AusSci

Year 3 science · Chemical sciences · AC9S3U04

What makes a solid turn into a liquid?

1On the screen, then for real

Solid or liquid?

How can you tell a solid from a liquid?

Some things hold their shape. Some things flow. Test six things in a jar to find out which are solids and which are liquids.

On this screen

  1. Test six things in the jar on the screen.
  2. Do the three tasks.
  3. Do the jar test for real.
  4. Read the key idea.

First, on the screen

Test six things in a jar on the screen. Your results table fills in as you go.

Choose a thing. Press Put it in the jar, or tap the jar, and look at what the thing does. Then press Tip the jar and look again. Whether a thing holds its shape is one of its properties. The table under the picture keeps your results.

The jar test

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Put all six things in the jar, and tip the jar each time.

    Need a hint?

    Which rows of your results table still have gaps? Choose that thing, press Put it in the jar, then press Tip the jar.

  2. Sort all six things: solid or liquid.

    Need a hint?

    Look at your results. A solid holds its shape. A liquid flows and takes the shape of the jar.

  3. Use your results: is honey a solid or a liquid?

    Need a hint?

    What did the honey do in the jar after a while? Did it hold its own shape?

Talk about it. How can you tell a solid from a liquid without touching it? Tell your partner.

Then, for real

The jar test

Now do the same test with real things. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • 2 clear plastic cups
  • A wooden block, a stone and an ice cube
  • Water, cooking oil and honey
  • A tray and a cloth for spills

What to do

  1. Put one thing in a cup. Does it hold its shape, or does it fill the bottom of the cup?
  2. Tip the cup a little, over the tray. What does the thing do?
  3. Test each thing the same way.

Take care. Do not taste anything. Tell your teacher if you have a food allergy. Wipe up spills straight away, so that nobody slips.

Did the real things do the same as the things on the screen?

Solids and liquids

A solid holds its own shape. Put a solid in a jar and its shape stays the same.

A liquid flows. It fills the bottom of a container and takes the container’s shape, and its top is flat. Tip the jar and the liquid moves, so that its top stays level.

Some liquids, like honey, flow slowly. They are still liquids.

My notebook

Which of these holds its own shape?

Honey flows very slowly. What is honey?

2On the screen, then for real

Solids that pour

Sand can be poured. Is it a liquid?

You can pour sand, sugar and rice, a bit like water. Pour them, then look closer, and see what they really are.

On this screen

  1. Do three tests on four things on the screen.
  2. Do the three tasks.
  3. Pour real sand, rice and sugar, and look closer.
  4. Read the key idea.

First, on the screen

Some things are tricky. Pour four things on the screen, and look at each one up close.

Choose a thing, then press a test. Pour it into the jar. Pour it onto the plate. Then look closer, to see what it is made of. You can also tap the jar, the plate or the magnifying glass in the picture. The table under the picture keeps your results.

Pour it and look closer

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Do all three tests on all four things.

    Need a hint?

    Which boxes in your results table are empty? Choose that thing, then press the test.

  2. Sort all four things: solid or liquid.

    Need a hint?

    Look at the plate and the close-up. A liquid spreads out flat. Grains that hold their shape are solids.

  3. Use your results: sand can be poured. Why is it a solid?

    Need a hint?

    Look at the last two columns of your table for sand, and compare them with water.

Talk about it. A friend says sand is a liquid, because you can pour it. What would you show them? Tell your partner.

Then, for real

Pour and look closer

Now do the same test with real things. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • Dry sand, rice and sugar
  • Water
  • 4 clear plastic cups and 4 plates
  • A magnifying glass

What to do

  1. Pour each thing into a cup. Look at its top: is it flat?
  2. Pour each thing onto a plate. Does it make a heap, or spread out flat?
  3. Look at each thing with the magnifying glass. Can you see grains?

Take care. Do not taste anything. Tell your teacher if you have a food allergy. Keep sand away from your eyes.

Did the real things do the same as the things on the screen?

Solids made of grains

Sand, sugar and rice can be poured, but they are solids. Each one is made of small grains, and every grain is a solid that holds its own shape.

The grains slide over each other. That is why you can pour them, and why they take the shape of a jar.

Pour grains onto a plate and they make a heap. Pour a liquid onto a plate and it spreads out flat.

My notebook

Why is sand a solid?

What does a liquid do when you pour it onto a plate?

