AusSci

Year 7 science · Chemical sciences · AC9S7U06

How can we get pure water and salt from muddy seawater?

1The problem

Muddy seawater

How could you get pure water and salt out of muddy seawater?

Seawater is a mixture. It has solids dissolved in it, mainly salt. This jar also has sand and mud stirred into it. In this lesson you solve one problem: how to get pure water, salt, and the sand and mud out of the jar. You start with the problem, before you are taught how to solve it.

How this lesson works. The lesson is problem-based, so the problem comes first. On this screen you look closely at the mixture and write a first plan. Screens 2 to 5 each teach something your plan needs, and each one ends by asking you to change your plan. On screen 6 you put the plan together and test it. Screen 7 shows separation techniques of First Nations Australians.

On this screen

  1. Read the problem.
  2. Look at the mixture through the lens, and leave it to stand.
  3. Do the three tasks, and read what you found.
  4. Write your first plan.

The problem

Your class has a jar of seawater with sand and mud stirred into it. Your job is to get three things out of it: pure water, salt with nothing else in it, and the sand and mud. Before anyone tells you how, look closely at the mixture and write a first plan.

The drawing shows the jar of muddy seawater. The round lens shows the particles at one place in the jar, magnified many times. Choose a place to look at, or drag the lens over the jar. Press Stir to mix the jar up again.

A jar of muddy seawater, and a lens on its particles

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, the table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Look through the lens at the top, the middle and the bottom of the jar.

    Need a hint?

    Press Top, Middle and Bottom under Look at. You can also drag the lens over the jar.

  2. Leave the jar to stand, and find out what settles and what does not.

    Need a hint?

    Press Leave it to stand, and watch until the water at the top is clear. Then look at the top through the lens.

  3. Decide if the clear water at the top is pure water.

    Need a hint?

    Leave the jar to stand first. Then answer the question under the table.

Talk about it. What do you already know that could help with the problem? What do you need to find out?

What is in the jar

Muddy seawater is a mixture of water, salt, sand and mud. In the lens, water particles are blue circles, salt particles are purple squares and specks of mud are brown lumps of particles. The colours and shapes only tell the kinds of particle apart: real particles are not blue or purple, or circles or squares.

When the jar stands, the sand drops to the bottom first. The mud settles more slowly. The salt does not settle.

After standing, the water at the top looks clear, but the lens shows salt particles spread among the water particles, so it is still a mixture of water and salt.

Practical

Make the problem

Do this in the laboratory, when your teacher says.

You need

  • A clear plastic jar or bottle with a lid
  • Tap water with a teaspoon of salt stirred in
  • A teaspoon of sand and a teaspoon of fine clay
  • A magnifying glass

What to do

  1. Half fill the jar with the salty water. Add the sand and the clay.
  2. Put the lid on tightly and shake the jar. Look at it closely with the magnifying glass.
  3. Leave the jar to stand. Look at it again after 5 minutes and after a day, and draw it each time.
  4. Write your first plan for getting pure water, salt, and the sand and mud out of the jar.

Take care. Never eat or drink anything in the laboratory, and that includes the water and the salt from this jar.

My notebook

Muddy seawater is left to stand for a day. What does not settle to the bottom?

After standing, the top of the jar is clear. What does the lens show there?

2Find out

Pure substances and mixtures

What does pure mean in science?

In science, a pure substance contains only one type of chemical, so in a particle drawing all its particles are the same kind. A mixture contains two or more different substances, in amounts that can vary, and they can be separated by physical changes such as evaporation.

On this screen

  1. Look at each sample through the lens.
  2. Sort the six samples into pure substances and mixtures.
  3. Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
  4. Go back to your plan.

Find out

Your plan needs pure water and pure salt. But what does pure mean in science? Find out by looking at six samples through the lens.

Choose a sample. The lens shows its particles. Count the kinds of particle, then press Pure substance or Mixture, and the sample goes on that shelf.

Six samples through the lens

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, the table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Sort all six samples into pure substances and mixtures.

    Need a hint?

    Choose a sample, look through the lens and count the kinds of particle. Then press Pure substance or Mixture.

  2. Find out how distilled water and seawater are different.

    Need a hint?

    Look at both of them through the lens. Then answer the first question under the table.

  3. Decide if 100% pure orange juice is a pure substance.

    Need a hint?

    Answer the second question under the table.

Talk about it. Where have you seen the word pure on a label? Would a scientist call that thing a pure substance?

Pure substance or mixture

Distilled water, salt and sugar are pure substances. Each one has only one kind of particle. Tap water is not pure water: it has other substances dissolved in it.

Seawater, sugar water and muddy seawater are mixtures. Seawater and sugar water look the same all through: they are solutions. Muddy seawater does not look the same all through.

In everyday words, pure often means that something comes from one source, as in 100% pure orange juice. In science, pure means that a substance has only one type of particle.

My notebook

Which of these is a pure substance?

A carton says 100% pure orange juice. In science, is the juice a pure substance?

3Find out

Solute, solvent, solution

Where does the salt go when it dissolves?

When a substance dissolves, its particles separate and spread out among the particles of the liquid, so you can no longer see it. The substance that dissolves is the solute, the liquid it dissolves in is the solvent, and together they make a solution. A substance that dissolves is soluble, and one that does not is insoluble.

On this screen

  1. Add salt to the water, and watch the lens and the balance.
  2. Try sugar and sand too.
  3. Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
  4. Go back to your plan.

