AusSci

Year 7 science · Biological sciences · AC9S7U02

Why did the fish die?

1A puzzle

Dead fish after the first storm

Why did the fish die?

A billabong is a pool left in a river channel or on a floodplain. In the Top End, fish kills most commonly happen early in the wet season, often after the first big storms send water into billabongs and waterholes (eriss). Sometimes hundreds of dead fish float on the water or wash up on the banks (Northern Territory Government).

How this lesson works. Each screen starts with something that happens in an ecosystem, which scientists call a phenomenon. You find out which parts of the ecosystem are involved, its components, and how one change leads to the next, which is the mechanism. After each simulation, the Explain it card asks first what happened, then how it happened. On screen 8 you put all three together to explain the dead fish on this screen.

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Explain it.
  3. Read the key idea, then write your first explanation in My notebook.

The simulation is a billabong at the end of the dry season, with 40 fish. The first big storm of the wet season comes on the night of day 4. Fish need the oxygen dissolved in the water to survive (USGS). Run the ten days, and watch the fish and the graph of dissolved oxygen.

A billabong through ten days

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain what happened. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Run the ten days, and find when the first fish died.

    Need a hint?

    Press Run 10 days. Watch the fish and the graph of oxygen, then read the words under the picture.

  2. Compare the oxygen at dawn and at 3 pm on a day before the storm.

    Need a hint?

    After the run, move Look at day to day 2, and read the line under the picture.

  3. Look at day 5, the morning after the storm, and compare it with day 2.

    Need a hint?

    Move Look at day to day 5.

Talk about it. What changed in the water after the storm? Why might the fish have died at night rather than in the afternoon?

The fish ran out of oxygen

Fish need dissolved oxygen to survive (USGS). In Top End waterways, lack of oxygen is the most common cause of natural fish kills, and it can kill susceptible fish within a few hours (eriss). In the simulation the oxygen fell after the storm, and the fish died in the early morning, when it was lowest.

The question for the rest of the lesson is what used the oxygen up, and why the fish died in the early morning rather than in the afternoon.

My notebook

When do fish kills in Top End waterways most often happen?

In the simulation, when was the oxygen lowest each day?

2Feeding links

Who eats whom in a billabong

How are the living things in a billabong linked?

A food chain is a sequence of living things through which energy and nutrients pass as one eats another, and a food web shows the many feeding links between producers and consumers (OpenStax). In this lesson each arrow points from the food to the eater, the way the energy and matter move.

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Explain it.
  3. Read the key idea.

Researchers from Griffith University, Charles Darwin University and the University of Western Australia studied what animals eat in Kakadu’s wetlands, using natural chemical tracers in the animals’ bodies. They found that small fish and invertebrates depend on tiny algae growing on water plants and in the water, and also on decaying plant matter. Algae are the key energy source for larger fish such as barramundi, because algae are the main food of their prey. Saltwater crocodiles in billabongs appear to get most of their food from the savanna around them (Northern Australia Hub). In the simulation, tap a food, then the animal that eats it, to draw an arrow.

The billabong food web

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain what happened. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Draw a food chain from the algae to the saltwater crocodile.

    Need a hint?

    Tap the algae, then an animal that eats algae. Keep going until an arrow reaches the crocodile.

  2. Draw every arrow into the jabiru.

    Need a hint?

    The jabiru eats fish and small crustaceans, and prawns are crustaceans. Tap each of its foods, then the jabiru.

  3. Find the food chain that reaches the crocodile from the land.

    Need a hint?

    Start with the grass. Which animal eats grass, and which eats that animal?

Talk about it. Which living things have the most arrows coming out of them? What would happen to the web without the algae?

Every food chain depends on producers

Algae, spike-rush and grass are producers. They make their own food using light energy. Every animal in the web is a consumer and depends on producers, even the crocodile, which eats no plants. Some food chains start with dead plants, which were producers when they were alive. Bacteria and fungi are decomposers. They break down dead matter and recycle it back into the living part of the ecosystem (OpenStax).

This web shows only some of the links. Barramundi eat “just about anything that lives in or around water” (Northern Territory Government), and a real billabong has many more arrows.

My notebook

In a food web, which way does an arrow point?

Why does every food chain in the billabong depend on producers?

3Energy

Where does the energy go?

How much of the energy in algae reaches a crocodile?

Energy flows through an ecosystem in one direction. It enters as sunlight and leaves as heat (OpenStax). Each feeding level in a food chain is called a trophic level.

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Explain it.
  3. Read the key idea.

Britannica gives an example. If the plants in a grassland hold 10,000 kilocalories of energy, only about 1,000 pass to the animals that eat them, and only 10 reach the animals three levels up (Britannica). In the simulation, a tenth of the energy at each level passes to the next. Choose a food chain from the billabong, then pass the energy along.

Energy up a food chain

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain what happened. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Pass the energy up a food chain of four, to the crocodile.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Algae, invertebrates, barramundi, crocodile, then press Pass the energy along.

