AusSci

Year 6 science · Earth and space sciences · AC9S6U02

Why do days get longer and shorter?

1Space view

The Sun and the planets

How do the planets move, and how far apart are they?

Earth is one of eight planets that go round the Sun. Together with the Sun, they belong to our solar system. Each planet follows its own path round the Sun, called its orbit. The eight planets all go round in the same direction, in nearly circular orbits that lie in roughly the same plane, like cars on tracks round a giant, flat racecourse (OpenStax).

How this lesson works. In this lesson you look at the sky in two ways. From Earth, you see the Sun, the Moon, the planets and the stars rise, cross the sky and set. From space, you would see Earth and the other planets moving round the Sun. Scientists explain what we see from Earth by working out what is happening in space. Screens 1 and 2 build up the view from space. From screen 3 on, each simulation shows the view from Earth and the view from space side by side, at the same moment, and the Link the views card asks you to join them up.

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Link the views.
  3. Read the key idea.

The picture looks down on the solar system from above the South Pole, so the planets go round clockwise. Choose a planet to read about its orbit. Then run one Earth year and watch how far each planet gets.

The planets going round the Sun

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you link the views. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Run one Earth year, and count how many times Mercury goes round.

    Need a hint?

    Press Run one Earth year. Watch Mercury, the planet closest to the Sun, and read the count under the picture.

  2. Find the planet that takes the longest to go round the Sun.

    Need a hint?

    Choose the planets one at a time with the buttons, and read how many Earth years each one takes.

  3. Show the true distances, and find the planets crowded near the Sun.

    Need a hint?

    Choose True distances, then look in the box that shows the middle of the picture bigger.

Talk about it. Why do you think the planets far from the Sun take so long to go round? What surprised you about the true distances?

The planets go round the Sun

All eight planets go round the Sun in the same direction. The closer a planet is to the Sun, the less time it takes to go round. Mercury takes 0.241 Earth years, about a quarter of a year, and Neptune takes 164.8 Earth years (NASA).

At their true distances, the four inner planets are close together near the Sun, and the four outer planets are spread far apart, with a lot of empty space between them (Night Sky Network). From Earth, the planets move in complex paths across the sky, while the stars keep their positions with respect to each other (ACARA).

My notebook

Which sentence about the planets is right?

Which planet takes the longest to go round the Sun?

2Space view

What keeps planets in orbit?

Why don’t the planets fly off into space, or fall into the Sun?

Gravity is an invisible force that pulls objects towards each other. It is why things fall down when you throw them or drop them (NASA Space Place). Anything that has mass has gravity, and objects with more mass have more gravity. Compared with the Sun, a planet has a tiny mass (OpenStax).

Isaac Newton found that one law of gravity holds for apples falling on Earth, for the Moon going round Earth and, as far as he knew, for everything in the universe (OpenStax).

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Link the views.
  3. Read the key idea.

In this simulation you can switch the Sun’s pull on and off, and change how fast the planet starts. The orange arrow shows the pull of the Sun’s gravity on the planet, and the blue arrow shows the way the planet is moving.

A planet and the Sun’s pull

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you link the views. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Switch off the Sun’s pull while the planet is going round.

    Need a hint?

    With the planet moving at Earth’s speed, choose Off for the Sun’s pull, and watch its path.

  2. Stop the planet, with the Sun’s pull switched on.

    Need a hint?

    Choose On for the Sun’s pull, then choose Stopped for the planet’s speed.

  3. Give the planet much more speed, with the Sun’s pull switched on.

    Need a hint?

    Choose On for the Sun’s pull, then choose Much faster.

Talk about it. What two things does a planet need to stay in orbit? What happens if one of them is missing?

Gravity bends the path

A moving object keeps going in a straight line unless a force bends its path (OpenStax). The Sun’s gravity pulls each planet towards the Sun, and the planet’s speed carries it sideways, so its path bends round into an orbit.

A bit slower or a bit faster, the planet still goes round the Sun, in a stretched oval. With no speed at all, it falls into the Sun, and with far too much speed it speeds past and does not stay in orbit (NASA Space Place).

My notebook

What keeps the planets in orbit round the Sun?

If the Sun’s gravity suddenly stopped, what would Earth do?

3Earth and space views

Day and night

Why does the Sun rise, cross the sky and set?

