Year 8 science · Chemical sciences · AC9S8U07
Physical or chemical change?
1Look
Same particles or new ones?
How can you tell a physical change from a chemical change?
In a physical change, such as ice melting, no new substance is made: the same particles are there at the end, though they may be arranged differently. In a chemical change, one or more new substances are made. The atoms are not lost. They are rearranged, joined in new ways in new particles. A chemical change is also called a chemical reaction.
How this lesson works. Each simulation in this lesson draws a graph while a change happens, as a sensor and data logger would. On screens 1, 2 and 4 you predict what will happen before each change, then watch the graph form and compare it with your prediction. On this screen the graph counts the molecules of each substance in the lens, which no real sensor can do.
On this screen
- Choose a change and predict whether new substances will form.
- Press Start and watch the lens and the graph.
- Sort the change: physical or chemical.
- Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
Look closely
In some changes the same particles are there at the end, and in others the atoms end up in new particles. Watch six changes through the lens, with a graph of the particles drawn as each change happens.
Choose a change. The picture on the left shows what you would see, and the lens shows its molecules. Choose your prediction, then press Start. The graph draws a line for each substance in the lens: blue for substances that were there at the start, and orange for new substances. Press Count the atoms to count every atom before and after. Hydrogen peroxide breaks down slowly on its own, so a catalyst is added to speed it up. Its solution is hydrogen peroxide dissolved in water, so the lens shows water molecules from the start.
Six changes through the lens
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Use your results
Do these three tasks with the simulation, the table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Sort all six changes into physical and chemical changes.
Need a hint?
Choose a change, make your prediction and press Start. Watch the lines on the graph, then press Physical change or Chemical change.
Compare ice melting with water being split by electricity.
Need a hint?
Run Ice melting, then Splitting water, and compare the lines on the two graphs.
Count the atoms before and after a chemical change.
Need a hint?
Run Methane burning, then press Count the atoms.
Talk about it. Ice melting and water splitting both start with water molecules. What is different at the end?
Physical and chemical changes
In a physical change no new substance is made. When ice melts, steam condenses or dry ice turns to gas, the same molecules are there at the end. Only how they are arranged and how they move change, so the line for each substance on the graph stays level.
In a chemical change new substances are made. When methane burns, each methane molecule and two oxygen molecules break apart, and their atoms join again as one carbon dioxide molecule and two water molecules. The lines for methane and oxygen fall, and new lines rise for carbon dioxide and water.
No atoms are made or lost in a chemical change. The same atoms are there before and after, joined in new ways, and the new substances have different properties from the ones at the start.
The same substance can have both kinds of change. Ice melting is a physical change, but water split into hydrogen and oxygen by an electric current is a chemical change.
Practical
Heat chocolate and egg white
Do this in the laboratory, when your teacher says.
You need
- A few grams of chocolate and about 4 cm³ of egg white
- Two test tubes, a test tube rack and a test tube holder
- A 250 cm³ beaker, a Bunsen burner, a heat resistant mat, a tripod and gauze
- Safety glasses
What to do
- Put the chocolate in one test tube and the egg white in the other. Write down what each one looks like.
- Fill the beaker about one-third full of cold water and stand both tubes in it, on the tripod and gauze.
- Heat until the water boils, and let it boil gently for about 5 minutes. Write down what happens in each tube.
- Turn off the Bunsen burner, then lift the tubes out with the holder and leave them in the rack to cool. Which change can be undone, and which made a new substance?
Take care. Wear safety glasses throughout, and tie long hair back. Do not sit down while you are heating the beaker or handling hot test tubes, and remember that the tripod, gauze and beaker get hot too. Never eat or taste the chocolate or egg, because food in a laboratory may be contaminated. Wash your hands afterwards. Your teacher will check for food allergies first.
My notebook
Which of these changes makes a new substance?
On this screen’s graph, what do the lines do in a physical change?
2Find out
Signs of a chemical change
What can you see or measure when a chemical change happens?
Particles are far too small to see, so chemists look for signs that a new substance has formed. A gas can be given off, a solid called a precipitate can form, the colour can change, or the temperature can change. A sensor and a data logger can measure these changes and graph them as they happen.
On this screen
- Choose a reaction and predict which graph will change.
- Press Mix and watch all four graphs.
- Read the signs in the table.
- Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
Find out
A chemical change can give signs that you can see or measure. Run four reactions with four sensors, and watch their graphs as each reaction happens.
Choose a reaction, choose the graph you think will change, then press Mix. Four sensors watch the flask: a thermometer, a gas syringe, a cloudiness sensor that shines a lamp through the liquid, and a colour strip that records the colour of the liquid. Each graph draws its line as the reaction happens, and the table under the graphs fills in when a run ends.
Four reactions, four sensors
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Use your results
Do these three tasks with the simulation, its graphs and the table under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Run all four reactions and record their signs.
Need a hint?
Choose a reaction, predict which graph will change, and press Mix. Watch all four graphs until the run ends.
