AusSci

Year 10 science · Earth and space sciences · AC9S10U03

Has the universe always looked the same?

By the early 1930s astronomers knew that the galaxies are moving apart. In 1948 there were two leading models of the universe that explained this in different ways. In the big bang model, the universe was once extremely hot and dense, and it has been expanding and cooling ever since. In the steady state model, the universe has always looked much the same, because new matter forms new galaxies in the gaps as the old ones move apart. Which model fits the evidence?

Two models of the universe

Each window shows the same part of space in one of the models. Move the slider from 13.8 billion years ago to now, and compare the two windows.

The same part of space in two models

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Model A: the big bang

About 13.8 billion years ago the universe was extremely hot and dense. It has been expanding and cooling ever since, and stars and galaxies formed as it cooled (OpenStax). The universe changes with time.

Model B: the steady state

Hermann Bondi, Thomas Gold and Fred Hoyle put this model forward in 1948 (Britannica). The universe expands, but its average properties never change. New hydrogen atoms form all the time, in amounts far too small to see, and make new stars and galaxies in the gaps (Britannica). The universe has always looked the same.

My notebook: rate the two models

How plausible does each model seem to you right now? 1 means greatly implausible or even impossible, and 10 means highly plausible. There is no wrong answer yet. You will rate them again on screen 8.

Model A: the big bang
Model B: the steady state

How the lesson works

1 · Rate the models

You have just rated how plausible each model seems before you see any evidence.

2 · Link the evidence

Screens 2 and 3 give you the tools. On screens 4 to 7, decide whether each line of evidence supports, strongly supports, contradicts or has nothing to do with each model.

3 · Weigh it all up

On screen 8 your choices make a model-evidence link diagram. Compare it with an astronomer’s, explain two of your links and rate the models again.

Why link evidence to two models?

In a study in the United States, Grade 7 classes that linked four lines of evidence to two models of climate change changed their judgements more, and learned more, than classes that studied the same evidence without the two models. Six months later they still knew more (Lombardi and others, 2013).

What we are learning

How the big bang theory models the origin and evolution of the universe, and how four lines of evidence support it: the galaxies moving apart, a microwave glow from every direction, the amount of helium, and distant galaxies seen as they were long ago.

I can

  • 1describe the big bang model and the steady state model of the universe, and say how they differ.
  • 2use astronomical units, light-years and scientific notation to describe distances in the universe, and explain how brightness gives a star’s distance.
  • 3explain how a spectrum shows which elements are in a star, and whether a star or galaxy is moving towards us or away from us.
  • 4describe Hubble’s law and use the expansion rate to estimate the age of the universe.
  • 5explain how the cosmic microwave background and the amount of helium support the big bang model.
  • 6explain why distant galaxies show us the past, and what they show about the universe.
  • 7judge how each line of evidence relates to each model, and put the main events since the big bang in order.

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 10, AC9S10U03: “describe how the big bang theory models the origin and evolution of the universe and analyse the supporting evidence for the theory”. The teacher notes at the end show which screen covers each part.

Which statement is part of the big bang model but not the steady state model?

In the steady state model, why doesn’t space get emptier as the galaxies move apart?

Printable activity

The big bang: model it, graph it, weigh it

Three pages: a practical that models the expansion with dots on a stretched strip of elastic, Hubble’s 1929 data to graph with a line of best fit and an age to work out, and a model-evidence link diagram to fill in.

2Tools 1 of 2

How far away are the galaxies?

How do astronomers write distances this big, and how do they measure them?

Distances in space are so large that kilometres become awkward. Astronomers use the astronomical unit (AU), the average distance from Earth to the Sun, for distances in the solar system, and the light-year, the distance light travels in a year, for stars and galaxies. Both are easiest to work with in scientific notation.

On this screen

  1. Move out from the Moon to the most distant quasars, and switch between kilometres, astronomical units and light-years.
  2. Notice how long each object’s light has been travelling when it reaches us.
  3. Then use the second simulation to see how a star’s brightness gives its distance.

From the Moon to the most distant quasars

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Looking far away is looking back in time

Light takes time to reach us, so the latest news we get from the Sun is always about 8 minutes old (OpenStax). Light from the Andromeda Galaxy set off a little more than 2 million years ago, so we see Andromeda as it was then. The most distant quasars show us the universe as it was 10 billion years ago or more (OpenStax). Screen 7 uses this to look at the past.

Brightness and distance

A light looks fainter the farther away it is. At twice the distance it looks 1/4 as bright, and at three times the distance 1/9 as bright. This is the inverse square law (OpenStax). If you know how much light a star gives out, how bright it looks tells you how far away it is.

Brightness and distance

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

How Hubble measured distances

In 1908 Henrietta Leavitt found that the cepheids with the longer cycles of brightening and dimming give out more light (OpenStax). So the length of a cepheid’s cycle tells astronomers how much light it gives out, and comparing that with how bright it looks gives its distance. In the 1920s Edwin Hubble found cepheids in the Andromeda Galaxy with the 100-inch (2.5 metre) telescope on Mount Wilson in California, and estimated that Andromeda was about 900,000 light-years away. That showed Andromeda is a separate galaxy, far outside the Milky Way. Modern measurements put it more than twice as far away (OpenStax).

× 10¹² km
AU

Light from the Andromeda Galaxy takes a little more than 2 million years to reach us. What does that mean when you look at it?

light-years

3Tools 2 of 2

What starlight tells us

How can a spectrum show what a star is made of, and how a galaxy is moving?

Spread starlight out into a spectrum and dark lines appear at certain wavelengths. Each type of atom has its own set of spectral lines, so the lines show which elements are in a star (OpenStax). If a star or galaxy is moving towards us or away from us, its whole pattern of lines shifts.