3On the screen, then for real

Ice in a sealed bag

What happens when ice melts in a sealed bag?

An ice cube is a solid. Leave ice on a bench and it will melt. This time the ice is sealed in a bag, so no water can get in or out.

On this screen

  1. Melt the ice in the bag on the screen, and weigh it.
  2. Do the three tasks.
  3. Do the test for real.
  4. Read the key idea.

First, on the screen

Ice cubes are sealed in a bag on the screen. Weigh the bag, watch the ice, and weigh the bag again. Your results table keeps each look.

Press Weigh the bag to put the bag on the scales. Then press Wait 30 minutes and watch the ice. The room is 20 °C, and a thermometer on the wall shows it. When all the ice has melted, weigh the bag again. Then put it in the freezer.

A sealed bag of ice

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Weigh the bag of ice, then wait until all the ice has melted.

    Need a hint?

    Press Weigh the bag first. Then press Wait 30 minutes until there is no ice left.

  2. Predict what the scales will read now the ice has melted. Then weigh the bag.

    Need a hint?

    The bag is sealed. Has any water gone into the bag or come out of it?

  3. Freeze the water again, and weigh the bag once more.

    Need a hint?

    Press Put it in the freezer, then Wait until the next day, then Weigh the bag.

Talk about it. No water went into the bag and none came out, but heat moved in. What changed, and what stayed the same? Tell your partner.

Then, for real

Ice in a sealed bag

Now do the same test with real things. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • 4 ice cubes
  • A plastic bag that seals
  • Kitchen scales
  • A tray and a cloth
  • A freezer

What to do

  1. Seal the ice cubes in the bag. Wipe the bag dry and weigh it. Write the number down.
  2. Leave the bag on a tray. Look at it every 30 minutes.
  3. When all the ice has melted, wipe the bag dry and weigh it again.
  4. Put the bag in a freezer until the next day. Then wipe it dry and weigh it once more.

Take care. Check that the bag is sealed. Do not eat the ice. Wipe up any water on the floor.

Did the real things do the same as the things on the screen?

Melting and freezing

The ice melted because the room was warmer than the ice. Heat moved from the warm room into the cold ice, and the ice changed from a solid to a liquid.

No water got into the sealed bag and none got out. So the bag weighed the same before the ice melted and afterwards.

In the freezer, heat moved out of the water, and the water changed back to a solid. Water freezes to ice. Ice and water are the same stuff: one is solid and one is liquid. A change like this is called a change of state.

My notebook

Ice melts in a sealed bag. What happens to the weight of the bag?

What makes ice melt on a bench?

4On the screen, then for real

Adding heat and taking it away

What does heat do to ice, butter and chocolate?

Ice is not the only thing that melts. Move ice, butter and chocolate to warmer and colder places, and watch what heat does.

On this screen

  1. Move the three bags to four places on the screen.
  2. Do the three tasks.
  3. Warm and cool real ice, butter and chocolate.
  4. Read the key idea.

First, on the screen

Three sealed bags hold ice, butter and chocolate. Move them on the screen to a colder place or a warmer place, and see which things change.

Three small sealed bags hold an ice cube, a piece of butter and a piece of chocolate. They start in the freezer. Choose a place, or tap it in the picture, and the bags move there and stay until nothing more changes. Each place has a thermometer that shows its temperature.

Colder places and warmer places

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Try all four places.

    Need a hint?

    Which rows of your results table are empty? Choose that place.

  2. Use your results: which thing is a liquid in the fridge?

    Need a hint?

    Look along the Fridge row of your table.

  3. Predict what happens to melted chocolate in the fridge. Then check.

    Need a hint?

    What happened to the water when you moved it back to the freezer?

Talk about it. You hold a piece of chocolate in your hand and it goes soft. Which way is the heat moving? Tell your partner.

Then, for real

Warm it and cool it

Now do the same test with real things. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • 3 small plastic bags that seal
  • An ice cube, a small piece of butter and a small piece of chocolate
  • A bowl of warm water, which your teacher gets ready
  • A fridge or a freezer

What to do

  1. Seal one thing in each bag. Feel each one through the bag.
  2. Hold the bags in the warm water for a few minutes. Which things have turned to liquid?
  3. Put the bags in the fridge or the freezer. Look again later.

Take care. Your teacher gets the warm water. It must be no hotter than a warm bath. Do not eat the butter or the chocolate. Tell your teacher if you have a food allergy.

