Year 9 science · Chemical sciences · AC9S9U06
What’s inside an atom?
1Black Box 1
What’s in the box?
How can you work out what is inside something you can’t open?
Nobody has looked inside an atom and seen its parts. Everything in this lesson about what atoms are made of was worked out from experiments, by doing something to atoms and watching what came out. Anything whose inside you can’t see is called a black box. On each screen you will work on a black box of your own, then think about how scientists work out what they can’t see.
On this screen
- Fire balls into each box and watch where they come out.
- Choose the shape that explains your shots, then open Box 1 and Box 2 to check.
- Decide what is inside Box 3, which never opens.
Each box has a shape fixed inside it. A ball fired into a box rolls in a straight line until it hits the shape, then bounces off it the way a ball bounces off a wall. You can see where each ball goes in and where it comes out, but the lid hides everything in between.
Three sealed boxes
Black boxThe boxes load here.
An observation is something you notice with your senses or measure with an instrument. An inference is an idea about something you can’t observe directly, which you work out from observations (Khishfe and Abd-El-Khalick). In the boxes, a good inference fits all of your shots, and it can change when a new shot doesn’t fit.
Observation or inference?
Sort four statementsThe cards load here.
How science works: observation and inference
Where a ball goes in and where it comes out are observations. The shape inside is an inference. The more shots you fire, the more observations your inference has to fit, but you can never be sure about Box 3, because you can’t open it. Scientists are in the same position with atoms. They infer what is inside an atom from experiments, and two people can infer different things from the same observations until a new observation rules one of them out.
Which of these is an observation?
Why is what scientists know about the inside of an atom an inference?
Two students fire the same shots into Box 3. One thinks it holds one small disc and the other thinks it holds two. What should they do?
2Black box 2
Rays in a tube
What are cathode rays made of?
When a voltage is put across two electrodes in a glass tube with most of the gas pumped out, streams of bright lines come from the negative electrode, the cathode. These are cathode rays, and where they hit the far end of the tube they make a glowing patch. In the 1890s most German physicists thought cathode rays were a kind of radiation, while most British physicists thought they were streams of particles with a negative charge. In 1897 J. J. Thomson ran a series of experiments in Cambridge that showed the British physicists were right (Cavendish Laboratory).
On this screen
- Switch the tube on and find the glowing spot.
- Turn the plates and the magnet on each way, and change the cathode metal.
- Use the slider to find a particle that lands exactly on the spot.
A cathode ray tube
Black boxThe tube loads here.
Thomson showed that the rays are bent by an electric field, which earlier experiments had failed to show, and he measured how far electric and magnetic fields bent them (Cavendish Laboratory). The beam bent towards the positive plate and away from the negative one, and it was the same whatever metal the electrodes were made of. His measurements showed that the particles were much lighter than atoms, so he concluded that they must be parts of all atoms (OpenStax). Thomson called them corpuscles. They are now called electrons.
Observation or inference?
Sort four statementsThe cards load here.
Thomson’s plum pudding model
Atoms have no overall charge, so if they hold negative electrons they must hold positive charge as well. In 1904 Thomson proposed a model of the atom made of positive charge with electrons dotted through it, carrying an equal amount of negative charge (OpenStax). It became known as the plum pudding model.
How science works: evidence you can’t see
Thomson never saw a single particle. He worked from measurements of the rays, such as where the glowing spot landed when he pushed on them with charged plates and a magnet. His conclusions were inferences from many careful observations. Before his experiments, German and British physicists had looked at the same rays and inferred different things about them.
When the top plate is positive, the spot moves up. What does this tell you about the particles in the rays?
Thomson got the same rays whatever metal the cathode was made of. What did he infer?
Thomson’s measurements showed that the particles had far more charge for their mass than a hydrogen ion. If their charge is the same size as a hydrogen ion’s, what does that mean?
What was Thomson’s 1904 model of the atom like?
3Black box 3
The gold foil experiment
What happens when alpha particles are fired at thin metal?
In 1909 Hans Geiger and Ernest Marsden, at the University of Manchester, aimed alpha particles from a radioactive source at metal. Each alpha particle that reached a zinc sulphide screen made a tiny flash, and they counted the flashes through a microscope. With a thick platinum plate, about 1 in 8000 of the alpha particles came back off the metal towards the side they came from (Geiger and Marsden; Rutherford). They tried gold, silver, aluminium and other metals too, and fewer came back from the lighter metals (Geiger and Marsden). They also found that gold foil only 0.00004 cm thick turned about 1 in 20,000 of the alpha particles through about 90° (Rutherford).
On this screen
- Choose Thomson’s model and fire alpha particles at the gold foil.
- Compare the counts at each angle with what the model predicts.
- Switch to the nuclear model and compare again.
In Thomson’s model the positive charge is spread through the whole atom. Alpha particles fired through atoms like that would be turned aside only slightly (OpenStax College Physics). The nuclear model puts all of the positive charge in a tiny centre, which can push an alpha particle that comes close to it through a large angle.
Alpha particles and metal foil
Black boxThe experiment loads here.