On this screen

  1. Lay each element’s pattern over the two stars’ spectra and find which elements made the dark lines.
  2. In the second simulation, line up a galaxy’s hydrogen line with the line measured on Earth, and read off the shift.
  3. Use the shift to work out how fast the galaxy is moving.

Which elements made the lines in each star’s spectrum?

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Why the Sun’s spectrum has no helium lines

The Sun is a huge ball of hydrogen and helium (NASA), yet helium’s pattern doesn’t match its spectrum. Most stars have nearly the same make-up as the Sun. Their spectra look different mainly because the stars have different temperatures, and each type of atom makes dark lines best at a particular temperature. In OpenStax’s table of star types, only stars hotter than about 10,000 K, such as Spica, show helium lines. Yellow stars like the Sun are 5200 to 6000 K (OpenStax).

Moving towards us or away?

When a light source moves away from us, the waves reaching us are stretched to longer wavelengths, and its lines move towards the red end of the spectrum: a redshift. When it moves towards us, they move towards the blue end: a blueshift. This is the Doppler effect. To find the speed, divide the change in wavelength (Δλ) by the wavelength measured in a laboratory on Earth (λ). That equals the speed (v) divided by the speed of light (c): Δλ/λ = v/c (OpenStax).

Measure a galaxy’s shift

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

What Slipher found

Beginning in 1912, Vesto Slipher photographed the spectra of more than 40 spiral galaxies, which were then called spiral nebulae. The lines of most of them showed a large redshift, so most galaxies are moving away from us. Only a few, such as the Andromeda and Triangulum Galaxies and M81, are coming towards us, and nearly all of the galaxies coming towards us belong to the Milky Way’s own group of galaxies (OpenStax).

The first quasar, found with help from Parkes

In 1962 Cyril Hazard used the Parkes radio telescope, run by CSIRO in New South Wales, to time the Moon passing in front of a radio source called 3C 273. That pinned down its position to less than a second of arc. Maarten Schmidt then picked out the matching object with an optical telescope and recognised its hydrogen lines, shifted 16% to longer wavelengths (Hazard and others). 3C 273 was the first quasar to be found. Try it in the simulation: its lines are far more shifted than any nearby galaxy’s.

Which elements made the dark lines in Spica’s spectrum?

The lines in the Andromeda Galaxy’s spectrum are shifted to shorter wavelengths. What does that tell you?

km/s

4Evidence 1 of 4

Hubble’s law

How does a galaxy’s speed depend on its distance?

In 1929 Edwin Hubble, at Mount Wilson Observatory in California, published the distances of 24 galaxies alongside their speeds towards or away from us. The speeds came from the shifts in their spectra, like the ones you measured on screen 3 (Hubble, 1929). Is there a pattern?

On this screen

  1. Drag the line until it runs through the middle of Hubble’s points, and read its slope.
  2. Switch to today’s value and drag a galaxy along the line. Watch what stays the same.
  3. Pick different galaxies as home in the second simulation, then link this evidence to the two models.

Hubble’s distances and speeds

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

My notebook

Hubble’s law

Hubble found that the more distant a galaxy is, the faster it moves away from us. In 1931 he and Milton Humason showed that the speeds are directly proportional to the distances. This is Hubble’s law: v = H × d, where H is the Hubble constant (OpenStax). Hubble’s own value was 500 km/s per million parsecs (Hubble, 1929), about 153 km/s per million light-years. Today’s value is about 22 km/s per million light-years (OpenStax), seven times smaller. Hubble’s distances were too small: he put the Andromeda Galaxy about 900,000 light-years away, and modern measurements put it more than twice as far (OpenStax). Distances that are too small make the line too steep.

Running the expansion backwards

If the galaxies have always moved apart at the same speeds, the time since they were all together is distance ÷ speed. On a straight line through zero that time is the same for every galaxy, and it equals 1/H (OpenStax). With today’s value it comes to about 14 billion years. The best current estimate, which also uses other measurements, is 13.8 billion years. The oldest stars formed about 12 to 13 billion years ago, so they are younger than the universe, as they must be (OpenStax). With Hubble’s own value, 1/H is only about 2 billion years, much less than other measures of the universe’s age at the time. This apparent problem was one reason Bondi, Gold and Hoyle put forward the steady state model in 1948. In that model the universe has no beginning. The problem went away when Hubble’s value of H was revised (Britannica).

Is the Milky Way at the centre?

Almost every galaxy is moving away from us. Does that put us at the centre? Choose a galaxy to be home, let the universe expand, and then choose another.

Every galaxy sees the same

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

No centre and no edge

In a loaf of rising bread, the raisins all move apart, and the more distant raisins move away faster (OpenStax). Observers in any galaxy would see the same pattern as we do. The universe has no boundaries, no edges and no centre. The galaxies aren’t rushing away from one place through space: space itself is stretching, and the galaxies are carried apart with it (OpenStax). The expansion stretches light too: the light waves from distant galaxies are stretched by the stretching of the space they travel through, and that shifts their lines towards the red (OpenStax).

Astronomers in a galaxy a billion light-years away measure the speeds of the galaxies around them. What do they find?

Hubble’s 1929 line is about seven times steeper than a line with today’s value of H. Why?

billion years

5Evidence 2 of 4

A glow from every direction

Where does the faint microwave glow in the sky come from, and which model predicted it?

In the mid-1960s Arno Penzias and Robert Wilson, at Bell Laboratories in the United States, were using a horn-shaped microwave antenna. They picked up faint microwaves coming from all directions at once. At first they thought the signal must come from inside their telescope (OpenStax).

