AusSci

Year 6 science · Biological sciences · AC9S6U01

Which condition made the difference?

1A survey

Conditions in a habitat

How do the conditions in a habitat differ from place to place and change over time?

A habitat is the place where a living thing lives and finds what it needs. Its physical conditions are the non-living parts of it, such as the temperature, the light, the water and the salt. On land, sunlight, temperature, water, nutrients and soil all limit where living things can live, and in water, salinity, currents and tides can matter too (OpenStax).

The conditions can change a lot through the year. At Darwin Airport, an average of 432 mm of rain falls in January, in the wet season, and 1 mm in July, in the dry season (Bureau of Meteorology).

How this lesson works. Screen 1 is a survey of a schoolyard. You measure the conditions there without changing anything, and look for patterns. In a real place many conditions change together, so from screen 2 on you run fair tests. A fair test changes one condition and keeps the others the same, so you can tell which condition made the difference. Each set in a test has several seedlings, seeds, slices of bread or pots, because living things vary. Comparing the spread of results in each set shows whether a difference between the sets is big enough to trust.

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Check the test.
  3. Read the key idea.

This screen is a survey of a schoolyard in Darwin. A data logger with three probes measures the air temperature, the light and the moisture in the soil. Light is measured in lux. At the pond, a probe measures the temperature of the water, and a measuring stick shows how deep it is. Choose a season, a time of day and a place, or choose a place in the picture, and read the probes.

A schoolyard in Darwin

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you check the test. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Compare the lawn and the shade under the tree in the dry season.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Dry season, then choose Lawn and Under the tree in turn, and compare the readings.

  2. Compare the wet season and the dry season at one place.

    Need a hint?

    Keep one place and one time, and switch between Wet season and Dry season. Watch the soil moisture, or the pond’s depth.

  3. Compare 9 am and 3 pm on the lawn in the dry season.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Lawn and Dry season, then switch between 9 am and 3 pm.

Talk about it. Which readings changed when you moved into the shade? Could you tell from the survey which one the ferns need?

Conditions change together

The conditions in a habitat differ from place to place. In the dry season the shade under the tree is cooler, darker and damper than the open lawn, and different living things live there. The conditions also change over time. Every place in the schoolyard is drier in the dry season than in the wet season. At Darwin Airport the air is on average about 2 °C warmer at 3 pm than at 9 am in January, and about 7 °C warmer in July (Bureau of Meteorology).

In a real place, conditions change together. Under the tree the light, the temperature and the soil moisture are all different from the lawn, so the survey can’t show which of them the ferns need. A fair test can, because it changes one condition at a time.

My notebook

On the lawn at 3 pm, which reading was about the same in the wet season and the dry season?

Slaters live under the log, where it is darker, damper and cooler than on the lawn. What can the survey tell you?

2A fair test

A fair test with bean seedlings

How do light, water, salt and temperature affect the growth of bean seedlings?

A variable is anything in a test that can change, such as the light, the water or the temperature. In a fair test you change one variable and keep all the others the same. Then, if the results are different, you can tell which variable made the difference.

A fair test of light

Set A is on a sunny windowsill and set B is in a dark cupboard. Both sets get tap water and are in a warm room.

Only the light is different, so any difference in the results comes from the light.

Not a fair test

Set A is on a sunny windowsill with tap water. Set B is in a dark cupboard with salty water.

The light and the water are both different, so you can’t tell which one made the difference.

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Check the test.
  3. Read the key idea.

Each set has five bean seedlings in pots, all 3 cm tall at the start. Choose the conditions for set A and set B, then press Grow for 14 days. The words under the picture tell you whether your test is fair. To compare the sets, line up each set’s five heights from shortest to tallest and take the middle one. This is the set’s middle height, and the graph shows it day by day.

Bean seedlings in two sets

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you check the test. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Run a fair test of light.

    Need a hint?

    Make sets A and B the same, except that one is on the sunny windowsill and the other is in the dark cupboard. Then press Grow for 14 days.

  2. Run a test that changes two variables at once, and read what the words say.

    Need a hint?

    Change two things for set B, such as the light and the water, then grow the seedlings.

  3. Run a fair test of salty water.

    Need a hint?

    Keep the light and the temperature the same for both sets. Give one set tap water and the other salty water.

Talk about it. Why can’t you tell what made the difference when two variables change? What surprised you about the seedlings in the dark?

Change one variable at a time

Bean seedlings grown in the dark grow taller than seedlings in the light, but they are pale, with small leaves. This is called etiolation. The long stem gives a seedling in the dark more chance of reaching light, and without light it dies once the food stored in its seed runs out (Ha, Morrow and Algiers).

Salty water slowed the seedlings and burnt the edges of their leaves. Salt in the soil makes it harder for a plant to take up water and nutrients, so it grows poorly, and the tips and edges of its leaves burn (DPIRD). Each of these results comes from a test that changed only one variable. With two variables changed at once, you can’t tell which one made the difference.

My notebook

Ari put set A on the windowsill with tap water, and set B in the cupboard with salty water. Set B grew less. What can Ari tell from this?