Find out

The salt in seawater can’t be seen, and it doesn’t settle. Find out where it goes when it dissolves, and whether it has really gone.

Choose a substance and press Add it to the water. The lens shows the edge of a crystal or a grain, with water particles around it. Press Stir to stir the water. The balance shows the mass of the water and everything in it.

Dissolving, on a balance

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, the table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Dissolve the salt, and watch its particles through the lens.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Salt and press Add it to the water. Press Stir, and wait until no salt crystal is left.

  2. Try sand, and find out what is different.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Sand and press Add it to the water. Watch the lens and the balance.

  3. Decide if the dissolved salt has gone.

    Need a hint?

    Dissolve the salt first. Then answer the question under the table.

Talk about it. When salt dissolves, has it disappeared? What evidence from the balance and the lens can you give?

Where the salt goes

Salt dissolves in water. Its particles leave the crystal one at a time and spread out among the water particles. In seawater, salt is the solute, water is the solvent and seawater is the solution. Dissolving is not melting: the salt does not turn into a liquid.

The dissolved salt has not gone. The balance reads the same before and after it dissolves, and the lens still shows every salt particle. A dissolved solute does not settle out of a solution.

Sand is insoluble in water. Its grains stay whole and lie on the bottom.

Practical

Dissolve and weigh

Do this in the laboratory, when your teacher says.

You need

  • Three beakers
  • Water
  • Salt, sugar and sand
  • A balance
  • A spatula and a stirring rod

What to do

  1. Put a beaker on the balance and zero it. Add 100 g of water.
  2. Weigh out 5 g of salt on a piece of paper. Add it to the water and write down the reading.
  3. Stir until the salt has dissolved. Write down the reading again.
  4. Do the same with sugar, then with sand, each in a clean beaker of water.

Take care. Wear eye protection. Never eat or drink anything in the laboratory.

My notebook

In seawater, which substance is the solute?

A beaker of water with salt in it reads 105 g on a balance. The salt dissolves. What does the balance read now?

4Find out

Settling, decanting and filtering

What can settling and filtering take out of muddy seawater?

Separation techniques work because the substances in a mixture have different properties, such as the size of their particles. When a mixture stands, the larger solid pieces drop to the bottom, so you can pour the liquid off them: this is decanting. Filtration separates by size. Filter paper has very tiny holes that water particles can pass through, but the larger solid pieces can’t.

On this screen

  1. Let the mixture settle and pour off the liquid.
  2. Filter the mixture, and look at what is left and what comes through.
  3. Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
  4. Change your plan.

Find out

The sand and mud are the easiest part of the problem. Find out how to take them out by letting them settle and pouring off the liquid, and by filtering. Then check what is still in the water.

Choose Settle and decant or Filter. Use the buttons to run each technique, and look through the lens at what you get.

Decanting and filtering muddy seawater

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation, the table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Let the mixture settle, then pour off the liquid.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Settle and decant. Press Leave it to settle, then press Pour off the liquid.

  2. Filter the mixture, and look at the filtrate through the lens.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Filter and press Pour into the funnel. When it has dripped through, look at the filtrate.

  3. Decide if the filtrate is pure water.

    Need a hint?

    Filter the mixture first. Then answer the question under the table.

Talk about it. Why does filter paper hold back the mud but not the salt? Use the word particle in your answer.

What settling and filtering do

Decanting pours the liquid off the solid that has settled. Letting the mixture settle first also makes filtering quicker. The finest mud may not have settled yet, so some of it can go with the liquid.

Filtering holds back the sand and mud on the filter paper: this is the residue. The liquid that comes through is the filtrate. School filter paper may let through very fine particles the size of silt.

The filtrate is still seawater. The dissolved salt particles are small enough to go through the holes in the filter paper, like the water particles. Each technique gives two products, and one of them can still be a mixture.

Sydney Water filters about 1.5 billion litres of water a day. The water flows down through two kinds of filter material, pulled by gravity, and the different materials catch particles of different sizes.

My notebook

Muddy seawater is filtered. What is in the filtrate?

Why does the sand stay on the filter paper?

5Find out

Evaporating and distilling

How can you get the salt out of salty water, and keep the water too?

Water turns into a gas far more easily than salt does: water is more volatile. When seawater boils, the water boils off and leaves the dissolved solids, mainly salt, behind. Evaporation lets the water go into the air. Distillation uses boiling and condensation to collect the water as well.

On this screen

  1. Evaporate salty water in a basin.
  2. Distil salty water with a condenser.
  3. Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
  4. Change your plan.

Find out

Filtering left salty water. Find out two ways to take the salt and the water apart using heat, and which one keeps the water.

Choose Evaporate or Distil. Press Heat to light the Bunsen burner, and look through the lens at the particles. To distil, turn the cooling water on first.

Evaporating and distilling salty water

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation and the table under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Evaporate the salty water, and turn off the heat when the first crystals appear.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Evaporate and press Heat. Watch the edge of the basin, and press Turn off the heat when white crystals appear.

  2. Distil the salty water, and collect water with only water particles in it.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Distil. Turn the cooling water on, then press Heat. Look at the beaker through the lens.

  3. Find out what happens when the cooling water is off.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Distil, turn the cooling water off and press Heat. Look at the condenser through the lens.

Talk about it. Why is the water lost when you evaporate, but kept when you distil?