In the late 1940s, Ralph Alpher and Robert Herman, working with George Gamow, had predicted that if the universe was once hot and dense, the glow from that time should still fill space, stretched to radio wavelengths (OpenStax). Was this what Penzias and Wilson had found?

On this screen

  1. Stretch space, starting from the moment the glow set off, and watch what happens to its wavelength, its spectrum and its temperature.
  2. Point the antenna in different directions and compare the readings.
  3. Link this evidence to the two models.

Stretching the glow

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Where the glow comes from

For a few hundred thousand years after the big bang the universe was so hot that electrons couldn’t stay in atoms, and light kept bouncing off the free electrons. When it had cooled to about 3000 K, about 380,000 years after the big bang, atoms formed. With no free electrons to scatter it, light could travel freely and the universe became transparent for the first time. Since then the expansion has stretched the wavelength of that light by a factor of about 1000, and its spectrum now closely matches a blackbody at 2.73 K (OpenStax). This is the cosmic microwave background.

Point the antenna

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

The same in every direction

The glow is extremely even. Apart from a small effect of our own motion through space (NASA), its temperature is the same in every direction to about 1 part in 100,000. In November 1989 NASA launched the satellite COBE, which measured its spectrum from above the atmosphere. Later spacecraft, WMAP and then Planck, mapped the tiny differences in more and more detail (OpenStax). A glow that is the same everywhere doesn’t come from any one star or galaxy. It fills the universe.

Why did the glow set off about 380,000 years after the big bang, and not earlier?

The glow is the same in every direction. What does that tell us?

mm

6Evidence 3 of 4

Where did the helium come from?

Could the stars have made all the helium in the universe?

Stars join hydrogen nuclei to make helium, and every generation of stars has added some (OpenStax). Yet about a quarter of the mass of all the atomic nuclei in the universe is helium (IAU OAE; OpenStax University Physics). Where did it all come from?

On this screen

  1. Try to join a proton and a neutron before about 3 minutes, then at about 3 minutes.
  2. Make as much helium as you can, then let the universe cool. Read the share of the mass that is helium.
  3. Add the helium that all the stars have made since, then link this evidence to the two models.

Making helium in the first minutes

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

How the helium was made

When the universe was about 3 minutes old and had cooled to about 900 million K, deuterium nuclei (a proton and a neutron) lasted long enough for collisions to turn some of them into helium. At higher temperatures these nuclei were blasted apart at once. For those few minutes the whole universe acted the way the centres of stars do today (OpenStax). There were about 7 protons for every neutron, and turning nuclei into helium used up almost all the neutrons. The expansion then cooled the universe enough that the nuclear reactions stopped (OpenStax University Physics). About 25% of the mass of the atomic nuclei was helium (IAU OAE).

Could the stars have done it?

OpenStax estimates that 10 times more helium was made in the first 4 minutes than in all the generations of stars over the next 10 to 15 billion years. In its words, “there is just too much helium in the universe to be explained by what happens inside stars.” In the steady state model every element had to be made in stars (Britannica).

Why could helium form only in the first few minutes?

%

Why can’t the stars explain all the helium?

7Evidence 4 of 4

Looking back in time

Did the universe look the same billions of years ago?

Light from distant galaxies has been travelling for billions of years, so telescopes show them as they were when the light set off (OpenStax). How long the light has been travelling is called the look-back time. Seeing the past is a way to test the two models. In model B the universe has always looked the same, so distant galaxies should look like nearby ones. In model A the universe changes, so they should look different.

On this screen

  1. Look further and further back, and compare what astronomers see with what model B predicts.
  2. Write down what changes as you look further back.
  3. Sort the data by the kind of telescope that collected it, then link this evidence to the two models.

Galaxies near and far

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

My notebook

What astronomers see

Very distant galaxies are smaller on average than nearby ones. They look very different from today’s galaxies, without clear spiral arms, discs or bulges, and much clumpier. Many are extremely blue, which shows that they have a lot of young stars. Over time, smaller galaxies collided and merged to build today’s large galaxies (OpenStax). Quasars were most common when the universe was only 20% of its present age, and their numbers drop off sharply towards the present day (OpenStax). In the 1950s and 1960s the radio astronomer Martin Ryle counted more radio galaxies at great distances than nearby, a result that could not be explained in steady state theory (Britannica).

The telescopes behind the evidence

The evidence in this lesson came from different kinds of telescope. Sort each kind of data by the telescope that collected it.

Which telescope collected it?

Sort

The cards load here.

Why do distant galaxies show us what the universe was like long ago?

Quasars were most common when the universe was 20% of its present age. Why is that a problem for the steady state model?

8Weighing up

Weigh the evidence

Which model does the evidence support?

On screens 4 to 7 you linked four lines of evidence to the two models. Here are all your links together in one model-evidence link diagram. Look at the diagram as a whole, compare it with an astronomer’s, then explain two of your links and rate the models again.

On this screen

  1. Choose any arrow to read its evidence and change your link if you want to.
  2. Show an astronomer’s links and look at any arrows that differ from yours.
  3. Explain two of your links, then rate the two models again.

My model-evidence link diagram

Diagram

The diagram loads here.

What astronomers concluded

By the mid-1960s the big bang had become the standard model of the universe, supported by the observed expansion, the measured amounts of the light elements and the microwave glow (Britannica). The expansion fits both models, so on its own it couldn’t decide between them. The big bang model predicted the glow and the helium, and the steady state model had no ready explanation for either. The distant universe showed that the universe changes with time. The steady state model has few supporters today, but it is credited with being a useful idea, because it stimulated much work in cosmology (Britannica).

