Year 5 science · Chemical sciences · AC9S5U04
What makes a solid, a liquid or a gas?
1Predict, observe, explain
Solid, liquid or gas?
What makes a solid, a liquid or a gas?
Almost everything around you is a solid, a liquid or a gas, or a mix of them. Each one has its own properties: the things it does. In this lesson you find out how tiny particles explain them.
How this lesson works. Each screen is one cycle of predict, observe and explain. First you predict: you choose what you think will happen. Then you observe: you try it in the picture with your partner and watch closely, particles and all. Then you explain: you choose the reason and draw it in your science book. It doesn’t matter if your prediction is wrong. The point is to find out why.
On this screen
- Predict with your partner.
- Observe in the picture, and do the try-it tasks.
- Explain, and draw the particles.
- Read the key idea.
Predict
A small box stands on top of a big box, with a trapdoor between them. You open the trapdoor under a wooden block, some water and a coloured gas in turn. Which one will spread out to fill the whole of both boxes?
A small box stands on top of a big box, with a trapdoor between them. Choose the block, the water or the gas, then open the trapdoor. The circle shows the particles, drawn far bigger than they really are.
Open the trapdoor
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Try it
Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. The first one is your observation. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Observe Open the trapdoor for all three.
Need a hint?
Choose the block, the water and the gas in turn, and press Open the trapdoor for each.
Find the one that keeps its own shape in the big box.
Need a hint?
Open the trapdoor for each one. Then answer Which one kept its own shape? under the picture.
Find the one that fills the whole of both boxes.
Need a hint?
Open the trapdoor for each one. Then answer Which one filled the whole of both boxes? under the picture.
Talk about it. The water changed its shape but not its amount. How do the particles explain that?
Explain
First make your prediction, then do the first try-it task in the picture.
Why does the gas fill the whole box?
Draw it. Draw the particles of a solid, a liquid and a gas in three boxes.
Solids, liquids and gases do different things
A solid keeps its own shape. A liquid flows and takes the shape of the bottom of its container, but there is the same amount of it. A gas spreads out to fill the whole of its container.
Particles explain this. In a solid, the particles are packed together in rows and jiggle on the spot. In a liquid, they touch but slide past each other. In a gas, they are far apart and move fast in all directions, with nothing between them.
What we are learning
How the way particles are arranged, and the way they move, explain what solids, liquids and gases do.
I can
- 1sort things into solids, liquids and gases by what they do.
- 2explain why a gas can be squashed and a liquid can’t, using particles.
- 3say what is between the particles of a gas.
- 4show that air has mass.
- 5describe how First Nations Peoples use heat to turn fat into oil, and water and plant oils into gases.
- 6act out particles and say what the role-play gets wrong.
Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 5, AC9S5U04: “explain observable properties of solids, liquids and gases by modelling the motion and arrangement of particles”. The teacher notes at the end show which screen covers each part.
My notebook
You move each of these into a bigger box. Which one keeps its own shape?
A little coloured gas is let into a bottle of air. Where does it go?
2Predict, observe, explain
Squash it
Can you squash a liquid or a gas?
You can squash a sponge, but can you squash water? Can you squash air? Predict first, then test it with two syringes.
On this screen
- Predict with your partner.
- Observe in the picture, and do the try-it tasks.
- Explain, and draw the particles.
- Read the key idea.
Predict
One syringe is full of air and one is full of water. Both ends are capped. Which one can you squash when you push the plunger?
Both syringes hold 20 mL, and both ends are capped, so nothing can get in or out. Choose how hard to push the plungers, then let go. Under each syringe you can see its particles.
Two syringes
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Try it
Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. The first one is your observation. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Observe Push both plungers hard.
Need a hint?
Choose Hard push and watch both syringes.
Let go, and watch what the air does.
Need a hint?
Push hard first, then press Let go.
Check that the air has the same number of particles when it is squashed.
Need a hint?
Push the plungers, then press Count the air particles.
Talk about it. A bicycle tyre is full of air. Why does it feel springy when you squeeze it?
Explain
First make your prediction, then do the first try-it task in the picture.
Why can you squash the air?
Draw it. Draw the air particles before and after you squash them. Draw the same number each time.
A gas can be squashed. A liquid hardly can.