The nuclear model
Most of the alpha particles passed straight through thin foil, so most of an atom must be empty space. A few were turned through large angles and a very few came almost straight back, so each atom must have a small, heavy, positively charged centre, the nucleus (OpenStax). Rutherford published this nuclear model in May 1911 (ChemTeam). The nucleus is about 100,000 times smaller across than the atom (OpenStax). If a nucleus were 1 cm across, its atom would be about 1 km across.
How science works: models can change
Scientists stopped using Thomson’s model because it couldn’t explain the alpha particles that came back, and Rutherford’s model could. Science educators describe scientific knowledge as tentative, meaning it is subject to change when new evidence comes in (Khishfe and Abd-El-Khalick).
Most of the alpha particles went straight through the gold foil. What does this tell you?
About 1 in 8000 alpha particles came back off a thick platinum plate. What did Rutherford infer?
Why did scientists stop using Thomson’s plum pudding model?
4Black box 4
The missing particle
What else is inside the nucleus?
In 1919 Ernest Rutherford reported that when alpha particles hit nitrogen, the nitrogen nuclei gave out what he suspected were hydrogen nuclei. He later named this particle the proton (US Department of Energy). A proton has a positive charge and is found in the nucleus of every atom (OpenStax).
On this screen
- Watch what came out of nitrogen when alpha particles hit it.
- Run Chadwick’s experiment with paraffin wax and with nitrogen gas.
- Test two ideas about the mystery radiation against the measurements.
Alpha particles and nitrogen
AnimationThe animation loads here.
There was still a puzzle. Chemists had found that many elements existed at different weights while behaving the same way in chemistry (US Department of Energy). Something in the nucleus was adding mass without changing the element.
In 1932 James Chadwick had a black box of his own. Alpha particles from polonium hitting beryllium gave off a radiation that could pass through lead (Chadwick). Nobody could see it or knew what it was. When it hit paraffin wax, which contains a lot of hydrogen, it knocked out hydrogen nuclei at up to 33,000 km/s. When it hit nitrogen gas, it set nitrogen nuclei moving at up to 4,700 km/s (Chadwick).
Chadwick’s experiment
Black boxThe experiment loads here.
The neutron
Chadwick showed that gamma rays could explain both speeds only if energy and momentum were not conserved in the collisions. A particle with no charge and about the same mass as a proton could explain them, and he called it the neutron (Chadwick). His first estimate of its mass was 1.15 times a hydrogen nucleus, and he warned that the speed of the nitrogen nuclei could be out by about 10%. A better method gave between 1.005 and 1.008 atomic mass units, very nearly the mass of a hydrogen atom (Chadwick). Chadwick’s discovery explained the different weights: atoms of the same element can have different numbers of neutrons (US Department of Energy).
How science works: imagination and testing
Chadwick couldn’t see a neutron. He imagined a particle that nobody had found, worked out what it would do to hydrogen and nitrogen nuclei, and checked those predictions against the measurements. He published his results in 1932, and other scientists could then check his reasoning.
What did Rutherford find in 1919?
Why did Chadwick decide the radiation wasn’t gamma rays?
Chadwick’s first estimate of the neutron’s mass was 1.15 times a hydrogen nucleus. A better method gave very nearly the mass of a hydrogen atom. What does this show?
5Black box 5
Build an atom
What decides which element an atom is, and whether its nucleus is stable?
By 1932 the model of the atom had three particles. Protons and neutrons make up the nucleus, and electrons are outside it. A proton and a neutron have almost the same mass, and an electron has far less (OpenStax). Nearly all of an atom’s mass is in its nucleus (OpenStax College Physics).
On this screen
- Add and remove protons, neutrons and electrons, and watch the readout.
- Use the chart to find stable and unstable nuclei.
- Build the three mystery atoms from their measurements.
The number of protons in an atom’s nucleus is its atomic number, and it decides which element the atom is. The number of protons plus the number of neutrons is the mass number (OpenStax). Atoms of the same element with different numbers of neutrons are isotopes. They have different masses but behave the same way in chemistry, because they have the same number of protons (OpenStax). An atom with more or fewer electrons than protons has an overall charge and is called an ion.
Build an atom
Black boxThe atom builder loads here.
Some isotopes are unstable
Carbon has three isotopes found in nature: carbon-12, carbon-13 and carbon-14. Carbon-14 is unstable: half of the carbon-14 nuclei in any sample decay in 5,730 years (ACARA). An unstable nucleus is radioactive. It changes into another nucleus by giving off radiation. On a chart of protons against neutrons, the stable nuclei lie in a band, and nuclei on either side of the band are unstable (OpenStax).
How science works: models are not pictures
The atom you built is a model, not a picture. A real nucleus is about 100,000 times smaller across than its atom (OpenStax), so in a drawing to scale the nucleus would be a dot far too small to see. The model is useful because it explains the measurements: the masses, the charges and which nuclei are stable.
Where is nearly all of an atom’s mass?
Carbon-12 and carbon-14 are isotopes. What is different about them?
An atom has 3 protons, 4 neutrons and 2 electrons. What is it?
6Black box 6
What comes out?