My notebook: explain two links

For each link, name the evidence and the model, say which kind of arrow you chose, and explain why.

My notebook: rate the two models again

1 means greatly implausible or even impossible, and 10 means highly plausible.

Model A: the big bang
Model B: the steady state

My ratings, before and after

Chart

The chart loads here.

Which line of evidence fits both models, so that on its own it can’t decide between them?

Why do astronomers count the microwave glow as strong support for the big bang model?

9Putting it together

The story of the universe

What happened between the big bang and today?

The evidence points to a universe that has changed a great deal since it was hot and dense. Sort the main events by how long after the big bang they happened, and watch your timeline build. The times run from a hundredth of a second to 13.8 billion years, so scientific notation helps.

On this screen

  1. Sort each event into a stretch of time. The timeline adds each event you place correctly.
  2. Switch the timeline between powers of ten and an ordinary scale, and compare.
  3. Answer the question from screen 1 again, then compare it with your first answer.

A timeline of the universe

Simulation

The timeline loads here.

Why use powers of ten?

On an ordinary scale, everything from the first second to the first galaxies is squashed into a sliver at the start of the line. On a powers-of-ten scale each step is ten times longer than the one before, so the first second, the first minutes and the first million years each get room. The scale can’t show time zero. Each step up the line is ten times closer to it, and the steps never reach it.

My notebook

Then and now

Your answers

Your answers load here.

Which of these happened first?

× 10¹³ s
Printable activity

The big bang: model it, graph it, weigh it

Three pages: a practical that models the expansion with dots on a stretched strip of elastic, Hubble’s 1929 data to graph with a line of best fit and an age to work out, and a model-evidence link diagram to fill in.

For teachers

Curriculum

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 10, Science understanding, Earth and space sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:

AC9S10U03 describe how the big bang theory models the origin and evolution of the universe and analyse the supporting evidence for the theory

  • describing the major components of the universe using appropriate scientific terminology and units including astronomical units, scientific notation and light-years
  • constructing a timeline to show major changes in the universe which are thought to have occurred from the Big Bang until the formation of the major components such as stars and galaxies
  • examining how stars’ light spectra and brightness is used to identify compositional elements of stars, their movements and their distances from Earth
  • explaining how each different type of evidence, such as cosmic microwave background radiation, red or blue shift of galaxies, Edwin Hubble’s observations and proportion of matter in the universe, provides support for the acceptance of the big bang theory
  • identifying the different technologies used to collect astronomical data and the types of data collected

The second quote gives five of ACARA’s seven elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. The lesson leaves out the elaboration on First Nations Australians’ knowledges of celestial bodies and explanations of the origin of the universe, which is best taught with local First Nations people and community-approved resources. It also leaves out the elaboration on recent advances, such as the Australian Square Kilometre Array Pathfinder, gravitational waves, dark matter and dark energy, which would make a good research task after the lesson. Each part of the content description is covered on these screens:

  • Describe how the big bang theory models the origin and evolution of the universe: screen 1 (the two models side by side), screen 5 (the hot, dense universe becoming transparent), screen 6 (helium made in the first minutes), screen 7 (the universe changing with time) and screen 9 (the timeline); q-models, q-newmatter, q-transparent, q-window, q-first, n-seconds.
  • Analyse the supporting evidence for the theory: screen 3 (spectra, redshift and blueshift), screen 4 (Hubble’s 1929 data and the age of the universe), screen 5 (the cosmic microwave background), screen 6 (the proportion of helium), screen 7 (distant galaxies and quasars, and the telescopes behind the evidence) and screen 8 (the whole model-evidence link diagram); q-elements, q-blue, n-speed, q-centre, q-steep, n-age, q-every, n-wien, n-helium, q-stars, q-lookback, q-quasars, q-decide, q-strong.
  • Screen 2 gives the units and the link between brightness and distance that the evidence screens rely on; n-km, n-au, q-look, n-candle.

The lesson also works on these content descriptions. The steady state model was a serious scientific rival that observations tested and rejected, and Hubble’s distances were later corrected, both examples of scientific knowledge being validated and refined (AC9S10H01). The card sort on screen 7 matches each kind of data to the telescope that collected it, from Mount Wilson’s 100-inch telescope to JWST (AC9S10H02). The model-evidence link diagram asks students to weigh each line of evidence against two explanations, including evidence that fits both and so can’t decide between them (AC9S10I06), and the explanation task on screen 8 asks for an argument based on the evidence (AC9S10I07).

AC9S10H01 explain how scientific knowledge is validated and refined, including the role of publication and peer review

AC9S10H02 investigate how advances in technologies enable advances in science, and how science has contributed to developments in technologies and engineering

AC9S10I06 assess the validity and reproducibility of methods and evaluate the validity of conclusions and claims, including by identifying assumptions, conflicting evidence and areas of uncertainty

AC9S10I07 construct arguments based on analysis of a variety of evidence to support conclusions or evaluate claims, and consider any ethical issues and cultural protocols associated with accessing, using or citing secondary data or information

How the lesson is taught

The lesson uses model-evidence link (MEL) diagrams, first reported by Chinn and Buckland (2012, cited in Lombardi and others, 2013) and developed further by Doug Lombardi and colleagues in the United States. Students rate how plausible two models are on a scale of 1 to 10, then work through four lines of evidence. For each one they draw an arrow to each model: a straight arrow if it supports the model, a squiggly arrow if it strongly supports it, a straight arrow with an X if it contradicts it, and a dashed arrow if it has nothing to do with it. Afterwards they explain some of their links in writing and rate the models again (Lombardi and others, 2013; Bailey and Lombardi, 2022).

