AusSci

Year 9 science · Biological sciences · AC9S9U02

Why have two parents?

1Clones

One banana, one disease

Why could one disease wipe out a whole banana farm?

Within Australia, over 95 per cent of the bananas grown in commercial plantations are one variety, Cavendish. Cavendish plants are grown from small suckers that sprout from the base of another plant, and more recently by tissue culture (University of Queensland). In 1997 a soil fungus that causes Panama disease tropical race 4, or TR4, was found near Darwin, and it mostly decimated the commercial banana industry in the Northern Territory (Queensland Government).

How this lesson works. On every screen you will read a fact and be asked why it would be true. Write your own answer first, then compare it with the reason given. In a study with 140 Grade 6 and 7 students, those who answered ‘why’ questions about science facts remembered the facts better than students who only read them (Woloshyn). Answering works best when you already know something about the topic (Dunlosky and colleagues), so use what you saw in the simulation.

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Write your answer to the why question, then compare it with the source.
  3. Answer the two questions in Explain it, then read the key idea.

The simulation is a model field of 24 banana plants, not real banana data. Each plant carries one of three types of a made-up gene, A, B or C, and each made-up disease kills the plants of one type. Plant the field from suckers or from seed, then bring in a disease.

A model banana field

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you answer the why question. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Plant the field from suckers, then bring in the disease that attacks the parent’s type.

    Need a hint?

    Choose From suckers and a parent, press Plant the field, then choose the disease for that type and press Bring in the disease.

  2. Plant a field from seed and bring in the same disease. Compare how many plants survive.

    Need a hint?

    Choose From seed, press Plant the field, then press Bring in the disease.

  3. Find a disease that a field grown from suckers survives completely, then one that kills every plant in it.

    Need a hint?

    Plant from suckers of a type B parent. Try the disease that attacks type A, then plant again and try the one that attacks type B.

Talk about it. Why did every plant in the sucker field share the same fate? What would a banana grower need, to stop one disease wiping out a whole farm?

Why would that be?

Do the first try-it task in the picture, then come back here.

The fact. Cavendish banana plants are grown from small suckers that sprout from the base of another plant, and more recently by tissue culture (University of Queensland). Panama disease TR4 attacks Cavendish (Queensland Government).

Plants grown from suckers are clones

Growing new plants from suckers is asexual reproduction, which has one parent and gives offspring that are genetically identical to it, clones (University of Queensland, OpenStax). A field of clones has no variation, so a disease that can attack one plant can attack every plant, and a disease that can’t attack one can’t attack any. Plants grown from seed take genes from two parents, so they vary, and some may have a type the disease can’t attack. Real Cavendish plants are sterile (University of Queensland), so a grower can’t raise a varied crop of them from seed, and TR4 attacks nearly all varieties of bananas (Queensland Government). The field grown from seed only models what variation does.

A grower plants 100 suckers taken from one banana plant. How do the new plants’ genes compare with the parent’s?

Why is Panama disease TR4 such a threat to Cavendish farms?

2Plants

Plants that copy themselves

How do plants make new plants without seeds?

Many plants can reproduce in two ways. Flowers make seeds, which is sexual reproduction. Runners, tubers, bulbs and rhizomes make new plants with no flowers or seeds, which is asexual reproduction, and growers copy plants on purpose by taking cuttings or by grafting (OpenStax).

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Write your answer to the why question, then compare it with the source.
  3. Answer the two questions in Explain it, then read the key idea.

Choose a plant and grow new plants from it. The three coloured bands under each plant stand for its genes, as in the model on screen 1: plants with matching bands have the same genes. Then grow the same kind of plant from seed, with a second parent, and compare.

A garden of copies and seedlings

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you answer the why question. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Grow new strawberry plants from runners.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Strawberry, then press Grow from runners.

  2. Grow the same kind of plant from seed, and compare the new plants’ genes with the copies.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Strawberry, Potato or Daffodil, press Grow from seed, and look at the bands of genes under each new plant.

  3. Graft a citrus variety onto a root stock.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Citrus tree, then press Graft onto a root stock.