The particles in a gas are far apart, with empty space between them, so pushing moves them closer together. The particles in a liquid already touch, so they can hardly move any closer.
Squashed air pushes back, which is why the plunger sprang out when you let go. The number of particles stays the same the whole time.
My notebook
Why can a gas be squashed?
You push the plunger of a capped syringe full of water. What happens?
3Predict, observe, explain
A coloured gas
What happens to the particles when you squash a gas?
You can’t see most gases, but a few are coloured. Squash a coloured gas, and watch its colour. Then think about what is between its particles.
On this screen
- Predict with your partner.
- Observe in the picture, and do the try-it tasks.
- Explain, and draw the particles.
- Read the key idea.
Predict
A capped syringe holds a coloured gas. You push the plunger, so the gas fills half the space. What happens to its colour?
Coloured gases such as nitrogen dioxide are harmful to breathe, so this demonstration is virtual. The syringe is capped, so no gas can get in or out. Choose how much space the gas fills.
Squash a coloured gas
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Try it
Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. The first one is your observation. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Observe Squash the gas into half the space.
Need a hint?
Choose Half: 20 mL.
Squash it as far as it will go.
Need a hint?
Choose A quarter: 10 mL. How dark does it look?
Pull the plunger back out to make the gas paler again.
Need a hint?
Squash the gas first, then choose Full: 40 mL.
Talk about it. What do you think is between the particles of the gas? Share your ideas before you read the key idea.
Explain
First make your prediction, then do the first try-it task in the picture.
Why does the squashed gas look darker?
Draw it. Draw the gas particles in the full syringe and in the half-full syringe. Label the space between them.
Squashing a gas crowds its particles
When you squash a gas, the same particles fit into less space. The coloured gas looked darker because every bit of the syringe had more coloured particles in it, and the light passed through more of them.
Between the particles of a gas there is nothing at all: empty space. That empty space is what you squash.
My notebook
A coloured gas is squashed into half the space. Why does it look darker?
What is between the particles of a gas?
4Predict, observe, explain
Does air have mass?
Can you weigh a gas?
Air is all around you, and you can’t see it. Does it have mass? Predict first, then find out with a balance and a ball on kitchen scales.
On this screen
- Predict with your partner.
- Observe in the picture, and do the try-it tasks.
- Explain, and draw the particles.
- Read the key idea.
Predict
A flat soccer ball is on kitchen scales. You pump air into it. What will the scales show?
Choose the balance or the ball. On the balance, two empty balloons hang from a ruler. On the scales, a flat soccer ball waits for the pump. The circle shows the air particles inside the ball.
Weigh the air
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Try it
Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. The first one is your observation. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Observe Pump the ball all the way up.
Need a hint?
Choose The ball on the scales and press Pump 5 times until the gauge reads 0.8.
Let the air out, and watch the scales.
Need a hint?
Pump the ball up first, then press Let the air out.
Blow up one balloon on the balance.
Need a hint?
Choose The balance and press Blow up the red balloon.
Talk about it. Why did the scales go back to 424 g when you let the air out?
Explain
First make your prediction, then do the first try-it task in the picture.
Why does the pumped-up ball have more mass?
Draw it. Draw the particles inside the flat ball and inside the pumped-up ball.
Air has mass
Air is made of particles, and every particle has a tiny mass. Pumping squeezes many more air particles into the ball, so the ball has more mass: about 5 g more for a soccer ball. When the air comes out, that mass goes with it.
A blown-up balloon tips a balance a little, for the same reason. Gases are matter, just like solids and liquids.
My notebook
A flat soccer ball has a mass of 424 g. You pump it up. What will the scales show now?
Two empty balloons balance on a ruler. You blow one up and hang it back on. What happens?
5Predict, observe, explain
Heat, oils and steam
How do First Nations Peoples use heat to change solids, liquids and gases?
First Nations Peoples have long used heat to change the state of a substance: for medicine, for tools and for cooking. Here are three ways, from ACARA’s background information.
On this screen
- Predict with your partner.
- Observe in the picture, and do the try-it tasks.
- Explain, and draw the particles.
- Read the key idea.
Predict
Fat from a stingray is heated in a big bailer shell. What will happen to the fat?
Choose one of the three: fat in a bailer shell, a steam pit or a ground oven. Read about it, then heat it, or pour in water, and watch. The circle shows its particles.
