Year 9 science · Physical sciences · AC9S9U05
Why is nothing 100% efficient?
1Problem 1 of 8
The power station
If energy is never destroyed, why does a coal-fired power station need so much more energy than it supplies?
The law of conservation of energy says: “Total energy is constant in any process. It may change in form or be transferred from one system to another, but the total remains the same.” (OpenStax). Yet a coal-fired power station takes in far more energy than it sends out as electricity. In this lesson you work out why nothing is 100% efficient, one problem at a time.
How this lesson works
Each screen is a context-rich problem: a short story in which you are the main character and have a reason to work something out. Physics education researchers at the University of Minnesota developed problems like these for small groups to solve together. As in a real situation, the story can hold information you don’t need, and it doesn’t always say exactly what to calculate.
Work in a group of three if you can. One of you is the manager, who keeps the group to its plan; one is the checker and recorder, who writes the solution down and checks that everyone understands each step; and one is the sceptic, who questions every step. Solve each problem in five steps:
- Focus the problem: what do you need to find, and which information do you need?
- Describe the physics: where does the energy come from and where does it go?
- Plan a solution: which calculations, in which order?
- Execute the plan: do the calculations.
- Evaluate the answer: does it make sense?
A simulation on each screen lets you test the situation before you solve the problem.
On this screen
- Read the problem, then run the power station at different rates.
- Follow one second of energy through the station.
- Solve the problem in five steps, then answer the questions.
Problem 1
You’re on work experience at a coal-fired power station, in the control room with the shift engineer. The big screen shows the station sending 1000 MW of electrical power to the grid. The engineer tells you that the boilers are burning coal fast enough to release about 2500 MW of chemical energy, that the station has four turbines, and that it has run all day without a break. A coal train arrives every second day.
A visiting councillor asks you how much power the cooling towers and the chimney are giving to the air, and what share of the coal’s energy becomes electricity. Work it out so that you can tell her.
A coal-fired power station
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Inside the station the energy changes form several times. OpenStax describes it: “the chemical energy contained in coal is converted into thermal energy as it burns to turn water into steam in a boiler. This thermal energy in the steam in turn is converted to mechanical energy as it spins a turbine, which is connected to a generator to produce electrical energy.” A turbine is a shaft with blades that the steam pushes round, and the generator turns that movement into electrical energy.
Power stations are compared by their power, the energy they transfer each second. The unit is the watt, “where 1 watt equals 1 joule/second (1 W = 1 J/s)” (OpenStax), so 1 MW, a million watts, is a million joules every second. “Even though energy is conserved in an energy conversion process, the output of useful energy or work will be less than the energy input.” (OpenStax). The tall cooling towers are there to get rid of the rest, as thermal energy.
Solve problem 1
Five stepsThe problem solver loads here.
Efficiency
A device’s efficiency is the share of the energy put in that comes out as useful energy:
efficiency = useful energy out ÷ total energy in × 100%
The rest isn’t destroyed. “In a coal-fired power plant, for example, about 40% of the chemical energy in the coal becomes useful electrical energy. The other 60% transforms into other (perhaps less useful) energy forms, such as thermal energy, which is then released to the environment through combustion gases and cooling towers.” (OpenStax). Energy in always equals energy out.
What does the law of conservation of energy say?
In a coal-fired power station, where does most of the coal’s energy end up?
2Problem 2 of 8
Six ways to make electricity
Which way of making electricity wastes the least energy, and does that make it the best?
Electricity can be made from coal, gas, nuclear fuel, falling water, wind and sunlight. Each kind of power station changes the energy from its source into electrical energy, and their efficiencies differ.
On this screen
- Look at each kind of power station and its Sankey diagram.
- Switch to 100 MJ of electricity out, and compare how much energy each kind needs.
- Solve the problem in five steps, then answer the questions.
Problem 2
You and your class are writing a one-page fact sheet for a council meeting about where the town should get its electricity. A councillor has asked one question: to make 100 MJ of electricity, how much energy has to go in at a coal-fired power station, and how much at a hydroelectric power station?
Your table already says that coal-fired stations are about 42% efficient (OpenStax) and hydroelectric stations about 90% (US Bureau of Reclamation). The meeting is on Thursday at 6 pm, and the last fact sheet was 12 pages long.
Six kinds of power station
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Coal, gas and nuclear power stations all boil water to make steam that turns a turbine. OpenStax says “Electrical power stations fired by coal, oil, and natural gas have greater actual efficiencies (about 42%), because their boilers can reach higher temperatures and pressures.” and “A typical nuclear power station’s actual efficiency is about 35%”. A hydroelectric station lets water stored behind a dam fall through a turbine, turning gravitational potential energy into electrical energy. The US Bureau of Reclamation says “The efficiency of today’s hydroelectric plant is about 90 percent.”
A wind turbine turns some of the wind’s kinetic energy into electrical energy, but never all of it. “If a wind turbine was 100% efficient, then all of the wind would have to stop completely upon contact with the turbine”, which can’t happen, because the air has to keep moving out of the way. The theoretical limit, the Betz limit, is 59.3%, and real turbines’ common efficiencies are 35 to 45% (Energy Education, University of Calgary). Solar panels turn sunlight straight into electricity. Your Home, an Australian Government guide, gives 15 to 20% for monocrystalline cells and 13 to 17% for polycrystalline cells.