Talk about it. Which new plants had exactly the parent’s genes, and why? When would a grower want copies, and when would they want variety?

Why would that be?

Do the first try-it task in the picture, then come back here.

The fact. Growers graft the stem of the citrus variety they want onto the roots of another plant, a root stock chosen for its resistance to disease (OpenStax).

Copies from stems, variety from seeds

Runners, tubers, bulbs and rhizomes are parts of a plant that can grow into new plants, and cuttings are a way growers do the same on purpose (OpenStax). These are asexual reproduction, which produces plants that are genetically identical to the parent plant, because no male and female gametes mix (OpenStax). Grafting is asexual too: the grafted stem keeps the genes of the variety it came from, and the roots keep the root stock’s. Seeds usually come from sexual reproduction in flowers. A seedling from cross-pollination has genes from two parent plants, so it can differ from both.

A farmer plants pieces of potato, each with an eye. What will the new plants be like?

Why do citrus growers graft a fruit variety onto a different root stock?

3Flowers

A flower at work

How do the parts of a flower work together to make seeds?

A flower is a plant’s reproductive system. Its stamens make pollen in their anthers, and its carpel, a stigma, a style and an ovary, holds the ovules (OpenStax). Pollination is the transfer of pollen from an anther to a stigma; cross-pollination brings pollen from a flower on a different plant of the same species (OpenStax).

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Write your answer to the why question, then compare it with the source.
  3. Answer the two questions in Explain it, then read the key idea.

The simulation shows a flower cut in half. Choose where the pollen comes from and pollinate the flower, then grow a pollen tube to each ovule. Switch the flower type to compare a flower pollinated by bees with one pollinated by wind.

A flower cut in half

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you answer the why question. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Pollinate the flower with pollen from another plant of the same kind.

    Need a hint?

    Under Pollen from, choose Another plant, then press Pollinate.

  2. Grow a pollen tube down to an ovule and fertilise it.

    Need a hint?

    After pollinating, press Grow a pollen tube until it reaches an ovule.

  3. Fertilise all four ovules and let the flower turn into a fruit.

    Need a hint?

    Grow a pollen tube to each ovule, then press Let it ripen.

Talk about it. Which parts of the flower make the pollen, and which parts receive it? What does each part of the carpel turn into?

Why would that be?

Do the first try-it task in the picture, then come back here.

The fact. Bees can’t see the colour red, and flowers pollinated by bees are usually blue, yellow or other colours (OpenStax).

From pollen to seed and fruit

Pollen made in the anthers lands on the sticky stigma. A pollen tube grows from the pollen grain down the style to an ovule, and the pollen grain forms the sperm that fertilises the egg (OpenStax). Each fertilised ovule develops into a seed, and the ovary’s walls thicken to form the fruit around the seeds (OpenStax).

What is pollination?

After fertilisation, what do the ovules and the ovary become?

4Sperm and eggs

Built for the job

How does the shape of a sperm cell and an egg cell suit its job?

Gametes are the cells of sexual reproduction. In humans they are sperm cells and egg cells, and each carries 23 chromosomes, so that a fertilised egg has all 46, half of them from the sperm (OpenStax). The two cells look very different, and each of their parts has a job.

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Write your answer to the why question, then compare it with the source.
  3. Answer the two questions in Explain it, then read the key idea.

Choose a cell, then hide one part at a time and read what the cell couldn’t do without it. The cells are drawn far larger than life. The egg is drawn bigger than the sperm, but not to scale.

A sperm cell and an egg cell

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you answer the why question. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Find the part of the sperm cell that moves it.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Sperm cell, then hide one part at a time and read what the sperm couldn’t do.

  2. Find the part that gets the sperm through the coverings around the egg.

    Need a hint?

    Look at the parts of the head.

  3. Look at the egg cell and find out why it is so much bigger than the sperm.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Egg cell and look at its cytoplasm.

Talk about it. How does each part of the sperm cell help it do its job? Why does the egg not need a flagellum?

Why would that be?

Do the first try-it task in the picture, then come back here.

The fact. The midpiece of a sperm cell is packed with mitochondria (OpenStax).