What do unstable nuclei give off, and when do they stop?
An unstable nucleus changes into another nucleus by giving off radiation. This is radioactive decay. The three main kinds of radiation are alpha particles, which are helium nuclei, beta particles, which are fast electrons from the nucleus, and gamma rays (OpenStax). None of them can be seen. You can only count them with a detector and find out what stops them.
On this screen
- Pick a source and count it with nothing, paper, a thin metal sheet and thick lead in front of the detector.
- Count it again with the charged plates on.
- Decide what each source gives off and check your inferences, then follow the decay chains.
A sheet or two of paper, or the top layer of skin, usually stops alpha particles. Beta particles pass through paper but are stopped by a thin layer of metal. Gamma rays pass through a thick layer of most materials, and dense metals such as lead cut them down (OpenStax). Charged plates pull alpha particles a little towards the negative plate and beta particles a lot towards the positive plate. Gamma rays go straight on, because they have no charge (OpenStax).
Three sealed sources
Black boxThe sources load here.
Observation or inference?
Sort four statementsThe cards load here.
Each decay changes the nucleus. In alpha decay the nucleus loses 2 protons and 2 neutrons, so its atomic number goes down by 2 and its mass number by 4. In beta decay a neutron turns into a proton and a beta particle, so the atomic number goes up by 1 and the mass number stays the same. Gamma rays carry away extra energy from a nucleus and change neither number (OpenStax). Decay goes on, one step at a time, until the nucleus is stable.
Decay chains
SimulationThe decay chains load here.
Radioactivity in medicine and industry
Cobalt-60 gives off gamma rays that are used to treat cancer, and to find flaws in metal used in structures (OpenStax). Iodine-131 collects in the thyroid gland (OpenStax; US EPA), and it is used to diagnose and treat cancers of the thyroid (CDC).
A source’s count drops to almost nothing when a sheet of paper is put in front of the detector. What does the source give off?
Radon-222 has 86 protons. It gives off an alpha particle. What is the new nucleus?
Iodine-131 gives off a beta particle and becomes xenon-131. What happened in its nucleus?
Why does the radon-222 decay chain stop at lead-206?
How is cobalt-60 used in industry?
7Black box 7
Half-life
Can you tell when an unstable nucleus will decay?
Radioactive decay is a matter of chance, like tossing coins. Each unstable nucleus has a 50% chance of lasting one half-life, and the chance is the same no matter when you start counting (OpenStax College Physics). The half-life is the time it takes for half of the atoms in a sample to decay, and each radioactive isotope has its own (OpenStax).
On this screen
- Tap one nucleus to follow it, then press Play.
- Watch how many nuclei are left after each half-life.
- Change the isotope and compare the time scales.
400 unstable nuclei
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
| Isotope | Half-life | Gives off |
|---|---|---|
| Radon-222 | 3.823 days | Alpha particles |
| Iodine-131 | 8.02 days | Beta particles and gamma rays |
| Cobalt-60 | 5.27 years | Beta particles and gamma rays |
| Carbon-14 | 5,730 years | Beta particles |
| Uranium-238 | 4.5 billion years | Alpha particles |
Half each half-life
Nobody can say when the nucleus you followed would decay. But with 400 nuclei, about half are left after one half-life, about a quarter after two and about an eighth after three. The more nuclei there are, the closer the count comes to exactly half each time, and a real sample holds far more than 400.
How science works: a pattern from many
In the simulation, the half-life comes from counting many decays over time, as in the chart, not from watching one nucleus. Because the pattern is so steady, the amount left can be used to work out how much time has passed. On the next screen you use it to date old samples.
You follow one nucleus in a sample of iodine-131. When will it decay?
Which of these would still be almost all there after a million years?
8Black box 8
Dating the past
How can you use carbon-14 to work out how long ago something died?
While a plant or animal is alive, it keeps taking in carbon, and a small share of that carbon is carbon-14. When it dies, it takes in no more, and its carbon-14 slowly decays to nitrogen-14 (ACARA). From the share of carbon-14 left in a sample, you can work out roughly how long ago it died. This is radiocarbon dating.
On this screen
- Pick a sample and drag the line to where the curve matches its carbon-14.
- Read off its age.
- Look at the dates for First Peoples in Australia, then at how the model of the atom changed.
Carbon-14 left over time
Black boxThe curve loads here.
Radiocarbon dates are reasonably accurate up to about 50,000 years. After about 10 half-lives, about 57,000 years, too little carbon-14 is left to measure (OpenStax). The share of carbon-14 in the air also hasn’t always been the same, and scientists use methods to allow for this (ACARA). Older layers need other methods. Luminescence dating estimates the last time grains of sediment were in sunlight or heated, and it can reach back several tens or hundreds of thousands of years (University of Wollongong).