  2. Run a food chain of three, and compare how much reaches the top.

    Need a hint?

    Try Algae, small fish, jabiru, or Grass, wallaby, crocodile.

  3. Find the food chain that gets the biggest share of the energy to the top.

    Need a hint?

    Try the shortest chain.

Talk about it. Why does a chain of four get less energy to the top than a chain of three? Where did the rest of the energy go?

Most of the energy is lost at each step

At each trophic level most of the energy is lost as heat, and some passes to decomposers (OpenStax). As little as 10 percent passes to the next level (Britannica). Biology 2e says the low efficiency of these transfers is usually the main thing that limits how long food chains are. After four to six transfers there isn’t enough energy left to support another level (OpenStax).

Energy leaves the food web as heat and doesn’t come back, and producers need new sunlight to keep the web going.

My notebook

In the simulation, the algae held 10,000 units of energy. How many units reached the small fish that ate them?

Where does most of the energy at each trophic level go?

4Matter

Where does the matter go?

What happens to the matter in a dead fish?

Energy flows through an ecosystem, but the matter that living things are made of is conserved and recycled (OpenStax). Photosynthesis turns carbon dioxide into the carbon compounds of food, and respiration turns them back into carbon dioxide (OpenStax).

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Explain it.
  3. Read the key idea.

Decomposers are usually bacteria or fungi. They feed on dead living things and recycle the material back into the living part of the ecosystem (OpenStax). Bacteria are microorganisms, and bacteria in water can use up oxygen as dead matter decays (USGS). In the simulation, follow a carbon atom around the billabong one step at a time, then follow the energy.

Follow the matter, then the energy

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain what happened. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Follow the carbon atom all the way round, back to the water.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Follow the carbon, then press Next step until the atom is back in the water.

  2. Follow the energy, and find where it leaves.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Follow the energy, then press Next step until the end.

  3. Take the bacteria and fungi away, and follow the carbon again.

    Need a hint?

    Choose No bacteria or fungi, then follow the carbon.

Talk about it. The carbon went round, but the energy didn’t. What would happen to a billabong with no decomposers?

Matter goes round, energy flows through

The same carbon atoms go round the billabong again and again, from carbon dioxide into algae, up the food chain, and back to carbon dioxide. Every living thing respires, and respiration turns carbon compounds back into carbon dioxide (OpenStax), so the algae, the fish and the barramundi each send some carbon back to the water while they live. Decomposers send back the carbon in dead matter, and the atom in the simulation is one that ended up in a dead barramundi. Energy goes one way. It enters as light and leaves as heat (OpenStax).

Decomposers keep the matter going round, and they use oxygen to do it. Bacteria in water can use up oxygen as dead matter decays (USGS). You will need this for the dead fish on screen 1.

My notebook

Which goes round and round in an ecosystem, and which flows through and leaves?

What do bacteria take from the water when they break down dead matter?

5Predict

Take one away

What happens to a food web when an animal disappears?

A change to one population can spread through a food web. In the north-west of the United States, the sea star Pisaster ochraceus lives where the tide comes and goes, and eats mussels. When it was removed, the mussels increased, which completely changed the mix of species and reduced biodiversity (OpenStax).

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Explain it.
  3. Read the key idea.

The simulation is a model of part of the billabong food web: algae, invertebrates, small fish, barramundi and jabiru. Every population starts at 100%, and the numbers are the lesson’s own. Take one animal away, choose a prediction for the algae, then run 10 years.

Take one away

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain what happened. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Take the barramundi away and run 10 years.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Barramundi under Take away, then press Run 10 years.

  2. Take away a different animal, and compare.

    Need a hint?

    Press Start again, choose another animal, and run it.

  3. Choose a prediction for the algae before a run, then check it.

    Need a hint?

    Before you run, choose More, Fewer or About the same for the algae.

Talk about it. Which populations changed even though the animal you took away never ate them? How did the change reach them?

A change spreads through the web

In the model, taking away one animal changed populations it never ate. With no barramundi, more small fish and invertebrates survived, and they ate more of the algae. A change that reaches a living thing through others is an indirect effect.

In one study, Grade 3 students usually noticed only the effect between a predator and its prey, and missed the wider effects through the web (Grotzer and Basca). To predict the effect of a change, follow the arrows from the living thing that changed, one link at a time.

My notebook

Barramundi eat small fish, and small fish eat algae. In the model, what happens to the algae if the barramundi disappear?

What is a population?

6Abiotic factors

Fire and the cypress pine

How does the timing of fires change a savanna?

Abiotic factors are the non-living parts of an ecosystem, such as water, oxygen and fire. The cypress pine Callitris intratropica grows in the savanna of northern Australia in small groves, where its trees stand much closer together than the trees around them. It is long-lived and fire-sensitive (Trauernicht and colleagues).

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Explain it.
  3. Read ACARA’s background information, then the key idea.