Evaporating and distilling

As the water evaporates, the salty water gets more concentrated. When it can’t hold all the salt, solid appears round the edge, and it is a saturated solution. Turning off the heat when the first crystals appear lets bigger crystals grow, and you don’t heat the basin until it is nearly dry, when hot salt can spit out.

In distillation the water boils, its gas is cooled in the condenser, and it condenses back to liquid water. The distillate has only water particles in it, and the salt stays in the flask. The thermometer reads close to 100 °C while the water boils.

If the cooling water is off, the condenser warms up and less of the gas condenses: more of it escapes from the end.

Evaporating leaves the salt and lets the water go into the air. Distilling collects the water as well as leaving the salt.

Practical

Watch a distillation

Do this in the laboratory, when your teacher says.

You need

  • Your teacher’s distillation apparatus
  • Salty water

What to do

  1. Watch your teacher heat the salty water in the flask until it boils gently.
  2. Read the thermometer while the water is boiling, and write down the reading.
  3. Watch where the liquid collects. At the end, look at what is left in the flask.

Take care. Your teacher does the distillation, with the flask and the condenser clamped and the cooling water on all the time. Wear eye protection and stand back from the apparatus. Hot glassware can burn. Never eat or drink anything in the laboratory.

My notebook

Salty water is heated in an evaporating basin until crystals appear. Where does the water go?

Which technique gets the salt out of salty water and keeps the water too?

6Solve it

Solve the problem

Which steps, in which order, get pure water, salt, and the sand and mud?

Each separation technique depends on a property: filtering on the size of the pieces, evaporating and distilling on how volatile each substance is. When a mixture has more than two substances, you may need more than one technique, and the order matters. Use what you found on screens 2 to 5 to plan the whole job.

On this screen

  1. Choose your steps, one at a time.
  2. Watch what each step makes, and look at the products through the lens.
  3. Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
  4. Compare your final plan with your first plan.

Solve it

Now plan the whole job. Choose the steps in order and run your plan on the jar of muddy seawater. A good plan gets pure water, salt and the sand and mud, with no water lost to the air.

Press a technique to add it to your plan. Each step works on the mixture left over from the step before, and its products appear in the drawing, each with a small lens showing its particles. Press Start again to clear the plan.

Your plan for muddy seawater

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation and the plan under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Get pure water: water with only water particles in it.

    Need a hint?

    Take out the sand and mud first. Then use the technique that collects the water.

  2. Get salt with no sand or mud in it.

    Need a hint?

    The sand and mud have to come out before the salt is left behind.

  3. Get all three from one jar: pure water, salt, and the sand and mud.

    Need a hint?

    Filter first. Then use the technique that keeps the water, and deal with what is left in the flask.

Talk about it. Why might the sand and mud from your filter paper still have some salt on them?

A plan that works

Filter first, and the sand and mud stay on the filter paper. Then distil the filtrate: the water collects in the beaker, and the salt stays in the flask with a little water. Last, evaporate what is left in the flask to get the salt.

Distilling first also works. The sand and mud are then left in the flask with the very salty water, and you filter them out before you evaporate. But if you evaporate before filtering, the water is lost, the sand and mud end up mixed with the salt, and you have to dissolve the salt again and filter it.

Water treatment plants solve the same kind of problem. The Sydney Desalination Plant makes drinking water from seawater. It filters the seawater through layers of filter coal (anthracite) and sand. Then the water is pushed at high pressure through reverse osmosis membranes, which act as a filter for the salt and let only fresh water pass through. The fresh water then has minerals added, and is fluoridated and chlorinated, so the drinking water is not pure water.

Practical

Separate muddy salty water

Do this in the laboratory, when your teacher says.

You need

  • About 50 cm³ of the stirred liquid from your jar on screen 1, or 50 cm³ of water with a teaspoon each of salt, sand and clay
  • A beaker, a filter funnel, filter paper and a conical flask
  • An evaporating basin, a tripod, a gauze, a heat resistant mat and a Bunsen burner
  • Eye protection

What to do

  1. Stir the muddy salty water. Fold the filter paper into a cone, put it in the funnel and filter the mixture into the conical flask.
  2. Look at the residue and the filtrate, and write down what you see. The filtrate may still be a little cloudy, because school filter paper may not filter out very fine particles.
  3. Pour the filtrate into the evaporating basin and heat it gently. When the first crystals appear round the edge, turn off the Bunsen burner and leave the basin to finish drying.
  4. Compare your results with your plan. Your teacher’s distillation shows how to keep the water too.

Take care. Wear eye protection throughout, and stand up while heating. Tie back long hair, keep clothing clear of the flame, and use the yellow flame when you are not heating. Hot salt can spit out when the basin is nearly dry, so turn off the heat when the first crystals appear and keep back. The basin, gauze and tripod stay hot after the flame is out, so leave them to cool. Never eat or drink anything in the laboratory.

My notebook

Why must the sand and mud be filtered out before you evaporate the water to get the salt?

Filtering muddy seawater gives two products. Which one needs another technique to get pure water from it?

7Other solutions

Separation techniques of First Nations Australians

Which property does each technique use?

ACARA describes separation techniques developed and used by First Nations Australians to get and process resources needed for everyday life and for survival in times of food and water shortages. This screen looks at three of them: winnowing, yandying and filtering.

On this screen

  1. Read about each technique.
  2. Winnow, yandy and filter in the simulation.
  3. Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
  4. Answer the last two questions and look at your results.