More than 60,000 years in Australia
Dating methods show that First Peoples of Australia have been on the continent for more than 60,000 years (ACARA). At Lake Mungo in western New South Wales, the remains known as Mungo Lady and Mungo Man were found in 1969 and 1974. The first radiocarbon dating suggested Mungo Lady’s remains might be as old as 26,500 years. In 2003 a panel of experts using more refined dating methods agreed that the remains are probably about 40,000 years old (ACARA). At the Madjedbebe rock shelter in Arnhem Land, luminescence dating shows that people were there by about 65,000 years ago, and radiocarbon dating was used for the younger layers near the top (ACARA; Clarkson and others). The custodians of Madjedbebe are the Mirarr Senior Traditional Owners, and the research was done and published with their permission (Clarkson and others).
The Lake Mungo remains are ancestral remains. Interfering with them is a sensitive issue for the Ngiyampaa, Mutthi Mutthi and Paakantji peoples, who are descendants of Mungo Lady and Mungo Man and custodians of the remains. In many cases, Aboriginal peoples’ view, embodied in the Dreaming and Aboriginal Law, is that they have always lived in Australia (ACARA).
How science works: dates can change
The dates for Lake Mungo changed as the dating methods improved, from as old as 26,500 years to about 40,000 (ACARA), in the same way that the model of the atom changed between 1897 and 1932 as new evidence came in.
How the model of the atom changed
TimelineThe timeline loads here.
Your black-box notebook
What you inferredYour notebook loads here.
Why does the share of carbon-14 in a dead plant fall over time?
Why can’t radiocarbon dating on its own date layers about 65,000 years old?
The dates for the Lake Mungo remains changed from as old as 26,500 years to about 40,000 years. What does this show about science?
Atoms: a black-box practical and a half-life model
Three pages: a practical in which you roll marbles under a board to work out the shape hidden beneath it, a half-life model with coins and a graph to draw, and a decay chain from radon-222 to lead-206 to complete on a chart.
For teachers
Curriculum
Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 9, Science understanding, Chemical sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:
AC9S9U06 explain how the model of the atom changed following the discovery of electrons, protons and neutrons and describe how natural radioactive decay results in stable atoms
- comparing the mass and charge of protons, neutrons and electrons
- examining how the discovery of electrons, protons and neutrons resulted from experimental evidence and answered questions related to properties and behaviours of atoms
- explaining that differences in the number of neutrons in atoms of the same element results in isotopes and that naturally occurring isotopes of some elements are unstable
- describing in simple terms how different unstable isotopes decay such as radon-222 releasing an alpha particle, iodine-131 releasing a beta particle and cobalt-60 releasing gamma radiation to form stable atoms
- defining half-life, examining the timescales of decay of different elements such as carbon-14 and uranium-238 and simulating or using digital simulations to examine radioactive decay including half-life
- investigating how radiocarbon and other dating methods have been used to establish that First Peoples of Australia have been present on the Australian continent for more than 60,000 years
- identifying where applications of radioactivity are used in medicine and industry such as diagnosing and treating cancer and checking for faults in materials used in aircraft and spacecraft
The second quote gives seven of ACARA’s eight elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. The eighth, on how mass and energy are connected and energy conversion in nuclei, isn’t covered. Each part of the content description is covered on these screens:
- Explain how the model of the atom changed following the discovery of electrons, protons and neutrons: screen 2 (Thomson’s cathode rays and the plum pudding model), screen 3 (the gold foil experiment and the nuclear model), screen 4 (the proton and Chadwick’s neutron) and screen 5 (the three particles, isotopes and ions); q-negative, q-metals, q-light, q-pudding, q-straight, q-back, q-tentative, n-scale, q-proton, q-gamma, n-ratio, q-refine, q-mass, q-isotope, n-neutrons, q-ion.
- Describe how natural radioactive decay results in stable atoms: screen 5 (stable and unstable nuclei), screen 6 (alpha, beta and gamma radiation and three decay chains that end in stable nuclei), screen 7 (half-life) and screen 8 (radiocarbon dating); q-paper, q-alpha, q-beta, q-stable, q-flaw, q-which, n-left, n-iodine, q-uranium, q-ratio, n-age, q-limit, q-mungo.
- Screen 1 sets up the method with three sealed boxes; q-observe, q-infer, q-differ.
The lesson also works on these content descriptions. Thomson’s model is replaced when it can’t explain the alpha particles that come back, Chadwick’s estimate of the neutron’s mass is refined by a better method, the Lake Mungo dates are revised, and Chadwick publishes his results for others to check (AC9S9H01). Each discovery depends on equipment: the cathode ray tube, the zinc sulphide screen and the detectors (AC9S9H02). The alpha particles that come back off the foil are an anomaly that the old model can’t explain (AC9S9I05). In every black box, students test ideas against data and judge which explanation the evidence supports (AC9S9I06).
AC9S9H01 explain how scientific knowledge is validated and refined, including the role of publication and peer review
AC9S9H02 investigate how advances in technologies enable advances in science, and how science has contributed to developments in technologies and engineering
AC9S9I05 analyse and connect a variety of data and information to identify and explain patterns, trends, relationships and anomalies
AC9S9I06 assess the validity and reproducibility of methods and evaluate the validity of conclusions and claims, including by identifying assumptions, conflicting evidence and areas of uncertainty
How the lesson is taught
The lesson uses black-box activities with explicit reflection on the nature of science. On every screen students work on something they can’t see inside, from a sealed box to a radioactive sample, and infer what is there from what goes in and what comes out. After each black box, a key idea headed “How science works” names what the activity shows about science: that scientific knowledge is based on observation, that it involves inference and imagination, and that it can change. Screens 1, 2 and 6 also ask students to sort statements into observations and inferences.