Three ways with heat
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Try it
Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. The first one is your observation. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Observe Heat the fat in the bailer shell.
Need a hint?
Choose Rendering fat and press Heat the fat.
Heat the steam pit.
Need a hint?
Choose A steam pit and press Heat the pit.
Pour water into the ground oven.
Need a hint?
Choose A ground oven and press Pour in water.
Talk about it. The steam pit and the ground oven both made a gas. Where did each gas come from?
Explain
First make your prediction, then do the first try-it task in the picture.
Why does the fat turn into a liquid?
Draw it. Draw the particles of the fat before and after it is heated.
Heat changes how particles move
Heating makes particles move faster. When fat is rendered, its particles jiggle harder and harder until they slide past each other: the solid fat has become a liquid oil. In the steam pit and the ground oven, heat sends particles of oil and water flying off as a gas, which spreads through the space: oil vapour in the pit and steam in the oven.
These are long-held practices, and many First Nations practices like them are ongoing. The Mabuygiwgal People of Mabuaig Island, for example, still boil turtle fat to collect its oil.
My notebook
Stingray fat is heated in a bailer shell. What happens to its particles?
Water is poured into a ground oven with hot stones in it. What does the water turn into?
6Predict, observe, explain
Be the particles
How good is a role-play as a model of particles?
Your class can act out particles in a role-play. A role-play is a model. It helps explain how particles behave, but like every model, it gets some things wrong.
On this screen
- Predict with your partner.
- Observe in the picture, and do the try-it tasks.
- Explain what the model gets wrong.
- Read the key idea, then try the role-play with your class.
- Answer the last two questions and look at your results.
Predict
Your class acts out particles. Which rule makes the class act like a liquid?
This is a playground seen from above, with 24 children in it. Choose a rule for the role-play and watch how the class moves.
The role-play
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Try it
Work with your partner. Try these in the picture above. The first one is your observation. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Observe Try all three rules: solid, liquid and gas.
Need a hint?
Choose Solid, Liquid and Gas in turn.
Squeeze the gas class into half the playground.
Need a hint?
Choose Gas, then press Squeeze into half.
Find out what the role-play gets wrong.
Need a hint?
Press What the role-play gets wrong.
Talk about it. After the squeeze, the children reached the cones and each other more often. How could that explain why squashed air pushes back?
Explain
First make your prediction, then do the first try-it task in the picture.
What does the role-play get wrong about real particles?
Draw it. Draw your class acting out a liquid. Then write one thing the role-play gets wrong.
A role-play is a model
The role-play shows how the particles are arranged and how they move in a solid, a liquid and a gas. Like every model, it gets some things wrong. The children are huge, there is air between them, and they choose where to go.
Real particles are far too small to see, there is nothing between them, and they just keep moving until they bump into something.
My notebook
In the role-play, which rule acts out a liquid?
Which of these does the role-play get wrong?
Predict, observe, explain: squashing and weighing air
Two pages. Page 1 has two real tests to predict, observe and explain: squashing air and water in capped syringes, and weighing a ball before and after pumping it up. Page 2 has boxes to draw the particles of a solid, a liquid and a gas, and the rules for a class role-play.
For teachers
Curriculum
Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 5, Science understanding, Chemical sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:
AC9S5U04 explain observable properties of solids, liquids and gases by modelling the motion and arrangement of particles
- classifying substances as solids, liquids and gases and investigating their properties
- exploring examples that demonstrate that gases have mass, such as blowing air through straws to move objects or using a balance to compare an empty balloon to one filled with air
- using role-play to model the arrangement and motion of particles in solids, liquids and gases
- observing a virtual demonstration of coloured gases being compressed and providing an explanation for the change in colour intensity
- exploring, through guided discussion, ideas about what is between particles
- recognising First Nations Australians’ knowledges and understandings of solids, liquids and gases and how these knowledges are applied in a range of processes and practices, including the extraction of oils, medical therapies and cooking
The second quote gives all six of ACARA’s elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each part of the content description is covered on these screens:
- Explain observable properties of solids, liquids and gases: screen 1, a wooden block, some water and a coloured gas let through a trapdoor into a bigger box; screen 2, air and water pushed in capped syringes; screen 4, the mass of air; screen 5, fat that melts and water that turns to steam; q-shape, q-fill, q-squash, q-water, q-mass, q-balloon and q-steam.