Solve problem 2
Five stepsThe problem solver loads here.
Efficiency isn’t everything
A hydroelectric station wastes the least energy, and solar panels turn the smallest share of their input into electricity. Efficiency is only one thing to weigh. “Renewable forms of energy are those sources that cannot be used up, such as water, wind, solar, and biomass.” (OpenStax), and burning coal or gas produces carbon dioxide (OpenStax). A solar panel’s lower efficiency means a bigger panel for the same electricity, not more fuel burnt. Your Home notes that the lower efficiency of polycrystalline cells “can be compensated for by using larger installations”.
Which kind of power station has the highest efficiency in this lesson’s sources?
Why can solar panels be worth using even though they are less efficient than a coal-fired station?
3Problem 3 of 8
Petrol or electric?
When energy passes through a chain of machines, how much is left at the end?
Energy often passes through several machines one after another: a power station, then power lines, then an electric motor. Each machine in the chain wastes some of the energy it gets, so less and less is left for the next one.
On this screen
- Drive both cars with electricity from coal, then from water.
- Include the power lines, and drive again.
- Solve the problem in five steps, then answer the questions.
Problem 3
You’re helping your family choose a new car. Your uncle says an electric car is no better than a petrol car, because its electricity comes from a coal-fired power station that wastes most of the coal’s energy.
You find a table of efficiencies in a physics book: a petrol engine is about 30% efficient, a coal-fired power station about 42% and an electric motor about 98% (OpenStax). Both cars cost about the same, and your uncle drives 40 km a day. For every 100 MJ of energy in the fuel, petrol or coal, how much ends up moving each car? Is your uncle right?
A petrol car and an electric car
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
The efficiencies in the problem come from OpenStax’s table of efficiencies, which gives representative values: a gasoline (petrol) engine 30%, a coal power plant 42% and an electric motor 98%. A petrol car has a short chain: the engine turns the petrol’s chemical energy into kinetic energy, and the rest becomes thermal energy. An electric car’s chain starts at the power station, so it has more steps.
Power lines waste energy too. Energy Education (University of Calgary) gives typical losses of 8% to 15% between a power station and a home. Charging the car’s battery changes electrical energy into chemical energy, and “It is never possible to change one form completely into another without losing some of it as thermal energy.” (OpenStax). The simulation leaves the battery out.
Solve problem 3
Five stepsThe problem solver loads here.
Efficiencies multiply
In a chain, each machine gets only what the one before it passes on, so the efficiency of the whole chain is the machines’ efficiencies multiplied together. A coal-fired station (42%) and an electric motor (98%) give 0.42 × 0.98 ≈ 0.41, or 41%. Every extra step, such as the power lines, takes another share, so a long chain wastes more energy along the way.
Two machines are each 50% efficient, and the first passes its useful energy to the second. What is the efficiency of the chain?
Why does including the power lines give the electric car less energy at its wheels?
4Problem 4 of 8
Flying on food energy
How much of the energy in food can a person turn into useful work?
“Our own bodies, like all living organisms, are energy conversion machines.” (OpenStax). Your muscles turn the chemical energy in food into useful work, such as pushing a bike’s pedals, and into thermal energy.
On this screen
- Fly the whole flight at 20%, then again at 25% or more.
- Compare how efficient people are at different activities.
- Solve the problem in five steps, then answer the questions.
Problem 4
You’re on the support team for the Daedalus 88, a pedal-powered aircraft, in April 1988. Its pilot, Kanellos Kanellopoulos, is about to fly it 119 km from Crete to Santorini, in Greece. His useful power output will be about 350 W, for a flight of about 234 minutes (OpenStax). Cyclists turn about 20% of their food energy into useful work (OpenStax).
You have to work out how much food energy his body will use during the flight, and warn the team how much thermal energy his body will have to get rid of on the way.
A pedal-powered aircraft
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
OpenStax says the chemical energy in food becomes useful work, thermal energy and stored chemical energy, and “By far the largest fraction goes to thermal energy, although the fraction varies depending on the type of physical activity.” Its table of efficiencies gives representative values: about 20% for cycling and climbing, 9% for weightlifting, 4% for swimming under water, 3% for shovelling and 2% for swimming at the surface. That is why you get hot when you exercise hard: most of the food energy your muscles use becomes thermal energy.
Kanellopoulos made the flight on 23 April 1988 (OpenStax). In the problem, the 350 W is his useful power output, the work he does on the pedals each second. His body uses food energy much faster than that.
Solve problem 4
Five stepsThe problem solver loads here.
People are about 20% efficient at cycling
When you cycle, about a fifth of the food energy your body uses becomes useful work, and the rest becomes thermal energy. Any gain in efficiency means more useful work from the same food energy, and less thermal energy to get rid of. In the simulation, a pilot 25% efficient would use 19,656 kJ of food energy for the same flight instead of 24,570 kJ.
Why do you get hot when you ride a bike hard?
Two cyclists do the same useful work. One is 20% efficient and the other 25%. Which statement is right?
5Problem 5 of 8
Ground ovens
How does a ground oven get so much of the hot stones’ energy into the food?