In the dark, bean seedlings grew taller than seedlings in the light. Why?

3Repeat the test

What do seeds need to start growing?

What do seeds need to germinate, and how big must a difference be before you believe it?

A seed germinates when it starts to grow into a new plant. Seeds need water, oxygen and the right temperature to germinate, and a seed can stay dormant, delaying germination until the conditions are right (Australian Academy of Science). Most seeds don’t need light to start germinating, but some do (Australian Academy of Science). Plants with small seeds usually need light as a signal to germinate (OpenStax).

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Check the test.
  3. Read the key idea.

Each set has three dishes, with ten bean seeds on paper towel in each dish. Choose the conditions for set A and set B, press Wait 7 days, and count the seeds that sprouted in each dish. The three dishes in a set have the same conditions, but their counts are not all the same. Compare the difference between the two sets with the difference between dishes in the same set.

Bean seeds in dishes

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you check the test. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Test whether seeds need water.

    Need a hint?

    Make the sets the same except for the water: damp paper for one set and dry paper for the other. Then press Wait 7 days.

  2. Test whether the temperature matters.

    Need a hint?

    Keep both sets damp and in the dark. Put one set at room temperature and the other in the cold, like a fridge.

  3. Test whether bean seeds need light, and see whether the dish counts overlap.

    Need a hint?

    Keep both sets damp and at room temperature. Put one set in the light and the other in the dark.

Talk about it. The three dishes in a set gave different counts. Why do you think that happened? How big must a difference between two sets be before you believe it?

Repeat to see the spread

The bean seeds needed water to germinate, and none of the dry seeds sprouted. None sprouted in the cold within 7 days either. Light made no difference. Beans have large seeds, and large seeds store enough food to germinate deep below the ground (OpenStax).

Dishes with the same conditions gave different counts, such as 9, 10 and 8, because seeds vary. In the light test the dish counts overlapped: set A’s dishes had 9, 10 and 8 sprouted seeds and set B’s had 10, 9 and 9, so the light made no real difference. In the water test every damp dish sprouted more seeds than any dry dish, so the water made a real difference. With only one dish in each set, you couldn’t tell a real difference from the normal spread.

My notebook

Which of these do bean seeds need to germinate?

Set A’s dishes had 9, 10 and 8 sprouted seeds, and set B’s had 10, 9 and 9. What does this show?

4Predict, then test

Bread mould in sealed bags

Where does bread mould grow fastest?

Mould is a kind of fungus. Moulds make spores, which float through the air and start new mould growing where they find suitable conditions (USDA). Fungi grow best where it is moist, and they can grow in the dark or in the light (OpenStax).

Keep the bags sealed. If you grow bread mould in class, seal the bread in plastic bags and never open them, so that no spores get into the air. Some moulds cause allergic reactions and breathing problems. Look at the mould through the plastic, never sniff it, and put the bags in the bin still sealed at the end (US EPA; USDA).

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Check the test.
  3. Read the key idea.

Each set has three sealed bags, each with a slice of bread. Choose the conditions for set A and set B. Before you run the test, predict which set will grow more mould. Then press Wait 10 days and check your prediction against what happened.

Bread in sealed bags

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you check the test. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Run a fair test of temperature.

    Need a hint?

    Make the bread the same in both sets, dry or damp, and choose a different temperature for each set. Then press Wait 10 days.

  2. Run a fair test of damp bread against dry bread.

    Need a hint?

    Keep the temperature the same for both sets, and make the bread damp in one set and dry in the other.

  3. Choose a prediction before a run, then check it.

    Need a hint?

    Before you run the test, choose Set A, Set B or About the same with the prediction buttons. Then run the test and read the words.

Talk about it. Which bags grew the most mould? How do people use what you found when they store food?

Warm, damp bread goes mouldy first

The mould grew fastest on damp bread in a warm place, and slowest in the fridge. Warm, humid conditions help mould to grow (USDA), and fungi need a lot of moisture to grow actively (OpenStax).

People use this knowledge when they package and store food. Keeping bread cool and dry slows mould down. Most moulds prefer warmth, but they can grow at fridge temperatures too, so food in the fridge can still go mouldy (USDA).

My notebook

Which slice of bread is likely to go mouldy first?

Why must the bags stay sealed during a bread mould test?

5Heat and time

Corals and warm water

How does warmer water affect corals?

Corals are animals. Tiny algae live inside many corals, and they give the corals most of the food and energy they need (OpenStax). Global warming caused by burning fossil fuels is raising ocean temperatures, and the warming has caused corals to lose their algae and turn white, which is called coral bleaching (OpenStax). Water only 1 °C above the normal summer maximum for four weeks can start bleaching (GBRMPA).

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Check the test.
  3. Read the key idea.

NOAA, a science agency in the United States, uses satellites to watch the temperature of the sea over coral reefs. It adds up the heat stress on a reef in degree heating weeks. Each week the water is at least 1 °C above its usual summer maximum adds that many degrees, so 1 °C extra for two weeks and 2 °C extra for one week both give 2 degree heating weeks (NOAA). In the simulation, choose how much warmer than usual the water gets and for how many weeks, then run the summer.