- By modelling the motion and arrangement of particles: the particle views beside the pictures on screens 1 to 5, the drawing at the end of every explain card, and screen 6’s role-play and what it gets wrong; q-darker, q-between, q-render, q-liquid and q-model.
- The elaborations: classifying substances as solids, liquids and gases and investigating their properties is screens 1 and 2. Gases having mass, with a balance comparing an empty balloon to a blown-up one, is screen 4, which adds a soccer ball weighed before and after pumping. Role-play is screen 6. The virtual demonstration of a coloured gas being compressed, with an explanation for its darker colour, is screen 3. What is between particles comes up in the label on screen 1’s gas particles, in screen 3’s talk prompt, notebook and q-between, and in the limits of screen 6’s role-play. First Nations Australians’ knowledges used in extracting oils, medical therapies and cooking are screen 5.
The lesson also works on these content descriptions. Every prediction asks for a reason, as AC9S5I01 asks; the printable’s syringe and scales tests use equipment to observe and measure, as in AC9S5I03; the particle drawings and the role-play are the visual and physical models AC9S5I04 names; and comparing each prediction with what happened, then choosing the explanation that fits the evidence, is practice at the reasoned conclusions of AC9S5I05.
AC9S5I01 pose investigable questions to identify patterns and test relationships and make reasoned predictions
AC9S5I03 use equipment to observe, measure and record data with reasonable precision, using digital tools as appropriate
AC9S5I04 construct and use appropriate representations, including tables, graphs and visual or physical models, to organise and process data and information and describe patterns, trends and relationships
AC9S5I05 compare methods and findings with those of others, recognise possible sources of error, pose questions for further investigation and select evidence to draw reasoned conclusions
It builds on Year 3’s AC9S3U04, “investigate the observable properties of solids and liquids and how adding or removing heat energy leads to a change of state”, and leads to Year 6’s AC9S6U04, “compare reversible changes, including dissolving and changes of state, and irreversible changes, including cooking and rusting that produce new substances”, where changes of state come back as reversible changes, and to Year 7’s AC9S7U05, “use particle theory to describe the arrangement of particles in a substance, including the motion of and attraction between particles, and relate this to the properties of the substance”.
How the lesson is taught
The method is predict-observe-explain. On every screen students first predict what will happen and say why, then observe it in the simulation, then explain what they saw and draw it with particles. Koyunlu Ünlü (2024) describes the strategy the same way, as a justified prediction, then observations, then an explanation of any difference between the two, and traces it to a technique used at the University of Pittsburgh in the 1980s. In this lesson the simulation stays closed until a prediction is chosen, and the prediction locks as soon as anything in the picture is pressed, so it can’t be changed once a result shows. The observation is the first try-it task, marked Observe. The explain card then puts the prediction beside what happened and offers three explanations. Each wrong one is a common idea about particles and gets its own reply, with another go. Each card ends with something to draw in the science book.
Run it in pairs. Have each pair agree on a prediction and a reason before anyone touches the picture, and use the Talk about it prompt at the end of the try-it cards before they choose an explanation. A wrong prediction costs nothing, and the recap on the explain card says so. RSC Education’s advice is to “let students handle solids, liquids and gases before you ask them to zoom in”, so the printable’s two tests are worth doing before screens 2 and 4.
A recent summary of the evidence is Koyunlu Ünlü’s meta-analysis of 35 studies published from 2008 to 2023, with 2,840 students in all. Students taught with predict-observe-explain did better than comparison groups, with an overall effect of g = 0.98 (95% confidence interval 0.77 to 1.19). For primary students the effect was 1.02, but from only five studies, with a wide interval (0.57 to 1.46). Chemistry studies had the largest effect of the main subjects (1.33), and middle school the smallest of the main levels (0.52). Versions supported by technology (0.88) did not differ significantly from the strategy on its own (1.02). The studies varied a lot (I² = 85%), and only studies in Turkish and English were searched. The author notes that Gustina and colleagues (2023) found a very low effect at primary level, and puts the difference down to their including studies in mathematics as well as science. The paper also calls for experimental studies in geology and astronomy at preschool and primary level, where there are few.