First Nations Australians have long cooked food in ground ovens, and many still do. ACARA’s background notes for teachers describe several, from the Barindji Peoples of south central New South Wales, the Bindal and Wulgurukaba Peoples of far North Queensland, the Torres Strait Islands and the Wik-Mungkan Peoples of the western Cape York Peninsula.
On this screen
- Cook in the model oven with each of the three arrangements.
- Watch where the stones’ energy goes and how each half of the food cooks.
- Solve the problem in five steps, then answer the questions.
Problem 5
You and your class are getting ready for a visit from a local Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander knowledge holder, who will talk about cooking in a ground oven. To understand the science first, your group uses a model of a pit oven. In the model, the hot stones start with 20 MJ of thermal energy.
With all the stones underneath the food and the pit left open, the food gains 3 MJ by the end of cooking. With stones underneath and on top, and the pit covered with earth, the food gains 7 MJ. The pit is 1 m across, and the food cooks for 3 hours. Your teacher asks what share of the stones’ energy reaches the food each way, where the rest goes, and why the second way works better.
A ground oven
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
ACARA’s notes say that for millennia the Barindji Peoples built a substantial fire to heat stones until they glowed red hot, then cooked large animals in a pit oven on the hot stones. “The oven is covered with grass, more hot stones placed on top and the oven completely enclosed with earth.” With hot stones underneath and above, heat “is transferred from the stones in both directions so that the meat is cooked through without needing to be dug up and turned.” The Bindal and Wulgurukaba Peoples also cook meat in earth ovens between layers of hot stones, and the notes add that “using only a single layer of hot stones may result in only one side of the food being cooked due to an uneven transfer of heat.” (ACARA).
“Ground ovens have long been used, and continue to be used, widely on the Torres Strait Islands.” They are called amai in the Meriam Mir language and ame or netebu in the Kala Lagaw Ya language, and food is layered with hot stones. The Wik-Mungkan Peoples use heated pieces of termite mound (ant-bed) to cook food, and many ground ovens today use steel offcuts with rocks, or instead of them (ACARA).
The physics: heat moves “from a warmer object to a cooler object” (ACARA). Hot stones pass heat to the food they touch by conduction. The earth that encloses a ground oven “acts as a lid that retains the heat and pressure generated by the hot stones”, as in a pressure cooker, where hot gases carry heat round the food by convection (ACARA).
Solve problem 5
Five stepsThe problem solver loads here.
Keeping the heat where it is needed
A ground oven gets more of the stones’ thermal energy into the food in two ways. Stones above and below heat it from both sides, so it cooks through evenly, and the earth cover slows the heat escaping into the air. “The success and efficiency of ground ovens is due to the heat transfer principles of conduction and convection.” (ACARA).
Why are hot stones placed on top of the food as well as underneath it?
What does the earth covering a ground oven do?
In a ground oven, which way does heat move?
6Problem 6 of 8
Reading the star rating
Does an appliance with more stars always use less energy?
Many appliances in Australian shops, such as fridges and washing machines, carry an Energy Rating Label. It shows two things: a star rating and an energy consumption figure. Energy Rating says “The star rating is about energy efficiency – that is, how much energy a product uses compared to similar products.”
On this screen
- Run Fridge P against Fridge Q for 10 years.
- Compare two fridges of the same size, and find the fridge that costs least to run.
- Solve the problem in five steps, then answer the questions.
Problem 6
You’ve been sent to the shop to choose between two fridges that fit the space, because your family’s old fridge has broken down. Fridge P has 4 stars and 600 L of space, and uses 420 kWh a year. Fridge Q has 3 stars and 380 L of space, and uses 380 kWh a year. Fridge P costs $200 more to buy, and both come in white or silver.
Electricity costs your family $0.307 per kWh, the tariff in Energy Rating’s examples. Your dad says the 4-star fridge will be cheaper to run. Work out what each fridge costs to run over 10 years, and whether he is right.
Two fridges and their energy labels
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Energy Rating explains the label. “More stars means more efficient, when compared to other models of a similar size and features.” “Most products are given between 1 and 6 stars.” “Energy consumption is how much electricity a model uses each year, in kilowatt hours (kWh).” and “You can use the energy consumption number to compare any model – no matter their size or features.” A kilowatt-hour is an amount of energy: electricity bills count energy in kilowatt-hours, “the product of power in kilowatts and time in hours” (OpenStax).
To work out a running cost, Energy Rating gives this formula: “Annual running cost = Total energy consumption (kWh) × Electricity tariff (dollars per kWh)”. Its own example is a fridge that uses 458 kWh a year at $0.307 per kWh, which comes to an estimated $140.61 a year.
Solve problem 6
Five stepsThe problem solver loads here.
Two numbers on the label
The stars compare a model with others of a similar size and features. The energy consumption, in kWh a year, tells you how much electricity it uses, and you can compare it across any models. “The star rating takes into account the size and features of the appliance.” (Energy Rating), so a big fridge with more stars can still use more energy than a small one with fewer.
OpenStax points out that saving energy, which it calls energy conservation, is different from the law of conservation of energy. Energy conservation means using less energy, by doing less or by using more efficient devices. The law says the total amount of energy never changes, whatever you do.