Each part has a job

A sperm cell is built to move and to get into the egg: a flagellum to move it, mitochondria in the midpiece to supply the energy for the flagellum, the genetic material in the head, and an acrosome with enzymes that digest the protective coverings around the egg (OpenStax). An egg cell can’t move by itself. When it forms, it gets most of the cytoplasm and its contents, and it is much larger than a sperm cell (OpenStax). After fertilisation, that one large cell divides into many smaller cells without any increase in mass (OpenStax).

Which part of a sperm cell moves it?

What does the acrosome at the top of a sperm cell’s head do?

5Human systems

Two systems, one job

How do the organs of the human reproductive systems work together?

In the male reproductive system, the testes make sperm, and a series of tubes and glands carries them out of the body. In the female reproductive system, the ovaries release eggs, the oviducts carry an egg to the uterus, the uterus supports a developing embryo, and the vagina is the birth canal (OpenStax). The organs of each system work together, passing the cells from one to the next.

About this screen. The diagrams are simple plans of the reproductive organs, and they use the proper names that doctors and biology books use. If you have a question you would rather not ask in front of the class, write it down and give it to your teacher.

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Write your answer to the why question, then compare it with the source.
  3. Answer the two questions in Explain it, then read the key idea.

Follow a sperm and an egg through the two systems, one step at a time. Each step names the organ and says what it does. The diagrams are plans, not to scale, and they leave out organs that aren’t part of the path.

The human reproductive systems

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you answer the why question. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Follow a sperm from where it is made to where it leaves the body.

    Need a hint?

    Press Follow a sperm, then Next step until the path ends.

  2. Follow an egg from the ovary to the uterus.

    Need a hint?

    Press Follow an egg, then Next step.

  3. Find the organ where fertilisation usually happens.

    Need a hint?

    Follow the egg and read each step. Then choose that organ under Where do they meet?

Talk about it. How does each organ pass the sperm or the egg on to the next one? Why does it matter that the egg can’t move by itself?

Why would that be?

Do the first try-it task in the picture, then come back here.

The fact. The testes hang outside the body in the scrotum (OpenStax).

Fertilisation happens in an oviduct

Sperm are made in the testes, which are held outside the body in the scrotum because they must be about 2 °C cooler than body temperature to produce viable sperm. The sperm pass through the epididymis and the sperm duct, the seminal vesicles and the prostate add fluid, and semen leaves through the urethra (OpenStax). An egg released from an ovary is helped into an oviduct by the fimbriae. Fertilisation happens soon after the egg leaves the ovary, and the embryo implants in the lining of the uterus eight or nine days later (OpenStax).

Why are the testes held outside the body, in the scrotum?

Where does fertilisation usually happen in humans?

6Variation

Why two parents?

How does sexual reproduction help a species survive change?

Asexual reproduction has real advantages. One animal can have young without a mate, and an asexual population could grow twice as fast as a sexual one (OpenStax). Yet most eukaryotes, the living things whose cells have a nucleus, can reproduce sexually, and in many animals it is the only way they reproduce (OpenStax). OpenStax gives several possible explanations, and one is the variation that sexual reproduction creates among the offspring.

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Write your answer to the why question, then compare it with the source.
  3. Answer the two questions in Explain it, then read the key idea.

The simulation is a model with two populations of a made-up animal. Each animal has three genes, shown as three coloured bands, and each gene comes in two forms. Each female has four young a generation. The asexual population is all female, and its young are copies of their mother. In the sexual population half the animals are male, and each young takes each gene from its mother or from its father. Food limits each population to 64.

Two populations and a disease

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you answer the why question. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Run both populations for three generations with no disease.

    Need a hint?

    Press Next generation three times and compare the two counts.

  2. Bring in a disease and run two more generations.

    Need a hint?

    Choose a disease, press Bring in the disease, then press Next generation twice.

  3. Find a disease the asexual population survives, and one it doesn’t.

    Need a hint?

    Press Start again between tries, and try each disease on the third generation.

Talk about it. Which population grew faster at first, and why? Which one could survive whichever disease came, and why?