In a fire experiment at Kapalga, in a northern Australian savanna, fires lit late in the dry season (September) were far more intense than fires lit early (June). They averaged 7,700 kilowatts per metre of fire edge, against 2,100. Late in the dry season there was more leaf litter, the fuel was drier and the fire weather was more extreme (Williams and colleagues). Fires also become more severe the longer it has been since the last fire (Murphy and Russell-Smith). Closed groves of cypress pine can keep out low-intensity fires (Trauernicht and colleagues), but adult trees are easily killed by moderate-intensity fires (Bowman and colleagues). In the simulation, choose when in the dry season the fires burn and how often, then run 12 years.

Fire in a savanna with cypress pines

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain what happened. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Burn late in the dry season every year for 12 years.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Late dry season (September) and Every year, then press Run 12 years.

  2. Burn early in the dry season every year, and compare.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Early dry season (June) and Every year.

  3. Burn early in the dry season, but only every 4 years.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Early dry season (June) and Every 4 years. Watch the fire intensity.

Talk about it. Why did leaving 4 years between early fires do more damage than burning every year? What builds up between fires?

From ACARA’s background information

First Nations Australians developed and implemented fire management practices over millennia, and these practices purposefully changed the distribution of plants and animals on the Australian continent. Aboriginal fire regimes, including frequent, low-intensity fires, remove the woody understorey, prevent fuel building up, allow grasses and tubers to flourish, increase the productivity of important food resources such as cycads, and protect fire-sensitive vegetation. In Aboriginal fire regimes, fire is purposely applied in a mosaic pattern, so that nearby unburnt areas can give wildlife a refuge, and this enhances habitat diversity.

The Dukaladjarranj Peoples of north-central Arnhem Land have used fire regimes to manage the Country of which they have had unbroken custody, and this has ensured abundant and diverse plant and animal species.

The lack of Aboriginal fire management has resulted in the decline of the cypress pine, an ethnobotanically important species that needs very specific fire management to keep its populations healthy. The Tiwi Peoples have long used it as a medicine and as an insect repellent. The fire ecologist Bowman concluded that “conservation of biodiversity in Northern Australia will hinge on land managers returning to fire regimes that approximate those used by Aboriginal people” (1995).

Since European colonisation, 30 Australian land mammal species have become extinct. There is no single cause, but the suppression or removal of Aboriginal fire regimes is thought to be a significant contributing factor.

On Saibai Island in the Torres Strait, fire management practices are being reinstated to suit Saibai’s own fire-adapted habitats, whose vegetation differs from mainland Australia’s, and Saibai Elder Mebai Warusam has contributed to the knowledge behind this. Before colonisation, fires on Saibai were purposefully set in a narrow seasonal window, September to October, and were more intense and covered larger areas than fires on mainland Australia. The habitats of Saibai are now acknowledged to be a product of this more intensive burning.

When a fire burns matters

Fire is an abiotic factor that changes which plants grow where. In the simulation, early dry season fires every year stopped at the edge of the closed groves, and every adult tree survived. Late dry season fires burned in and killed every tree. Early fires that came only every 4 years, after fuel had built up, burned in too and killed some of the trees.

ACARA’s background information links the decline of the cypress pine to the lack of Aboriginal fire management, and describes Aboriginal fire regimes of frequent, low-intensity fires that protect fire-sensitive vegetation. It doesn’t say in which part of the dry season mainland Aboriginal burning happens.

My notebook

In the Kapalga experiment, which fires were more intense?

What does ACARA’s background information say about the cypress pine?

7A new species

A new grass on the floodplain

How can a grass that fish don’t eat change the fish?

Para grass is probably native to the floodplains of tropical Africa, and it was introduced into Australia as a pasture grass. It is highly invasive and has spread widely across Top End floodplains, where it can replace the many grasses, sedges and shrubs that native animals need with vast areas of para grass alone (Northern Territory Government).

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Explain it.
  3. Read the key idea.

Researchers in Kakadu found that upright grasses like para grass support very little algae, so they reduce the food in the food web where they stop other plants from growing (Northern Australia Hub). The Northern Territory Government adds that para grass seeds give seed-eating animals very little nutrition compared with native wild rice, and that the loss of habitat for magpie geese is a particular concern. In the simulation, choose how much of the floodplain para grass covers, then survey it.

Para grass on a floodplain

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain what happened. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Survey the floodplain with half of it covered by para grass.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Half under Para grass cover, then press Survey the floodplain.

  2. Find what happens to the magpie geese as para grass spreads.

    Need a hint?

    Survey with one amount of para grass, then with another, and compare the magpie geese.

  3. Survey a floodplain covered by para grass.

    Need a hint?

    Choose All under Para grass cover.

Talk about it. Para grass was brought to Australia as a pasture grass. Which animals did it change, even though they don’t depend on it for food?

A new species can change a whole food web

In the survey, para grass reduced animals that don’t depend on it for food. It replaced the native plants and the algae growing on them. Small fish and invertebrates depend on that algae, and barramundi eat small fish and invertebrates. Magpie geese lost the native plants that give them habitat and food.