Other solutions

Find out how three separation techniques of First Nations Australians work, and which property of a mixture each one uses.

Choose a technique. The drawings show only the containers and what is in them, as ACARA describes them. On this screen, particles means pieces you can see, such as seeds, husks and grains of sand, which is how ACARA uses the word.

Winnowing, yandying and filtering

Simulation

The simulation loads here.

Use your results

Do these three tasks with the simulation and the table under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.

  1. Winnow the seeds until no husks are left in the koolamon.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Winnowing, set the wind to Light, and press Throw it lightly a few times.

  2. Yandy the seeds until the sand and ash have collected at the bottom.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Yandying and press Shake it gently until the sand and ash are in the bottom layer.

  3. Find a hole size that holds back all the mud and lets the water through.

    Need a hint?

    Choose Filtering. Try each hole size, and press Pour each time.

Talk about it. Which technique on this screen is most like one you used on screens 4 to 6? What is the same, and what is different?

Three techniques and the properties they use

Winnowing is designed to remove lighter particles while keeping heavier ones. A mixture of seeds and husks is placed in a container such as a koolamon and thrown lightly into the air. The wind removes the lighter husk particles while the heavier seeds fall safely back into the container. The property it uses is how heavy the particles are.

Yandying is like gold panning. A mixture is placed in a wooden container called a yandy. The yandy is held in the hand, raised in one corner and gently shaken back and forth. The smaller and denser particles collect at the bottom, while the larger and less dense particles remain higher up. Traditionally, Yankunytjatjara Aboriginal peoples in north-western South Australia relied heavily on mulga seeds as a food source. To prepare seeds for consumption they would undergo a double yandying process. The seeds would initially be separated from their pods through threshing and rubbing and then yandied to separate them from the pod fragments. The seeds would then be baked in hot sand and ashes, requiring an additional yandying process to remove sand and ashes. The properties yandying uses are size and density.

Sieving, filtering and straining let smaller particles, or liquids, pass through, while larger particles or solids are kept in place. How well they work depends on the size of the holes compared with the size of the particles. In traditional times, Gunditjmara Aboriginal peoples in southwest Victoria used flowering honeysuckle cones (banksias) to filter water from muddy pools when clean drinking water was unavailable.

My notebook

In winnowing, what does the wind remove?

In traditional times, what did Gunditjmara Aboriginal peoples use flowering honeysuckle cones (banksias) for?

Printable activity

Separating mixtures: particle drawings and practical record

Two pages. Page 1 has boxes to draw the particles in pure substances, mixtures and the products of separating muddy seawater. Page 2 is a record sheet for separating muddy salty water: your plan, what you saw at each step, and questions.

For teachers

Curriculum

Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 7, Science understanding, Chemical sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:

AC9S7U06 use a particle model to describe differences between pure substances and mixtures and apply understanding of properties of substances to separate mixtures

  • using representations of particles to show the difference between samples of pure substances and mixtures, and identifying examples of each
  • examining different solutions and identifying the solvent and solute
  • investigating and using a range of physical separation techniques such as filtration, decantation, evaporation, crystallisation, chromatography and distillation
  • exploring and comparing separation methods used in a variety of situations such as in the home, recycling industries and purifying water
  • analysing how the physical properties of substances in mixtures, such as particle size, density or volatility, determine the separation technique used
  • investigating separation techniques used by First Nations Australians, such as hand-picking, sieving, winnowing, yandying, filtering, cold-pressing and steam distilling

The second quote gives ACARA’s six elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each has a place in the lesson, three of them only in part:

  • Representations of particles in pure substances and mixtures: the lens on screen 2 shows six samples as particles, to be sorted into pure substances and mixtures, and the same lens shows the particles on screens 1 and 3 to 6; q-pure and q-juice.
  • Solutions, the solvent and the solute: screen 3 dissolves salt and sugar in water on a balance, and names salt, water and seawater as the solute, the solvent and the solution; q-solute and q-mass.
  • Physical separation techniques: met in part. Decanting and filtration are on screen 4, evaporation, crystallisation and distillation on screen 5, and all of them are combined on screen 6. The practical on screen 6 filters and evaporates, and the distillation is a teacher demonstration on screen 5. The lesson does not teach chromatography.
  • Separation methods in different situations: touched on. Two key ideas give examples of purifying water, Sydney Water’s filtration on screen 4 and the Sydney Desalination Plant on screen 6, but no task asks students to compare them. The lesson does not cover separation in the home or in recycling industries.
  • How properties decide the technique: particle size for filtering on screen 4, how volatile each substance is for evaporating and distilling on screen 5, and on screen 7 how heavy the particles are for winnowing, and size and density for yandying. Screen 6 asks students to choose the techniques and their order; q-residue and q-order.
  • Separation techniques used by First Nations Australians: met in part. Screen 7 has winnowing, yandying and filtering, from ACARA’s background information; q-winnow and q-gunditjmara. ACARA’s page also describes hand-picking, cold-pressing and steam distillation, which the lesson does not teach.

The lesson also works on parts of these content descriptions. Students plan a separation, choosing and ordering the techniques, and each practical has care lines for its risks, a step towards AC9S7I02, though there are no variables to control. They use a balance, a filter funnel and an evaporating basin, and record masses with the balance, a step towards AC9S7I03 (the equipment is chosen for them). On the printable they draw particle models and fill in a results table (AC9S7I04); in the simulations the tables fill themselves.