Why would that be?

Do the first try-it task in the picture, then come back here.

The fact. An asexual population could grow twice as fast as a sexual one, because every individual can have young, while in a sexual population the males don’t produce the offspring themselves (OpenStax).

Variety helps a species survive change

In the model, the clones all share one set of genes, so a disease that kills one of them kills them all, and a disease that spares one spares them all. Sexual reproduction combines genetic material from two parents, so the offspring vary, and that variety is thought to give the species a better chance of surviving in a changing environment (OpenStax). OpenStax says that asexually reproducing species may be at a disadvantage in an unstable or unpredictable environment, because all the offspring are genetically identical and may not have the variation to survive new conditions.

Which kind of reproduction gives offspring that differ from each other?

Why could an asexual population grow twice as fast as a sexual one?

7Animals

Water or land?

How are animals’ ways of reproducing related to where they live?

Some animals release eggs and sperm into the water, so that fertilisation happens outside the body; in others the eggs are fertilised inside the female’s body (OpenStax). Some invertebrates, animals without a backbone, such as corals and sea stars, can also reproduce asexually, by budding or fragmentation, and some insects by parthenogenesis (OpenStax).

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Write your answer to the why question, then compare it with the source.
  3. Answer the two questions in Explain it, then read the key idea.

Choose each animal, read how it reproduces, and put it in a group. Some animals fit more than one group, and the words will say so. Then show where each one lives.

Eight animals found in Australia

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you answer the why question. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Sort all eight animals by how they reproduce.

    Need a hint?

    Choose an animal, read about it, then press the group it fits. Some animals fit more than one group.

  2. Show where each animal lives, and find what the animals fertilised outside the body have in common.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Where it lives under Show, after sorting.

  3. Find the animal that lives in the sea but lays its eggs on land, and how its eggs are fertilised.

    Need a hint?

    Look for an animal that nests on a beach.

Talk about it. Why do the animals that release eggs and sperm into the water live in water? Which of the eight can reproduce asexually, and how?

Why would that be?

Do the first try-it task in the picture, then come back here.

The fact. External fertilisation, where eggs and sperm are released and meet outside the body, usually happens in water (OpenStax).

Breeding in water or on land

External fertilisation usually happens in water, which keeps the eggs from drying out, and most of it happens by spawning, when females and males release eggs and sperm in the same place at the same time (OpenStax). Internal fertilisation happens most often in land animals, and it protects the fertilised egg from drying out on land (OpenStax). A green turtle lives in the sea but lays its eggs on a beach, and its eggs are fertilised inside its body (Queensland Government, Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority). Asexual reproduction happens in some invertebrates, such as corals, sea stars and stick insects, and some vertebrates, such as certain reptiles, amphibians and fish, reproduce by parthenogenesis (OpenStax).

Where does external fertilisation usually happen?

What is one advantage of internal fertilisation for an animal that lays its eggs on land?

8Care

Many eggs or much care?

Why do some animals have millions of young and others only one?

A large female crown-of-thorns starfish can release over 200 million eggs a year (AIMS). A red kangaroo has one baby at a time (Australian Museum). Put five animals found in Australia on a chart of how many eggs or young they have and how much care they give, and look for the pattern.

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Write your answer to the why question, then compare it with the source.
  3. Answer the two questions in Explain it, then read the key idea and the answer to the lesson’s question.

Choose an animal and read its facts. Choose its care and its number of eggs or young, and put it on the chart. Each line up the chart is ten times the line below it.

Young and care

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you answer the why question. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Put the crown-of-thorns starfish on the chart.

    Need a hint?

    Choose the crown-of-thorns starfish, then choose its care and its number of eggs, and press Put it on the chart.

  2. Put all five animals on the chart and read the pattern.

    Need a hint?

    Read each animal’s facts first: they give the care and the number.

  3. Work out how many adults a clutch of turtle eggs gives.

    Need a hint?

    Answer the question under the chart once the turtle is on it.

Talk about it. What pattern does the chart show? Why does an animal that gives a lot of care not need millions of young?

Why would that be?