The particle views are there because the content description asks students to model particles, and because a simulation of particles may have helped primary students in a small trial. Papageorgiou, Johnson and Fotiades (2008) taught two Grade 6 classes at one town primary school in Greece the same six one-hour lessons on melting and evaporation. One class used software that zoomed from the everyday view to moving particles, and the other used still pictures. Afterwards 6 of the 12 pupils interviewed from the software class explained melting with moving particles, against 4 of 12, and 5 of 12 gave full particle explanations of evaporation, against 2 of 12. The authors write that the software “did not seem to do any harm and more likely was of benefit”, and that with their small sample the “differences are small and must be treated with caution”.
The drawings come from Fiorella and Zhang’s (2018) review of learning by drawing. Creating drawings was “consistently more effective at fostering comprehension and transfer” than reading alone or text-based strategies. Against other model-based strategies, or pictures provided by the teacher, the effects were mixed and “may depend on the level of drawing guidance provided, among other factors”, and drawing “can also be cognitively demanding and time consuming”. The review is about drawing to learn from science texts, not from simulations, so take it as a guide here. Each drawing prompt says exactly what to draw, and the simulation’s particle view is there to check the drawing against.
Handle with care
- Syringes. Use plastic syringes with no needles, and keep the tips pointing down at the table. RSC Education suggests “a simple demonstration of water in a plastic syringe to show that liquids are not compressible”. A finger over the tip does the job of a cap. When students let go of the squashed air syringe the plunger springs back out, so keep faces clear of the plunger end.
- Balls and scales. A soccer ball gains only about 5 g between soft and pumped up, so use kitchen scales that show 1 g. Beyond appearances notes that “A sensitive balance is required to demonstrate that mass would increase.” Let all the air out first, with the needle in the valve and no pump on it, so the soft ball starts at the pressure outside. Don’t pump a ball past the pressure printed on it, and let an adult push the pump needle into the valve.
- Balloons. ASCIA’s information on latex allergy says “Allergic reactions usually occur after exposure to dipped products like gloves, balloons and condoms.” Check for latex allergies before the balloon balance, or use the ball test instead. Use a balloon pump, and pick up burst pieces straight away.
- The coloured gas. Screen 3 is virtual because coloured gases such as nitrogen dioxide are harmful. ATSDR describes nitrogen dioxide as “a liquid at room temperature, becoming a reddish-brown gas above 70°F” (21 °C), and says that breathing high levels of nitrogen oxides can burn and swell the throat and airways. ACARA’s elaboration suggests “a virtual demonstration”.
- The role-play. It needs a clear space marked with cones, and walking only. Jo James (Tes, 2020) warns that acting out heated liquid particles with arm-throwing movements can lead students to “believe there is an air gap between particles”, and that some read the movement as particles getting bigger. Her fix is to keep arms by the sides, which the printable asks for. The gas rule has children turn just before they would bump, and for the liquid rule anyone who prefers can stay close instead of touching. Screen 6 and q-model ask students what the role-play gets wrong.
- Students’ ideas about particles. Vanessa Kind’s Beyond appearances, published by the Royal Society of Chemistry, reports students filling the spaces between particles with things like “Dust and other particles; other gases such as oxygen and nitrogen; air, dirt, germs”, giving particles the bulk properties of the substance, thinking that particles expand when they are heated, and answering that gases have “no mass”. The lesson’s wrong explanations and check answers come from these ideas, so expect students to choose them. The review is about secondary and older students, and the same ideas are worth listening for in Year 5.
- The First Nations content. Screen 5, its key idea, q-render and q-steam use only ACARA’s teacher background information for elaboration 6. No people are drawn, and the pictures are the lesson’s own. ACARA’s page warns that some of its consulted works may contain material that is culturally offensive or breaches cultural protocols, that they are not classroom resources, and that written records are often non-Indigenous interpretations that lack the viewpoints of the people they discuss and can carry the attitudes and scientific ideas of the past; it recommends careful selection and community consultation. Screen 5 has not been checked with Anguthimri, Awngthim, Mabuygiwgal, Wiradjuri or Barindji people. Follow your school’s or system’s protocols for First Nations content, for example by asking Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander staff or education officers, and ask your local community for advice on teaching screen 5, bearing in mind that these practices belong to the Peoples named.
- Reduced motion. With the device’s reduce-motion setting on, each change in a simulation jumps to its end, and the particles move on only when Run on is pressed.