AC9S7I02 plan and conduct reproducible investigations to answer questions and test hypotheses, including identifying variables and assumptions and, as appropriate, recognising and managing risks, considering ethical issues and recognising key considerations regarding heritage sites and artefacts on Country/Place

AC9S7I03 select and use equipment to generate and record data with precision, using digital tools as appropriate

AC9S7I04 select and construct appropriate representations, including tables, graphs, models and mathematical relationships, to organise and process data and information

The lesson builds on the particle model from earlier in Year 7 (AC9S7U05, the site’s lesson How does particle theory explain the properties of substances?). It does not teach elements and compounds, or the difference between physical and chemical change, which come in Year 8.

How the lesson is taught

The method is problem-based learning. The problem comes before any teaching: screen 1 gives the class a jar of seawater with sand and mud stirred into it, and asks for pure water, salt, and the sand and mud. Students look at the mixture through the lens, say what they know and what they need to find out (the Talk about it prompt), and write a first plan in the notebook. Screens 2 to 5 each teach one thing the plan needs, and each notebook prompt takes the new idea back to the problem. On screen 6 students build a plan in the simulation, test it, and compare it with their first plan; the practical on screen 6 runs the plan with real muddy salty water. Screen 7 shows separation techniques that First Nations Australians developed for problems of their own. Show screen 1 and let groups argue about the problem before anyone explains it. You can teach one or two screens in a session.

The research. Joi Merritt, Mi Yeon Lee, Peter Rillero and Barbara M. Kinach (2017) reviewed studies of problem-based and project-based learning, which they treat together, in mathematics and science from kindergarten to Year 8. A search of ERIC and PsycInfo found 504 records, and they kept nine articles with experimental or quasi-experimental designs, all of them in science. Seven of the eight studies that measured achievement (87.5%) found that students in the problem-based group outperformed the control group, and three of the four that looked at knowledge retention found better retention. They conclude that problem-based learning is “at least as effective as traditional instruction” for achievement and knowledge retention. They name the limits themselves: they included only quantitative studies that used the term problem-based learning or project-based learning, and the studies had no agreed definition of it.

Orhan Akınoğlu and Ruhan Özkardeş Tandoğan (2007) compared two groups of 25 Year 7 students at a primary school in Kadıköy, Istanbul, chosen at random, in the 2004–05 school year; a pre-test was used to form groups at the same level. The unit, on force, motion and energy, ran for 30 class hours over ten weeks. The problem-based group was given the problem scenarios before any information, brainstormed, and then worked the new knowledge back into the problem. This lesson uses the same order: the problem comes first, and each screen’s notebook prompt asks students to take the new idea back to the problem, though the screens teach each idea themselves. The problem-based group scored higher on the achievement test (means of 12.76 and 10.12) and on an attitude scale. Its misconceptions were fewer, though not all removed; the concept learning was looked at qualitatively, not tested statistically. The researcher carried out the study, so treat it as an example of the method rather than proof that it will work in your class.

Students’ ideas

  • Oak National Academy’s Year 7 lesson on pure substances warns that students take the everyday meaning of pure, as on a carton of pure orange juice, for the scientific one. Its advice is that the everyday word means one source, and the scientific word is about the particles, and it adds: “Take particular care when discussing water.” Screen 2 sorts the samples by their particles, its second question asks what pure means on a juice label, and its key idea says tap water is not pure water; the Royal Society of Chemistry’s Nuffield practical evaporates tap water to show its solid residue.
  • Oak’s lesson on mixtures and solutions notes that students confuse solute, solvent, solution, soluble and insoluble. Screen 3’s lede gives all five, q-solute asks for the solute in seawater with the solvent and the solution as the wrong answers, and each word is in the word list.
  • The Royal Society of Chemistry’s resource on mass and dissolving, from Chemical misconceptions, says younger learners may think solutes “disappear” when they dissolve, and may not expect the solute’s mass to count. When it was piloted in schools, some learners did not expect mass to be conserved. Screen 3 shows the balance reading staying at 105.0 g while the salt dissolves, and asks whether the salt has gone.
  • Oak’s lesson on separating salt from rock salt lists the idea that filtration alone can separate the salt. Its answer is that each technique so far makes two products, and one of them may still be a mixture. Screen 4 ends with the filtrate still salty, and screen 6 makes students carry on with it.
  • Oak’s distillation lesson notes that students think heating harder and for longer makes distillation better. Screen 5 does not let the heat be turned up; it shows instead that the condenser has to be kept cold.
  • Oak’s lesson on dissolving teaches that dissolving is not the same as melting, and screen 3’s key idea says so: the salt does not turn into a liquid.
  • Victoria’s science continuum notes that students may think the particles of a blue solid are themselves blue, and that models explain how particles behave, not how they look. The key idea on screen 1 says the colours and shapes in the lens only tell the kinds of particle apart.