Do the first try-it task in the picture, then come back here.

The fact. A large female crown-of-thorns starfish can release over 200 million eggs a year (AIMS), but a red kangaroo has one baby at a time (Australian Museum).

More care, fewer young

Across the five animals, the more care the parents give, the fewer eggs or young they have, and OpenStax gives the same pattern for animals in general. Animals that produce large numbers of young usually give them little if any care: a cane toad lays up to 35,000 eggs in a clutch (Queensland Government), and a large crown-of-thorns starfish can release over 200 million eggs a year (AIMS). Those young are small and easily eaten by predators, so producing many of them lets enough survive to keep the species going (OpenStax). Animals with few young, such as kangaroos, usually give them a lot of care (OpenStax). A green turtle buries its eggs in the sand and leaves them, and as few as 1 in 1,000 hatchlings survive to adulthood (Queensland Government).

Back to the question: why have two parents?

Sexual reproduction has costs. An asexual population could grow twice as fast, and an animal that reproduces asexually needs no mate (OpenStax). On screens 1 and 6, a population of clones lived or died together, because every member had the same genes. Sexual reproduction gives each offspring a new mix of genes from two parents, and that variety is thought to give the species a better chance of surviving in a changing environment (OpenStax).

Animals that give their young a lot of care usually have

Why does a crown-of-thorns starfish release so many eggs?

Printable activity

A flower at work, and many eggs or much care

Two pages. Page 1 has a flower to label and the steps from pollen to fruit to put in order. Page 2 has ways of reproducing to sort, and five animals found in Australia to put on a chart of young and care.

For teachers

Curriculum

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 9, Science understanding, Biological sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:

AC9S9U02 describe the form and function of reproductive cells and organs in animals and plants, and analyse how the processes of sexual and asexual reproduction enable survival of the species

  • examining how the male and female reproductive organ structures work collectively as a system
  • explaining how the forms of male and female gametes relate to their specific function
  • identifying and comparing sexual and asexual reproductive strategies in plants
  • exploring how sexual reproduction creates a greater rate of variation among offspring compared with asexual reproduction
  • examining how the reproductive strategies of multicellular animals are related to their environment and the complexity of the organism
  • examining how the number of offspring produced by animals is related to the amount of parental care

The second quote gives all six of ACARA’s elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each part of the content description is covered on these screens:

  • The form and function of reproductive cells and organs in plants and animals: the flower on screen 3, the sperm cell and the egg cell on screen 4 and the human reproductive systems on screen 5; q-pollinate, q-fruit, q-flagellum, q-acrosome, q-testes and q-meet.
  • How sexual and asexual reproduction enable survival of the species: the banana field on screen 1, the garden on screen 2, the population model on screen 6 and the chart of young and care on screen 8; q-clone, q-tr4, q-tuber, q-graft, q-vary, q-twice, q-care and q-many.
  • The elaborations, in ACARA’s order. Male and female reproductive organs working as a system is screen 5, with the flower as a plant’s system on screen 3. The forms of male and female gametes and their functions is screen 4. Sexual and asexual strategies in plants is screen 2, with the bananas on screen 1. Variation among offspring from sexual and asexual reproduction is screens 1, 2 and 6. Animals’ reproductive strategies, their environment and the complexity of the animal is screen 7, which relates each animal’s way of reproducing to where it breeds and shows asexual reproduction in coral, the sea star and the spiny leaf insect; the lesson doesn’t go further into complexity. The number of offspring and the amount of parental care is screen 8.

AC9S9I01 develop investigable questions, reasoned predictions and hypotheses to test relationships and develop explanatory models

AC9S9I04 select and construct appropriate representations, including tables, graphs, descriptive statistics, models and mathematical relationships, to organise and process data and information

AC9S9I05 analyse and connect a variety of data and information to identify and explain patterns, trends, relationships and anomalies

It builds on Year 3’s AC9S3U01, “compare characteristics of living and non-living things and examine the differences between the life cycles of plants and animals”, which the site’s Year 3 living things lesson teaches, and Year 8’s AC9S8U01, “recognise cells as the basic units of living things, compare plant and animal cells, and describe the functions of specialised cell structures and organelles”, which the site’s Year 8 cells lesson teaches. It leads to Year 10’s AC9S10U01, “explain the role of meiosis and mitosis and the function of chromosomes, DNA and genes in heredity and predict patterns of Mendelian inheritance”, which the site’s Year 10 inheritance lesson teaches, and AC9S10U02, “use the theory of evolution by natural selection to explain past and present diversity and analyse the scientific evidence supporting the theory”, which the site’s Year 10 evolution lesson teaches.