From Earth, the Sun seems to move. It rises in the east, crosses the sky and sets in the west. From space, you can see what causes this. Earth turns on its axis, an imaginary line through the North and South Poles, once every 24 hours, and east is the direction Earth turns towards (OpenStax).

On this screen

  1. Turn Earth with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Link the views.
  3. Read the key idea.

The space view looks down on Earth from above the South Pole, with sunlight coming from the left. The sky view shows Darwin’s sky at an equinox, at the same moment, seen from a little above, looking towards the north-west, so north is at the back on the right. Turn Earth and watch both views.

Darwin from space and from the ground

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you link the views. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Turn Earth until it is sunrise in Darwin.

    Need a hint?

    Press Turn Earth 3 hours, or drag the slider. Watch for Darwin’s dot moving out of the dark side into the sunlight.

  2. Turn Earth until it is midday in Darwin.

    Need a hint?

    Midday is when Darwin faces the Sun, and the Sun is highest in Darwin’s sky.

  3. Turn Earth until it is midnight in Darwin.

    Need a hint?

    Midnight is when Darwin faces straight away from the Sun.

Talk about it. In the space view, which way does Earth turn? In the sky view, which way does the Sun seem to move? How are the two connected?

Earth turns, so the Sun seems to move

Earth turns on its axis every 24 hours, and that is why we see the Sun, Moon and stars rise and set (OpenStax). Seen from above the South Pole, Earth turns clockwise (Astronomical Society of the Pacific). The half of Earth facing the Sun has day, and the other half has night.

As Earth’s turning carries Darwin into the sunlight, the Sun rises in the east. As it carries Darwin back into the dark, the Sun sets in the west.

My notebook

What causes day and night?

In the space view, Darwin is on the side of Earth facing straight away from the Sun. What time is it in Darwin?

4Earth and space views

The Sun’s path through the year

Why are summer days longer than winter days?

Earth’s axis is tilted by about 23.5° (Bureau of Meteorology), and it keeps pointing the same way in space all year (OpenStax). As Earth goes round the Sun, first one hemisphere and then the other leans towards the Sun. Around 21 December, the summer solstice, the Southern Hemisphere is tilted towards the Sun, giving the longest day (Bureau of Meteorology).

On this screen

  1. Move through the months with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Link the views.
  3. Read the key idea.

The space view shows Earth going round the Sun, seen from the side and a little below, from the South Pole’s side as on screen 1, so Earth goes round clockwise. The red dot is Melbourne at midday. The sky view shows the Sun’s path across Melbourne’s sky on the 21st of the month, seen from a little above, looking towards the north-west, so north is at the back on the right. The dashed paths are for 21 June and 21 December.

Melbourne’s Sun through the year

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you link the views. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Show Melbourne’s Sun in December.

    Need a hint?

    Move the month slider to December. Look at which pole leans towards the Sun, and at the Sun’s path.

  2. Compare it with June.

    Need a hint?

    Move the slider to June. Compare where the Sun rises, how high it gets and how long it is up.

  3. Find a month when the Sun rises due east.

    Need a hint?

    Try the months halfway between June and December.

Talk about it. In December the Sun’s path is long and high, and in June it is short and low. What is Earth’s tilt doing in each month?

The tilt changes the Sun’s path

In December the Southern Hemisphere leans towards the Sun. In Melbourne the Sun rises south of east, climbs high at midday and sets south of west, and the day lasts nearly 15 hours. In June the Southern Hemisphere leans away. The Sun rises north of east, stays low and sets north of west (OpenStax), and the day lasts about 9½ hours.

A high Sun heats the ground more than a low Sun, whose light is spread over a wider area, and a long day gives the ground more hours of sunlight (OpenStax; Bureau of Meteorology). Earth’s distance from the Sun changes by only about 3% in a year (OpenStax). Earth is closest to the Sun in January, when the Northern Hemisphere is in the middle of winter (OpenStax). At that moment Melbourne has summer, at the same distance from the Sun, so distance is not the cause of the seasons (NASA Space Place).

My notebook

Why is it summer in Melbourne in December?

How is Melbourne’s Sun different in December from June?

5Earth and space views

Long days and long nights

Why does the South Pole have months of daylight, then months of darkness?