About the models

  • The lens. Each kind of particle has its own shape as well as its colour: water particles are blue circles, salt particles purple squares and sugar particles orange hexagons. A speck of mud is a brown lump of small particles, and a sand grain is a big tan shape packed with particles. The model draws each substance as one kind of particle, to keep the picture simple. The numbers of salt and sugar particles are not to scale, and real specks of mud and grains of sand are far bigger, next to the particles of water, than they are drawn. Every process in the lens is speeded up.
  • Seawater. Chemguide says the solids dissolved in seawater are mainly salt, and the Royal Society of Chemistry’s practical on salts from seawater says it contains various different salts. The model’s seawater has salt only, and the note under the drawing on screen 1 says so. For the same reason the practicals use tap water with table salt stirred in, not real seawater.
  • Screen 1. When the jar stands, the sand drops first and the mud settles slowly: the Royal Society of Chemistry’s sheet on filtration says larger solid pieces drop to the bottom of a beaker that is left to settle, Oak describes a suspension’s solid particles settling over time, and OpenStax says a dissolved solute will not settle out of a solution. The times in the drawing are the model’s own.
  • Screen 3. The amounts, 5 g of solid in 100 g of water, are the lesson’s own, chosen to keep the numbers easy. The reading stays at 105.0 g because mass is conserved when substances are mixed, as Oak’s lesson on mixtures and solutions teaches. A real balance’s reading can wander a little; the model shows none of that. Sand is shown not dissolving, as it stays behind in the filter paper in the Royal Society of Chemistry’s sand and salt practical.
  • Screen 4. The Royal Society of Chemistry’s sheet says the holes in filter paper let water particles through but not the larger solid pieces, and its page on separating salt from sand says school filter paper may let through very fine particles the size of silt; the key idea says so. The lens draws the paper as fibres with gaps between them, which is the lesson’s own picture. Letting the mixture settle first makes filtering quicker, as the Royal Society of Chemistry’s sheet says. The lesson’s own reading is that some fine mud goes with the decanted liquid because it has not settled yet; Oak says the solid particles in a suspension eventually settle over time. The Royal Society of Chemistry’s page on separating salt from sand warns that school filter paper may not filter out very fine particles, so with fine clay in the real mixture the filtrate may be cloudy and the salt may not be clean. This is worth talking about with the class.
  • Screen 5. Crystals appear round the edge when the solution is saturated, and turning the heat off at the first crystals lets bigger crystals grow, as the Royal Society of Chemistry’s sheet describes. Hot salt spits when evaporation is almost complete, as its sand and salt practical warns. The thermometer reads close to 100 °C while the water boils, which the Royal Society of Chemistry’s water condenser demonstration gives as the boiling point of the distillate; the drawing shows no other temperatures. Cooling water goes in at the lower end of the condenser and out at the higher, as Chemguide describes. With the cooling water off, the condenser warms up and more gas escapes, as Oak’s distillation lesson says. The bubbles in the boiling flask contain water vapour, not air, as the water condenser page says. Water vapour can’t be seen, and the white wisps over the basin are tiny drops of liquid water, as the Royal Society of Chemistry’s Evaporation in action explains, so no white cloud is drawn at the end of the condenser. Evaporation happens at the surface, at any temperature, so the basin is not drawn boiling. The model turns the heat off before the flask boils dry, and it leaves out the stands and clamps.
  • Screen 6. Each step is a short version of a real technique, and real products are less tidy. The residue on the filter paper is damp with salty water (the lesson’s own reading); the Royal Society of Chemistry’s practical asks for two reasons the sand might still contain salt (the Talk about it prompt). Distilling leaves a little very salty water in the flask, which is evaporated to get the salt; if the sand and mud are still in the flask, they are filtered out of it first. Water from the tap that is added and then distilled is not counted as the jar’s pure water. The Sydney Desalination Plant uses reverse osmosis, not distillation, to take the salt out of seawater.
  • Screen 7. Only the containers and what is in them are drawn, and no people. In the winnowing model the husks are slowed by the air and pushed by the wind much more than the seeds, so that the wind removes the husks, as ACARA describes; the shapes and colours, where the husks land, the direction of the wind and the result with no wind are the model’s own. The yandying model moves the small grains of sand and ash down past the seeds, which stay higher up; it shows what ACARA describes, not why it happens. The mesh, its three hole sizes and the three sizes of the pieces of mud are the lesson’s own, a general model of sieving and filtering, not the Gunditjmara technique.

Practical work and safety

  • Do your school’s own risk assessment for each practical, following your state or territory’s requirements. Oak National Academy’s lessons on pure substances, on separating salt from rock salt and on distillation each note that adult supervision and a risk assessment are needed.
  • Every practical says never to eat or drink anything in the laboratory, as in the Royal Society of Chemistry’s Nuffield practical on tap water and seawater. This matters here because the problem is about getting water and salt: none of the water or salt the class makes is for tasting or drinking.
  • Screen 1’s jar is plastic, so nothing breaks when it is shaken. Screen 3 asks for eye protection.
  • Screen 5’s distillation is a teacher demonstration, as on the Royal Society of Chemistry’s water condenser page. That page asks for eye protection throughout, lists two stands, bosses and clamps, and puts a few anti-bumping granules in the flask, which help the bubbles form so that the liquid does not boil violently. Do not add granules once the liquid is boiling, as CLEAPSS’s student safety sheet on handling hot liquids in beakers says. The Royal Society of Chemistry’s simple distillation resource says to clamp the neck of the flask, to take care with hot glassware, which can burn, and to take the Bunsen away if the solution starts to boil rapidly. Keep the cooling water on throughout, since the simulation’s third task, with the water off, is not one to copy.
  • Screen 6’s practical follows the Royal Society of Chemistry’s sand and salt practical: eye protection throughout, students standing while they heat, and care because hot salt spits when evaporation is almost complete. The lesson’s method turns the heat off at the first crystals, as in the Royal Society of Chemistry’s sheet on crystallisation, so the basin is not heated until it is nearly dry. Its practical on salts from seawater adds care with hot apparatus and solutions. CLEAPSS advises letting apparatus cool down naturally, and warns that the tripod gets very hot. CLEAPSS’s sheet on using a Bunsen burner adds tying back long hair, keeping clothing clear of the flame, standing the burner on a heat resistant mat 30 to 40 cm from the edge of the bench, and using the yellow flame when it is not heating anything. The care line on screen 6 and the printable include all of these except the mat.