Para grass can also carry intense fires in dry wetlands, and these fires can kill native animals such as turtles (Northern Territory Government). The Kakadu researchers say it is important to reduce the spread of exotic plants such as para grass and salvinia (Northern Australia Hub).

My notebook

Why are there fewer small fish where para grass has taken over?

Where did para grass come from?

8Explain

Back to the dead fish

Why did the fish die?

You have seen how energy and matter move through a billabong, what decomposers do, and how one change can spread to others. Now use what you found to explain the fish kill on screen 1.

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Explain it, then read the key idea.
  3. Rewrite your explanation from screen 1 in My notebook.
  4. Answer the last two questions and look at your results.

Early wet season storms sometimes wash large amounts of organic matter and soil into billabongs, which can raise the water’s biochemical oxygen demand and strip it of oxygen (eriss). Biochemical oxygen demand is the oxygen that bacteria and other microorganisms use as they break down organic matter (USGS), and organic matter includes dead plant material. In the simulation, change what the storm washes in and how warm the water is, then run the ten days again.

The billabong again, with the bacteria shown

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you explain what happened. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Run the storm with lots of dead plant material washed in.

    Need a hint?

    Keep Lots of dead plant material and Warm, then press Run 10 days.

  2. Run it with nothing washed in, and compare.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Nothing under What the storm washes in.

  3. Run it with lots washed in, in cooler water, and compare the deaths.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Cooler under The water, and keep Lots of dead plant material.

Talk about it. Which living things in the billabong used the oxygen? Why did cooler water save some fish?

Explaining the fish kill

The explanation in three parts
What happened (the phenomenon)Fish died in the early morning after the first big storm of the wet season.
The parts involved (the components)The dead plant material the storm washed in, the bacteria, the oxygen dissolved in the water, the algae and water plants, the fish, and how warm the water was.
How it happened (the mechanism)Bacteria broke down the dead plant material, using oxygen as they did. In daylight the algae and plants replaced some of the oxygen, but at night every living thing kept using it and none was made. By dawn there was too little oxygen for many of the fish (eriss; USGS).

Warm water holds less oxygen than cooler water (USGS), so the warm billabong had less to lose. To explain the fish kill you need screen 4’s decomposers, screen 1’s oxygen readings and screen 5’s idea that a change in one part of an ecosystem spreads to others.

My notebook

What is biochemical oxygen demand?

In the simulation, why did fewer fish die in cooler water?

Printable activity

Explain a change in a food web

Two pages. Page 1 is the billabong food web to complete, with what each living thing eats, and a question on taking one away. Page 2 has three changes to explain by what happened, which parts were involved and how it happened.

For teachers

Curriculum

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 7, Science understanding, Biological sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:

AC9S7U02 use models, including food webs, to represent matter and energy flow in ecosystems and predict the impact of changing abiotic and biotic factors on populations

  • analysing food webs to show feeding relationships between organisms in an ecosystem and the role of microorganisms
  • modelling how energy flows into and out of an ecosystem via the pathways of food webs
  • predicting the effects on local ecosystems when living things such pollinators or predators are removed from or die out in an area
  • examining how events such as seasonal changes, destruction of habitat or introduction of a species impact abiotic and biotic factors and cause changes to populations
  • considering how First Nations Australians’ fire management practices over tens of thousands of years have changed the distribution of flora and fauna in most regions of Australia

The second quote gives five of ACARA’s six elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements; the sixth, on First Nations Australians’ responses to invasive species, is not covered. Each part of the content description is covered on these screens:

  • Using models, including food webs, to represent matter and energy flow in ecosystems: the billabong food web on screen 2, energy up five food chains on screen 3, and a carbon atom’s loop beside the energy’s one-way path on screen 4; q-arrow, q-producer, q-tenth, q-heat, q-cycle and q-decomp.
  • Predicting the impact of changing abiotic and biotic factors on populations: taking away a predator on screen 5, the timing of fires on screen 6, para grass spreading over a floodplain on screen 7, and the oxygen and temperature of the billabong on screens 1 and 8; q-indirect, q-intense, q-algae, q-cool and the predictions on screen 5.
  • The elaborations, in ACARA’s order. Analysing food webs and the role of microorganisms is screens 2 and 4, with bacteria and fungi as decomposers and bacteria using oxygen, and screen 8. Energy flowing into and out of an ecosystem through food webs is screens 3 and 4. Predicting the effects of removing predators is screen 5; pollinators are not covered. Seasonal changes, the destruction of habitat and the introduction of a species are screens 1 and 8 (the start of the wet season) and screen 7 (para grass, an introduced species that replaces native vegetation). First Nations Australians’ responses to invasive species are not covered. First Nations Australians’ fire management is screen 6, from ACARA’s background information for elaboration 6.

The lesson also works on these content descriptions. Screen 5 asks for a reasoned prediction before each run, the food web and the energy pyramid are models that organise information, students read graphs of oxygen and of populations on screens 1, 5 and 8, and screen 8 builds an evidence-based explanation. Screen 6 gives ACARA’s account of how First Nations Australians’ fire knowledge bears on biodiversity, and screen 7 the Kakadu researchers’ view on reducing the spread of para grass.