As you move closer to the poles, the periods of winter darkness and summer daylight get longer (Australian Antarctic Program). Australia’s Davis research station in Antarctica is at about 68.6° S, south of the Antarctic Circle. Darwin is close to the equator, and Melbourne is in between.

On this screen

  1. Move through the year with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Link the views.
  3. Read the key idea.

The space view shows Earth from the side, with sunlight coming from the left. As Earth turns, each place travels along its line of latitude. The yellow part of a line is in daylight, and the dashed part is in night. The bars show each place’s 24 hours, and the graph shows one place’s hours of daylight through the year.

Daylight from Darwin to the South Pole

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you link the views. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Move the date to December, and compare the four places.

    Need a hint?

    Drag the date slider to any day in December, then read the bars.

  2. Find a date when the Sun doesn’t rise at Davis station.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Davis station to see its graph, then try dates in the middle of the year.

  3. Find out how long the South Pole has the Sun up without a break.

    Need a hint?

    Choose South Pole, then read its graph and the words under it.

Talk about it. Why does the Sun stay up all day near the South Pole in December, but not in Darwin? What happens in June?

Months of light and months of dark

Around 21 December the Southern Hemisphere leans towards the Sun. As Earth turns, places south of the Antarctic Circle never turn out of the sunlight, so the Sun stays up all day. Around 21 June the Southern Hemisphere leans away, and those places never turn into the sunlight. The South Pole has one sunrise and one sunset each year, with six months of light and six months of twilight and darkness (United States Antarctic Program).

The difference between the seasons grows the farther you go from the equator (OpenStax). Darwin’s days change by only about an hour and a half through the year, and Melbourne’s by more than five hours.

My notebook

Why does Davis station have weeks with no sunrise around June?

Why do Darwin’s days change so little through the year?

6Earth and space views

Venus and keeping time

How can the sky be used to keep track of time?

For many thousands of years, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples have observed the patterns in the movements of the moon, stars, planets and sun. These patterns were, and continue to be, used to track time and to mark important events (ACARA).

Venus orbits the Sun inside Earth’s orbit. When Venus trails the Sun in the sky, it appears just after sunset as the Evening Star, and when it is on the other side of the Sun, it shows in the early dawn as the Morning Star (ACARA).

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Link the views.
  3. Read ACARA’s background information, then the key idea.
  4. Answer the last two questions and look at your results.

The space view looks down from above the South Pole at the orbits of Venus and Earth. The sky view shows where Venus is seen from Earth. Run the days and watch Venus change.

Venus as the Evening Star and the Morning Star

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you link the views. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Run the days until Venus is the Evening Star.

    Need a hint?

    Press Run the days, or On 20 days, and watch the sky view.

  2. Keep going until Venus is too close to the Sun to see.

    Need a hint?

    After the Evening Star, keep running the days, and watch Venus come between Earth and the Sun.

  3. Find the day Venus first rises as the Morning Star.

    Need a hint?

    Keep going after Venus disappears, until it shows in the eastern sky before sunrise.

Talk about it. Why does Venus disappear for a while between the Evening Star and the Morning Star? How could watching for its return help you keep track of time?

From ACARA’s background information

The Yolngu People of north eastern Arnhem Land use Venus to time the start of a special ceremony that celebrates the first rising of Venus as the Morning Star, after it has been the Evening Star. This detailed scientific knowledge of the orbital pattern of Venus, developed from watching the night sky for millennia, is told in story and song within the Yolngu community. On the island of Mer in the Torres Strait, Venus is told apart from the stars because it does not twinkle, and it can be seen moving against the stars as it goes round the sun.

For many First Nations Peoples, the moment a planet, star or constellation is first seen on the horizon, its heliacal rising, marks an important time, such as the beginning of a season, a ceremony or the time for travel. The Pitjantjatjara Peoples of the central Australian desert know that when the constellation Pleiades appears in the dawn sky, the cold season is beginning. On the western islands of the Torres Strait, the first appearance of Baidam, the Shark constellation, on the horizon shows that yams are ready for harvesting and that the turtle mating season is starting.

The peoples of the Tiwi Islands, north of Darwin, have long known that the planets are different from stars and that they belong to a connected system. They describe the planets as wives of the moon, because they follow the same path across the sky, and this knowledge is passed down in oral records through generations.