The First Nations content

  • Where it comes from. The First Nations knowledge on screen 7, in its lede, its key idea, its simulation’s words, q-winnow, q-gunditjmara and the word list entries for winnowing, yandying, koolamon and yandy, comes only from ACARA’s teacher background information for AC9S7U06, elaboration 6: the first section, Connecting the elaboration and content description, and the parts on winnowing, yandying, and sieving and filtering. The properties each technique uses (how heavy the particles are, and size and density) are the lesson’s own reading of ACARA’s words lighter, heavier, smaller and denser. ACARA’s page also describes hand-picking, cold-pressing, steam distillation and more examples of winnowing, which the lesson does not use.
  • Not checked. This content has not been checked with the Gunditjmara or Yankunytjatjara Aboriginal peoples, or with the Kamilaroi or Yindjibarni people, whose knowledge and words it uses.
  • Before you teach screen 7. This advice is the lesson’s own, not ACARA’s. Find out whose Country your school is on. Talk with your school’s Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander education staff, or with local community members, about separation techniques used locally and what may be shared, and invite a local knowledge holder if you can, paying or properly recognising them; Be You’s national protocols say it is disrespectful to ask Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people to work for free. Check how a People’s name is spelt with the community or its language centre: the lesson keeps ACARA’s spelling, Yindjibarni, while the Wangka Maya Pilbara Aboriginal Language Centre spells the language Yindjibarndi. Do not present one People’s technique as the practice of all First Nations Australians, and do not make these techniques into a classroom practical without that advice.
  • ACARA’s cautions. ACARA’s page lists the works it consulted, and reminds educators that written records, though useful, can be problematic: they are often based on non-Indigenous interpretations of First Nations Peoples’ behaviours, actions, comments and traditions, often lack the viewpoints of the people they discuss, and can contain outdated ideas, and some may contain cultural breaches that cause offence. It warns that some of the sources may contain material considered culturally offensive or inappropriate, and that they are not provided or recommended as classroom resources. It says that, with careful selection, evaluation and community consultation, the consulted works may help teachers build culturally appropriate materials, and it calls the ability to select and evaluate appropriate resources an “essential cultural capability skill for educators”.
  • ACARA’s words. The screen names the Peoples as ACARA names them: the Gunditjmara Aboriginal peoples, the Yankunytjatjara Aboriginal peoples, and the Kamilaroi people and Yindjibarni people as the sources of the words koolamon and yandy. It keeps ACARA’s tenses and verbs: Gunditjmara Aboriginal peoples used banksia cones in traditional times, Yankunytjatjara Aboriginal peoples traditionally relied heavily on mulga seeds, which would be baked in hot sand and ashes, and the techniques themselves are described in the present tense. The lesson draws no people. The yandy is drawn as a plain shallow wooden dish, from ACARA’s description of it as a wooden container and a shallow dish similar to a koolamon. ACARA does not say what a koolamon is made of, so it is drawn as a plain shallow dish with no wood grain. The seeds, husks, sand and ash are simple shapes, not any particular plant.
  • The plainer words, with ACARA’s words in italics. The lede: developed and used for developed and utilised; to get and process resources needed for that enable the procurement and processing of resources necessary for. Winnowing: Winnowing is designed for Winnowing is a separation method that is designed; keeping for maintaining; a container such as a koolamon for a specifically designed container, such as a koolamon; and thrown lightly into the air. The wind removes for The mixture is then thrown lightly into the air allowing the wind to remove. Yandying: Yandying is like gold panning for Yandying is akin to the process of gold panning; raised in one corner and gently shaken back and forth for raised in one corner, and then gently shaken back and forth; The smaller and denser particles collect at the bottom, while for forcing the smaller and denser particles to collect at the bottom while. Filtering: let smaller particles, or liquids, pass through, while larger particles or solids are kept in place for allow the smaller particles, or liquids, to pass through while keeping the larger particles or solids in place; How well they work depends on the size of the holes compared with the size of the particles for The effectiveness of these techniques depends on the size of the holes in relation to the size of the particles to be separated; In traditional times, Gunditjmara Aboriginal peoples in southwest Victoria used for A practical example of filtering can be found in southwest Victoria, where in traditional times, Gunditjmara Aboriginal peoples used. The word list: A separation method designed to remove lighter particles while keeping heavier ones for a separation method that is designed to remove lighter particles while maintaining heavier ones; stay higher up for remain higher up; the specifically designed container that a mixture of seeds and husks is placed in for winnowing for The mixture of seeds and husks is placed in a specifically designed container, such as a koolamon; is now part of Australian English for is now in the Australian vernacular; to describe the dish for to describe a shallow dish similar to a koolamon. The questions: ACARA gives separating sand, dirt or ash from seeds as a common purpose for yandying for A common purpose for yandying would be to separate sand, dirt or ash from seeds; Winnowing uses a container such as a koolamon, and Yandying uses a wooden container called a yandy, from the same sentences as above. The simulation: raised at one corner for raised in one corner; a shallow wooden dish for a shallow dish and a wooden container.