Did the real things do the same as the things on the screen?

What heat does

Adding heat can change a solid to a liquid. This is melting. Taking heat away can change a liquid to a solid. This is freezing.

Heat moves from a warmer thing to a cooler thing. In a warmer place, heat moves into the bags. In a colder place, heat moves out of them.

Different things melt at different temperatures. Ice melts at any temperature above 0 °C, so it melts even in a fridge. Butter and chocolate stay solid on a cool bench and melt in warm water.

My notebook

What can adding heat do to a solid such as butter?

Melted butter is put in the fridge. What happens?

5On the screen, then for real

Beeswax and resin

How do First Nations Australians change beeswax and resin so they can be used?

First Nations Australians have long known that heat can change a solid to a liquid, and that taking the heat away changes it back. They use this knowledge with beeswax and resin.

On this screen

  1. Add heat and take it away for three examples on the screen.
  2. Do the three tasks.
  3. Read the box about finding out more.
  4. Read the key idea.

First, on the screen

First Nations Australians have used beeswax and resin for a very long time. On the screen, add heat to each one and take the heat away, and read how it is used.

Choose one of the three. Press Add heat and read what happens and how the liquid is used. Then press Take the heat away. The three examples are about the Wimaranga Peoples, the Warnindilyakwa Peoples and the Peoples of the Tiwi Islands. We read about them on the website of ACARA, the group that writes the Australian Curriculum. The picture shows only the wax or the resin.

Heating and cooling beeswax and resin

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Add heat and take it away for all three.

    Need a hint?

    Which rows of your results table have gaps? Choose that one, press Add heat, then press Take the heat away.

  2. Use your results: what does adding heat do to the beeswax and the resin?

    Need a hint?

    Look down the With heat column of your table.

  3. Use your results: what happens when the heat is taken away?

    Need a hint?

    Look down the last column of your table.

Talk about it. Why does the resin need to be a liquid when it goes on, and a solid afterwards? Tell your partner.

Then, for real

Ask and find out

There is no test to do for real on this screen. Fire and hot wax are not safe in a classroom. Ask your teacher who your class could ask to find out more about beeswax and resin.

Changing state to use a material

For a very long time, First Nations Australians have added heat to beeswax and resin, and taken heat away, to change them into the state that is needed.

Heat changes the solid into a liquid, and the liquid is used: to repair a water carrier, to fix a spearhead to its shaft, or as a binder. When the heat is taken away, the wax or resin is a solid again.

First Nations Australians still use beeswax and resin for many purposes today.

My notebook

The Wimaranga Peoples heat beeswax with fire. What does the heat do to the wax?

Liquid resin is put on the join of a spear. What happens when the resin cools?

6On the screen, then for real

Melt it and make it again

How do melting and cooling help us recycle?

An old glass jar can become a new glass bottle. To recycle glass and plastic, people change them from solid to liquid and back again.

On this screen

  1. Recycle glass and plastic on the screen, step by step.
  2. Do the three tasks.
  3. Melt ice and freeze it in a new shape for real.
  4. Read the key idea.
  5. Answer the last two questions and look at your results.

First, on the screen

Recycle old glass and old plastic on the screen, one step at a time. Your results table shows when each one is a solid and when it is a liquid.

Choose Glass or Plastic. For glass, choose the mould too: a bottle or a jar. Then press the step button, or tap the picture, to do one step at a time. The glass is melted in a furnace. The plastic ends up as pellets. The table under the picture shows each step.

Recycling glass and plastic

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, your results table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Recycle the glass, from old bottles and jars to a new one.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Glass, then press the step button until the new glass has cooled.

  2. Recycle the plastic, from old things to new pellets.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Plastic, then press the step button until the pellets are made.

  3. Use your results: why is the old glass melted?

    Need a hint?

    What can a liquid do in a mould that a solid cannot?

Talk about it. What else could be melted and made into a new shape? Tell your partner.

Then, for real

Melt it and make a new shape

Now do the same test with real things. Your teacher will tell you when.

You need

  • Ice cubes
  • A plastic cup
  • An ice tray or a small tub with a different shape
  • A freezer

What to do

  1. Let the ice cubes melt in the cup.
  2. Pour the water into the new shape.
  3. Freeze it until the next day. What shape is the ice now?