AC9S7I01 develop investigable questions, reasoned predictions and hypotheses to explore scientific models, identify patterns and test relationships

AC9S7I04 select and construct appropriate representations, including tables, graphs, models and mathematical relationships, to organise and process data and information

AC9S7I05 analyse data and information to describe patterns, trends and relationships and identify anomalies

AC9S7I07 construct evidence-based arguments to support conclusions or evaluate claims and consider any ethical issues and cultural protocols associated with using or citing secondary data or information

AC9S7H02 investigate how cultural perspectives and world views influence the development of scientific knowledge

AC9S7H03 examine how proposed scientific responses to contemporary issues may impact on society and explore ethical, environmental, social and economic considerations

It builds on Year 4’s AC9S4U01, “explain the roles and interactions of consumers, producers and decomposers within a habitat and how food chains represent feeding relationships”, and Year 6’s AC9S6U01, “investigate the physical conditions of a habitat and analyse how the growth and survival of living things is affected by changing physical conditions”, which the site’s Year 4 food chains and Year 6 habitats lessons teach. It leads to Year 9’s AC9S9U03, “represent the carbon cycle and examine how key processes including combustion, photosynthesis and respiration rely on interactions between Earth’s spheres (the geosphere, biosphere, hydrosphere and atmosphere)”.

Elaboration 6 asks students to consider First Nations Australians’ fire management. Screen 6 gives them ACARA’s teacher background information to read, so if students are to investigate further, follow it with local sources that the community has approved.

How the lesson is taught

The method is systems thinking with a conceptual representation: each change in an ecosystem is explained by its phenomenon (what happened), its components (the living and non-living parts involved) and its mechanism (how one change led to the next). Hmelo-Silver, Jordan, Eberbach and Sinha (2017) say their Components-Mechanisms-Phenomena (CMP) representation “was designed to enable students to construct coherent mental models”, and they used it with modelling and simulations in a classroom intervention on ecosystems. Their quasi-experimental study found that “students deepened their understanding of ecosystem dynamics when compared to students who engaged in traditional instruction without use of the CMP conceptual representation”. An earlier version of the work, built on structures, behaviours and functions, ran a two-week aquarium unit in which “students could manipulate various ecosystem components (e.g., number of fish, amount of food, number of plants)”. With 311 students and four teachers in three public middle schools in the north-eastern United States, it reported “moderate to large effects” between the pre-test and the post-test, with effect sizes of 0.58 and 1.13 (Hmelo-Silver, Eberbach and Jordan, 2014).

Screen 1 opens with a phenomenon to explain, a fish kill after the first storm of the wet season, and students write a first explanation in their notebook. Screens 2 to 7 each give a simulation to work, then an Explain it card that asks first what happened and then how it happened, with the components named in the options and a reply to each wrong option. Screen 8 returns to the fish kill with the bacteria added to the picture, sets out the full explanation as a table of the phenomenon, the components and the mechanism, and asks students to rewrite their explanation from screen 1. Page 2 of the printable gives three changes to explain in the same three parts: the fish kill, dying cypress pine groves and para grass.

In their own study of Grade 3 students, Grotzer and Basca found that “Students typically failed to note any systemic implications within the food web beyond the specific two-way, predator-prey relationship”. Reviewing earlier studies, they report that “Students are more likely to trace effects from trophic levels up the food web, than from top predators down to trophic levels”, and that “High school students believe that a change in the size of a prey population has no influence on its predator’s population”. Screen 5 asks for a prediction about the algae after a predator is taken away, which is a change traced down the web, and screen 7 has a plant change animals that don’t depend on it for food.

These studies have limits. The 2017 abstract gives no figures for its comparison, and the 2014 study had no comparison group: its authors write, “We acknowledge that our study is limited by lacking a comparison group within our pre-post design.” The 2014 study ran a two-week unit of its own in the United States, and the 2017 study a classroom intervention with modelling and simulations; one lesson is far less than either. Grotzer and Basca’s own study was of Grade 3 students. The simulations, the models and the cards are the lesson’s own. Run the lesson in pairs. After each Explain it card, ask one pair to say the phenomenon and the mechanism aloud in their own words, and ask the class which parts of the ecosystem were involved. Keep the notebook explanations from screen 1, and on screen 8 have students compare their two versions.