About the models
- Screen 1: the boxes are drawn to scale, 7 cm and 20 cm wide, both 12 cm high and 5 cm deep. The 300 mL of water is 300 ÷ (7 × 5) = 8.6 cm deep in the small box and 300 ÷ (20 × 5) = 3 cm deep in the big one; the block is a 5 cm cube. The properties are Chemistry 2e’s (1.2): “A solid is rigid and possesses a definite shape”, a liquid “flows and takes the shape of its container” with a flat or slightly curved top, and “A gas takes both the shape and volume of its container.” The particle views follow Chemistry 2e 10.1: particles in a solid “vibrate about fixed positions”, in a liquid “they move past each other but remain in essentially constant contact”, and in a gas “they move independently of one another except when they collide.” The big box starts full of air, so once the gas has spread the magnifier shows a few coloured particles among air particles, and the boxes look paler: the same gas in about four times the space, by screen 3’s rule for colour. Here there are air particles between the coloured ones; between any two particles, air or coloured, there is nothing.
- Screen 2: the syringes hold 20 mL and are capped. The pushes are the lesson’s own: a gentle push makes the pressure inside 1.5 times the air outside, and a hard push 2.5 times. Boyle’s law, “The volume of a given amount of gas held at constant temperature is inversely proportional to the pressure under which it is measured” (Chemistry 2e 9.2), gives 20 ÷ 1.5 = 13.3 mL and 20 ÷ 2.5 = 8 mL. The water stays at 20 mL because liquids “have volumes that are very nearly independent of pressure” (1.2). The particle boxes show 24 air particles at every push, and enough water particles to fill seven tenths of their box.
- Screen 3: the syringe holds 40 mL of a coloured gas, drawn as 30 particles. How dark the gas looks is the lesson’s own rule: the light crossing the syringe passes more coloured particles when the same particles are in less space, so the shade is 1 − e−0.9 × 40 ÷ V ÷ 2 for a volume of V mL. That is 0.36 at 40 mL, 0.59 at 20 mL and 0.83 at 10 mL, shown as how dark out of 100 under the picture. The simulation doesn’t name a real gas.
- Screen 4: a size 5 soccer ball 69 cm around, inside the IFAB’s “between 68 cm (27 ins) and 70 cm (28 ins)”, holds C³ ÷ 6π² = 5.55 litres. Dry air is 1.20 g per litre at 25 °C and 1 atm (Chemistry 2e, Table 1.4). Gauge pressure is “the pressure relative to atmospheric pressure” (College Physics 2e 11.6), so a soft ball with its gauge at 0 holds air at the pressure outside, and pumped to 0.8, inside the IFAB’s 0.6 to 1.1 atmosphere, it holds 1.8 times as much air in the same space (Boyle’s law). The extra air is 0.8 × 5.55 × 1.20 = 5.3 g, so the scales go from 424 g to 429 g, inside the IFAB’s 410 to 450 g for a ball at the start of a match. The 20 pushes and the 424 g are the lesson’s own. The magnifier shows 12 air particles in the soft ball and 22 in the pumped one, 1.8 times as many, rounded. The balance’s tip of 4° is the lesson’s own and bigger than a real one.
- Screen 5: ACARA’s background information gives no sizes, temperatures or times, so those in the pictures are the lesson’s own, and the fire, the shell and the pits are drawn without people. The grass, the hot stones on top of the food, the earth over the oven and the hole made to pour in water all come from elaboration 6, which doesn’t say how the bailer shell was heated: the fire under it is the lesson’s own. In the particle views the fat’s particles jiggle harder as it heats, then slide past each other as a liquid oil, and in the steam pit and the ground oven particles leave the oil or the water one at a time and move about as a gas, as Chemistry 2e 10.3 describes for vaporisation. The wisps in the pictures are a way of drawing the gas as it spreads, not what it looks like.
- Screen 6: the 24 children move by the same particle model as the other screens, scaled up: in rows that jiggle, touching and sliding past each other, or far apart in straight lines. The squeeze halves the playground. The three limits are the lesson’s own list.
Where sources disagree and what to check
- Air’s density. Chemistry 2e’s 1.20 g per litre is for dry air at 25 °C and 1 atm. College Physics 2e, Table 11.1, lists air at 1.29 × 10−3 g/mL (1.29 g per litre) without a temperature; with that figure the ball’s extra air would be about 5.7 g. The air inside also has a little less room than 5.55 litres, because of the thickness of the ball’s cover, so a real ball gains a little less.