A reef through a hot summer

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you check the test. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Keep the extra heat at 1 °C and change only the number of weeks.

    Need a hint?

    Leave Warmer than usual on 1 °C, and run the summer twice with different numbers of weeks.

  2. Find a summer that bleaches the corals.

    Need a hint?

    Try 1 °C warmer than usual, and increase the number of weeks. Then press Run the summer.

  3. Find a summer that puts corals at risk of dying.

    Need a hint?

    The heat stress needs to reach 8 degree heating weeks. Try 2 °C warmer for longer.

Talk about it. A summer can be a little warmer for a long time, or much warmer for a short time. Why do scientists add up both the heat and the time?

Heat and time both count

The heat stress on a reef depends on how much warmer the water is and on how long it stays warm. NOAA warns of bleaching across a reef when the heat stress reaches 4 degree heating weeks, and of the most heat-sensitive corals dying as well at 8. At 12, 16 and 20 it warns of more and more corals dying, and at 20 or more, of nearly all of them (NOAA).

Bleached corals don’t always die. Without their algae they begin to starve, but if conditions return to normal, they can slowly take their algae back and recover. Shallow reefs in high temperatures and strong sunlight are most at risk (GBRMPA).

My notebook

Why do corals turn white when they bleach?

A reef bleached in a hot summer. What can happen to its corals next?

6Compare two plants

Salt and survival

Why can some plants grow in salty soil when others can’t?

The saltiness of water or soil is called its salinity. Salt in the soil makes it harder for plants to take up water and nutrients, and plants vary greatly in how much salt they can tolerate (DPIRD). Beans tolerate very little salt (FAO). Saltbush is a native Australian plant that is salt-tolerant. Farmers grow it as food for their animals, and it can be used to bring salty land back into use (Agriculture Victoria).

On this screen

  1. Run the simulation with your partner, and do the try-it tasks.
  2. Answer the two questions in Check the test.
  3. Read ACARA’s background information, then the key idea.
  4. Answer the last two questions and look at your results.

Each set has three pots. Choose beans or saltbush for each set, and how much salt goes in its water, then press Grow for 4 weeks. Beans and saltbush grow to different sizes anyway, so each pot is compared with the same kind of plant given no salt.

Beans and saltbush in salty water

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Try it

Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. Do the first one before you check the test. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Test salt on saltbush.

    Need a hint?

    Make both sets saltbush, then give one set no salt and the other lots of salt. Press Grow for 4 weeks.

  2. Test salt on bean seedlings.

    Need a hint?

    Make both sets beans, then change only the salt.

  3. Compare beans and saltbush, both with lots of salt.

    Need a hint?

    Give both sets lots of salt, and choose beans for one set and saltbush for the other.

Talk about it. Your tests changed only one variable each time, but a different one. What did each test show? Why would saltbush be useful on salty land?

From ACARA’s background information

Many Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples today continue to recognise that the growth and survival of the plants and animals they use is deeply connected to the way physical conditions change with the seasons. They use this knowledge to harvest from and manage their Country or Place sustainably.

The plant Pandanus spiralis provides food, fibre for making things, and medicine. The Bardi Peoples of the Kimberley region of Western Australia have long recognised that the season of king tides, Iralbu, is the time to travel to the coast, because Pandanus fruit will be ripe and ready to harvest. On Murrunga Island, off the coast of north-east Arnhem Land, the Yan-nhaŋu and other peoples of the wider Yolŋu Nation used Pandanus leaves to twine fibre for building fish traps, and this process is still in use today.

Many native Australian plants are sensitive to salt and can’t grow where there is a lot of it. Bulrushes grow in Australia’s freshwater wetlands. The Wirramayo Language speakers of Ngadjuri Country, in the mid-north of South Australia, made nets up to 12 metres long from bulrush fibre to catch kangaroo and emu. Aboriginal Peoples, including the Ngarrindjeri, also sustainably harvested bulrushes as a starchy food.

The water fern nardoo is also sensitive to salty soil, and it thrives only in places with short-lived fresh water, which it needs to germinate. Its spores can stay dormant through long droughts and germinate after rain or floods. The Yandruwanda Peoples of the lakes area in South Australia used this knowledge to grow and harvest large amounts of nardoo. Prepared in the right way, the spores are a nutritious food, and ground spores can make flour for baking.

On the Island of Saibai in the Torres Strait, the freshwater inland areas are farmed to grow plants such as taro, and the saltwater environments are carefully managed so that saltwater food is maintained.

The seasons tell people when to harvest and collect resources, and when to hold gatherings and meetings between cultural groups. Each year bogong moths migrate from southern Queensland and northern New South Wales when warmer temperatures make their food scarce. They fly to the Australian Alps and rest in cool caves, and when the temperature drops and food is plentiful again in the north, they return to breed. This migration united families from different Language Groups, who came together to roast the moths on hot rocks in places including the lands of the Ngarigo Peoples in the Snowy Mountains region near Canberra. Families also came together at Yarralumla, in the ACT, and gathered bogong moths from Birragai in the lands of the Ngunnawal People.