What do the stars on an Energy Rating Label compare?
Which number lets you compare the energy use of any two fridges, whatever their size?
7Problem 7 of 8
Checking Sankey diagrams
How can you tell when an energy diagram can’t be right?
A Sankey diagram shows energy flowing through a system as arrows, each as wide as the amount of energy it carries. The arrow coming in splits into the useful energy out and the wasted energy out. You have used one in problems 1 to 5. Now you check some that other people have drawn.
On this screen
- Find and fix the mistake in each of the four diagrams.
- Solve the problem about the light globe in five steps.
- Answer the questions.
Problem 7
You’re the checker for a poster about efficiency that your group is making for the school’s science night. One group’s Sankey diagram says a 60 W incandescent light globe gives out 20 W of light and 45 W of thermal energy. They drew it on bright yellow card, and the poster goes to the printer tomorrow.
OpenStax says “a 60-W incandescent bulb converts only 5 W of electrical power to light”. Find what’s wrong with the diagram, fix the numbers, and work out the globe’s efficiency for the caption.
Four Sankey diagrams to check
DiagramThe diagrams load here.
Check three things in any Sankey diagram. First, the arrows coming out add up to the arrow going in, because energy is conserved. Second, each arrow’s width matches its amount, so a wasted arrow carrying 70% of the energy is drawn more than twice as wide as a useful arrow carrying 30%. Third, the useful arrow’s share of the input, the efficiency, is less than 100%, because “It is never possible to change one form completely into another without losing some of it as thermal energy.” (OpenStax). The curriculum describes this as “applying ratios to accurately represent usable and waste energy in transfer and transformation diagrams such as Sankey diagrams” (ACARA).
Solve problem 7
Five stepsThe problem solver loads here.
A Sankey diagram that is right
The energy in equals the total of the energy out. Each arrow is as wide as its share of the input. The useful output is labelled, and its share of the input is the efficiency, which is always less than 100%. A diagram that breaks any of these rules can’t be right, however neatly it is drawn.
A diagram shows 100 J going in, and 30 J of useful energy and 80 J of thermal energy coming out. What is wrong?
In a correct Sankey diagram for a petrol engine that is 30% efficient, which arrow coming out is wider?
8Problem 8 of 8
A machine that runs forever?
Why is nothing 100% efficient?
People have spent a great deal of effort, time and money trying to build a perpetual motion machine, which OpenStax defines as “a hypothetical machine that operates or produces useful work indefinitely and/or a hypothetical machine that produces more work or energy than it consumes”. The law of conservation of energy “cannot be proven from basic principles, but is a very good bookkeeping device, and no exceptions have ever been found” (OpenStax).
On this screen
- Spin the flywheel and watch until it stops.
- Try it with both machines at 99%, then with the globe on.
- Solve the problem in five steps, answer the questions, then look at your results for the whole lesson.
Problem 8
You open a video your friend has sent of a machine in which an electric motor turns a flywheel and a generator, and the generator’s electricity runs the same motor. The video says that once you give the flywheel a spin, the machine runs forever and lights a globe as well. The motor and the generator are each 90% efficient, the video has 2 million views, and the machine is painted gold.
Your friend wants to pay $50 for the plans. Work out how much of the flywheel’s energy is left after one trip round the loop and after five trips, so you can tell your friend whether the plans are worth buying.
A motor, a flywheel and a generator in a loop
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Every machine in the loop changes energy from one form to another, and “It is never possible to change one form completely into another without losing some of it as thermal energy.” (OpenStax). That thermal energy spreads out into the room. Spread-out thermal energy can’t be gathered up again to turn the flywheel: “When entropy increases, a certain amount of energy becomes permanently unavailable to do work. The energy is not lost, but its character is changed, so that some of it can never be converted to doing work” (OpenStax). Physicists use entropy to measure how much energy has become unavailable in this way.
OpenStax sums it up: “Even though energy in an isolated system is a conserved quantity, the final result of most energy transformations is waste heat transfer to the environment, which is no longer useful for doing work.”
Solve problem 8
Five stepsThe problem solver loads here.
Why nothing is 100% efficient
Energy is always conserved, but every real change of form turns some of it into thermal energy. That thermal energy spreads into the surroundings, where it can’t be used to do the job again. So no machine is 100% efficient, and a machine can’t keep itself running forever, let alone light a globe as well.
A motor turns a generator that runs the same motor. Why does it slow down and stop?
Once the flywheel has stopped, where is the energy it started with?
Your school asks everyone to switch off lights to save energy. Does that break the law of conservation of energy?
Energy efficiency: context-rich problems and a kettle practical
Two pages: two context-rich problems to solve in five steps on paper, one about solar panels on the school hall and one about the heat from a spin class, and a practical that measures how much of an electric kettle’s energy ends up in the water, with a results table and questions.