Timekeeping is recorded in oral language, paintings, petroglyphs and stone arrangements. At Ngaut Ngaut, in Ngarrindjeri Country in South Australia, the Traditional Owners share the knowledge of a series of dots and lines carved into the rock to show the phases of the moon. At Wurdi Youang in Victoria, the Wathaurong Peoples built an egg-shaped arrangement of over 50 basalt stones. In a western context, prominent stones on its western side show where the sun sets at the equinoxes and the solstices.

On screen 4 you saw the place where the Sun sets move through the year.

Keeping time with Venus

Venus’s orbit is inside Earth’s, so from Earth, Venus is never far from the Sun in the sky. For months it shows as the Evening Star after sunset. Then it passes between Earth and the Sun, too close to the Sun to see, and comes back as the Morning Star before sunrise.

The pattern repeats, so Venus’s first rising as the Morning Star comes round again and again. The Yolngu People use it to time a special ceremony (ACARA).

My notebook

Why is Venus seen only in the evening or the early morning?

For many First Nations Peoples, what can the first sight of a planet, star or constellation on the horizon mark?

Printable activity

Planets and seasons: two models

Two pages. Page 1 is a pocket solar system: a 1 m paper strip with the planets marked at their true distances, and questions about what it shows. Page 2 is a model of the seasons with a globe and a lamp, with a table to fill in.

For teachers

Curriculum

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 6, Science understanding, Earth and space sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:

AC9S6U02 describe the movement of Earth and other planets relative to the sun and model how Earth’s tilt, rotation on its axis and revolution around the sun relate to cyclic observable phenomena, including variable day and night length

  • exploring simulations of the solar system such as a pocket solar system to appreciate the distances and relationships between the sun and planets
  • recognising the role of gravity in keeping the planets in orbit around the sun
  • using 3-dimensional models or role-play to model how Earth’s rotation on its axis causes day and night
  • using virtual simulations or real-time views of Earth from space to explore why different regions on Earth, such as the South Pole, experience long periods of sunlight or darkness over the cycle of one revolution of Earth around the sun
  • using 3-dimensional models to explore how the tilt of Earth points one hemisphere towards the sun and the other away at different times of the year, and predicting how this affects the amount of sunlight on the surface of different regions on Earth
  • researching First Nations Australians’ understandings of the night sky and its use for timekeeping purposes as evidenced in oral cultural records, rock paintings, paintings and stone arrangements

The second quote gives ACARA’s six elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each part of the content description is covered on these screens:

  • The movement of Earth and other planets relative to the sun: the eight planets going round the Sun on screen 1, and the Sun’s pull on screen 2; q-orbit, q-year, q-gravity and q-straight.
  • Earth’s rotation on its axis and day and night: screen 3; q-daynight and q-midnight.
  • Earth’s tilt and its revolution around the sun, and cyclic observable phenomena, including variable day and night length: the Sun’s path across Melbourne’s sky through the year on screen 4, and the hours of daylight from Darwin to the South Pole on screen 5; q-tilt, q-path, q-davis and q-darwin. Venus changing from the Evening Star to the Morning Star on screen 6 is another cycle seen from Earth; q-venus.
  • The elaborations, in ACARA’s order: a pocket solar system is page 1 of the printable, with screen 1 as its simulation; the role of gravity in keeping the planets in orbit is screen 2; 3-dimensional models or role-play of Earth’s rotation causing day and night are screen 3 and the role-play under How the lesson is taught; virtual simulations of why regions such as the South Pole have long periods of sunlight or darkness are screen 5; 3-dimensional models of the tilt pointing one hemisphere towards the sun and the other away are screen 4 and page 2 of the printable, a globe and a lamp; and First Nations Australians’ understandings of the night sky and its use for timekeeping are screen 6, from ACARA’s teacher background information.

The lesson also works on these content descriptions. The notebook questions on screens 3 and 4 ask students to predict, as in AC9S6I01; measuring and marking the pocket solar system is AC9S6I03; the simulations, the graph on screen 5, the strip and the globe model are representations that show patterns and relationships, as in AC9S6I04; and screen 6 shows how First Nations Peoples use their knowledge of the sky to decide when events happen, which links to AC9S6H02.