Answers at a glance

  • Screen 1: just after stirring, the lens shows water, salt and mud at every place, and grains of sand falling at the bottom; after standing, water and salt at the top and in the middle, and sand and mud at the bottom; the clear water at the top still has salt in it. q-settle the salt; q-clear water particles and salt particles.
  • Screen 2: distilled water, salt and sugar are pure substances, and seawater, sugar water and muddy seawater are mixtures; seawater has salt particles as well as water particles; on a juice label, pure means from one source. q-pure distilled water; q-juice no, it is a mixture.
  • Screen 3: salt and sugar dissolve and sand does not; the balance reads 100.0 g with water only, 105.0 g just after the solid is added and 105.0 g at the end; the dissolved salt has not gone. q-solute salt; q-mass 105 g.
  • Screen 4: decanting after settling leaves the sand and most of the mud, and pours off water, salt and a little mud; filtering leaves the sand and mud as the residue, and the filtrate is water and salt, so it is not pure water. q-filtrate water and salt; q-residue its pieces are bigger than the holes.
  • Screen 5: evaporating leaves salt crystals and loses the water to the air; turn off the heat when the first crystals appear; distilling collects pure water in the beaker and leaves the salt in the flask, with the thermometer close to 100 °C; with the cooling water off, gas escapes and less water collects. q-evap into the air, as a gas; q-distil distilling.
  • Screen 6: there are two three-step plans: filter, distil, then evaporate what is left in the flask; or distil, filter what is left in the flask, then evaporate the filtrate. Settling and decanting first also works. Evaporating the jar’s water loses it, and water added later to dissolve the salt again does not count as the jar’s water. q-order so that the salt is not left mixed with the sand and mud; q-two the filtrate.
  • Screen 7: winnowing with a light wind leaves only seeds in the koolamon; yandying collects the sand and ash at the bottom with the seeds higher up; the small holes hold back all the mud and let the water through. q-winnow the lighter husks; q-gunditjmara to filter water from muddy pools.
  • The printable: the drawings vary. Distilled water and salt each have one kind of particle; seawater has water and salt particles spread through each other; sugar water has water and sugar particles spread through each other, so it is a mixture; the filtrate has water and salt particles; the distillate has water particles only. If the salt is not white, very fine clay probably went through the filter paper.

Saved progress

Answers, notes, results tables and settings are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere. If students share devices, clear the saved answers between them.

Sources by screen

  • Screen 1: OpenStax, Chemistry: Atoms First (mixtures); Chemguide, Simple distillation (the solids dissolved in seawater); the Royal Society of Chemistry, Separating salts from seawater (various different salts); Victoria’s science continuum, Macroscopic versus microscopic properties (the colours are a code); the Royal Society of Chemistry, Filtration, evaporation and crystallisation (settling); Oak National Academy, Dissolving (suspensions); OpenStax, Chemistry 2e (a dissolved solute does not settle).
  • Screen 2: Oak National Academy, Pure substances; OpenStax, Chemistry: Atoms First (pure substances, mixtures, solutions and sucrose); the Royal Society of Chemistry, Dissolved substances in tap water and seawater (tap water); the Royal Society of Chemistry’s water condenser demonstration and Chemguide (distilled water is pure water); Oak National Academy, Separating pure salt from dirty rock salt (pure salt).
  • Screen 3: Oak National Academy, Mixtures and solutions and Dissolving; OpenStax, Chemistry 2e; the Royal Society of Chemistry, Separating sand and salt by filtering and evaporation, and Mass and dissolving.
  • Screen 4: the Royal Society of Chemistry, Filtration, evaporation and crystallisation, and Separating salt from sand; Oak National Academy, Separating pure salt from dirty rock salt; Sydney Water, Drinking water filtration.
  • Screen 5: Chemguide, Simple distillation; the Royal Society of Chemistry, Filtration, evaporation and crystallisation, Recovering pure water from a solution using a water condenser, Separating sand and salt by filtering and evaporation, Evaporation in action, and Simple distillation; Oak National Academy, Distillation practical.
  • Screen 6: Oak National Academy, Separating pure salt from dirty rock salt; the Royal Society of Chemistry, Separating sand and salt by filtering and evaporation; the Sydney Desalination Plant, How desalination works.
  • Screen 7: ACARA’s teacher background information for AC9S7U06, elaboration 6. The teacher notes also use Be You’s protocols for culturally respectful engagement and the Wangka Maya Pilbara Aboriginal Language Centre’s page on Yindjibarndi.
  • The method: Merritt, Lee, Rillero and Kinach (2017); Akınoğlu and Tandoğan (2007).
  • Students’ ideas: Oak National Academy’s lessons above; the Royal Society of Chemistry, Mass and dissolving; Victoria’s science continuum, Macroscopic versus microscopic properties.
  • Safety: the Royal Society of Chemistry’s sand and salt, salts from seawater, tap water and seawater, water condenser and simple distillation pages; CLEAPSS, Student safety sheets 92 and 95; Oak National Academy’s lessons above.
  • Printable: the same sources as screens 2 to 6.

Word list