One of the most serious environmental problems in the wetlands of the Murray-Darling Basin is soil that has become saltier because of land clearing and irrigation schemes. Traditional Owners, represented by the Northern Basin Aboriginal Nations and the Murray Lower Darling Rivers Indigenous Nations, are working with scientific and government organisations to restore the wetlands. This includes bringing back salt-tolerant native plants such as saltbush.

Some plants tolerate salt

Salt slowed the beans and burnt their leaves, and with lots of salt they barely grew. Saltbush kept growing well. Plants vary greatly in how much salt they tolerate (DPIRD), and saltbush is salt-tolerant (Agriculture Victoria).

So saltbush can grow on land that has become too salty for beans and for many native plants. In the Murray-Darling Basin, where land clearing and irrigation have made the soil saltier, Traditional Owners are working with scientific and government organisations to bring back salt-tolerant native plants such as saltbush (ACARA).

My notebook

With lots of salt in the water, what happened to the beans and the saltbush?

According to ACARA, how do many Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples use their knowledge of how physical conditions change with the seasons?

Printable activity

Fair tests: plan one, check others

Two pages. Page 1 is a fair test with seeds: a planning table, a results table for six dishes over five days, and a grid for a line graph. Page 2 has four short investigations to check: is each one a fair test, and how would you fix it?

For teachers

Curriculum

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 6, Science understanding, Biological sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:

AC9S6U01 investigate the physical conditions of a habitat and analyse how the growth and survival of living things is affected by changing physical conditions

  • identifying the physical conditions in an aquatic or terrestrial habitat and how they change over time
  • investigating how changes to physical conditions such as salinity, soil type, sunlight or temperature affect plant growth
  • examining how changes in physical conditions such as temperature, light availability and rainfall affect animals, such as corals, honey bees or flying foxes, and predict impacts of these changes
  • investigating changes in physical conditions that are the result of human activity and exploring the impact of these on living things, such as the impact of urban lighting on nocturnal and migratory animals
  • investigating the effect of physical conditions on the growth of bread mould colonies in sealed plastic bags
  • recognising that environmental conditions can affect stages of life, such as ponds drying up, seeds requiring water to germinate, or temperatures being too hot or cold for eggs to hatch
  • investigating First Nations Australians’ knowledges and understandings of the physical conditions necessary for the survival of certain plants and animals

The second quote gives ACARA’s seven elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each part of the content description is covered on these screens:

  • Investigating the physical conditions of a habitat: the survey of a Darwin schoolyard on screen 1, with the air temperature, light and soil moisture at three places and the water at the pond, in two seasons and at two times of day; q-season and q-together.
  • Analysing how the growth and survival of living things is affected by changing physical conditions: fair tests of light, water, salt and temperature on bean seedlings on screen 2, of water, temperature and light on germination on screen 3 and of temperature and damp on bread mould on screen 4, the heat and the time that bleach corals on screen 5, and salt on beans and saltbush on screen 6; q-fair, q-dark, q-seeds, q-repeat, q-mould, q-bleach, q-recover and q-salt.
  • The elaborations, in ACARA’s order. The physical conditions of an aquatic or terrestrial habitat and how they change over time are screen 1, with a lawn, the shade under a tree, the ground under a log and a pond. Salinity, sunlight and temperature affecting plant growth are screens 2 and 6, and soil type is not covered. Changes in temperature affecting corals, with a prediction, are screen 5 and its notebook question; honey bees and flying foxes are not covered. Changes caused by human activity are the ocean warming on screen 5 and the soils made saltier by land clearing and irrigation in the Murray-Darling Basin on screen 6; urban lighting is not covered. Bread mould in sealed plastic bags is screen 4. Seeds needing water to germinate is the water test on screen 3; the pond’s falling depth in the dry season on screen 1 touches on ponds drying up, but no stage of life is shown, and eggs hatching is not covered. First Nations Australians’ knowledges of the physical conditions plants and animals need are on screen 6, from ACARA’s teacher background information.

The lesson also works on these content descriptions. Screen 4 asks for a prediction before each mould test, as in AC9S6I01, whose elaborations include “making reasoned predictions about the physical conditions that will result in the largest mould colonies growing on bread”. The bench on screens 2, 3, 4 and 6 and page 1 of the printable have students decide which variable to change, which to measure and which to keep the same, and screen 4’s safety note describes a risk, as in AC9S6I02. Screen 1’s probes are the “digital thermometers or soil moisture probes” of an AC9S6I03 elaboration. The graph on screen 2 and the line graph students draw on the printable show change over time under different conditions, as in AC9S6I04. The unfair test on screen 2 and the investigations to check on page 2 of the printable deal with “changing too many variables”, one of the errors named in an AC9S6I05 elaboration. On screen 6, Traditional Owners working with scientific and government organisations in the Murray-Darling Basin links to AC9S6H01, and screen 4’s key idea follows the AC9S6H02 elaboration on food packaging and storage.