Black boxes are a long-standing way to teach the nature of science. In Khishfe and Abd-El-Khalick’s study (2002), the first activity was about atomic structure: the teacher shot table tennis balls through a wire grid into a large box, and groups inferred the shape of an object fixed inside it from which balls passed through. The Understanding Science site’s mystery tubes lesson, and the cube activity in the National Academy of Sciences’ Teaching About Evolution and the Nature of Science, work the same way. Students can’t open the tube or turn the cube over.
The reflection is the part that matters most. Khishfe and Abd-El-Khalick (2002) taught two classes of sixth graders, 62 students in all, with the same inquiry activities for 10 weeks. Only one class also discussed the nature of science after each activity. The views of the class that didn’t were no different at the end. In the class that did, substantially more students than in the other class gave more informed views of at least one aspect, although only 24% reached consistent and integrated understandings. A review of attempts to improve teachers’ understanding found the explicit approach relatively more effective than the implicit one, though much was still needed (Abd-El-Khalick and Lederman, 2000), and the Understanding Science site says the research suggests that the most effective instruction is explicit and reflective. That is a modest base: one classroom study with sixth graders, who are younger than Year 9 students, and a review of studies with teachers.
The reflection works best as talk. After each black box, ask the class the question in the “How science works” box before they read it: what did we observe, what did we infer, and could someone infer something else from the same observations? The printable sheet starts with a black box for groups to make and swap. Plan for about two lessons of 50 to 60 minutes: screens 1 to 4, then screens 5 to 8. The marble practical needs about 30 minutes more.
Handle with care
- Students often think scientists have looked inside atoms. The lesson keeps saying that what is known about the inside of an atom is inferred, and that a model is not a picture. The drawings of atoms are not to scale: a nucleus is about 100,000 times smaller across than its atom (OpenStax).
- The lesson follows the discovery of the three particles up to 1932. It leaves out Bohr’s model of 1913 and the models that came after it (OpenStax), and it draws electrons as dots around the nucleus with a note that the drawing doesn’t show where they are.
- The experiment is usually called the gold foil experiment, but the figure of about 1 in 8000 coming back is from Geiger and Marsden’s 1909 paper, for a thick platinum plate (Rutherford). The lesson says so where it gives that figure. For gold foil 0.00004 cm thick, Rutherford (1911) reports their finding that about 1 in 20,000 were turned through an average angle of 90°, and the gold foil on screen 3 is based on that figure.
- ACARA’s elaboration says cobalt-60 releases gamma radiation. Cobalt-60 decays by giving off a beta particle and becomes nickel-60, and it gives off gamma rays too (OpenStax; US EPA; KAERI). The lesson shows both. The elaboration’s radon-222 example releases an alpha particle and becomes polonium-218, which is not stable either; the chain on screen 6 follows it through eight steps to stable lead-206.
- Screen 8 is based on ACARA’s Science Teacher Background Information for elaboration AC9S9U06_E6. ACARA says some of the sources it consulted may contain material that is culturally offensive and are not recommended for the classroom. It also says that written records, though very useful, can be problematic, because they are often based on non-Indigenous interpretations of First Nations Peoples’ behaviours, actions, comments and traditions. The Lake Mungo remains are a sensitive matter for the Ngiyampaa, Mutthi Mutthi and Paakantji peoples, who are the descendants of Mungo Lady and Mungo Man and the custodians of the remains, and many Aboriginal peoples hold that they have always lived in Australia (ACARA). The custodians of Madjedbebe are the Mirarr Senior Traditional Owners, who gave permission for the research there and for its publication (Clarkson and others). Present the dating as what the scientific methods show, alongside that view. Where you can, involve local First Nations knowledge holders or community-approved resources, and follow your school’s protocols.
- The sources on screen 6 are simulations. Follow your school’s and your state’s rules for any real radioactive source.
About the models
- Screen 1: each box is 100 units square. Box 1 holds a disc of radius 23, Box 2 a triangle and Box 3 one small disc of radius 4.5 in the middle. Balls are treated as points that travel in straight lines and bounce off the shape at the same angle as they hit it. An idea explains a shot if it sends the ball out of the same side within 2.5 units of where the real ball came out.
- Screen 2: the plates and the magnet move the spot by the same made-up amount for the real particles. The slider sets the mass for the charge of a test particle, compared with a hydrogen ion. The test particle is treated as moving at the same speed as the real ones, so its spot moves in proportion to its charge for its mass. Thomson balanced the electric and magnetic pushes so that the spot didn’t move, which gave him the particles’ speed (Cavendish Laboratory). The cathode is drawn in its metal’s colour, and a table under the tube records where the spot lands with each metal for the plates and magnet as they are, so students can see that it is the same for all three. The readout rounds to 2 significant figures, so the match shows as about 1/1,800. Today’s figure is 1/1,836 of a hydrogen ion’s mass for the same charge, and Thomson’s own results implied about 1/1000 (OpenStax College Physics).