None of AC9S9U02’s elaborations is about First Nations Australians, so the lesson has no First Nations content.

How the lesson is taught

The method is elaborative interrogation. In Dunlosky and colleagues’ review of learning techniques, “the key to elaborative interrogation involves prompting learners to generate an explanation for an explicitly stated fact.” Every screen has a “Why would that be?” box: it states a fact about a plant’s or an animal’s form or way of reproducing, asks why the fact would be true, and waits for the student to write an answer of at least four words. Only then can the student see the reason, which gives the sources’ facts and the lesson’s reasoning from them, and they say how close their answer was. The Explain it card opens after that, and checks the explanation with two multiple-choice questions. The why box opens after the first try-it task, so students have something to reason from when they answer.

The research behind it. Dunlosky and colleagues rated elaborative interrogation as having moderate utility, and they write that its effects “generally increase as prior knowledge increases” and that “The benefit for lower-knowledge learners is less certain.” In Woloshyn’s study, 140 students in Grades 6 and 7 processed science facts, half of them facts that went against common misconceptions; the students who answered why questions “performed significantly better on all memory measures than did reading-controls”. Boudreau and colleagues found that elaborative interrogation worked better when the main ideas were underlined in advance, and when specific why questions were given as well. Each box here states one fact and asks one why question about it.

Its limits. Dunlosky and colleagues give the most common materials in the studies as “sets of facts about various familiar and unfamiliar animals”, and say that elaborative interrogation has “not been adequately evaluated in educational contexts”. Boudreau and colleagues’ university students, working without support on an eight-page passage, had difficulty recognising its main ideas. In Woloshyn’s study, all students found facts that addressed common misconceptions harder than new facts. So the lesson keeps each box to one short fact, puts it after the simulation, and checks the explanation afterwards. Expect some students to write very little at first. Before screen 1’s box, model one answer aloud, and treat Different as useful, because the difference shows the student what to fix.

Handle with care

  • The human reproductive systems. Check your school’s policy for teaching screen 5, including whether families are told beforehand. The diagrams are plans of the reproductive organs, labelled with their proper names, and the screen keeps to how sperm and eggs are made and meet. Students’ bodies, families and experiences differ, so keep examples general, and give students a way to ask questions privately, as the box on the screen suggests. If a student discloses something personal, follow your school’s procedures; the Western Australian Department of Health’s guidance for teachers says all staff must know them, and their legal responsibilities.
  • Flowers in class. If students cut flowers open, check for pollen allergies first, choose flowers you know are safe to handle, and have students wash their hands afterwards.
  • Bananas in Queensland and the Northern Territory. Panama disease TR4 is caused by a fungus that lives in the soil, and anything that moves or harbours soil and water can spread it (Queensland Government). Don’t bring banana plants, soil or farm equipment from a banana-growing area into class.

About the models

Screen 1. The field is a model, not real banana data, and the words say so. Each plant has one made-up gene of type A, B or C, and each made-up disease kills one type. The real TR4 fungus invades the roots of banana plants, limiting their supply of water and nutrients (Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry), and it attacks nearly all varieties of bananas (Queensland Government). The seed field shows what variation does; it isn’t a way to grow Cavendish, which is sterile (University of Queensland). The disease spreads from one corner in waves, one step of distance at a time, and the field grown from seed is the same every time: 8 plants of type A, 9 of type B and 7 of type C.

Screen 2. The three bands under each plant are a picture of its genes, as on screen 1. A copy has exactly its parent’s bands, and a seedling takes each band from one parent or the other. Ginger and the citrus tree are shown only with their asexual methods.