Take care. Do not eat the ice. Wipe up any water on the floor. Do not try to melt glass or plastic yourself: that is done in factories.

Did the real things do the same as the things on the screen?

Recycling by changing state

Glass and some plastics can be melted and made into new things. Heat is added until the solid changes to a liquid.

A liquid takes the shape of its container, so liquid glass takes the shape of a mould. Then heat is taken away, and the liquid changes back to a solid that keeps the new shape.

Changing from solid to liquid and back again lets us use the same glass again and again.

My notebook

Why is old glass melted when it is recycled?

Which step comes last when a glass jar is recycled?

Printable activity

For real: ice in a bag, and solid or liquid?

Two pages for the real tests. Page 1 is ice in a sealed bag: predict, weigh, watch the ice melt, weigh again, then freeze it. Page 2 is a table for testing real things to see if they are solids or liquids, and a melt-and-freeze test that gives ice a new shape.

For teachers

Curriculum

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 3, Science understanding, Chemical sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:

AC9S3U04 investigate the observable properties of solids and liquids and how adding or removing heat energy leads to a change of state

  • observing the properties of substances and classifying them as solids (that hold their shape) or liquids (that fill the bottom of containers)
  • investigating ice melting or water freezing in a sealed bag and explaining their observations
  • using ice cubes, butter or chocolate to explore how changes of state involve the removal of heat or the addition of heat
  • investigating how changes of state in materials used by First Nations Australians such as beeswax or resins are important for their use
  • exploring how changes from solid to liquid and liquid to solid can help us recycle materials such as glass or plastics

The second quote gives all five of ACARA’s elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each part of the content description is covered on these screens:

  • The observable properties of solids and liquids: screen 1 tests six things in a jar and sorts them, and screen 2 tests rice, sugar, sand and water three ways; q-shape, q-honey, q-sand and q-heap.
  • How adding or removing heat energy leads to a change of state: screen 3 melts ice in a sealed bag and freezes it again, and screen 4 moves ice, butter and chocolate between a freezer, a fridge, a bench and warm water; q-weigh, q-where, q-add and q-away.
  • The elaborations, in ACARA’s order. Classifying substances as solids or liquids is screens 1 and 2. Ice melting or water freezing in a sealed bag is screen 3. Ice cubes, butter and chocolate, with heat added and removed, are screen 4. Beeswax and resins used by First Nations Australians are screen 5; q-wax and q-hard. Recycling glass and plastics is screen 6; q-mould and q-order.

The lesson also works on these content descriptions. Students predict on screens 3 and 4, follow a procedure and read real scales on screen 3 (thermometers are read only in the simulations; you check the real warm water), keep a results table on every screen, compare the simulation’s results with the real test’s in the box ‘Then, for real’, and see on screens 5 and 6 how people use what they know about changes of state. No screen asks whether a test was fair, which is part of AC9S3I05; the question in each ‘Then, for real’ box is a place to raise it.

AC9S3H02 consider how people use scientific explanations to meet a need or solve a problem

AC9S3I01 pose questions to explore observed patterns and relationships and make predictions based on observations

AC9S3I03 follow procedures to make and record observations, including making formal measurements using familiar scaled instruments and using digital tools as appropriate

AC9S3I04 construct and use representations, including tables, simple column graphs and visual or physical models, to organise data and information, show simple relationships and identify patterns

AC9S3I05 compare findings with those of others, consider if investigations were fair, identify questions for further investigation and draw conclusions

It goes with Year 3’s AC9S3U03, “identify sources of heat energy and examine how temperature changes when heat energy is transferred from one object to another”, which the site’s Year 3 heat lesson teaches, and leads to Year 5’s AC9S5U04, “explain observable properties of solids, liquids and gases by modelling the motion and arrangement of particles”, which the site’s Year 5 states of matter lesson teaches. Gases and the particle model are left for Year 5.

How the lesson is taught

The method is a simulation followed by the same test done for real. On each screen students first run a test in a simulation, which fills in a results table, and answer three questions from the table. Then they do the same test with real things: the box ‘Then, for real’ lists what is needed and what to do, and asks whether the real things did the same as the things on the screen. Screen 5 has no real test; Handle with care says why.