AC9S6I01 pose investigable questions to identify patterns and test relationships and make reasoned predictions

AC9S6I03 use equipment to observe, measure and record data with reasonable precision, using digital tools as appropriate

AC9S6I04 construct and use appropriate representations, including tables, graphs and visual or physical models, to organise and process data and information and describe patterns, trends and relationships

AC9S6H02 investigate how scientific knowledge is used by individuals and communities to identify problems, consider responses and make decisions

It builds on Year 2’s AC9S2U01, “recognise Earth is a planet in the solar system and identify patterns in the changing position of the sun, moon, planets and stars in the sky”, and leads to Year 7’s AC9S7U03, “model cyclic changes in the relative positions of the Earth, sun and moon and explain how these cycles cause eclipses and influence predictable phenomena on Earth, including seasons and tides”, which the site’s Year 7 sun, Earth and Moon lesson teaches.

The heating explanation in screen 4’s key idea and q-tilt also teaches part of AC9S7U03, whose first elaboration has Earth’s tilt and position causing “differences in light intensity on Earth’s surface, resulting in seasons”. Elaboration 6 is about students researching. Screen 6 gives them ACARA’s teacher background information to read, so if students are to research, follow it with local sources that the community has approved.

How the lesson is taught

The method is linking Earth and space views, from Julia Plummer and colleagues’ research on how children learn to explain what they see in the sky. Explaining the sky means connecting what we see from Earth’s surface with Earth’s motion in space, and Plummer, Kocareli and Slagle (2014) found that “focusing on a single frame of reference resulted in less sophisticated explanations”. Screens 1 and 2 build the view from space: the planets’ orbits and the Sun’s pull. On screens 3 to 6 each simulation shows what is seen from Earth (the sky over Darwin or Melbourne, day and night bars for four places, or Venus in the evening or morning sky) beside a view from space at the same time or date. The Link the views card on those screens asks first what students saw from Earth, then what is happening in space. On screens 1 and 2 the card asks about the space view first, then links it to something seen from Earth: planets moving among the stars, and a thrown ball falling. Each wrong option gets its own reply.

Run it in pairs. Before screen 3, run a role-play. Plummer, Wasko and Slagle’s children used their own bodies as Earth to experience how the Sun would appear to move. One way to do it is to set a lamp on a table in a darkened room as the Sun. Each student stands as Earth, with their head as the North Pole, faces the lamp (midday) and turns slowly to their left, which is the way Earth turns. Ask what the lamp seems to do: it slips out of view on one side (sunset), is behind them at midnight, and comes back into view on the other side (sunrise). They turn one way, and the lamp seems to move the other way. Then go to screen 3 and find the same moments in both views. In the role-play students look down on their own North Pole, and Earth turns anticlockwise. Screen 3 looks from above the South Pole, where the same turning looks clockwise. Point this out before they compare the two. Page 2 of the printable does the same for the seasons with a globe carried round a lamp, as in Plummer and Maynard’s lessons. Use the Talk about it prompts, and have each pair point to both views before they choose on the card.

Plummer, Wasko and Slagle (2011) interviewed 24 third graders before any astronomy teaching and found that “about half are working from naive mental models”; half explained the Sun’s apparent motion with its actual motion. Their teaching moved between the Earth-based and the space-based views with computer simulations, hands-on modelling and kinaesthetic activities, and 16 gifted third graders reasoned better afterwards. Plummer, Kocareli and Slagle (2014) interviewed 99 students aged 8 and 9 after one of four kinds of teaching: a space-based focus, an Earth-based focus in a planetarium, classroom lessons that connected the two views, and the planetarium followed by those lessons. Teaching both views worked better than teaching one, though few students reached a fully scientific explanation. Plummer and Maynard (2014) taught the seasons to 38 students aged 13 and 14 in ten lessons that included globes moved round a bulb, acting out Earth’s motions and tracing the Sun’s path. Average scores rose from 13.3 to 21.9 out of 39, but only 7 students reached the scientific level, and the authors name connecting what is seen from Earth with Earth’s motion in space as one of the major challenges that held students back.

These are small studies in US schools. The 2011 teaching was tried with 16 gifted students who started with unusually high knowledge, which limits how far the results generalise; Plummer and Maynard had 38 students in one school, with moderate reliability and a construct map they do not claim is definitive. Plummer’s 2014 review adds that learning progressions do not describe how every student will progress. This lesson takes the studies’ pairing of Earth and space views and the role-play; the simulations, the places and the cards are the lesson’s own.