Lombardi, Sinatra and Nussbaum (2013) studied Grade 7 Earth science classes in the south-west of the United States, with classes assigned at random and the activity taught by the classes’ own teachers. 169 students completed the pre-test, the activity and the post-test, and 96, in three teachers’ classes, took the six-month test. The MEL classes judged a climate change model more plausible after the activity and learned more than comparison classes, which used the same four evidence texts in a normal curriculum activity without the two models. In follow-up tests six months later, the MEL classes still scored higher than the comparison classes. The effects were small to medium (η² = .061 for plausibility and .053 for knowledge), and the authors name external validity as their biggest limitation.

Lombardi, Bickel, Bailey and Burrell (2018) used MELs on four topics with 299 students in Grades 9 to 12. Plausibility judgements shifted towards the scientific explanations, and knowledge increased, generally by 3 to 5% a topic. The shifts in plausibility were significant for climate change and fracking but not for wetlands or the formation of Earth’s Moon. The study had no comparison group, and the authors call the results modest. Bailey and others (2022) report larger plausibility shifts with a build-a-MEL, in which students choose some of the evidence and models, than with a ready-made MEL on a different topic. They say this only partly supported their hypothesis, and the effect sizes were modest.

This lesson follows the Origins of the Universe MEL from the same project. Its scientific model is the same as model A here. The Physics Teacher version also offers a universe that “has always existed in its current state” (Bailey and Lombardi, 2022), and the lesson makes that the steady state model, which was a real rival from 1948 until the mid-1960s. Much of the evidence for the big bang refutes the steady state model (Bailey, Klavon and Dobaria, 2020). One small study used a build-a-MEL on the origins of the universe, in which students chose four lines of evidence from eight and two models from three: the big bang, a steady state model and an explosion model (Dobaria and others, 2022). With 14 high school students and 28 preservice teachers in the United States, plausibility judgements shifted towards the scientific model and knowledge scores rose. The authors call the sample relatively small and say the findings can’t be generalised, and no group worked without a MEL. The 2018 study’s results for the Moon, another topic far from everyday life, are another reason for caution.

The research versions give the feedback in a class discussion of students’ ideas, after which the teacher says which model scientists accept and why. Here the feedback comes as soon as a student picks a link. To keep the discussion, have students choose their links on paper first (page 3 of the printable sheet), discuss them in groups, and only then enter them on screen.

Plan for about two lessons of 50 to 60 minutes: screens 1 to 5, then screens 6 to 9. The elastic-strip practical on the printable sheet needs about 30 minutes more.

Handle with care

  • Many students picture the big bang as an explosion at one point, flinging matter out into empty space. The expansion began everywhere at once, and there is no place where the big bang happened (OpenStax). Screen 1 fills its window evenly with the early glow, and screen 4 shows that every galaxy sees the same pattern and that space itself stretches. The windows on screen 1 and the second simulation on screen 4 each show one patch of space, so the patch seems to have a centre only because the drawing has edges. OpenStax itself calls the big bang an explosion in one sentence of section 29.1, so warn students who read it. The research version of this MEL offers an explosion model as a third choice (Bailey and Lombardi, 2022). This lesson leaves it out, so raise it in the class discussion.
  • The redshifts of distant galaxies come from the stretching of space, not from galaxies speeding through space away from us (OpenStax), as screen 4 says. Screen 3 uses the Doppler formula because it gives the right speeds for the nearby galaxies in Hubble’s list. For a big shift like 3C 273’s, the lesson gives only the size of the shift.
  • A light-year is a distance, not a time. The lesson keeps pairing the two on purpose: an object’s distance in light-years is also how many years its light has travelled. This holds from the Moon out to the galaxy clusters. For the most distant quasars and galaxies, turning a redshift into a distance depends on a model of the universe (OpenStax), so screen 7 gives look-back times, how long the light has travelled.
  • The steady state model is not a straw man. It made clear predictions, which is why observations could test it, and it is credited with being a useful idea for the development of cosmology (Britannica). Screen 4 gives one reason it was put forward: with Hubble’s value, the big bang universe came out younger than other measures of its age.
  • The age from 1/H is right only if the expansion rate has been constant (OpenStax). Screen 4 says the best estimate, 13.8 billion years, also uses other measurements. The calculation with 22 km/s per million light-years gives 13.6 billion years.
  • The models on screen 1 and the patches on screen 7 are drawings, not to scale. The numbers of quasars in the screen 7 drawings show only where they were most common. They are not real counts.