The method comes from Jaakkola and Nurmi (2008). In their experiment “66 elementary school students were placed into three different learning environments: computer simulation, laboratory exercise and a simulation-laboratory combination”, to learn about simple electric circuits. Jaakkola’s thesis gives them as “66 fourth and fifth grade students”, “10 to 11 years old”, in Finnish schools. The combination “led to statistically greater learning gains than the use of either simulation or laboratory activities alone”, and “There were no statistical differences between simulation and laboratory environments.” In the combination, the thesis says, the students made every circuit “twice in a row: first using the simulation” and then, straight after, “with the real equipment (circuits) placed next to the computer.” The authors’ reasoning is that a simulation can help students understand the principles first, but that it is necessary to show “that the laws and principles that are discovered through a simulation also apply in reality.” This lesson keeps that order: the screen, then the real thing.

The study closest to this lesson’s content is Wang and Tseng (2018), who taught “208 third-grade students” about evaporation and condensation with hands-on work alone, a simulation alone, or the simulation followed by the hands-on work. Their abstract reports that “using virtual preceding physical manipulatives and virtual manipulatives alone enhanced students’ knowledge gains about evaporation and condensation greater than the use of physical laboratory activities alone.”

The limits are these. Jaakkola and Nurmi’s students were about two years older than Year 3 students and were learning about circuits, not changes of state. Wang and Tseng’s topic was evaporation and condensation, which this lesson leaves out, and in their study the simulation alone also did better than the hands-on work alone and gained as much knowledge as the two together, so most of that gain may come from the simulation. On their test of conceptual understanding, though, the simulation followed by the hands-on work did best. The best order is not settled either: Tseng and colleagues (2023), studying heat and temperature with 205 primary school students, found that hands-on work followed by a simulation did better than a simulation followed by hands-on work, and no better than the simulation alone. For changes of state, this lesson’s topic, their abstract reports that hands-on work and a simulation were as effective as each other. Jaakkola and Nurmi’s students were in Finland, and Wang and Tseng work in Taiwan; neither of the later abstracts says where the students were. None of the studies used this lesson’s simulations.

The screens work without the real tests: the key idea opens when the three tasks are done, and nothing waits for the real test. But the method is the two together, so do the real tests for screens 3 and 4 at least. The printable is the record sheet for the real tests on screens 1 to 3 and 6; screen 4’s results can go in that screen’s notebook. Pairs can share a device, and the real tests suit groups of three or four with one set of things. Each real test takes about ten minutes of hands-on time; the ice in the bag then needs a look every 30 minutes and a freezer overnight.