AC9S6I01 pose investigable questions to identify patterns and test relationships and make reasoned predictions

AC9S6I02 plan and conduct repeatable investigations to answer questions including, as appropriate, deciding the variables to be changed, measured and controlled in fair tests; describing potential risks; planning for the safe use of equipment and materials; and identifying required permissions to conduct investigations on Country/Place

AC9S6I03 use equipment to observe, measure and record data with reasonable precision, using digital tools as appropriate

AC9S6I04 construct and use appropriate representations, including tables, graphs and visual or physical models, to organise and process data and information and describe patterns, trends and relationships

AC9S6I05 compare methods and findings with those of others, recognise possible sources of error, pose questions for further investigation and select evidence to draw reasoned conclusions

AC9S6H01 examine why advances in science are often the result of collaboration or build on the work of others

AC9S6H02 investigate how scientific knowledge is used by individuals and communities to identify problems, consider responses and make decisions

It builds on Year 1’s AC9S1U01, “identify the basic needs of plants and animals, including air, water, food or shelter, and describe how the places they live meet those needs”, and Year 5’s AC9S5U01, “examine how particular structural features and behaviours of living things enable their survival in specific habitats”, which the site’s Year 1 needs and Year 5 adaptations lessons teach. It leads to Year 7’s AC9S7U02, “use models, including food webs, to represent matter and energy flow in ecosystems and predict the impact of changing abiotic and biotic factors on populations”.

Elaboration 7 is about students investigating. Screen 6 gives them ACARA’s teacher background information to read, so if students are to investigate further, follow it with local sources that the community has approved. AC9S6I02 also asks students to identify “required permissions to conduct investigations on Country/Place”. If your students survey a habitat, especially beyond the school grounds, one of ACARA’s elaborations for it suggests consulting land councils for permission and for guidance on culturally sensitive places.

How the lesson is taught

The method is the control of variables strategy (CVS), taught explicitly, with repeated trials and attention to the spread of results. In Klahr and Nigam’s (2004) study of 112 children in Grades 3 and 4, the instructor in the direct instruction condition “provided good and bad examples of CVS, explained what the differences were” and asked whether each design would let the children “tell for sure”. In the discovery condition “there were no examples and no explanations”. After 8 children who already used the strategy were set aside, 52 were left in each condition, and 40 of them (77%) became masters of the strategy after direct instruction against 12 (23%) after discovery, and the masters from direct instruction were as good at judging science fair posters as the masters from discovery. Schwichow and colleagues’ (2016) meta-analysis of 72 studies, with 5355 students aged 6 to 24, found a mean effect of g = 0.61 for teaching the strategy. Effects were larger where teaching used demonstrations of good experiments or set up cognitive conflict, with no systematic effect of age, and neither hands-on nor virtual training, which is what the simulations are, did better: they found “a trend (albeit non-significant) of lower effect sizes for studies using hands-on or virtual training activities”.

Screen 2 opens with a fair test and an unfair one side by side, each with its reason. On screens 2, 3, 4 and 6 the words under the simulation say whether the set-up is a fair test, and the second try-it task on screen 2 has students run an unfair test and read why it can’t tell them anything, a small cognitive conflict. Each Check the test card asks first about the test and then what it showed, and each wrong option gets its own reply. The work on variation comes from Lehrer and Schauble (2004), whose students at the end of primary school learned about distribution while modelling the growth of a whole population of plants, and from Watson, Wright, Fitzallen and Kelly (2023), who had 64 Year 6 students in an Australian school compare plant growth under a control and three treatments and look at the variation in their group’s data. Each set in the lesson has several seedlings, dishes, bags or pots, students compare middle heights and spreads, and screen 3 asks whether every dish in one set sprouted more seeds than any dish in the other, or whether the dish counts overlap.

Dean and Kuhn (2007) followed three groups of 15 Grade 4 students. Two groups worked on problems that needed the strategy in 12 sessions over 10 weeks, one of them after a session of direct instruction, and the third had only the direct instruction. They concluded that “direct instruction appears to be neither a necessary nor sufficient condition for robust acquisition or for maintenance over time”, and that the patterns they saw “point instead to a gradual and extended process of acquisition and consolidation”. One lesson is far less practice than that, so come back to fair tests in later science lessons. Run this one in pairs. Before screen 2, read the fair test and the unfair test aloud with the class and ask, for each one, whether it would let them tell for sure. If you can, run page 1 of the printable as a real test with bean seeds on damp paper towel alongside screen 3. In a real test the places matter as well. A sunny windowsill can be warmer than a cupboard, so for a test of light keep both sets in the same place out of direct sun and cover one set with a box, and a fridge is dark inside, so for a test of temperature put the other set in a dark cupboard. Use the Talk about it prompts, and ask pairs to say which variable they changed before they choose on the card.