About the simulations and the numbers

  • Screen 1 draws the same window of space in each model. In model A the galaxies’ spacing grows from about a fifth of today’s spacing 13.5 billion years ago to today’s, values chosen for the drawing. In model B the spacing grows by a factor of about 2.7 over the 13.8 billion years (an exponential with a time of 13.8 billion years) and new galaxies are born at a rate that keeps the number in the window about the same. Galaxy colours show age in both: blue for young, yellow for old. Model A’s early glow fills the window evenly, because it filled all of space. A grid fixed to space stretches with it in both windows, and two ringed galaxies show one gap growing: 20% of today’s gap 13.5 billion years ago in model A, and 37% 13.8 billion years ago in model B. In model B a sparkle marks each new galaxy.
  • Screen 2 uses the distances and units in OpenStax: the Moon at about 384,000 km, the Sun at 1 AU (1.496 × 10¹¹ m, about 150 million km), Proxima Centauri at 4.25 light-years, the Milky Way about 100,000 light-years across, the Andromeda Galaxy a little more than 2 million light-years away, large clusters of galaxies at about 50 million light-years, and quasars at 10 billion light-years or more. A light-year is 9.461 × 10¹⁵ m, so it is 9.461 × 10¹² km and 63,242 AU. The Moon’s light time, about 1.3 seconds, is 384,000 km ÷ 299,792 km/s. The Milky Way drawing puts the Sun about halfway from the centre to the edge of the disc (OpenStax). The Sun is somewhat less than 30,000 light-years from the centre (OpenStax), so the far side of the Milky Way is tens of thousands of light-years away. The zoom puts each object at its real distance from Earth, with the view running from about 4 × 10⁵ km to about 2.5 × 10²³ km across. Bodies are drawn to scale when they are bigger than a pixel or two, and smaller ones as glowing points. The Milky Way and Andromeda are drawings, and the groups of galaxies, the large cluster and the distant clusters are placed at random to show the idea. The card gives the rough distances, such as “a little more than 2 million light-years”, to two significant figures in kilometres and astronomical units. The brightness simulation uses the inverse square law (OpenStax). The cepheid numbers in n-candle are an example, not real stars.
  • Screen 3 draws some of each element’s strongest lines between 380 and 700 nm from NIST’s Handbook of Basic Atomic Spectroscopic Data: hydrogen 410.2, 434.0, 486.1 and 656.3 nm; helium 402.6, 447.1, 471.3, 492.2, 501.6, 587.6 and 667.8 nm; sodium 589.0 and 589.6 nm; calcium (ionised) 393.4 and 396.8 nm. Helium’s strong line at 388.9 nm is left out because hydrogen has a line at almost the same wavelength. Real spectra have many more lines. When helium or sodium is laid under a spectrum, a zoomed-in strip from 584 to 593 nm shows that helium’s line at 587.6 nm and sodium’s pair are close but not in the same place. Spica shows hydrogen and helium and the Sun shows hydrogen, sodium and calcium, as OpenStax’s table of spectral classes gives for B and G stars. The Sun is a huge ball of hydrogen and helium (NASA), but in that table only stars hotter than about 10,000 K show helium lines. The galaxy shifts use the speeds in Hubble’s 1929 table and Δλ/λ = v/c with c = 299,792 km/s: −220 km/s for Andromeda gives −0.48 nm, 270 km/s for NGC 5194 gives 0.59 nm and 960 km/s for NGC 4151 gives 2.10 nm, at 656.3 nm. 3C 273’s lines are multiplied by 1.16, its redshift of 0.16 (Hazard and others). The waves above the spectrum show the Doppler effect with the speeds hugely exaggerated, at 30% of the speed of light for each galaxy, where the real speeds are well under 1%.
  • Screen 4 plots all 24 galaxies of Hubble’s Table 1 (Hubble, 1929), with distances changed from parsecs to light-years (1 parsec = 3.262 light-years). The best straight line through zero (least squares) has a slope of 424 km/s per million parsecs, or 130 km/s per million light-years, which gives 1/H = 2.3 billion years. Hubble’s solutions gave 465 ± 50 for the 24 galaxies and 513 ± 60 for 9 groups. They are steeper partly because he solved for the Sun’s own motion at the same time, and his Figure 1 plots speeds corrected for it, while the lesson plots the measured speeds in his Table 1. His K = 500 km/s per million parsecs, a round number between his two solutions, is 153 km/s per million light-years and gives 2.0 billion years. Today’s value is 22 km/s per million light-years (OpenStax), which gives 13.6 billion years. Andromeda’s distance was about 2.2 times too small (2 million ÷ 900,000), which explains only part of the factor of 7. Britannica (Shu) says Hubble’s value was about an order of magnitude too large because of confusion between two kinds of variable star (Population I and II) and between H II regions and bright stars. The second simulation scales every position from the chosen home by the same factor, and its grid, fixed to space, stretches by the same factor.
  • Screen 5’s first simulation divides 3000 K by the stretch to get the temperature, and uses Wien’s law, λmax = 3 × 10⁶ ÷ T nm (OpenStax), for the peak. A stretch of 1099 brings 3000 K to 2.73 K, which OpenStax rounds to a factor of 1000. The curves are blackbody spectra drawn against wavelength on a powers-of-ten scale, each scaled to the same height, so they compare shapes and peaks, not brightness. The antenna reads 2.73 K in every direction. The real differences, about 1 part in 100,000, would change the reading by about 0.00003 K. Our own motion through space makes the glow slightly brighter in one direction and dimmer in the opposite one, a signal about a thousandth of the sky’s brightness (NASA). The 1 part in 100,000 is what is left once that is taken out. The antenna’s sky map uses Mollweide’s projection, split into 12 parts, and always reads 2.73 K. Its two exaggerated views are illustrations, not data: the first is warm towards one direction and cool in the opposite one, the shape of the pattern from our motion, and the second is smooth random noise made up to look like the kind of map COBE, WMAP and Planck produced.
  • Screen 6 starts with 14 protons and 2 neutrons, the 7 to 1 ratio at the time helium formed (OpenStax University Physics), and treats protons and neutrons as having the same mass, so one helium-4 nucleus is 4 of the 16 mass units, 25%. Students join a proton and a neutron to make deuterium and two deuterium nuclei to make helium-4. The real reactions have more steps. Light is drawn as short waves, shorter when hotter, and before about 3 minutes a new deuterium nucleus is struck by light and blasted apart (OpenStax). The stars’ helium is a tenth of the first minutes’ helium (OpenStax), drawn as an extra 2.5% of the mass.
  • Screen 7 shows sketches of what telescopes see at look-back times of 0.5, 4, 8, 11 and 13.5 billion years, following OpenStax: galaxies smaller, clumpier and bluer further back, quasars most common when the universe was 20% of its present age (about 2.8 billion years old, 11 billion years ago), and the most distant galaxies known seen about 300 million years after the big bang. Model B’s view is the nearby mix at every distance. Each view has five galaxies for every one in the lesson’s data, and faint smudges beyond them.
  • Screen 8 draws the student’s own links from screens 4 to 7, which are saved with their answers, so changing a link on screen 8 changes it on the earlier screen too. The astronomer’s links are: galaxies moving apart supports both models; the glow and the helium strongly support model A and contradict model B; the distant universe supports model A and contradicts model B. On screens 4 to 7, “supports” and “strongly supports” are both accepted for links to model A, and both are accepted for the expansion and model B. A student who picks “supports” for the glow or the helium and model A is told that the astronomer’s diagram has a squiggly arrow there.
  • Screen 9 places the events on a powers-of-ten scale of seconds after the big bang: 0.01 s (10⁻² s), about 3 minutes (1.8 × 10² s), 380,000 years (1.2 × 10¹³ s), a few hundred million years (taken as 300 million, about 10¹⁶ s), 2.76 billion years, 20% of 13.8 (8.7 × 10¹⁶ s), 9.2 billion years (2.9 × 10¹⁷ s, using 4.6 billion years ago for the Sun and Earth from NASA) and 13.8 billion years (4.4 × 10¹⁷ s). Neither 0.01 seconds nor the time the Sun formed appears on an earlier screen, so the Sun’s card gives “4.6 billion years ago” and the 100 billion K card’s hint gives 0.01 seconds.