For teachers
Curriculum
Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 9, Science understanding, Physical sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:
AC9S9U05 apply the law of conservation of energy to analyse system efficiency in terms of energy inputs, outputs, transfers and transformations
- explaining that the law of conservation of energy explains that total energy is maintained in energy transfer and transformation in a system
- explaining efficiency and recognising that in energy transfer and transformation a variety of processes can occur, so that the amount of usable energy is reduced and the system is not 100% efficient
- using and critiquing representations such as Sankey diagrams to show energy inputs, changes and outputs in a system
- investigating the efficiency of ground ovens used by First Nations Australians
- comparing the efficiency of electricity generation from coal and other sources such as nuclear, hydroelectricity, gas, solar and wind
- examining the meaning of energy star ratings given to appliances such as refrigerators and washing machines and criteria used to determine these ratings
- examining how improving efficiency in energy transfer and transformations in sporting activities such as pole vaulting or archery improves athletic performance
The second quote gives ACARA’s seven elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each part of the content description is covered on these screens:
- Apply the law of conservation of energy: every problem except the fridge problem on screen 6 uses energy in = energy out, and screens 1, 7 and 8 make it the main idea (the 1500 MW the station gives to the air, a poster diagram that puts out more energy than goes in, and a flywheel whose energy all ends up as thermal energy); q-law, q-addup and q-unavail.
- To analyse system efficiency: every problem calculates an efficiency or uses one, from a single device (screens 1, 2, 4 and 7) to a chain of machines (screens 3 and 8); n-planteff, n-hydroin, q-chain, n-chain, n-food and n-globe.
- In terms of energy inputs, outputs, transfers and transformations: in seven of the eight problems, step 2 names the energy in, the useful energy out and the wasted energy out, or puts a chain of machines in order, and step 4 draws a Sankey diagram to scale; the fridge problem on screen 6 draws its running costs as bars. The simulations show the transformations (chemical to thermal to kinetic to electrical in the power station) and the transfers (heat from hot stones to food in the ground oven).
- The elaborations: total energy maintained in transfers and transformations on screens 1 and 8; efficiency and why systems aren’t 100% efficient on every screen, and as the answer to the lesson’s question on screen 8; Sankey diagrams, used in every problem except screen 6’s and critiqued on screen 7; ground ovens on screen 5; electricity generation from coal, gas, nuclear fuel, water, wind and sunlight on screen 2; energy star ratings for fridges and washing machines, and the criteria behind them, on screen 6; and efficiency in a sporting activity, cycling, on screen 4.
The lesson also works on these content descriptions. Screen 2 touches on “exploring how scientists and engineers make machines more energy efficient” (AC9S9H02) through OpenStax’s point that coal, oil and gas stations are more efficient than nuclear stations because their boilers reach higher temperatures and pressures. Seven of the eight problems draw their answer as a Sankey diagram to scale in step 4, as in ACARA’s example “applying ratios to accurately represent usable and waste energy in transfer and transformation diagrams such as Sankey diagrams” (AC9S9I04). Screens 7 and 8 ask students to evaluate claims: a poster’s diagrams, and a video’s machine that runs forever (AC9S9I06).
AC9S9H02 investigate how advances in technologies enable advances in science, and how science has contributed to developments in technologies and engineering
AC9S9I04 select and construct appropriate representations, including tables, graphs, descriptive statistics, models and mathematical relationships, to organise and process data and information
AC9S9I06 assess the validity and reproducibility of methods and evaluate the validity of conclusions and claims, including by identifying assumptions, conflicting evidence and areas of uncertainty
How the lesson is taught
The lesson uses context-rich problems, developed by the physics education research group at the University of Minnesota. Each screen has a short story in which the student is the main character and has a reason to calculate something: a councillor’s question on work experience, a family choosing a car or a fridge, a friend about to buy plans for a machine. The group’s guide to writing them says “Always start a context rich problem with ‘You.’” and “This personalizes and motivates the problem for the students.” The stories include extra information someone in the situation would have, sometimes leave out common knowledge, and don’t always name the quantity to calculate, which are three of the guide’s “difficulty” characteristics. The guide suggests using only three or four of these in any one problem.
Students solve each problem with a five-step strategy taken from Heller and Heller’s user’s manual (2010): focus the problem, describe the physics, plan a solution, execute the plan and evaluate the answer. On screen, the solver opens one step at a time. Step 1 asks what the problem wants and which information is needed; step 2 names the energy in and out, puts a chain in order or, on screen 6, reads the label; step 3 chooses a plan; step 4 takes the numbers and then draws the answer to scale, as a Sankey diagram or, on screen 6, as bars; step 5 checks that the answer makes sense.
The method is meant for small groups. Heller and Heller advise: “Use cooperative groups of three, or at most four.” Their manual’s three roles are manager, checker and recorder, and sceptic and summariser, with summariser a separate fourth role in a group of four. Screen 1 gives students these roles without the summarising. Heller, Keith and Anderson (1992) found “that better problem solutions emerged through collaboration than were achieved by individuals working alone”, and that the approach “improved the problem solving performance of students at all ability levels”. Heller and Hollabaugh (1992) report that “Groups were more likely to use an effective problem-solving strategy when given context-rich problems to solve than when given standard textbook problems.” Both studies were with college physics students, so using the method with Year 9 students is this lesson’s own application. PhysPort, which summarises research-based teaching methods in physics, lists context-rich problems with a bronze rating for research validation.
Context-rich problems differ from problem-based learning, in which a large, open problem runs over days and drives what students learn. Here each problem is short, has one answer and is solved with a set strategy, after the physics it needs has been introduced. They also differ from worked examples: the solver doesn’t show a solution to copy, and the student makes each decision.