Handle with care

  • The lamp and the globe. Keep the lamp’s cord out of the way so nobody trips, don’t touch the lamp’s bulb while it is on, because it can get hot, and don’t stare into the light. A ball with a skewer through it can stand in for a globe; an adult pushes the skewer through, and students keep the sharp end pointing away from people.
  • Looking at the sky. If students look for Venus at home, they look only after sunset or before sunrise, with an adult, and never look at the Sun itself.
  • The First Nations content. Screen 6, its key idea and q-rising use only ACARA’s teacher background information for elaboration 6. No people are drawn, and the simulation shows only Venus and Earth going round the Sun. ACARA’s page warns that some of the sources in its consulted works “may contain material that is considered culturally offensive or inappropriate”, that they “are not provided or recommended as classroom resources”, and that written records can be problematic, as they are often “based on non-Indigenous interpretations of observations”. It adds that these sources “often lack the viewpoints of the people they discuss” and “can contain ideas based on outdated scientific theories”, that although they are public they “may contain cultural breaches and cause offence to the Peoples concerned”, and that with careful selection, evaluation and community consultation they could be “culturally audited, refined and adapted” into culturally appropriate teaching materials. ACARA’s page spells the Yolngu People’s name two ways; the lesson uses Yolngu. Screen 6 has not been checked with the Peoples it names. Follow your school’s or system’s protocols for First Nations content, for example by asking Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander staff or education officers, and ask your local community for advice on teaching screen 6, bearing in mind that this knowledge belongs to the Peoples named.
  • Ideas worth listening for. Half of Plummer, Wasko and Slagle’s third graders explained the Sun’s apparent motion with its actual motion: the Sun moving round Earth. Before teaching, 58% of Plummer and Maynard’s students were at the naive level. One student wrote “The Sun is farther away in the winter and closer in the summer.”, and at first the students thought Earth’s orbit was very stretched. An earlier study they cite found the idea that the tilt flips back and forth. Sneider, Bar and Kavanagh’s review of 41 studies says that teaching the seasons in depth touches on “connecting the model of Earth as a planet in space with observations that students can make on their own.” Some of the wrong options carry these ideas (the Sun going round Earth on screen 3, Earth much closer to the Sun in December and the axis flipping over on screen 4), and each gets a reply. Listen too for the idea that the midday Sun is straight overhead everywhere: in Melbourne it never is, and on screen 4 it gets no higher than 76°. In Darwin and the rest of the tropics the midday Sun is not always in the north. By NOAA’s equations, Darwin’s midday Sun is overhead around 16 February and 26 October and in the south from late October to mid-February. Screen 3 shows an equinox.