- How soft the ball starts. The scales show only the air squeezed in above the pressure outside: about 5.3 g from 0 to 0.8 on the gauge, whatever shape the soft ball starts in, because air that only fills out a squashed ball is buoyed up by the air it pushes aside (College Physics 2e 11.7). A ball that is soft but not empty at the start, or pumped to less than 0.8, gains less.
- The balloon balance. A blown-up balloon takes up more space, so the air around it buoys it up more (College Physics 2e 11.7, Archimedes’ principle), and that cancels most of the weight of the air inside. Expect only a small tip, and balance the ruler carefully first. RSC Education still suggests the demonstration, because it “helps to overcome the misconception that air (or a gas) is nothing.”
- Real nitrogen dioxide. A real syringe of nitrogen dioxide doesn’t behave quite like screen 3’s gas. Chemistry 2e (13.1) shows brown nitrogen dioxide in equilibrium with colourless dinitrogen tetroxide, and 13.3 explains that making the volume of a gas mixture smaller shifts its equilibrium towards the side with fewer gas particles, here the colourless gas. So squashed nitrogen dioxide darkens at once and then fades a little. Screen 3’s gas is a plain coloured gas.
- Liquids squash a little. Chemistry 2e says the volumes of liquids are “very nearly” independent of pressure, not completely. A plastic syringe also flexes, and an air bubble left in the water will squash, so a real water plunger may move a little.
- Particle pictures. Every particle drawing is a model: real particles are far too small to see, far more numerous and far faster. The lesson draws a liquid’s particles almost as close as a solid’s, as Chemistry 2e 10.1 describes them, “close together with no regular arrangement”. The rows in a solid are a simplification too: Chemistry 2e says a solid’s particles are “tightly packed together and often arranged in a regular pattern”, so not always in rows.
Answers at a glance
- Screen 1: prediction, the gas. The block drops and keeps its shape (a solid); the water runs down and spreads over the bottom of the big box, the same amount (a liquid); the gas spreads until it fills both boxes (a gas). Explanation: its particles are far apart and move fast in all directions. q-shape a wooden block; q-fill it spreads through the whole bottle.
- Screen 2: prediction, the air. The air squashes into 13.3 mL with a gentle push and 8 mL with a hard push, and springs back to 20 mL; the water stays at 20 mL; there are 24 air particles at every push. Explanation: there is empty space between the air particles. q-squash its particles have empty space between them; q-water it hardly moves at all.
- Screen 3: prediction, it looks darker. The gas looks darker at 20 mL, darker still at 10 mL, and paler again back at 40 mL. Explanation: the same particles are crowded into less space, so the light passes more of them. q-darker the same particles are crowded into less space; q-between nothing.
- Screen 4: prediction, more than before. The scales go from 424 g to 429 g, and back to 424 g when the air is let out; the blown-up balloon’s side of the balance goes down a little. Explanation: air is made of particles, each with a tiny mass. q-mass about 429 g; q-balloon the blown-up balloon’s side goes down a little.
- Screen 5: prediction, it melts into a liquid oil. Heating melts the fat into oil; heating the steam pit turns oil from the leaves into a gas; water poured into the ground oven turns into steam. Explanation: heating makes the particles move faster, until they can slide past each other. q-render they move faster, until they slide past each other; q-steam steam, a gas that spreads through the oven.
- Screen 6: prediction, stay touching but move slowly past each other. Explanation: there is air between the children, but nothing between real particles. q-liquid stay touching, but move slowly past each other; q-model there is air between the children.
- Printable: Test 1, the air squashes and springs back, and the water hardly moves. Test 2, the pumped-up ball has more mass; a soccer ball gains about 5 g, and numbers depend on the ball and how hard it is pumped. Part 3, a solid’s particles touch in rows, jiggling on the spot; a liquid’s touch but are jumbled and slide past each other; a gas’s are far apart, moving fast in all directions, with nothing between them. Part 4, the children are far bigger than particles, there is air between them, and they choose where to go. In the PDF the answers are printed upside down at the foot of page 2; in the Word file they are in a strip at the foot of page 2 to fold under.