The online solver gives choices at each step, so it carries some of the thinking a group would do on paper. For a stronger version, have groups write their own solution on paper first, using the five headings, then check it with the solver. The simulation on each screen is a test rig rather than a picture of the problem; Heller and Heller’s problems give no picture, so ask students to sketch the situation before they open the solver. Plan for about three lessons of 50 to 60 minutes: screens 1 to 3, screens 4 to 6, and screens 7 and 8 with the kettle practical.
Handle with care
- Screen 5 is based on ACARA’s Science Teacher Background Information for elaboration AC9S9U05_E4. ACARA warns that “some of the sources listed in the consulted works may contain material that is considered culturally offensive or inappropriate”, and that these sources “often lack the viewpoints of the people they discuss”. Where you can, involve local First Nations knowledge holders or community-approved resources, and follow your school’s protocols. The ground oven model and its numbers are the lesson’s own; they don’t describe any community’s oven, and the problem asks students to understand why the traditional arrangement works, not to improve on it.
- Screen 4 is about the physics of the flight. OpenStax’s section on the human body also discusses food energy and body fat; the lesson leaves that out, and the food energy is treated only as fuel for the flight.
- The efficiencies are representative values from the sources named, not measurements of particular power stations, cars or people.
- Screen 6’s fridges are the lesson’s own examples, not real models, and the labels in the drawing are simplified. The tariff of $0.307 per kWh is the one in Energy Rating’s examples; real tariffs vary.
- Kettle practical: hot water and steam can scald. Fill the kettle and use the thermometer only while the kettle is switched off at the wall, keep the cord away from the edge of the bench, and stop heating at about 50 °C. A teacher can run it as a demonstration.
About the models
- Screen 1: the station is 40% efficient at every rate, OpenStax’s example: about 2500 MW of chemical energy in, 1000 MW of electric power out and 1500 MW of heat transfer to the surroundings. Keeping the efficiency the same at every rate is the lesson’s own simplification. The coal control moves in steps of 250 MW and starts at 500 MW, and the output changes over a few seconds after the coal changes. The button that follows one second of energy shows it as packets: at 2500 MW, 2500 MJ in, 1000 MJ to the grid and 1500 MJ to the air, all of it through the cooling tower, though OpenStax says some leaves through the combustion gases too. The dots show which way the energy moves, not how much.
- Screen 2: the model uses about 42% for coal-fired and gas-fired stations and about 35% for nuclear (OpenStax), about 90% for hydroelectric (US Bureau of Reclamation), 40% for wind, the middle of the 35 to 45% Energy Education gives for real turbines, and 17.5% for solar, the middle of the 15 to 20% Your Home gives for monocrystalline cells. The gas-fired station is drawn as a boiler station, the kind OpenStax’s 42% is for. A hydroelectric station’s 10% is shown as thermal energy; for wind and sunlight the diagram shows the rest as energy not turned into electricity, because it takes several forms.
- Screen 3: each car starts with 100 MJ of energy, in petrol or at the power station. A petrol engine is 30% efficient, a coal power plant 42% and an electric motor 98% (OpenStax’s table); hydroelectric 90% and solar 17.5% as on screen 2, with the energy from sunlight that isn’t turned into electricity shown as not electricity, because it takes several forms. The power lines lose 10% when included, the lesson’s own figure inside Energy Education’s 8 to 15%. Both cars need 0.5 MJ at their wheels for every km, which is the lesson’s own figure. The model leaves out charging the battery and the gears.
- Screen 4: a useful power output of 350 W for 234 minutes, as OpenStax gives for the Daedalus 88 flight, played at 10 minutes a second. Cycling is about 20% efficient (OpenStax); the 10 to 30% range of the control is the lesson’s own. At 20% the flight uses 24,570 kJ of food energy, 4914 kJ of useful work and 19,656 kJ of thermal energy; at 25%, 19,656 kJ of food energy. The aircraft is a simplified drawing, not a plan of the Daedalus 88.
- Screen 5: the ground oven model is the lesson’s own. The stones start 500 °C hotter than the air at 25 °C, with a heat capacity of 40,000 J per °C, so they hold 20 MJ; with stones on top, 60% of them are underneath. The food has a heat capacity of 101,000 J per °C and is stopped at 95 °C: while food still holds water it can’t get much hotter than 100 °C, the boiling point of water, because extra energy turns the water into steam. Heat flows in proportion to the difference in temperature: stones to food 3.4 W per °C, bottom of the food to top 1.0, steam from the stones underneath to the top of the food in a covered pit 0.6, stones underneath to the soil 3.1, stones on top to the earth cover 1.0, top of the food to the earth cover 0.6, and in an open pit the top of the food to the air 9 and the stones underneath to the air 7. In a covered pit, 35% of the steam from the bottom of the food warms the top. A half of the food counts as cooked after 60 minutes above 70 °C. The model works in 1 s steps. After 3 hours the food has gained 3.0 MJ with the pit open (15%), 6.0 MJ with the stones underneath and the pit covered (30%, with the top only partly cooked), and 7.0 MJ with stones above and below and the pit covered (35%, cooked through).