About the models

  • Screen 1. The distances are NASA’s ratios to Earth’s values. The periods are the time to go once round the Sun relative to the stars, NASA’s sidereal orbit periods, compared with Earth’s. For Mercury to Saturn these match the periods in NASA’s ratio table to the figures shown. For Uranus and Neptune the ratio table gives the time from one equinox to the next, 83.7 and 163.7 years, so the lesson takes 84.0 and 164.8 years from NASA’s Uranus and Neptune fact sheets. The planets go round in circles at steady speeds, from starting places the lesson chose. Squeezed orbits are evenly spaced, so they are not to scale. At true distances, Neptune’s orbit fills the picture, and the box shows the middle of the picture 6 times bigger. The planets and the Sun are drawn far bigger than they would be at either scale. Run for one Earth year, Mercury goes round 4 times and a bit more (1 ÷ 0.241 is about 4.1).
  • Screen 2. The Sun’s pull gets weaker with the square of the distance, as OpenStax describes for Newton’s law, and it is set so that a planet starting at Earth’s speed goes round in a circle. Slower, the planet swings in to about 0.4 of its starting distance and back; faster, out to about 2.6 times; much faster, it never comes back. Stopped, it falls straight in. With the pull switched off, it goes off in a straight line.
  • Screen 3. The day is an equinox, so day and night are each 12 hours, as OpenStax gives, and the model leaves out the bending of sunlight by the air. Times are counted from midnight by the Sun, with midday when the Sun is highest, so they are not clock times. At midday the Sun is about 78° up, in the north, because Darwin is at 12.42° S. The space view looks down from above the South Pole, where Earth turns clockwise.
  • Screen 4. The Sun’s position for the 21st of each month of 2026 comes from NOAA’s general solar position equations, and the hours of daylight use NOAA’s 90.833°, which allows for the bending of sunlight by the air and the size of the Sun. Sunrise and sunset directions are for the middle of the Sun on the horizon. On 21 December Melbourne’s Sun rises 30° south of east, reaches 76° at midday and is up for 14 hours 47 minutes; on 21 June it rises 30° north of east, reaches 29° and is up for 9 hours 32 minutes; on 21 March and 21 September it rises due east. The space view looks at the orbit from a little below, on the South Pole’s side, so Earth goes round clockwise, as on screens 1, 3 and 6. The red dot is Melbourne at midday, and from January to April it is on the far side of Earth in this view. Earth’s place on its orbit is spread evenly through the year, and its distance from the Sun uses NASA’s closest and farthest distances, 147.095 and 152.100 million km, with the closest on 3 January in the model.
  • Screen 5. The same equations, for every day of 2026, at Darwin (12.42° S), Melbourne (37.83° S), Davis station (68.58° S) and the South Pole. Darwin’s daylight runs from 11 hours 24 minutes to 12 hours 51 minutes, and Melbourne’s from 9 hours 32 minutes to 14 hours 47 minutes. At Davis the Sun doesn’t rise from 4 June to 10 July and stays up all day from 25 November to 18 January. At the South Pole it stays up from 22 September to 23 March and down from 24 March to 21 September. The space view tilts the axis towards or away from the Sun by the right amount for the date. That tilt decides the hours of daylight, and the rest of Earth’s lean, sideways to the sunlight, is left out. The yellow parts of the lines and the South Pole’s dot use the same hours as the bars. Each line is a circle seen side-on, so the length of its yellow part is not the share of the day.
  • Screen 6. Venus and Earth go round in circles, at NASA’s distance for Venus (0.723 of Earth’s) and NASA’s periods (224.701 and 365.256 days), starting with Venus on the far side of the Sun. In the model Venus first shows as the Evening Star on day 39, comes within 10° of the Sun as it passes between Earth and the Sun on day 286, and first rises as the Morning Star on day 299. Its greatest angle from the Sun is about 46°, and the pattern repeats every 583.92 days. The 10° cut-off is the lesson’s own; how close to the Sun Venus can be seen depends on the sky and the observer. The sky view puts Venus straight above the Sun’s position, at a height that grows with its angle from the Sun.

Where sources disagree and what to check

  • 548 days or 584. ACARA’s background information says the Yolngu ceremony is “an event that occurs every 548 days”. NASA’s Venus fact sheet gives a synodic period of 583.92 days, the time for Venus to return to the same position compared with Earth and the Sun, and in the model the first rising as the Morning Star comes round every 583.92 days. Duane Hamacher, writing about the first rising of Venus as the Morning Star after it has been the Evening Star, says it “occurs every 584 days”. 548 looks like a slip for 584, with the last two digits swapped, so screen 6 gives no number of days.
  • Darwin’s hours of daylight. The Bureau of Meteorology gives about 11.5 hours at the winter solstice and about 12.5 hours at the summer solstice. The model gives 11 hours 24 minutes and 12 hours 51 minutes, worked out to the minute. For Hobart the model gives 9 hours 1 minute and 15 hours 21 minutes, and the Bureau around 9 and 15 hours.
  • 12 hours at an equinox. OpenStax gives about 12 hours of day and night. The Bureau gives about 12 hours 8 minutes of daylight on the spring equinox, because the air bends sunlight, so that the Sun can be seen just before it has risen and just after it has passed below the horizon at sunset. Screen 3 leaves the bending out, and screens 4 and 5 put it in.
  • Davis station’s dark weeks. The Australian Antarctic Program reported that in 2016 the Sun last set near Davis on 2 June and stayed below the horizon for close to 38 days, and that in 2019 it dipped below the horizon, not to rise again until 10 July. The model gives 4 June to 10 July for 2026, within a day or two of these. The Antarctic Circle is at 66°34′ S (Australian Antarctic Program); OpenStax rounds this to within 23° of the South Pole.
  • Which way things turn. Most diagrams look down from above the North Pole, where Earth turns and the planets go round anticlockwise. Screens 1, 3 and 6 look from above the South Pole, and screen 4 from a little below the orbit on the same side, so that Darwin and Melbourne are in view. From there Earth turns and the planets go round clockwise (Etz). The role-play and the globe on page 2 of the printable are seen from above, on the North Pole’s side, so there the turning and the walk round the lamp go anticlockwise.