Where sources disagree, and what to check

  • OpenStax gives Penzias and Wilson’s measurement as 3.5 K, and Britannica gives an excess temperature of 3.3 K. The lesson gives neither.
  • OpenStax gives the temperature at about 3 minutes as about 1 billion K in one subsection of 29.3 and about 900 million K in a later one. OpenStax University Physics says atoms formed as the universe cooled below 4000 K, and OpenStax Astronomy says about 3000 K. The lesson uses 3000 K and 900 million K.
  • OpenStax University Physics and the IAU give about 25% of the mass as helium. Britannica’s account of the helium problem for the steady state model mentions 30 per cent.
  • OpenStax gives the Hubble constant as near 22 km/s per million light-years in one section and 21 or 22 in another, and as about 70 km/s per million parsecs, which is 21.5 km/s per million light-years. Appendix E gives approximately 20 km/s per million light-years.
  • NASA gives the Sun’s age as 4.5 billion years and the solar system’s formation as about 4.6 billion years ago. The timeline uses 4.6.
  • Hubble’s 1929 distances were too small. His value for Andromeda is about 900,000 light-years, and modern measurements put it at a little more than 2 million (OpenStax, section 1.7). Section 26.1 gives about 2.5 million light-years.

Answers at a glance

  • Screen 1: in model A the window starts hot and glowing, the first small blue galaxies appear close together, and the galaxies then grow, age and spread apart. In model B the window looks the same at every time, with galaxies of all ages. q-models, the universe was once much hotter and denser; q-newmatter, new matter forms in the gaps and makes new galaxies.
  • Screen 2: n-km 9.461 (× 10¹² km); n-au about 63,200 AU; q-look, you see Andromeda as it was a little more than 2 million years ago; n-candle 200,000 light-years.
  • Screen 3: Spica has hydrogen and helium, and the Sun hydrogen, sodium and calcium. Andromeda’s line is at about 655.8 nm (blueshift), NGC 5194’s at about 656.9 nm and NGC 4151’s at about 658.4 nm. In the zoomed-in strip, Spica’s line at 587.6 nm matches helium, not sodium. q-elements, hydrogen and helium; q-blue, Andromeda is moving towards us; n-speed 960 km/s.
  • Screen 4: the points rise from left to right with a lot of scatter, and several of the nearest galaxies, including Andromeda, have negative speeds (coming towards us). Best line 130 km/s per million light-years. With today’s value every galaxy on the line gives the same time, 13.6 billion years. Every home sees the same pattern. Links: supports (or strongly supports) for both models. q-centre, almost all galaxies moving away from them, faster when farther; q-steep, his distances were too small; n-age 13.6 billion years.
  • Screen 5: as space stretches 1099 times, the temperature falls from 3000 K to 2.73 K and the peak moves from 1000 nm (infrared) to 1.1 mm (microwaves). The antenna reads 2.73 K in every direction. Links: strongly supports (or supports) model A, contradicts model B. q-transparent, before then light kept bouncing off free electrons; q-every, it doesn’t come from any one star or galaxy; n-wien 1.1 mm.
  • Screen 6: before about 3 minutes every deuterium nucleus breaks apart; at about 3 minutes one helium-4 nucleus can form, from both neutrons, leaving 12 protons: 25% of the mass is helium. The stars add about 2.5%. Links: strongly supports (or supports) model A, contradicts model B. q-window, too hot before and too cool after; n-helium 28.6%; q-stars, all the stars have made only about a tenth as much helium as there is.
  • Screen 7: further back, galaxies get smaller, clumpier and bluer, and quasars become more common, most of all at 11 billion years; at 13.5 billion years there are only a few small, faint galaxies. Model B shows the same mix at every distance. Telescopes: spectra of spiral galaxies and cepheid distances, optical telescopes on the ground; the microwave glow, the position of 3C 273 and radio galaxy counts, radio telescopes on the ground; the glow’s spectrum from COBE and the most distant galaxies, telescopes in space. Links: supports (or strongly supports) model A, contradicts model B. q-lookback, their light set off long ago; q-quasars, in model B quasars should be as common now.
  • Screen 8: q-decide, galaxies moving apart; q-strong, the model predicted it before anyone found it. Expect most students to rate model A higher and model B lower than on screen 1.
  • Screen 9: under a second, 100 billion K; seconds to an hour, helium nuclei; an hour to a million years, atoms and the glow; a million to a billion years, the first stars and galaxies; over a billion years, quasars most common, the Sun and Earth, today. q-first, helium nuclei formed; n-seconds 1.2 (× 10¹³ s).
  • Printable sheet: on the elastic strip every dot moves away from the home dot, and dots twice as far away move twice as far in the same time, so speed is proportional to distance, with any dot as home. Hubble’s data give a line of about 130 km/s per million light-years (anything from about 110 to 160 is reasonable by eye) and an age of about 2 to 3 billion years; today’s value gives about 14 billion years. The diagram on page 3 matches the astronomer’s links above.