Handle with care

  • Near water. Saltwater crocodiles live in Top End billabongs. If you take students near a billabong, a waterhole or a river, follow your school’s excursion rules and local crocodile safety advice.
  • Soil and mud in the Top End. Soil can carry the bacteria that cause melioidosis. The Northern Territory Government says the chance of getting sick is higher in the wet season, from October to April, and advises rubber gloves when handling soil, waterproof shoes or boots in wet and muddy conditions, and keeping cuts covered with a clean dressing when going outside.
  • Fire. Screen 6 is about fires in a savanna. Students don’t light fires or test anything with fire, at school or at home.
  • The First Nations content. Screen 6’s box, its key idea and q-acara use only ACARA’s teacher background information for elaboration 6. No people are drawn, and the simulation shows only trees, grass and fire. ACARA’s page warns that some of the sources in its consulted works “may contain material that is considered culturally offensive or inappropriate”, that they “are not provided or recommended as classroom resources”, and that written records are often “based on non-Indigenous interpretations of observations and records”. It says that “Such interpretations privilege western paradigms of non-First Nations authors and include, at times, attitudes and language of the past.” It adds that “These sources often lack the viewpoints of the people they discuss and can contain ideas based on outdated scientific theories”, that although they are public “they may contain cultural breaches and cause offence to the Peoples concerned”, and that with careful selection, evaluation and community consultation they “could be culturally audited, refined and adapted to construct culturally appropriate teaching and learning materials”, and that “The ability to select and evaluate appropriate resources is an essential cultural capability skill for educators.” As ACARA does, the lesson uses the present tense for Aboriginal fire regimes and the reinstatement of burning on Saibai, the present perfect for the Dukaladjarranj Peoples’ fire regimes and the Tiwi Peoples’ use of the cypress pine, and the past tense for Saibai’s fires before colonisation. ACARA gives a season only for those fires on Saibai (September to October, more intense than mainland fires), not for Aboriginal burning on the mainland, so the simulation doesn’t say who lights its fires. Its fires are in cypress pine groves on the mainland and say nothing about Saibai. Screen 6 has not been checked with the Peoples it names. Follow your school’s or system’s protocols for First Nations content, for example by asking Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander staff or education officers, and ask your local community for advice on teaching screen 6, bearing in mind that this knowledge belongs to the Peoples named.
  • Ideas worth listening for. Listen for students who draw an arrow from the eater to its food, read an arrow as meaning eats, or think energy is recycled like matter, and for the idea that who eats whom never changes: barramundi eat young crocodiles, and big crocodiles eat barramundi (Northern Territory Government; Northern Australia Hub). Listen too for the idea that decomposers only make soil (they also return carbon dioxide to the water and use oxygen), and that taking away a predator changes only its prey (Grotzer and Basca). On screen 8, listen for the idea that the fish died because the water got colder at night; cold water holds more oxygen, not less (USGS). A student who says the storm cooled and mixed the water is giving a second mechanism, which eriss describes and the model leaves out (see Where sources disagree).

About the models

Screens 1 and 8. The billabong is the lesson’s own model, worked out in steps of 5 minutes from 6 am on day 0. In daylight, algae and plants add oxygen at up to 1.9 mg/L an hour at noon. Every living thing uses 0.7 mg/L an hour. The water takes oxygen from the air at 8% of the gap an hour, up to 7.4 mg/L when it is warm and 8.4 mg/L when it is cooler. Bacteria use 0.1 mg/L an hour for each unit of dead plant material, which they break down at 3% an hour. Both uses are multiplied by O ÷ (O + 0.2), where O is the oxygen in mg/L, so they slow down when there is very little oxygen left. The storm brings 3.2 units (some) or 8 units (lots) at 8 pm on day 4. Each of the 40 fish has its own lowest oxygen, from 0.05 to 0.55 mg/L, and dies after 1.5 hours below it. Before the storm the oxygen is 3.1 mg/L at dawn and 10.3 mg/L at 3 pm in warm water, and 4.0 and 11.3 mg/L in cooler water. With lots of dead plant material in warm water, the oxygen falls to 0.2 mg/L at dawn on day 5 and 29 fish die, all early on the morning of day 5: the first at about 5 am, and 26 of them before 6 am. In cooler water the oxygen falls to 0.3 mg/L at dawn on day 5 and 12 fish die, all soon after dawn on day 5. With some dead plant material the lowest oxygen at dawn is 1.4 mg/L in warm water and 2.3 mg/L in cooler water, and no fish die; the eriss fact sheet says the fish of northern Australia’s tropical waterways are “generally untroubled by oxygen levels around 1mg/L”. With nothing washed in, no fish die.

Screen 2. The web has 12 boxes and 14 arrows. Each arrow is from a source: algae and decaying plant matter to invertebrates and small fish (Northern Australia Hub); dead plants to bacteria and fungi (OpenStax); prawns and insects, and fish, to barramundi (Northern Territory Government); fish and small crustaceans to the jabiru (Australian Museum); barramundi and wallabies to the saltwater crocodile (Northern Australia Hub); the bulbs of spike-rush and grasses to the magpie goose (Frith and Davies); and grasses to the agile wallaby (Territory Wildlife Park).

Screen 3. A tenth of each level’s energy passes to the next, from 10,000 units in the producers: 1,000, then 100, then 10. The 10,000 units are the lesson’s own.

Screen 4. The carbon atom goes from carbon dioxide in the water into the algae, a small fish and a barramundi, into the dead barramundi on the bottom, and back to carbon dioxide through the bacteria and fungi, in six steps. With no bacteria or fungi it stays in the dead barramundi. The energy goes from the Sun into the algae (10,000 units), the small fish (1,000) and the barramundi (100), then to the bacteria and fungi, and leaves as heat.