- Screen 6: four example fridges, P (4 stars, 600 L, 420 kWh a year), Q (3 stars, 380 L, 380 kWh), R (5 stars, 380 L, 300 kWh) and S (2 stars, 600 L, 560 kWh). Running cost = energy consumption × tariff (Energy Rating), starting at $0.307 per kWh. A year plays in about a second.
- Screen 7: each of the four poster diagrams has one mistake. The fixes use OpenStax’s numbers: 5 W of light from a 60 W incandescent bulb, a petrol engine 30% efficient, 1000 MW of electric power from 2500 MW, and cycling 20% efficient. The light globe’s outputs change in steps of 5 W and the cyclist’s in steps of 10 kJ.
- Screen 8: the flywheel gets 10 kJ when spun. Each trip round the loop keeps the generator’s efficiency × the motor’s efficiency of the energy, and the globe, when on, takes 10% of the electrical energy each trip, all counted as light for simplicity. The model counts the flywheel as stopped below 1% of the start, and friction turns that last bit into thermal energy. At 90% and 90%, 81% is left after one trip and about 35% after five; it stops after about 22 trips. At 99% and 99% it takes about 229 trips.
- With reduced motion, each run is worked out at once and the drawing shows how it ends; on screens 1 and 2 each change runs the model on at once, and the Run on button runs it further.
Where sources disagree and what to check
- Coal-fired stations: OpenStax gives “about 40%” in its text on conservation of energy, “35 to 40%” for “the typical electric power plant” in its section on power, and 42% in its table and its section on heat engines. Energy Education gives 32% to 42% for coal and natural gas power plants, so 42% is the top of its range. Screen 1 uses 40%, from OpenStax’s 2500 MW example; screens 2 and 3 use 42%.
- Electric heaters: screen 8’s rule that every real change of form loses some energy as thermal energy is about devices whose job is something other than heating. An electric heater turns nearly all of its electrical energy into thermal energy, which is what it is for, and OpenStax’s table gives 90% for a residential gas heater.
- Solar cells: OpenStax’s table gives 10% for a solar cell. Your Home (2023) gives 15 to 20% for monocrystalline cells and 13 to 17% for polycrystalline cells. The lesson uses Your Home’s figures.
- Wind: the Betz limit of 59.3% is the theoretical maximum, and Energy Education gives 35 to 45% as common efficiencies for real turbines.
- The electric motor’s 98% is OpenStax’s representative value for electric motors in general, not a figure for car motors.
- Screen 2 calls hydroelectric stations the most efficient in the lesson’s sources. The US Bureau of Reclamation pamphlet calls hydroelectric powerplants “the most efficient means of producing electric energy”.
Answers at a glance
- Screen 1: 2500 − 1000 = 1500 MW to the air; 1000 ÷ 2500 = 40%. q-law the total energy stays the same; q-plantwaste in the surroundings, as thermal energy; n-planteff 1260 ÷ 3000 = 42%.
- Screen 2: 100 ÷ 0.42 ≈ 238 MJ (coal-fired); 100 ÷ 0.90 ≈ 111 MJ (hydroelectric); efficiency is only one thing to weigh. q-mosteff hydroelectric; q-renew sunlight is renewable, so a lower efficiency means a bigger panel; n-hydroin 450 ÷ 0.90 = 500 MJ.
- Screen 3: petrol car 0.30 × 100 = 30 MJ; electric car 0.42 × 0.98 × 100 ≈ 41 MJ; the model leaves out the power lines and the battery. q-chain 25%; n-chain 0.90 × 0.98 × 100 = 88.2 MJ; q-lines the lines turn some electrical energy into thermal energy.
- Screen 4: useful work 350 × 234 × 60 = 4,914,000 J = 4914 kJ; food energy 4914 ÷ 0.20 = 24,570 kJ; thermal energy 24,570 − 4914 = 19,656 kJ. q-bodyheat most of the food energy becomes thermal energy; n-food 60 ÷ 0.20 = 300 kJ; q-better the 25% cyclist uses less food energy.
- Screen 5: 3 ÷ 20 = 15% with the pit open; 7 ÷ 20 = 35% covered, with stones above and below; 20 − 7 = 13 MJ didn’t reach the food. q-both heat flows in from both sides; q-lid it acts as a lid that keeps the heat in; q-flow from the hot stones into the cooler food, soil and air.
- Screen 6: Fridge P 420 × 0.307 × 10 = $1289.40; Fridge Q 380 × 0.307 × 10 = $1166.60; the stars compare fridges of a similar size, and Fridge P is bigger. q-stars efficiency compared with models of a similar size and features; q-kwh the energy consumption; n-cost 150 × 0.307 = $46.05.
- Screen 7: the outputs add to 65 W, more than 60 W; fixed, 5 W of light and 55 W of thermal energy; efficiency 5 ÷ 60 ≈ 8.3%. The four diagrams: the globe’s outputs become 5 W and 55 W; the engine’s widths are swapped; the station’s caption becomes 40%; the cyclist needs an 80 kJ thermal energy arrow beside 20 kJ of useful work. q-addup 110 J out, 100 J in; q-width the thermal energy arrow; n-globe 6 ÷ 40 = 15%.