Answers at a glance

Screen 1: in one Earth year Mercury goes round 4 times and a bit more; Neptune takes longest, 164.8 Earth years; at true distances Mercury, Venus, Earth and Mars are crowded near the Sun; the closer a planet is to the Sun, the less time it takes to go round, and the planets move among the stars because they and Earth go round the Sun. Screen 2: with the pull off the planet goes off in a straight line; stopped, it falls into the Sun; much faster, it escapes; the same force, gravity, pulls a thrown ball down and keeps the planets in orbit. Screen 3: sunrise at 6 hours after midnight, midday at 12 with the Sun about 78° up in the north, and midnight at 0 or 24; at the equinox the Sun rises in the east, is high in the north at midday and sets in the west, because Earth turns on its axis. Screen 4: in December the Sun rises 30° south of east, reaches 76° and is up for 14 hours 47 minutes; in June it rises 30° north of east, reaches 29° and is up for 9 hours 32 minutes; it rises due east in March and September; the tilted axis keeps pointing the same way, so the Southern Hemisphere leans towards the Sun in December. Screen 5: in December Davis and the South Pole have the Sun up all day; the Sun doesn’t rise at Davis from 4 June to 10 July; the South Pole has the Sun up from 22 September to 23 March, about six months; the Southern Hemisphere leans towards the Sun in December. Screen 6: Venus is the Evening Star from day 39, too close to the Sun to see as it passes between Earth and the Sun from day 286, and first rises as the Morning Star on day 299; its orbit is inside Earth’s. Notebook: Perth sees sunrise after Darwin, because Earth turns towards the east and Darwin is farther east; Darwin’s days change less than Melbourne’s, because it is closer to the equator. Questions: q-orbit they all go round the Sun in the same direction; q-year Neptune; q-gravity the pull of the Sun’s gravity, while they move sideways; q-straight keep moving, in a straight line; q-daynight Earth turning on its axis once a day; q-midnight around midnight; q-tilt the Southern Hemisphere leans towards the Sun then; q-path it rises south of east, climbs higher and is up for longer; q-davis the Southern Hemisphere leans away from the Sun; q-darwin Darwin is close to the equator; q-venus its orbit is inside Earth’s; q-rising an important time, such as the beginning of a season, a ceremony or the time for travel.

Saved progress

Answers, choices, notes, settings and the try-it tasks are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere. If students share devices, clear the saved answers between them.

References

Sources by screen

  • Method: Plummer, Wasko and Slagle (2011); Plummer, Kocareli and Slagle (2014); Plummer (2014); Plummer and Maynard (2014); Sneider, Bar and Kavanagh (2011).
  • Screen 1: NASA’s planetary fact sheet (distances and periods) and its Uranus and Neptune fact sheets (their periods); Astronomy 2e 7.1 (orbits); the Night Sky Network and NISE Net (the pocket solar system); ACARA’s background information for elaboration 6 (planets moving among the stars).
  • Screen 2: NASA Space Place (gravity and orbits); NASA’s What is an orbit? (Grades 5-8); Astronomy 2e 3.3 (Newton’s law of gravitation).
  • Screen 3: Astronomy 2e 2.1 and 4.1 (Earth’s turning, east); Etz (which way Earth turns); the Bureau of Meteorology (Darwin’s latitude).
  • Screen 4: the Bureau of Meteorology (the tilt, the solstices, sunlight and Melbourne’s latitude); Astronomy 2e 4.2 (the seasons and sunrise directions); NASA Space Place (the seasons); NASA’s Venus fact sheet (Earth’s closest and farthest distances); NOAA’s general solar position calculations.
  • Screen 5: the Australian Antarctic Program (four pages); the United States Antarctic Program (the South Pole); Astronomy 2e 4.2; the Bureau of Meteorology (day lengths and latitudes); NOAA’s general solar position calculations.
  • Screen 6: ACARA’s background information for elaboration 6; NASA’s Venus fact sheet; StarDate (Venus too close to the Sun to see); Schaefer (heliacal rising, for the word list); Hamacher (584 days, in Where sources disagree).
  • Word list: the sources for the screen where each word is first used.

Word list