, so other sources give slightly different figures. The figure of about 830 times uses OpenStax’s values. The diffusion constants in College Physics 2e, Table 12.2 are for 20 °C and 1 atm.
  • Kind’s chapter on the Royal Society of Chemistry website gives no year, so the reference has none.

Answers at a glance

  • Screen 1: q-made the particles are the same, but they move and are arranged differently; q-level how each particle moves; q-rules the particles spread out to fill the box.
  • Screen 2: q-vibrate they vibrate about fixed positions; q-spacing gas; q-faster they break away from each other and the liquid becomes a gas. On the chart, the typical distance between particles is about the same in the solid and the liquid and much larger in the gas.
  • Screen 3: fluorine and chlorine give a gas, bromine a liquid and iodine a solid. q-strong iodine; q-mp substance A; q-room the attraction between its particles is too weak to hold them together at that temperature.
  • Screen 4: q-heatup they vibrate faster; q-plateau into pulling the particles apart against their attraction; q-condense condensation.
  • Screen 5: the sort puts keeps its own shape and vibrate about fixed positions under solid; flows with a flat top and move past each other but stay close together under liquid; volume hardly changes under solid or liquid; and fills its container, can be pushed into a much smaller space and move on their own, far apart under gas. q-squash a gas’s particles are far apart, but a liquid’s are already close together; n-dense 1.0 ÷ 0.0012 ≈ 830 times; q-flow a liquid’s particles can move past each other, but a solid’s stay in fixed positions.
  • Screen 6: q-expand its particles move faster and hit the piston harder; q-size the particles stay the same size and move faster and further apart; q-rail on hot days the rails expand, and the gaps leave room for them.
  • Screen 7: q-diffusion its particles move at random and collide with the particles around them; q-hot it spreads much faster in the hot water; q-gasliq in a gas the particles are far apart, so a particle travels further before it hits another.
  • Screen 8: the challenges need a liquid (for example a medium speed with attraction 1), then a gas made by lowering the attraction, then a solid at a high speed made by turning the attraction up near its top. The sort puts the balloon and the railway gaps under heated particles move faster; the pizza smell under particles move at random; the syringe and the density of air under the space between gas particles; iodine and chlorine, and water drops, under particles attract each other; and the food colouring under heated particles move faster or particles move at random. q-theory particles are always moving, and they attract the particles near them; q-model from all the particles following the same simple rules together; q-explain its particles slow down until the attraction between them can hold them together.
  • Printable sheet: in the drawings, the solid’s particles are packed tightly in a regular pattern, the liquid’s are close together with no pattern, and the gas’s are far apart; heated and squeezed particles stay the same size. In the practical, the food colouring spreads much faster in the hot water. For question 2, credit both faster-moving particles and moving water carrying the colour. The same size, amount and drop make it a fair test, so only the temperature differs (question 3), and stirring or bumping would move the water and carry the colour with it (question 4).

Saved progress

Choices, answers, records and settings are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere.

References

Sources by screen

  • Method: Wilensky and Resnick (1999); Levy and Wilensky (2009).
  • Screen 1: ACARA (particle theory); Wilensky and Resnick (1999, levels); OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 10.1 (particles in each state).
  • Screen 2: OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 9.5 (energy of motion and temperature) and 10.1 (arrangement and motion in each state); OpenStax College Physics 2e, 13.2 (temperature and the energy of motion of atoms).
  • Screen 3: OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 10.1 (the halogens, Table 10.1, and melting and boiling points as signs of the strength of attraction); Jefferson Lab (chlorine’s boiling point, in “Where sources disagree”).
  • Screen 4: OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 10.1 (condensation) and 10.3 (heating a solid, melting and freezing points, where the heat goes during a change of state, plateaus, condensation, and water at 0 °C and 100 °C).
  • Screen 5: OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 1.2 (shape and volume of each state), 1.4 (density and Table 1.4), 9.2 (the syringe), 9.5 (gas particles compared with the distances between them) and 10.1.
  • Screen 6: OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 9.2 (Charles’s law and the balloon) and 9.5 (pressure from collisions, and fewer but harder collisions when a heated gas expands); OpenStax College Physics 2e, 13.2 (thermal expansion, expansion joints and thermometers); Kind (n.d.).
  • Screen 7: OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 9.4 (diffusion and the pizza); OpenStax College Physics 2e, 12.7 (diffusion, food colouring in still water, temperature, Table 12.2 and Example 12.11); University of Iowa (food colouring in hot and cold water).
  • Printable sheet: University of Iowa (the practical); Victorian Building Authority (hot water).
  • Screen 8: Wilensky and Resnick (1999); OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 10.1 (condensation); and the sources for screens 1 to 7, which the sort’s feedback names.
  • Handle with care: Kind (n.d.); OpenStax Chemistry 2e, Table 1.4 and 10.3; OpenStax College Physics 2e, 12.7 and 13.2; Victorian Building Authority.
  • Word list: the sources for the screen where each word is first used.

Word list