These studies have limits. Klahr and Nigam say they “intentionally magnified the difference between the two instructional treatments”. Their numbers carry limits as well: only 12 children became masters through discovery, and 79 of the 112 children were girls, with one of the four schools all girls. Schwichow and colleagues say their analysis “does not include all research on CVS instruction” and that moderator variables are often confounded: nearly all the studies that set up cognitive conflict also used demonstrations. Watson and colleagues worked in one school with one teacher, found that letting groups choose from many treatments was complex to organise, and report that generally “over half of the responses to the workbook questions were acceptable”. The simulations, the models, the places and the cards are the lesson’s own.

Handle with care

  • Bread mould. Grow it only if your school allows it, and check first for students with mould allergies or asthma. The US EPA’s classroom activity says “It is very important that the bags stay sealed to prevent allergic reactions and the spread of mold spores into the air”, that students must not open the bags, that the bags go on a shelf “where they will get warm, but not hot”, and that the sealed bags go in the bin at the end. It adds that “Some people, with or without allergies, are very sensitive to mold”. The USDA says not to sniff mouldy food, because it can cause breathing trouble. Screen 4’s safety note tells students the same. Follow your school’s or system’s rules for growing mould and throwing it away.
  • Seeds, salt and water. Students don’t eat the seeds or drink the salty water, and they wash their hands after handling seeds, soil and salty water. Seeds on damp paper towel can go mouldy; if they do, students don’t sniff them, and they put them in the bin and wash their hands. Wipe up spills so nobody slips.
  • Working outside. If students measure conditions in the schoolyard, they wear hats and sun protection, keep away from the edges of ponds and drains, and leave an adult to lift logs and rocks, because snakes and spiders can shelter under them. In the Top End, soil can carry the bacteria that cause melioidosis. The Northern Territory Government says the chance of getting sick is higher in the wet season, from October to April, and advises rubber gloves when handling soil and keeping cuts covered with a clean dressing when going outside.
  • The First Nations content. Screen 6, its key idea and q-knowledge use only ACARA’s teacher background information for elaboration 7. No people are drawn, and the simulation shows only beans and saltbush in pots. ACARA’s page warns that some of the sources in its consulted works “may contain material that is considered culturally offensive or inappropriate”, that they “are not provided or recommended as classroom resources”, and that written records are often “based on non-Indigenous interpretations of observations and records”. It adds that “These sources often lack the viewpoints of the people they discuss” and “can contain ideas based on outdated scientific theories”, that although they are public “they may contain cultural breaches and cause offence to the Peoples concerned”, and that with careful selection, evaluation and community consultation they “could be culturally audited, refined and adapted to construct culturally appropriate teaching and learning materials”. As ACARA does, the lesson uses the present tense for the Yolŋu fish traps, Saibai, the seasonal knowledge and the work in the Murray-Darling Basin, and the past tense for the Wirramayo nets, the Ngarrindjeri and Yandruwanda harvests and the bogong moth gatherings. Screen 6 has not been checked with the Peoples it names. Follow your school’s or system’s protocols for First Nations content, for example by asking Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander staff or education officers, and ask your local community for advice on teaching screen 6, bearing in mind that this knowledge belongs to the Peoples named.
  • Ideas worth listening for. Listen for students who change two variables to make a difference bigger, or who keep both sets the same, as in the wrong options on the Check the test cards; Klahr and Nigam’s question, whether a design would let you “tell for sure”, helps here. Listen too for the ideas that seeds need light and that seedlings grow less in the dark. Bean seeds sprout as well in the dark, because most seeds don’t need light to germinate (Australian Academy of Science), and seedlings in the dark grow taller but pale (Ha, Morrow and Algiers). A total one or two seeds higher can be taken as proof when the dish counts overlap, and bleached corals can be taken as dead, though GBRMPA says bleaching does not automatically mean they will die. Listen also for the ideas that seeds need soil (the seeds on screen 3 sprout on paper towel) and that dishes with the same conditions should give the same count, so that a different count means a mistake; both are wrong options on screen 3.