Saved progress

Answers, notes, ratings and links are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere.

References

Curriculum attribution

© Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) 2010 to present, unless otherwise indicated. This material was downloaded from the Australian Curriculum website (Website) (accessed 10 November 2026) and was not modified. The material is licensed under CC BY 4.0 Attribution 4.0 International Deed. Version updates are tracked in the ‘Curriculum version history’ section on the ‘About the Australian Curriculum’ page of the Australian Curriculum website.

ACARA does not endorse any product that uses the Australian Curriculum or make any representations as to the quality of such products. Any product that uses material published on this website should not be taken to be affiliated with ACARA or have the sponsorship or approval of ACARA. It is up to each person to make their own assessment of the product, taking into account matters including, but not limited to, the version number and the degree to which the materials align with the content descriptions and achievement standards (where relevant). Where there is a claim of alignment, it is important to check that the materials align with the content descriptions and achievement standards (endorsed by all education Ministers), not the elaborations (examples provided by ACARA).

Sources by screen

  • Screen 1: OpenStax Astronomy 2e, sections 26.5, 29.1 and 29.3 (the galaxies moving apart; 13.8 billion years; hot and dense; the first galaxies); Britannica, The steady-state challenge and Steady-state theory (1948; Bondi, Gold and Hoyle; average properties unchanged; new hydrogen); Lombardi and others (2013).
  • Screen 2: OpenStax Astronomy 2e, Appendix E (the AU, the light-year and the parsec), sections 1.6 and 1.7 (the distances; 8 minutes; looking back; the Sun less than 30,000 light-years from the centre), 5.1 (the inverse square law), 19.3 (brightness and the square of the distance; Leavitt’s cepheids), 25.1 (the Sun halfway out) and 26.1 (Hubble’s cepheids in Andromeda; about 900,000 light-years).
  • Screen 3: OpenStax Astronomy 2e, sections 5.5 (each atom’s own lines), 5.6 (the Doppler formula; redshift and blueshift), 17.3 (spectral classes; temperatures), 26.5 (Slipher’s redshifts; the approaching galaxies) and 27.1 (quasars); NASA, Sun facts (hydrogen and helium); NIST, Handbook of Basic Atomic Spectroscopic Data (the line wavelengths); Hubble (1929) (the galaxies’ speeds); Hazard and others (3C 273 and Parkes).
  • Screen 4: Hubble (1929) (Table 1; K); OpenStax Astronomy 2e, sections 26.1, 26.5 and 29.1 (Hubble’s law; today’s value; raisin bread; no centre; 1/H; 13.8 billion years; the oldest stars) and 29.2 (light stretched by stretching space); Britannica, Steady state theory and other alternative cosmologies (the age problem; the revised value) and Steady-state theory (no beginning).
  • Screen 5: OpenStax Astronomy 2e, sections 29.4 (the prediction; Penzias and Wilson; 3000 K; transparency; 380,000 years; a factor of 1000; 2.73 K; COBE, WMAP and Planck; 1 part in 100,000) and 5.2 (Wien’s law; microwaves); NASA Goddard Space Flight Center, COBE science results (our own motion; a part in 100,000).
  • Screen 6: OpenStax Astronomy 2e, section 29.3 (3 minutes; 900 million K; blasted apart; deuterium into helium; 10 times more helium; too much helium for stars); OpenStax University Physics Volume 3, section 11.7 (7 protons to each neutron; the neutrons used up; the reactions stopped; a quarter of the mass); IAU OAE glossary (25% by mass); Britannica, The steady-state challenge (all elements in stars).
  • Screen 7: OpenStax Astronomy 2e, sections 27.3 (quasars) and 28.1 (distant galaxies; JWST); Britannica, The steady-state challenge and Steady state theory and other alternative cosmologies (Ryle’s radio counts); for the card sort, OpenStax sections 26.1, 26.5, 28.1 and 29.4 and Britannica.
  • Screen 8: Britannica, The steady-state challenge (the standard cosmology by the mid-1960s) and Steady state theory and other alternative cosmologies (a useful idea); Lombardi and others (2013) (the four kinds of arrow).
  • Screen 9: OpenStax Astronomy 2e, sections 27.3, 28.1, 29.1, 29.3 and 29.4; NASA, Sun facts (4.6 billion years ago).
  • Teacher notes: OpenStax Astronomy 2e, sections 28.1 and 29.2 (redshifts into distances; the expansion began everywhere) and 29.1 (the word explosion); Bailey and Lombardi (2022) and Dobaria and others (2022) (the research MELs); Lombardi and others (2013, 2018) and Bailey and others (2022) (the studies); Hubble (1929) and Britannica (Hubble’s solutions and the revised value).
  • Word list: the sources for the screen where each word is first used.

Word list