- Screen 3: the foil always behaves like real metal. Each particle is turned through an angle drawn from Rutherford’s pattern, in which the share turned through more than an angle θ is proportional to 1 ÷ tan²(θ/2). For gold the share turned through more than 90° is set to 1 in 20,000, from Rutherford’s report of gold foil 0.00004 cm thick. The other metals’ shares are scaled from gold’s by the square of the nuclear charge, as in Rutherford’s model, as if each foil had the same number of atoms. Thomson’s model is given a made-up spread of about 1 degree, with nothing beyond 10 degrees. The lines drawn from the foil to the screen show where each counted particle went; Geiger and Marsden saw only the flashes. In the close-up, the nuclei are drawn thousands of times too big, and the particles shown are ones that pass near a nucleus.
- Screen 4: in a head-on collision, a particle of mass m and speed v gives a nucleus of mass M a speed of 2mv ÷ (m + M). Setting the hydrogen speed to Chadwick’s 33,000 km/s, the nitrogen speed is 33,000 × (m + 1) ÷ (m + 14) km/s, which matches his 4,700 km/s at m = 1.16; Chadwick wrote 1.15. For gamma rays, Chadwick worked out that rays strong enough for the hydrogen nuclei would give nitrogen nuclei at most 450,000 electron volts of energy, which is about 2,500 km/s, against the 4,700 km/s measured. The 2,500 km/s is worked out here from his 450,000 electron volts. The hydrogen speed was measured with a counter, and the nitrogen speed comes from tracks photographed in a cloud chamber (Chadwick). The readout rounds the mass to 2 decimal places, and the speed is worked out from the rounded mass. In the animation of Rutherford’s 1919 experiment the alpha particle stays in the nucleus. Rutherford concluded that the nitrogen nucleus had broken up, but Patrick Blackett’s cloud chamber photographs, taken by 1924, showed that the alpha particle is captured and the nucleus becomes oxygen-17 (CERN Courier). Oxygen-17 is one of the mystery atoms on screen 5.
- Screen 5: the builder counts a nucleus as stable if it is one of the isotopes CIAAW lists for hydrogen to oxygen (KAERI’s table of nuclides lists the less familiar ones, such as helium-3, lithium-6, boron-10 and oxygen-17, as stable). Every other nucleus on the chart is unstable. The particle masses are OpenStax’s: proton 1.00727, neutron 1.00866 and electron 0.00055 atomic mass units. The readout rounds the mass to the nearest atomic mass unit, because the particles’ masses added up come to a little more than the mass of a real atom. OpenStax calls the difference the mass defect.
- Screen 6: the count rates are made up, and background radiation is left out. Paper stops alpha particles and lets most beta particles through, a thin metal sheet stops beta particles, and thick lead lets through 6% of cobalt-60’s gamma rays and none of iodine-131’s (made-up shares that follow OpenStax’s description). Each source is shown giving off only the radiation from its own decay, and the note under the sources says so. A real radon-222 source soon also gives off beta particles from lead-214 and bismuth-214 further down its chain, which have half-lives of under half an hour (KAERI). With the plates on, charged particles are turned aside and miss the detector.
- Screen 7: in each step of one tenth of a half-life, each nucleus left has a chance of 1 − 2^(−0.1), about 6.7%, of decaying. Each run is worked out from a seed, so it comes back the same after a reload.
- Screen 8: the curve is 100 × 2^(−age ÷ 5,730)%. It assumes the share of carbon-14 in the air has always been the same, which ACARA notes is not the case. Samples A, B and C are made up, with 50%, 25% and 6% of their carbon-14 left. The Lake Mungo and Madjedbebe dates are from ACARA and Clarkson and others (2017).
Where sources disagree and what to check
- ACARA spells the rock shelter Madjedebe (Malakunanja II); Clarkson and others (2017) spell it Madjedbebe, which this lesson uses. ACARA says at least 65,000 years; the paper says around 65,000 years ago, a new minimum age for the arrival of people in Australia. ACARA says radiocarbon and luminescence methods were used together. In the paper, the 65,000-year age comes from luminescence (optical) dating, and the radiocarbon dates are from the upper 2 m of the deposit.
- ACARA says radiocarbon dating can measure dates up to about 40,000 years; OpenStax says reasonably accurate dates up to about 50,000 years, with a limit of about 57,000 years. Both are given as rough limits.
- Chadwick’s own figure for the neutron’s mass from the two speeds was 1.15; working it out again from the speeds he gives, 3.3 × 10⁹ and 4.7 × 10⁸ cm per second, gives 1.16. He gave 1.005 to 1.008 from a better method, in atomic mass units, on a scale where a hydrogen atom is 1.0078 (Chadwick). Today’s value, 1.00866 (OpenStax), is a little above his range.