About the models

  • Screen 1. The air temperatures on the open lawn are the Bureau of Meteorology’s mean 9 am and 3 pm temperatures for Darwin Airport, rounded to whole degrees: 28 and 30 °C in January, and 23 and 30 °C in July. Everything else is the lesson’s own: the four places, the shade under the tree 1 to 3 °C cooler than the lawn, the light (30,000 to 80,000 lux on the lawn, 3,000 to 8,000 under the tree and 50 to 150 under the log), the soil moisture (35%, 40% and 45% in the wet season and 6%, 12% and 20% in the dry season for the lawn, the tree and the log), the pond 60 cm deep in the wet season and 35 cm in the dry, and the living things.
  • Screen 2. Each seedling starts at 3 cm and grows by 12 cm × the light × the water × the temperature × its own factor, along an S-shaped curve over 14 days, (1 − cos(π × day ÷ 14)) ÷ 2. The factors are 1.6 in the dark, 0.45 with salty water and 0.55 in a cool room, and 1 otherwise; each set’s five seedlings have their own factors, from 0.86 to 1.14. With no water a seedling stops growing after day 3, wilts by day 6 and has dried out by day 9. On day 14 the middle heights are 15 cm on a sunny windowsill with tap water in a warm room, 22 cm in the dark, 8 cm with salty water, 10 cm in a cool room (9 cm for set B, whose seedlings differ a little) and 4 cm with no water. The factors and sizes are the lesson’s own. Taller, paler seedlings in the dark follow Ha, Morrow and Algiers, and slower growth with burnt leaf edges in salty water follows DPIRD; what a cool room and no water do in the model is the lesson’s own choice. In the model the seedlings in the dark are still alive on day 14.
  • Screen 3. The day each seed sprouts is the lesson’s own. On damp paper at room temperature (22 °C), set A’s dishes reach 9, 10 and 8 sprouted seeds by day 7 and set B’s 10, 9 and 9, the first on day 2. In the cold (5 °C) no seeds sprout within the 7 days; common bean “seeds germinate poorly below 15°C” (De Ron and colleagues). Dry seeds never sprout, and light makes no difference. The words call a difference between the sets real when every dish in one set sprouted more seeds than any dish in the other, and otherwise say that the dish counts overlap.
  • Screen 4. The share of each slice the mould covers follows an S-shaped curve from none on day 0, reaching about half on day 5 for warm, damp bread, day 9 for damp bread at room temperature, day 9.5 for warm, dry bread, day 12 for dry bread at room temperature, day 14 for damp bread in the fridge and day 16 for dry bread in the fridge, with each bag up to half a day earlier or later. On day 10 the cover is about 99% for warm, damp bread, 62 to 80% for damp bread at room temperature, 50 to 71% for warm, dry bread, 8 to 17% for dry bread at room temperature, 1 to 3% for damp bread in the fridge and under 1% for dry bread in the fridge, which shows as no mould you can see. The words say a set grew more mould when its average cover is more than 1.25 times the other set’s and more than 5 points higher, and otherwise about the same. When both sets average under 5%, they say both grew very little, so the test can’t show much difference or check a prediction. All of this is the lesson’s own.
  • Screen 5. The heat stress is added up the way NOAA describes: each week the water is at least 1 °C above its usual summer maximum adds that many degrees, over a 12-week summer. The usual summer maximum of 29 °C and the 28.5 °C outside the hot weeks are the lesson’s own, and the hot weeks come at the start of the summer. The picture follows NOAA’s Bleaching Alert Area levels. The corals turn white as the heat stress goes from 3 to 4 degree heating weeks, and one of the seven has died and turned grey by 8, two by 12, four by 16 and six by 20. Those numbers and the order the corals die in are the lesson’s own, set beside NOAA’s risks: heat-sensitive corals dying at 8, more than 50% of corals at 16 and more than 80% at 20. NOAA’s levels give the risk across a reef, and real corals vary.
  • Screen 6. The size after 4 weeks, compared with the same plant given no salt, is the lesson’s own: beans reach 40% with some salt and 10% with lots of salt, and saltbush 100% and 80%. Each plant is drawn to scale, growing from a small sprout along the same S-shaped curve as the seedlings, over 28 days, and each pot is up to 6% bigger or smaller than its set’s figure. The numbers follow the sources’ directions (beans rated “Very poor” for salt tolerance in a 1977 Canada Department of Agriculture table in the FAO bulletin, and saltbush salt-tolerant) and are not measured values.

Where sources disagree and what to check

  • Seeds and light. The Australian Academy of Science says “Most seeds don’t need light to set off germination”, and OpenStax says “Seeds of small-seeded species usually require light as a germination cue”. Both fit the lesson, because beans have large seeds, and OpenStax says large seeds have enough food reserves to germinate deep below ground. If students test small seeds, light may make a difference.
  • When bleaching starts. GBRMPA says a rise of one degree above the normal summer maximum for four weeks can trigger bleaching, and NOAA puts significant bleaching at 4 degree heating weeks, which 1 °C for four weeks gives. NOAA’s threshold is 1 °C above the highest summertime mean temperature of the sea’s surface, not the hottest day. NOAA’s Degree Heating Week tutorial and its Science On a Sphere page expect severe, widespread bleaching and significant deaths by 8. Its current Bleaching Alert Area levels spread the risk of deaths out from 8: heat-sensitive corals at 8, many species at 12, more than 50% of corals at 16 and more than 80% at 20. The lesson follows the current levels.
  • Saltbush with some salt. Agriculture Victoria calls saltbush salt-tolerant. Hussin, Geissler and Koyro found that old man saltbush, one of the two saltbushes Agriculture Victoria names, grew best with some salt: “Raising NaCl salinity stimulated the plant growth, which was highest at 50 % sws”, half the salinity of seawater. The model gives saltbush the same size with some salt as with none.
  • Bogong moths. ACARA says the moths migrate in the hot summer months, but the Australian Academy of Science says they travel to the Australian Alps in spring, so screen 6 gives no season for the migration.
  • Where Pandanus spiralis grows. ACARA says it is restricted to warm coastal regions with saline soils and high seasonal rainfall, but the Northern Territory Government’s Bushtucker in the Top End fact sheet says it is “Found throughout the Top End near river systems and flood plains”, so screen 6 doesn’t say where it grows.
  • Seedlings in the dark. The model keeps them alive to day 14, but Ha, Morrow and Algiers say a seedling grown in the dark will die when the food reserves in its seed run out, unless it is put in the light.
  • Two spellings. ACARA’s background information for this elaboration writes Yolŋu, and its page for AC9S6U02 elaboration 6, used in the site’s day, night and seasons lesson, writes Yolngu. Each lesson follows the page it uses.