Screen 5. The populations follow dx/dt = x(r + Σ a x) for the algae, invertebrates, small fish, barramundi and jabiru, worked out in 400 steps a year for 10 years. Each feeding link takes c × prey × predator from the prey and gives 0.6 of it to the predator, with c = 0.004 for algae to invertebrates and to small fish, 0.003 for invertebrates to barramundi, 0.004 for small fish to barramundi, 0.002 for invertebrates to jabiru and 0.003 for small fish to jabiru. Each population also limits itself (0.012 for the algae, 0.002 for invertebrates and small fish, 0.004 for barramundi and jabiru), and r is set so that every population at 100% is steady. After 10 years: with no barramundi, algae 58%, invertebrates 150%, small fish 175% and jabiru 149%; with no jabiru, algae 78%, invertebrates 118%, small fish 148% and barramundi 137%; with no small fish, algae 108%, invertebrates 176%, barramundi 72% and jabiru 77%; with no invertebrates, algae 115%, small fish 154%, barramundi 88% and jabiru 95%. Within 10% of the start counts as about the same.

Screen 6. Each fire’s intensity is the Kapalga mean for its season (2,100 kilowatts per metre early in the dry season, 7,700 late) times a fuel factor of 1 after one year, 1.4 after two and 2.2 after four. A closed grove keeps out a fire below 4,000. A fire that burns into a grove kills 1 of its 10 trees, 3 if it is 6,000 or more, or 5 if it is 8,000 or more, and opens the grove; after that, any fire gets in and kills at least 1. Early fires every year (2,100) or every 2 years (2,940) leave all 60 trees alive. Early fires every 4 years (4,620) leave 42. Late fires every year (7,700) or every 2 years (10,780) kill every grove by year 4, and every 4 years (16,940) by year 8. The model counts only adult trees, not seedlings or young trees. The 10,780 and 16,940 are beyond the range of most of the Kapalga fires, which Williams and colleagues give as 100 to 10,000 kilowatts per metre.

Screen 7. With para grass on c% of the floodplain, the algae are (100 − c) + 0.12c of the floodplain with none, the invertebrates and small fish follow the algae, the barramundi are half the algae’s share plus 50, and the magpie geese are 100 − c. A quarter gives algae, invertebrates and small fish 78%, barramundi 89% and magpie geese 75%; half gives 56%, 78% and 50%; three quarters 34%, 67% and 25%; and all of it 12%, 56% and none.

Where sources disagree and what to check

  • How much energy passes on. Britannica says “As little as 10 percent” passes to the next level, while OpenStax gives about 14.48 percent for the first step at Silver Springs, Florida. The model uses 10%. OpenStax also says that the net production efficiency of cold-blooded animals is about ten times that of warm-blooded ones (“NPE for ectotherms is an order of magnitude (10x) higher than for endotherms”), so a warm-blooded animal such as the jabiru turns less of the energy it eats into its own body.
  • Crocodiles. The web has the crocodile eating barramundi and wallabies, from the Northern Australia Hub’s research story. The Hub’s 2014 summary found that saltwater crocodiles in billabongs “appear to be largely disconnected from the aquatic food web”, and its research story says “Most of the big crocs are eating a lot of food from the land, especially during the dry season”. The Northern Territory Government’s Be Crocwise page says “Saltwater crocodiles mostly eat fish, but will eat almost anything that they can overpower”. Adame and colleagues found that “Introduced species such as water buffaloes (Bubalus bubalis) and pigs (Sus scrofa) could contribute between 53 and 84% to the nutrition of the sampled crocodiles”; in their results, pigs and buffalo together made up about 45% on the East Alligator River and 51% on the South Alligator. The web’s one land link, through the agile wallaby, leaves out these feral animals.
  • Storms and oxygen. eriss gives a second way a storm can take oxygen from a billabong: “Wind and rain can cool the surface layer and mix the water, reducing the oxygen levels.” The mixing also stirs up organic matter from the bottom. The model leaves this out, and its Cooler setting means a billabong that is cooler all through, not one cooled by the storm.
  • Cypress pine and fire. The model counts only adult trees. Bowman and Panton found that “Stands with dense regeneration were significantly associated with an area actively protected from fire by a forestry operation”. Murphy and Russell-Smith found that between 1 and 5 years after a fire, the chance of a severe fire rose “from 3 to 8% for early dry-season fires, and from 21 to 43% for late dry-season fires”, so in the model early fires after four years’ fuel do far less harm than late fires.
  • Extinctions. ACARA’s page gives 30 Australian land mammal species extinct since European colonisation. The 2021 State of the Environment report cites a 2019 count of 100 endemic species listed as extinct or extinct in the wild since 1788, 34 of them mammals.
  • Magpie geese. Frith and Davies (1961) studied the geese with the rice industry in view. Their main foods are the seeds of swamp grasses, the blades of dry-land grasses and the bulbs of spike-rush; the web joins the two kinds of grass in one box.
  • The Kapalga fires. The 2,100 and 7,700 kilowatts per metre are means of experimental fires lit in June or September between 1990 and 1994, and the model uses them as the intensity after one year’s fuel.
  • Para grass. The Northern Territory Government says it is “probably native” to the floodplains of sub-Saharan tropical Africa.