- OpenStax College Physics says that about once in 8000 times in Rutherford’s experiment an alpha particle was scattered straight back. Geiger and Marsden’s 1 in 8000 was for a thick platinum plate, and for gold foil 0.00004 cm thick Rutherford gives about 1 in 20,000 (Rutherford, 1911).
Answers at a glance
- Screen 1: Box 1 holds a large disc, Box 2 a triangle and Box 3 one small disc. Observations: the ball that came straight back, and most balls going straight through Box 3. Inferences: something small and hard in Box 3, and the three-sided shape in Box 2. q-observe the ball came out of the top of the box; q-infer nobody can see inside an atom, so it is worked out from experiments; q-differ fire balls where the two ideas send them to different places.
- Screen 2: the test particle matches at about 1/1,800 of a hydrogen ion’s mass for its charge. Observations: the spot moving up, and the spot in the same place with every metal. Inferences: negative particles, and particles in every element. q-negative a negative charge; q-metals the particles are part of the atoms of every element; q-light much lighter than a hydrogen atom; q-pudding electrons dotted through a ball of positive charge.
- Screen 3: with 100,000 alpha particles fired at gold, the nuclear model predicts about 5 bouncing back and Thomson’s model none. q-straight most of an atom is empty space; q-back each atom has a tiny, heavy, positive centre; q-tentative it couldn’t explain the alpha particles that came back; n-scale 100 m ÷ 100,000 = 1 mm.
- Screen 4: the particle matches both speeds at a mass of about 1.16. q-proton hydrogen nuclei came out of nitrogen when alpha particles hit it; q-gamma gamma rays couldn’t give both kinds of nuclei their measured speeds; n-ratio 33,000 ÷ 4,700 = 7.0; q-refine better measurements can refine what scientists know.
- Screen 5: mystery atoms carbon-14 (6 protons, 8 neutrons, 6 electrons), oxygen-17 (8, 9, 8) and a lithium-7 ion (3, 4, 2). q-mass in the nucleus; q-isotope carbon-14 has two more neutrons; n-neutrons 14 − 6 = 8; q-ion a lithium ion with a charge of +1.
- Screen 6: source A is radon-222 (alpha particles), source B iodine-131 (beta particles and gamma rays) and source C cobalt-60 (beta particles and gamma rays). Observations: source A’s count falling to zero behind paper, and source C’s count with the plates on. Inferences: alpha particles from A, and uncharged radiation from C. q-paper alpha particles; q-alpha polonium-218; q-beta a neutron turned into a proton; q-stable lead-206 is stable; q-flaw its gamma rays are used to find flaws in metal.
- Screen 7: q-which nobody can say; n-left 400, 200, 100, 50; n-iodine 3 half-lives, 12.5%; q-uranium uranium-238.
- Screen 8: sample A about 5,700 years, sample B about 11,500 years and sample C about 23,300 years. q-ratio it takes in no new carbon, and its carbon-14 decays; n-age 2 × 5,730 = 11,460 years; q-limit too little carbon-14 is left to measure; q-mungo scientific knowledge can change as methods and evidence improve.
- Printable sheet: on page 2, starting with 100 coins, about 50, 25, 13, 6 and 3 should be left after each throw, and each throw stands for one half-life. On page 3 the chain is radon-222, polonium-218 (alpha), lead-214 (alpha), bismuth-214 (beta), polonium-214 (beta), lead-210 (alpha), bismuth-210 (beta), polonium-210 (beta) and lead-206 (alpha), which is stable: four alpha decays and four beta decays.
Saved progress
Shots, choices, answers and settings are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere.
References
- Abd-El-Khalick, F. and Lederman, N. G. (2000). Improving science teachers’ conceptions of nature of science: a critical review of the literature. International Journal of Science Education, 22(7), 665–701. Description on SERC.
- Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) (2022). Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Years 7 to 10 curriculum content. Australian Curriculum website.
- Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) (n.d.). Science teacher background information AC9S9U06_E6. Australian Curriculum Version 9 support resources.
- Cavendish Laboratory, University of Cambridge (n.d.). The discovery of the electron (G. L. Squires, 1997).
- Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) (2025). Iodine-131. Radiation emergencies.
- CERN Courier (2019, 8 May). Rutherford, transmutation and the proton (J. Campbell).
- Chadwick, J. (1932a). Possible existence of a neutron. Nature, 129, 312. https://doi.org/10.1038/129312a0. Text on ChemTeam.
- Chadwick, J. (1932b). The existence of a neutron. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A, 136, 692–708. Text on ChemTeam.
- ChemTeam (n.d.). Rutherford’s experiment, part I: 1906 to early 1911.
- Clarkson, C., Jacobs, Z., Marwick, B., Fullagar, R., Wallis, L., Smith, M., Roberts, R. G., Hayes, E., Lowe, K., Carah, X., Florin, S. A. and others (2017). Human occupation of northern Australia by 65,000 years ago. Nature, 547, 306–310. https://doi.org/10.1038/nature22968
- Commission on Isotopic Abundances and Atomic Weights (CIAAW) (2024). Isotopic compositions of the elements 2024. IUPAC.