Handle with care

  • Food allergies. The real tests on screens 1, 2 and 4 use food: honey, cooking oil, rice, sugar, butter and chocolate. Check each one against your students’ allergies before the lesson, reading the label of every food, the cooking oil and the honey included. Allergy & Anaphylaxis Australia tells schools to “avoid all activities that contain a child’s food allergen” and says “Teachers should speak with parents or guardians and older children before cooking classes and activities using food.” If a child is allergic to a food, leave that food out of the room; the simulation still shows it. A sealed bag is not a way round an allergy: the same page warns that even empty milk cartons “could still contain small amounts of milk.” You can bag the butter and the chocolate yourself beforehand. Nothing is tasted or eaten in any test, the ice included.
  • Warm water. The real test on screen 4 uses a bowl of warm water, which you get ready. Keep it no hotter than a child’s bath: the Raising Children Network says “A safe bath temperature for babies and children is between 37°C and 38°C.” and that “A child can be severely scalded in under a second when the temperature of water coming out of your taps is around 65°C.” Mix the water yourself, check it with a thermometer, and keep kettles away from students.
  • No flames, hot plates or hot wax. No real test needs more heat than the warm water. The fire on screen 5 and the furnace on screen 6 are on the screen only.
  • Spills. Water, oil and honey on the floor are slippery. Run the tests over trays and keep a cloth at each table. Sand should be kept away from eyes.
  • The First Nations content. Screen 5, its key idea, q-wax and q-hard use only ACARA’s teacher background information for elaboration 4. ACARA describes these practices as continuing (“Beeswax continues to be used for many purposes due to this property.”), and gives the three examples on the screen in the present tense, so the lesson does too. No people are drawn, and neither are the fire, the water carriers, the spears or the painted implements: the picture shows only the wax or the resin. Screen 5 has not been checked with the Wimaranga Peoples, the Warnindilyakwa Peoples or the Peoples of the Tiwi Islands. ACARA’s page warns that written records “can also be problematic”, that “These sources often lack the viewpoints of the people they discuss”, and that, although they are in the public domain, “they may contain cultural breaches and cause offence to the Peoples concerned.” It warns that some of the sources listed in its consulted works “may contain material that is considered culturally offensive or inappropriate”, that “The consulted works are not provided or recommended as classroom resources.”, that “The ability to select and evaluate appropriate resources is an essential cultural capability skill for educators.”, and that, with careful selection, evaluation and community consultation, they may give teachers material that “could be culturally audited, refined and adapted to construct culturally appropriate teaching and learning materials.” Follow your school’s or system’s protocols for First Nations content, for example by asking Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander staff or education officers, and ask your local community for advice on teaching screen 5.
  • Why screen 5 has no real test. Melting wax or resin over a fire is not safe in a classroom. The lesson also leaves out how these materials are worked: ACARA’s page does not give it, and the lesson’s own view is that it is for the Peoples named to teach. That view is the lesson’s, not ACARA’s. The box asks students to find out who they could ask instead. If your community offers a demonstration, that is the real thing for this screen.
  • Children’s ideas about solids and liquids. Kind’s review for the Royal Society of Chemistry says that “Children find that pourable powders have liquid properties but do not produce a sensation of wetness,” and reports Stavy and Stachel’s finding that “50% of 12- and 13-year-olds classify non-rigid solids” such as sand and sugar apart from hard solids such as coins. Those students were about four years older than Year 3. Stavy and Stachel’s abstract says of all the ages they studied, from 5 to 12, that “Powders are misclassified by all ages and are referred to either as liquids or as a separate group.” Screen 2 is for this: the heap on the plate and the close-up are the evidence that sand is a solid. Expect ‘it’s a liquid because it pours’ and ‘it’s a solid because it’s dry’, and send students back to the two tests.
  • Children’s ideas about weight. Smith, writing for the Inquiry Project, reports that “Children initially think that when something freezes or melts, its weight should change as well.” and that “they think that ice should be heavier than water”. Screen 3 asks for a prediction before the melted ice is weighed for this reason. Horizon Research adds that “Students may think that water leaked through the baggie.” when they see water on the outside of the bag; that water comes from the air, so wipe the bag dry before each weighing. Its answer to the leak idea is a demonstration: “The teacher can fill a separate baggie with water and demonstrate that the baggie is water tight.”
  • Heat moves, cold does not. OpenStax says that when two things at different temperatures touch, “energy is transferred from the hotter to the colder object”. If a student says the cold comes out of the ice, turn it round: heat moves from the warmer room into the ice, and in the freezer heat moves out of the water.
  • Where you are. The model’s room is 20 °C. In a hot classroom the real tests will not match the screen, and that is worth using. The RSC’s fact sheet gives chocolate’s melting points as a range of crystal types from 17.3 °C to 36.3 °C, and the Physics Factbook lists four published values for butter, from 21 °C to under 40 °C; one of them is the range from 28 °C to 36 °C. On a day of 30 °C or more, butter left on the bench goes soft or runny and chocolate goes soft, and ice melts in much less than the model’s 2 hours. The question in each ‘Then, for real’ box is there for results like these: ask the group what was different in the room.
  • Butter and chocolate in the real test. In water no hotter than a bath, real butter and chocolate may only go soft in a few minutes, and the water cools while the bags are in it. The Physics Factbook’s author measured butter melting at 33 °C in one trial and 38 °C in another, and the RSC’s last type of chocolate crystal melts at 36.3 °C. A soft, half-melted lump is a result for the question in the box, not a failed test. Butter that has melted and gone solid again also looks different: Kind writes that “Re-solidified butter, for example, never looks the same as it did before melting”. Smith reports that “Children are not always sure that it is still the same kind of material.” It is still butter, and it is worth saying so.
  • Recycling at home. Screen 6 shows what happens in a factory. Planet Ark notes that “Not all glass can be recycled via your household recycling bin.”: drinking glasses, window glass and oven-proof glass are left out. Which plastics a council takes varies, so check your own council’s list before students go home with the idea that all plastic can go in the bin.
  • Reduced motion. With the device’s reduce-motion setting on, each change jumps to its end: the honey is shown already settled, and the ice already melted to the next step. The words under each picture still say that the honey flows slowly.