Screen 3. The flower has one carpel with four ovules, and in the model each ovule is fertilised by its own pollen tube. Switching to a flower pollinated by wind changes the picture to OpenStax’s description: usually green and small, with small petals or none, and large amounts of pollen.

Screen 4. The cells are drawn far larger than life, and the egg is drawn bigger than the sperm but not to scale. OpenStax describes its micrograph of a sperm touching an egg as showing an egg much larger than the sperm, but no reliable source found for this lesson gives the sizes of human eggs and sperm, so the lesson gives no numbers. Biology 2e calls the part of the sperm that holds the mitochondria the neck; the lesson calls it the midpiece, as OpenStax’s Anatomy and Physiology does. Hiding a part asks what the cell couldn’t do without it; the words for that are the lesson’s reasoning from what OpenStax says each part does.

Screen 5. The diagrams are front-view plans, not to scale. The male plan shows the organs on the sperm’s path, with the bladder added for position. The female plan shows the organs on the egg’s path, which ends at the uterus, and the cervix and vagina below it.

Screen 6. The model’s rules are on the screen. Each female has four young a generation, so the asexual population, all female, grows four times each generation while the sexual population, half male, doubles; food stops each at 64. The sexual population’s young take each gene from the mother or the father at random, with a fixed seed, so pressing Start again repeats the same run. The asexual population’s genes are the same in every animal, so Disease 1 wipes it out and Diseases 2 and 3 leave it untouched. Real animals have far more than three genes.

Screen 7. The three groups are the lesson’s. Three animals fit two groups: coral and the sea star spawn and can also reproduce asexually, and a female spiny leaf insect can lay eggs after mating or without mating. The words give each animal’s facts from its source.

Screen 8. The care levels are the lesson’s four groups, and the chart’s scale goes up ten times at each line. Each animal’s number is its eggs or young per breeding, from its source: for the crown-of-thorns starfish it is a year’s eggs, and for the turtle one clutch.

Where sources disagree and what to check

  • Crown-of-thorns starfish eggs. AIMS’s current page says a large female “can release over 200 million eggs a year”; an older AIMS information sheet says a female “can produce up to 50 million eggs a year”. The chart uses the current page’s figure, in the top band, 100 million or more. The older figure is one band lower, 10 million to 99 million, and still the highest on the chart.
  • Cane toad eggs. The Queensland Government says a female lays up to 35,000 eggs in a single clutch; the Australian Government’s 2010 fact sheet says females can lay 8,000 to 30,000 eggs at a time. The chart uses 35,000. 35,000 and 30,000 are in the same band of the chart, 10,000 to 99,999, and 8,000 is one band lower.
  • Green turtle clutches. The Queensland Government gives about 115 eggs per clutch, as the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority does for green turtles. On clutches in a season they differ: the Queensland Government says females may lay up to 6 times, and the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority says three to seven. The chart uses one clutch.
  • Why the testes are outside the body. Biology 2e says sperm are immobile at body temperature, and also that the testes must be about 2 °C cooler than body temperature to produce viable sperm. Anatomy and Physiology says sperm production proceeds more efficiently when the testes are 2 to 4 °C below core body temperature. The lesson gives only the reason about producing sperm.
  • The platypus. The Australian Museum says the female incubates the eggs “for possibly 10 days”, so the incubation time isn’t certain.
  • Bananas. The University of Queensland article gives Cavendish as over 95 per cent of the bananas grown in Australia’s commercial plantations. Check the Queensland Government’s Panama disease page for where TR4 has been found since; on 18 November 2026 it said TR4 had been found on farms in the Tully Valley.