- Flowers, P., Theopold, K., Langley, R. and Robinson, W. R. (2019). Chemistry 2e. OpenStax. Sections 2.2 Evolution of atomic theory, 2.3 Atomic structure and symbolism, 6.2 The Bohr model, 21.1 Nuclear structure and stability, 21.3 Radioactive decay, 21.5 Uses of radioisotopes and 21.6 Biological effects of radiation.
- Geiger, H. and Marsden, E. (1909). On a diffuse reflection of the α-particles. Proceedings of the Royal Society of London A, 82, 495–500. Text on ChemTeam.
- Khishfe, R. and Abd-El-Khalick, F. (2002). Influence of explicit and reflective versus implicit inquiry-oriented instruction on sixth graders’ views of nature of science. Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 39(7), 551–578. https://doi.org/10.1002/tea.10036
- Korea Atomic Energy Research Institute (KAERI) (n.d.). Table of Nuclides, with data from NuDat. For example, cobalt-60.
- National Academy of Sciences (1998). Teaching About Evolution and the Nature of Science, chapter 6: Activities for teaching about evolution and the nature of science. National Academy Press.
- Rutherford, E. (1911). The scattering of α and β particles by matter and the structure of the atom. Philosophical Magazine, series 6, 21, 669–688. Text on ChemTeam.
- University of California Museum of Paleontology (n.d.). Understanding Science: Educational research and Mystery tubes lesson. University of California, Berkeley.
- University of Wollongong (n.d.). Optical Dating Facility.
- Urone, P. P. and Hinrichs, R. (2022). College Physics 2e. OpenStax. Sections 30.2 Discovery of the parts of the atom: electrons and nuclei and 31.5 Half-life and activity.
- US Department of Energy, Office of History and Heritage Resources (n.d.). Exploring the atom. The Manhattan Project: an interactive history.
- US Environmental Protection Agency (n.d.). Radionuclide basics: cobalt-60 and Radionuclide basics: iodine.
Curriculum attribution
© Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) 2010 to present, unless otherwise indicated. This material was downloaded from the Australian Curriculum website (Website) (accessed 10 November 2026) and was not modified. The material is licensed under CC BY 4.0 Attribution 4.0 International Deed. Version updates are tracked in the ‘Curriculum version history’ section on the ‘About the Australian Curriculum’ page of the Australian Curriculum website.
ACARA does not endorse any product that uses the Australian Curriculum or make any representations as to the quality of such products. Any product that uses material published on this website should not be taken to be affiliated with ACARA or have the sponsorship or approval of ACARA. It is up to each person to make their own assessment of the product, taking into account matters including, but not limited to, the version number and the degree to which the materials align with the content descriptions and achievement standards (where relevant). Where there is a claim of alignment, it is important to check that the materials align with the content descriptions and achievement standards (endorsed by all education Ministers), not the elaborations (examples provided by ACARA).
Sources by screen
- Method: Khishfe and Abd-El-Khalick (2002), Abd-El-Khalick and Lederman (2000), Understanding Science (educational research and the mystery tubes lesson), National Academy of Sciences (1998).
- Screen 1: Khishfe and Abd-El-Khalick (2002) (observations and inferences).
- Screen 2: Cavendish Laboratory (cathode rays, the two views and Thomson’s experiments); OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 2.2 (Thomson’s conclusions and the plum pudding model); OpenStax College Physics 2e, 30.2 (Thomson’s hydrogen ion comparison and today’s figure for the electron).
- Screen 3: Geiger and Marsden (1909); Rutherford (1911) (the thick platinum plate and the gold foil figure); ChemTeam (the date of Rutherford’s paper); OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 2.2 and 2.3 (the results, the nuclear model and the size of the nucleus); OpenStax College Physics 2e, 30.2 (what Thomson’s model predicted).
- Screen 4: US Department of Energy (Rutherford’s hydrogen nuclei, the proton, and the different weights the neutron explained); CERN Courier (what Blackett’s photographs showed); Chadwick (1932a, 1932b); OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 2.2.
- Screen 5: OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 2.2, 2.3 and 21.1 (particles, atomic and mass numbers, isotopes and the band of stability); OpenStax College Physics 2e, 30.2; ACARA, AC9S9U06_E6 (carbon’s isotopes); CIAAW and KAERI (stable isotopes).
- Screen 6: OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 21.3, 21.5 and 21.6 (decay, the decay series, uses and penetration); US EPA (cobalt-60 and iodine-131); CDC (iodine-131’s radiation and its use in diagnosing and treating thyroid cancer); KAERI (decay products, their stability and half-lives).
- Screen 7: OpenStax College Physics 2e, 31.5 (decay as chance); OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 21.3 (half-life and the half-lives); US EPA (the half-lives of cobalt-60 and iodine-131); CDC (iodine-131’s radiation).
- Screen 8: ACARA, AC9S9U06_E6; OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 21.3 (the limits of radiocarbon dating); University of Wollongong (luminescence dating); Clarkson and others (2017) (Madjedbebe, its dating and its custodians).
- Teacher notes: OpenStax Chemistry 2e, 6.2 (Bohr’s model of 1913).
- Word list: the sources for the screen where each word is first used.