About the models

  • Screen 1: the six things are the lesson’s choice. A liquid’s top is drawn flat; OpenStax describes it as “a flat or slightly curved upper surface”. When the jar tips, the amount of liquid drawn stays the same. Honey is drawn about five times slower than water to pour and about twelve times slower to go level; the numbers are the lesson’s own, chosen so that students can watch it. Real honey is far slower: in a University of Leeds outreach test, “Honey took almost 100 times longer to get to the same place on the slope when compared with water.”
  • Screen 2: the grains in the jar and the heap are drawn larger than life, and the close-up shows what a magnifying glass shows. The RSC’s notes say of sand and other granular solids that “These can be poured and take on the shape of the container.” and “However unlike liquids, when poured, solids form a heap.” The bumpy top in the jar is the lesson’s way of drawing a small heap.
  • Screen 3: the room is 20 °C and the freezer −18 °C; the NSW Food Authority says “Freezers should be kept at -18°C or below.” The bag with its 4 ice cubes weighs 100 g, the ice melts in four steps of 30 minutes, and the water is frozen again by the next day: these numbers are the lesson’s own. Horizon Research says real ice in a bag “may take a couple of hours” to melt. The scales read 100 g at every weighing, as the law of conservation of matter says they should: OpenStax states that there is “no detectable change in the total quantity of matter present” when matter “changes among solid, liquid, or gaseous states”.
  • Screen 4: the freezer is −18 °C and the fridge 4 °C (the NSW Food Authority: “Home fridges should be kept below 5°C at all times.”); the bench at 20 °C and the warm water at 38 °C are the lesson’s choice. A thing is drawn as a liquid when the place is warmer than 0 °C for ice (OpenStax gives “the freezing point of water at 0ºC”), 36 °C for butter and 36.3 °C for chocolate. The 36.3 °C is the top of the RSC’s range for chocolate, and the 36 °C is the top of one range the Physics Factbook lists for butter; both are the lesson’s choice. Real butter and chocolate soften over a range of temperatures: the RSC says of chocolate’s melting point, “There isn’t an exact point.” A thing that has melted and gone solid again is drawn flat, in the shape it had as a liquid.
  • Screen 5: the lump that spreads into a pool and stays flat when it is solid again is the lesson’s own drawing. It stands for beeswax or resin in general, not for any one way of working them.
  • Screen 6: the steps for glass are from the ACT Government’s fact sheet and Planet Ark. The new raw materials are left out: Planet Ark says the crushed glass is melted “usually with additional raw materials”. The steps for plastic are from Planet Ark’s page on rigid plastics, and the cooling before the pellets are chopped is from its page on plastic scraps, which is about off-cuts from factories. Real factories differ.

Where sources disagree and what to check

  • What a solid is. ACARA’s elaboration has solids “(that hold their shape)” and liquids “(that fill the bottom of containers)”. OpenStax says “A solid is rigid and possesses a definite shape.” The RSC’s primary notes say “Solid – a material that has a fixed volume and holds its shape.” The lesson uses ‘holds its shape’ and leaves out ‘rigid’ and volume. Soft solids such as a sponge or play dough are not on the screens; Kind reports that children find them hard to class as solids, so they are worth a talk if they come up.
  • Freezing. Screen 4’s key idea calls the change from liquid to solid freezing, and the RSC’s notes define freezing as “the change of state from a liquid to a solid at a temperature called the freezing point.” Elsewhere the lesson says water ‘freezes’ and butter, chocolate, wax, resin, glass and plastic ‘go solid again’, which is how people talk about them. Kind reports that many students hold firmly to the idea that freezing has to happen when it is cold. Melted butter going solid on the model’s 20 °C bench is an example to point to.
  • Glass. The lesson treats glass as a solid that melts to a liquid and goes solid again. The RSC’s notes point out that “Some liquids harden without forming a crystalline structure, eg glass, oils.” and that for these “there is no sharply defined freezing point like there is for water.” That is left for later years.
  • Butter. The Physics Factbook lists four published values, from 21 °C to under 40 °C, and concludes that butter “doesn’t have a definite melting point.” The lesson’s 36 °C is the top of one of them, the range from 28 °C to 36 °C, used so that butter is solid on the model’s bench and liquid in the warm water. The Factbook’s author measured 33 °C and 38 °C in two trials, so real butter may not melt right through in water at 38 °C.
  • How often glass can be recycled. The ACT Government says “Glass can be recycled forever.” and Planet Ark says “Glass is infinitely recyclable in this manner.” The lesson says ‘again and again’.
  • Heat. ACARA writes ‘heat energy’. OpenStax defines heat as “the spontaneous transfer of energy due to a temperature difference.” The lesson says heat ‘moves’ from a warmer thing to a cooler one, and that heat is ‘added’ or ‘taken away’. ACARA’s content description has “adding or removing heat energy”, and an elaboration of AC9S3U03 has “the movement of heat from one object to another”.