Saved progress
Predictions, explanations, answers, notes, settings and the try-it tasks are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere. If students share devices, clear the saved answers between them.
References
- Agency for Toxic Substances and Disease Registry (ATSDR) (2014). ToxFAQs for nitrogen oxides. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention.
- Australasian Society of Clinical Immunology and Allergy (ASCIA) (2015). Latex allergy. ASCIA information for patients, consumers and carers (content last updated January 2010), hosted by The Royal Children’s Hospital Melbourne.
- Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) (2022). Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Foundation to Year 10 curriculum content. Australian Curriculum website.
- Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) (n.d.). Science teacher background information, AC9S5U04 elaboration 6: recognising First Nations Australians’ knowledges and understandings of solids, liquids and gases and how these knowledges are applied.
- Australian Curriculum, Assessment and Reporting Authority (ACARA) (n.d.). Science teacher background information, AC9S9U05 elaboration 4: investigating the efficiency of ground ovens used by First Nations Australians.
- Fiorella, L. and Zhang, Q. (2018). Drawing boundary conditions for learning by drawing. Educational Psychology Review, 30(3), 1115–1137. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10648-018-9444-8
- Flowers, P., Theopold, K., Langley, R. and Robinson, W. R. (2019). Chemistry 2e. OpenStax. Sections 1.2 Phases and classification of matter, 1.4 Measurements, 9.2 Relating pressure, volume, amount, and temperature: the ideal gas law, 9.5 The kinetic-molecular theory, 10.1 Intermolecular forces, 10.3 Phase transitions, 13.1 Chemical equilibria and 13.3 Shifting equilibria: Le Châtelier’s principle.
- James, J. (2020, 6 March). 4 memorable ways to bring particle states to life. Tes.
- Kind, V. (2004). Beyond appearances: students’ misconceptions about basic chemical ideas (2nd edition). Royal Society of Chemistry. Chapter online: Students’ ideas about the particulate nature of matter. RSC Education.
- Koyunlu Ünlü, Z. (2024). Effect of the predict-observe-explain (POE) strategy on achievement in science education: a meta-analysis study. Van Yüzüncü Yıl Üniversitesi Eğitim Fakültesi Dergisi, 21(3), 893–920. https://doi.org/10.33711/yyuefd.1570041
- Papageorgiou, G., Johnson, P. and Fotiades, F. (2008). Explaining melting and evaporation below boiling point. Can software help with particle ideas? Research in Science & Technological Education, 26(2), 165–183. https://doi.org/10.1080/02635140802037336
- Royal Society of Chemistry (n.d.). Help students move beyond labelling diagrams to build a confident, accurate understanding of the particle model. RSC Education.
- The IFAB (2026). Laws of the Game, Law 2: The Ball. The International Football Association Board.
- Urone, P. P. and Hinrichs, R. (2022). College Physics 2e. OpenStax. Sections 11.2 Density, 11.6 Gauge pressure, absolute pressure, and pressure measurement and 11.7 Archimedes’ principle.
Sources by screen
- Method: Koyunlu Ünlü (2024); Papageorgiou, Johnson and Fotiades (2008); Fiorella and Zhang (2018).
- Screen 1: Chemistry 2e 1.2 and 10.1.
- Screen 2: Chemistry 2e 1.2 and 9.2; RSC Education (water in a syringe).
- Screen 3: ACARA’s elaborations; ATSDR (nitrogen dioxide); Chemistry 2e 9.5, 13.1 and 13.3; Beyond appearances (what is between particles).
- Screen 4: the IFAB’s Law 2; Chemistry 2e 1.2, 1.4 and 9.2; College Physics 2e 11.2, 11.6 and 11.7; RSC Education (the balloon balance); Beyond appearances (gases have mass).
- Screen 5: ACARA’s teacher background information for AC9S5U04 elaboration 6; Chemistry 2e 10.1 and 10.3.
- Screen 6: Chemistry 2e 9.5 and 10.1; Jo James (Tes); Beyond appearances.
- Printable: the sources for screens 2, 4 and 6.
- Safety: ASCIA (latex); ATSDR (nitrogen dioxide); RSC Education; Beyond appearances; Jo James (Tes).
- Word list: the sources for the screen where each word is first used, and ACARA’s background information for Year 9 (a bailer is a melon shell).