Answers at a glance

Screen 1: all 40 fish live until the storm, then 29 die, most before dawn on day 5; the oxygen is 3.1 mg/L at dawn and 10.3 mg/L at 3 pm on day 2, and 0.2 mg/L at dawn on day 5; the card answers are the deaths on the morning after the storm and the fall in oxygen, lowest at dawn; q-killtime early in the wet season, q-dawn at dawn. Screen 2: the chains to the crocodile run from the algae through invertebrates or small fish to the barramundi, and from the grass through the agile wallaby; the jabiru eats small fish and invertebrates; the card answers are the algae, grass and dead plants at the start of the crocodile’s chains, and energy captured by producers passing along each arrow; q-arrow from the food to the eater, q-producer producers make the food every animal depends on. Screen 3: the crocodile gets 10 of 10,000 units in a chain of four, the top of a chain of three gets 100 and the magpie goose 1,000; the card answers are a thousandth, and energy used for living and lost as heat or passed to decomposers; q-tenth 1,000 units, q-heat used for living and lost as heat. Screen 4: the card answers are the atom back in the water, and bacteria and fungi breaking down the dead barramundi, using oxygen, and releasing carbon dioxide; q-cycle matter goes round and energy flows through, q-decomp oxygen. Screen 5: the card answers are fewer algae, and more small fish and invertebrates surviving to eat them; q-indirect they decrease, q-pop all the members of one species in an area. Screen 6: late dry season fires every year kill every grove by year 4, early fires every year leave all 60 trees, and early fires every 4 years leave 42; the card answers are the groves burned and killed, and more litter, drier fuel and more extreme weather late in the dry season; q-intense late, q-acara the lack of Aboriginal fire management has resulted in its decline. Screen 7: half covered gives 56% as many small fish and 50% as many magpie geese; the card answers are fewer small fish, and native plants replaced and very little algae; q-algae very little algae, q-introduced a pasture grass, probably from Africa. Screen 8: lots washed in kills 29 fish in warm water and 12 in cooler water, and nothing washed in kills none; the card answers are bacteria breaking down the dead plant material, and oxygen lowest at dawn after a night with none made; q-bod the oxygen used by bacteria and other microorganisms breaking down organic matter, q-cool cooler water holds more oxygen.

Saved progress

Answers, choices, notes, settings and the try-it tasks are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere. If students share devices, clear the saved answers between them.

References

Sources by screen

  • Method: Hmelo-Silver, Jordan, Eberbach and Sinha (2017); Hmelo-Silver, Eberbach and Jordan (2014); Grotzer and Basca (2003).
  • Screens 1 and 8: eriss’s Natural causes of fish kills in Top End waterways; the Northern Territory Government’s page on reporting fish kills; the USGS pages on dissolved oxygen and on biochemical oxygen demand.
  • Screen 2: the Northern Australia Hub’s Who eats who in Kakadu National Park’s wetlands and What do crocodiles eat?; the Northern Territory Government (barramundi, and its Be Crocwise page on saltwater crocodiles); Adame and colleagues (crocodiles’ food); the Australian Museum (black-necked stork); Frith and Davies (magpie goose); the Territory Wildlife Park (agile wallaby); Concepts of Biology 20.1 and Biology 2e 46.1 (food chains, food webs and decomposers).
  • Screen 3: Britannica (energy flow and trophic levels); Concepts of Biology 20.1 and 20.2 and Biology 2e 46.2 (heat, decomposers, four to six transfers and Silver Springs).
  • Screen 4: Concepts of Biology 20.2 and Biology 2e 46.1 and 46.3 (matter recycled, carbon dioxide, decomposers); the USGS (bacteria using oxygen).
  • Screen 5: Concepts of Biology 19.4 (the sea star Pisaster ochraceus); Biology 2e 45.6 (communities); Grotzer and Basca (2003).
  • Screen 6: Williams, Gill and Moore (1998); Murphy and Russell-Smith (2010); Trauernicht, Murphy, Portner and Bowman (2012); Bowman, MacDermott, Nichols and Murphy (2014); Bowman and Panton (1993); ACARA’s background information for elaboration 6; the 2021 State of the Environment report (extinctions).
  • Screen 7: the Northern Territory Government’s para grass weed note; the Northern Australia Hub (2013 and 2014); Frith and Davies (magpie goose).
  • Printable: the sources for screens 1, 2, 6 and 7, and Bowman and Panton (1993) for the dead cypress pine stands.
  • Handle with care: the Northern Territory Government (melioidosis); ACARA (cautions on the consulted works).
  • Word list: the sources for the screen where each word is first used.

Word list