Answers at a glance

  • Screen 1: the wooden block, the stone and the ice cube are solids; the water, the cooking oil and the honey are liquids. Honey is a liquid, because it flows and takes the shape of the jar. q-shape a stone; q-honey a liquid.
  • Screen 2: the rice, the sugar and the sand are solids; the water is a liquid. Sand is a solid because each grain holds its shape, and the grains make a heap. q-sand because each grain holds its own shape; q-heap it spreads out flat.
  • Screen 3: the scales read 100 g at the start, after the ice has melted and after the water has frozen again. The prediction is 100 g, the same as before. q-weigh it stays the same; q-where heat moves into the ice from the warmer room.
  • Screen 4: in the freezer all three are solid; in the fridge and on the bench the ice is liquid and the butter and chocolate are solid; in the warm water all three are liquid. The thing that is a liquid in the fridge is the ice. Melted chocolate goes solid again in the fridge. q-add change it to a liquid; q-away heat moves out of it and it goes solid.
  • Screen 5: adding heat changes the beeswax and the resin from solid to liquid; when the heat is taken away they are solid again. q-wax it changes the wax from a hard solid to a soft liquid; q-hard it forms a smooth, hard surface.
  • Screen 6: the glass is solid, solid, liquid, liquid, solid over its five steps, and the plastic solid, solid, solid, liquid, solid. Heat is added at the melting step and taken away at the cooling step. The glass is melted so that the liquid can take the shape of a mould. q-mould because liquid glass takes the shape of a mould; q-order cooling the glass, so it goes solid.
  • Printable: in the PDF the answers are printed upside down at the foot of page 1; in the Word copy they are in a strip to fold under. Real results vary. The bag should weigh the same each time, to within a gram or two on kitchen scales, if it is wiped dry first.

Saved progress

Answers, notes, results tables and settings are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere. If students share devices, clear the saved answers between them.

References

Sources by screen

  • Method: Jaakkola and Nurmi (2008); Jaakkola (2012); Wang and Tseng (2018); Tseng and colleagues (2023). Children’s ideas: Kind’s two chapters, the first on Stavy and Stachel (1985); Smith (2011); Horizon Research.
  • Screen 1: Chemistry 2e, 1.2 (a solid has a definite shape; a liquid flows and takes the shape of its container, with a flat or slightly curved top); the RSC’s Intriguing ice notes (viscous: a liquid that flows slowly); the University of Leeds’s viscosity page (how slowly real honey flows); ACARA’s elaboration (solids hold their shape; liquids fill the bottom of containers).
  • Screen 2: the RSC’s Biscuit bashing notes (solids made of small grains can be poured and take the shape of the container, but form a heap; each grain is solid; salt, sand, rice and sugar as examples).
  • Screen 3: Chemistry 2e, 1.2 (the law of conservation of matter); College Physics 2e, 13.1 (the freezing point of water) and 14.1 (energy is transferred from the hotter to the colder object) and 14.3 (water freezes when cooled by colder surroundings; condensation on a cold glass); Horizon Research (the sealed bag, wiping it dry, how long melting takes); the NSW Food Authority (the freezer’s temperature).
  • Screen 4: the NSW Food Authority (fridges and freezers); the RSC’s Melting chocolate fact sheet; the Physics Factbook (butter); College Physics 2e, 13.1 and 14.1; the Raising Children Network (a safe temperature for warm water).
  • Screen 5: ACARA’s background information for elaboration 4.
  • Screen 6: the ACT Government’s glass recycling fact sheet (the furnace at about 1,500 °C, the mould, the air, cooling); Planet Ark’s Recycling Near You pages on glass containers (crushing, melting, what stays out of the home bin), rigid plastic (shredding, washing, melting, pellets) and plastic scraps (cooling before chopping).
  • Printable: the sources for screens 1 to 3 and 6.
  • Word list: the sources for the screen where each word is first used; Chemistry 2e, 10.3 (melting point and freezing point).

Word list