Answers at a glance

Screen 1: in the dry season at 3 pm the shade under the tree is 27 °C, 8,000 lux and 12% soil moisture, and the lawn 30 °C, 80,000 lux and 6%; the soil moisture falls from the wet season to the dry season everywhere (the lawn 35% to 6%, the tree 40% to 12%, the log 45% to 20%), and the pond from 60 to 35 cm deep; on the lawn in the dry season the air warms from 23 °C at 9 am to 30 °C at 3 pm; three conditions are different under the tree at once, so the survey can’t show which one the ferns need. Screen 2: a fair test of light gives middle heights of 22 cm in the dark and 15 cm in the light, with pale seedlings in the dark; salty water gives 8 cm with burnt leaf edges, against 15 cm with tap water; changing two variables at once can’t show which one made the difference. Screen 3: 27 or 28 of the 30 damp seeds sprout and none of the dry seeds; 27 or 28 at room temperature and none in the cold; 27 in one light condition and 28 in the other, with the dish counts overlapping, so light makes no real difference. Screen 4: with dry bread, a fair test of temperature gives under 1% in the fridge, 8 to 17% at room temperature and 50 to 71% in a warm cupboard; at room temperature, damp bread grows more mould than dry bread (62 to 80% against 8 to 17%); the bags stay sealed. Screen 5: at 1 °C warmer, more weeks give more degree heating weeks (2 weeks give 2, 6 weeks give 6); 1 °C warmer for 4 weeks gives 4 degree heating weeks and bleaching; 2 °C warmer for 4 weeks gives 8, when NOAA warns that heat-sensitive corals may die. Screen 6: with lots of salt, beans reach 10% and saltbush 80% of their size with no salt; with some salt, beans reach 40% and saltbush grows as well as with none. Notebook: 2 °C warmer for 3 weeks gives 6 degree heating weeks, when NOAA warns of bleaching across the reef. Questions: q-season the air temperature; q-together where slaters live, but not which condition they need; q-fair nothing for sure, because the light and the water both changed; q-dark their stems grew long, which gives them more chance of reaching light; q-seeds water and the right temperature; q-repeat no real difference, because the dish counts overlap; q-mould damp bread in a warm place; q-safe so mould spores don’t get into the air; q-bleach they lose the tiny algae that live inside them; q-recover if the water goes back to normal, they can slowly recover; q-salt the beans barely grew, but the saltbush kept growing well; q-knowledge to harvest from and manage their Country or Place sustainably.

Saved progress

Answers, choices, notes, settings and the try-it tasks are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere. If students share devices, clear the saved answers between them.

References

Sources by screen

  • Method: Klahr and Nigam (2004); Schwichow, Croker, Zimmerman, Höffler and Härtig (2016); Dean and Kuhn (2007); Lehrer and Schauble (2004); Watson, Wright, Fitzallen and Kelly (2023).
  • Screen 1: Biology 2e 44.2 (what limits where living things live); the Bureau of Meteorology’s statistics for Darwin Airport (rainfall and temperatures).
  • Screen 2: Ha, Morrow and Algiers (etiolation); DPIRD’s Minimising salt damage (salt and leaf burn).
  • Screen 3: the Australian Academy of Science (germination, dormancy and light); Biology 2e 32.2 (small and large seeds); De Ron and colleagues (bean seeds in the cold, in About the models).
  • Screen 4: USDA FSIS (mould growth, spores, allergies and fridges); the US EPA’s Hold the mold! (sealed bags); Biology 2e 24.1 and 24.3 (fungi and moisture); ACARA’s AC9S6H02 elaboration (food packaging and storage).
  • Screen 5: Biology 2e 28.2 and 44.4 (corals, algae and bleaching); NOAA Coral Reef Watch’s Degree Heating Week tutorial and Bleaching Alert Area levels, and NOAA Science On a Sphere (degree heating weeks); GBRMPA’s coral bleaching fact sheet and page (bleaching, recovery and risk).
  • Screen 6: DPIRD’s Water salinity and plant irrigation and Minimising salt damage (salt and plants); Abrol, Yadav and Massoud for the FAO (beans); Agriculture Victoria (saltbush); ACARA’s background information for elaboration 7; in Where sources disagree, Hussin, Geissler and Koyro (saltbush with some salt), the Australian Academy of Science (bogong moths) and the Northern Territory Government (Pandanus spiralis).
  • Handle with care: the US EPA and USDA FSIS (mould); the Northern Territory Government (melioidosis).
  • Word list: the sources for the screen where each word is first used.

Word list