Answers at a glance

Screen 1: a field grown from suckers of one parent is all that parent’s type, so the disease for that type kills all 24 and the others kill none; the field grown from seed loses only the plants of the type attacked. Screen 2: runners, tubers, bulbs and rhizomes give copies with the parent’s bands; a graft joins the variety’s stem to the root stock’s roots; seedlings have mixed bands. Screen 3: pollen must reach the stigma, a pollen tube grows down the style to each ovule, fertilised ovules become seeds and the ovary becomes the fruit. Screen 4: the flagellum moves the sperm, the mitochondria in the midpiece supply the energy for it, the acrosome gets it through the egg’s coverings, and the egg is bigger because it gets most of the cytoplasm. Screen 5: the testes are outside the body because they must be about 2 °C cooler to produce viable sperm; sperm go from the testes through the epididymis, sperm duct and urethra; an egg goes from the ovary past the fimbriae into the oviduct, where fertilisation happens, then to the uterus. Screen 6: Disease 1 wipes out the asexual population; Diseases 2 and 3 leave it untouched; the sexual population survives all three. Screen 7: coral, the crown-of-thorns starfish, the sea star and the cane toad are fertilised outside the body, and all four breed in water; coral, the sea star and the spiny leaf insect can also reproduce asexually; the turtle lives in the sea but nests on land, with internal fertilisation. Screen 8: the more care, the fewer young, because young left on their own are small and easily eaten, so many are needed for enough to survive; a clutch of 115 turtle eggs gives fewer than one adult on average if 1 in 1,000 hatchlings survive.

Saved progress

Answers, choices, notes, settings and the try-it tasks are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere. If students share devices, clear the saved answers between them.

References

Sources by screen

  • Screen 1: the University of Queensland (Cavendish, suckers, tissue culture and sterile fruit); the Queensland Government (TR4 near Darwin in 1997, the Northern Territory, Cavendish, the soil fungus, the Tully Valley); the Department of Agriculture, Fisheries and Forestry (the fungus in the roots); Biology 2e 43.1 (asexual reproduction and clones) and 32.3 (tissue culture as asexual reproduction).
  • Screen 2: Biology 2e 32.3 (runners, tubers, bulbs, rhizomes, cuttings and grafting, and plants genetically identical to the parent); Biology 2e 43.1 (genetic material from two individuals).
  • Screen 3: Biology 2e 32.1 (stamens, anthers and carpels) and 32.2 (pollination, cross-pollination, the pollen tube, the seed, bees, nectar guides and wind); Concepts of Biology 14.4 (the style, the sticky stigma, nectar and fruit).
  • Screen 4: Biology 2e 43.3 (the sperm cell, the acrosome, the egg’s cytoplasm and 46 chromosomes), 11.1 (23 chromosomes in each gamete) and 43.6 (the egg much larger than the sperm, and the first cell divisions); Anatomy and Physiology 27.1 (the midpiece and its mitochondria powering the flagellum); Concepts of Biology 18.3 (the flagellum for moving).
  • Screen 5: Biology 2e 43.3 (the organs, what they do, the testes 2 °C cooler, the fimbriae, fertilisation in the oviducts and the week in the oviduct) and 43.5 (fertilisation soon after the egg leaves the ovary, and implantation); the Western Australian Department of Health (disclosures, in these notes).
  • Screen 6: Biology 2e 11.2 (why sexual reproduction is common, and an asexual population growing twice as fast); Biology 2e 43.1 (no mate needed, and advantages and disadvantages in a changing environment).
  • Screen 7: Biology 2e 43.1 (budding, fragmentation and parthenogenesis), 43.2 (external and internal fertilisation, spawning, toads, insects) and 28.7 (echinoderms spawning); the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority (coral spawning, marine turtles); AIMS (crown-of-thorns starfish); the Queensland Government (cane toads introduced in 1935, green turtles); the Australian Government (cane toads); the Australian Museum (stick and leaf insects, the platypus, the red kangaroo); Schneider and Elgar (the spiny leaf insect).
  • Screen 8: AIMS (crown-of-thorns starfish); the Queensland Government (cane toads, green turtles); Animal Diversity Web (cane toads); the Australian Museum (the platypus, the red kangaroo); the Great Barrier Reef Marine Park Authority (marine turtles); Biology 2e 45.2 (numbers of young, parental care and predation).
  • How the lesson is taught: Dunlosky and colleagues (2013); Woloshyn (1991); Boudreau and colleagues (1999).

Word list