- Screen 8: one trip 0.9 × 0.9 = 81%; five trips 0.81⁵ ≈ 35%; it can’t run forever. q-forever each machine turns some energy into thermal energy; q-unavail spread out as thermal energy in the room; q-saving no, saving energy means using less.
- Printable sheet, problem 1: sunlight on the panels at most 1.3 kW per square metre × 30 m² = 39 kW (OpenStax); 20% of that is 7.8 kW, which is more than the hall’s 6 kW, but only on a clear day with the sun high, and the other 31.2 kW isn’t turned into electricity. Your Home says a panel’s rated output is what it achieves in perfect laboratory conditions, and that heat, shade, dirt and the panels’ angle reduce it, so in practice the margin is small. Problem 2: each rider does 150 W × 1200 s = 180 kJ of useful work, uses 180 ÷ 0.20 = 900 kJ of food energy and makes 720 kJ of thermal energy in their body; 20 riders make 14,400 kJ, about 14.4 MJ, in 20 minutes. For step 5: the useful work ends up as thermal energy too, in the bikes, so the room gains about 18 MJ in all. Kettle practical: energy supplied = power rating × time; energy to the water = mass × 4186 × temperature rise (OpenStax gives 4186 J per kg per °C for water); the rest of the energy warms the kettle itself, the air around it and any steam.
Saved progress
Answers, problem steps and settings are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere.
References
- Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) (2022). Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Years 7 to 10 curriculum content. Australian Curriculum website.
- Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) (n.d.). Investigating the efficiency of ground ovens used by First Nations Australians (Science Teacher Background Information, AC9S9U05_E4).
- Energy Education (n.d.). Betz limit and Efficiency. University of Calgary.
- Energy Rating (n.d.). Understand the Energy Rating Label. Australian Government.
- Heller, K. and Heller, P. (2010). Cooperative Problem Solving in Physics: A User’s Manual. Why? What? How?. University of Minnesota. PDF at aapt.org.
- Heller, P. and Hollabaugh, M. (1992). Teaching problem solving through cooperative grouping. Part 2: Designing problems and structuring groups. American Journal of Physics, 60(7), 637–644. https://doi.org/10.1119/1.17118.
- Heller, P., Keith, R. and Anderson, S. (1992). Teaching problem solving through cooperative grouping. Part 1: Group versus individual problem solving. American Journal of Physics, 60(7), 627–636. https://doi.org/10.1119/1.17117.
- PhysPort (n.d.). Context-Rich Problems.
- University of Minnesota Physics Education Research and Development Group (n.d.). Creating context rich problems.
- Urone, P. P. and Hinrichs, R. (2022). College Physics 2e. OpenStax. Sections 7.6 Conservation of energy, 7.7 Power, 7.8 Work, energy, and power in humans, 7.9 World energy use, 14.2 Temperature change and heat capacity, 15.4 Carnot’s perfect heat engine: the second law of thermodynamics restated and 15.6 Entropy and the second law of thermodynamics: disorder and the unavailability of energy, and the end-of-chapter pages Chapter 7 Problems & Exercises (problem 55, the Daedalus 88) and Chapter 15 Conceptual Questions (question 8, perpetual motion).
- US Bureau of Reclamation (n.d.). Hydroelectric power (pamphlet).
- Your Home, Australian Government (2023). Photovoltaic systems.
Sources by screen
- Method: Heller, Keith and Anderson (1992); Heller and Hollabaugh (1992); Heller and Heller (2010); University of Minnesota Physics Education Research and Development Group; PhysPort.
- Screen 1: OpenStax College Physics 2e, 7.6 (the law of conservation of energy, efficiency and the coal-fired plant) and 7.7 (the watt, the 2500 MW example and typical power plants).
- Screen 2: OpenStax College Physics 2e, 7.9 (renewable sources and carbon dioxide) and 15.4 (the efficiencies of coal, oil, gas and nuclear power stations); US Bureau of Reclamation (hydroelectric); Energy Education (wind); Your Home (solar cells).
- Screen 3: OpenStax College Physics 2e, 7.6 (the table of efficiencies) and 7.7 (no complete change of form); Energy Education (losses in power lines); US Bureau of Reclamation (hydroelectric); Your Home (solar cells).
- Screen 4: OpenStax College Physics 2e, 7.6 (the table of efficiencies) and 7.8 (energy in the human body), and the chapter 7 problems and exercises, problem 55 (the Daedalus 88 flight).
- Screen 5: ACARA, Science Teacher Background Information, AC9S9U05_E4.
- Screen 6: Energy Rating; OpenStax College Physics 2e, 7.7 (kilowatt-hours) and 7.9 (energy conservation and the law of conservation of energy).
- Screen 7: OpenStax College Physics 2e, 7.6 and 7.7; ACARA (AC9S9I04).
- Screen 8: OpenStax College Physics 2e, 7.7 (waste heat), 7.9 (the law of conservation of energy), 15.6 (entropy), and the chapter 15 conceptual questions, question 8 (the perpetual-motion machine).
- Printable sheet: OpenStax College Physics 2e, 7.6 (cycling), 7.7 (sunlight’s power) and 14.2 (the specific heat of water); Your Home (solar cells).
- Word list: the sources for the screen where each word is first used.