Find the reaction that gives off a gas.
Need a hint?
Look at the gas graph and the table after all four runs, then answer the first question under the table.
Find the reaction whose only sign shows on a graph, not in the flask.
Need a hint?
Look at the table after all four runs, then answer the second question under it.
Talk about it. Which sign would you miss if you only looked, and did not measure?
Signs of a chemical change
A gas given off, a solid forming, a colour change and a temperature change are all signs of a chemical change. Sodium hydrogencarbonate and citric acid give off carbon dioxide gas. Sodium chloride and silver nitrate make a white solid, silver chloride. Copper wire in silver nitrate makes grey silver on the wire and a blue solution.
One reaction can give more than one sign. Sodium hydrogencarbonate and citric acid fizz and get colder at the same time.
Some signs show only when you measure. Hydrochloric acid and sodium hydroxide stay clear when they react, but the thermometer shows the temperature rising from 22.0 °C to 28.9 °C.
Burning gives out light as well as heat, which is another sign. A graph drawn while a reaction happens shows how fast each sign appears, and when it stops.
My notebook
Which of these is a sign of a chemical change?
Two clear solutions are mixed, and the mixture turns cloudy and white. What has happened?
3Test
Clues, not proof
How can you be sure a change is chemical?
The signs of a chemical change can come from a physical change too. Boiling water bubbles, freezing water makes a solid, a crystal dissolving can colour the water, and dissolving can change the temperature. A sign is a clue. The proof is a new substance, with different properties from the substances at the start, and a test can find it. Bubbling a gas through limewater is a test for carbon dioxide.
On this screen
- Choose a sign, and run both changes that give it.
- Compare the two lines on the graph.
- Test what is there after each change.
- Sort all eight changes.
- Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
Test
Bubbles, a solid, a colour or a temperature change can come from a physical change too. Compare pairs of changes that look the same on a graph, then test what is there afterwards.
Choose a sign. Two changes give it, and the graph draws a line for each: a solid line for change 1 and a dashed line for change 2. After they have run, press Test change 1 and Test change 2. Each pair has one test, done on both changes. Sort a change once you have tested it.
Four pairs of look-alike changes
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Use your results
Do these three tasks with the simulation and the table under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Run both changes in all four pairs, and compare their graphs.
Need a hint?
Choose a pair, then press Run both. The two lines on the graph show the same sign.
Test what is there after all eight changes.
Need a hint?
After a pair has run, press Test change 1 and Test change 2.
Sort the eight changes into physical and chemical changes.
Need a hint?
Use the test results. A new substance means a chemical change.
Talk about it. Why is a sign of a chemical change a clue and not a proof?
Clues and proof
Boiling water, freezing water, Condy’s crystals dissolving and calcium chloride dissolving give the same signs as chemical changes, but they are physical changes. The tests found the same substances at the end as at the start.
The chemical changes made new substances: carbon dioxide gas, a white solid called silver chloride, grey silver and a blue solution, and salt.
To decide whether a change is chemical, look for a new substance with new properties. Test a gas, warm a solid, or get back what dissolved by evaporating the water.
Dissolving is usually classed as a physical change, because what dissolved can be got back by evaporating the water. Some chemists argue that dissolving can count as a chemical change, because it usually comes with an energy change and, when a salt dissolves, the bonds that hold its crystal together are broken up.
Practical
Iron and sulfur, before and after
Do this in the laboratory, when your teacher says.
You need
- Your teacher shows this, in a well-ventilated laboratory
- Iron powder, sulfur powder and a mixture of the two
- A magnet
- Safety glasses
What to do
- Look at the iron and the sulfur, and write down the colour of each one.
- Watch your teacher hold the magnet near the mixture. Write down what happens to the iron and to the sulfur.
- Watch your teacher heat a little of the mixture in a test tube until it glows orange.
- When it has cooled, your teacher breaks the tube open to get the product out. Compare it with the mixture. Write down its colour, and whether a weak magnet pulls it out.
Take care. This is a demonstration by your teacher. Heating sulfur can make sulfur dioxide, a toxic gas that can bring on an asthma attack, so tell your teacher if you have asthma. Wear safety glasses throughout.
My notebook
Boiling water makes bubbles. Why is boiling a physical change?
Which is the best evidence that a chemical change has happened?
4Measure
Energy out, energy in
How does a temperature graph show whether energy is given out or taken in?
Changes can give out energy or take it in. An exothermic change gives out energy to its surroundings, so they get warmer. An endothermic change takes in energy from its surroundings, so they get colder. In a cup of liquid, the liquid around the change is its surroundings, so a thermometer in it shows which way the energy went. Physical changes can give out or take in energy too.
On this screen
- Choose a mixture and predict: warmer, colder or no change?
- Press Mix and watch the temperature graph for 3 minutes.
- Sort the mixture: exothermic or endothermic.
- Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
Measure
Some changes give out energy and warm their surroundings. Others take energy in and cool them. Watch the temperature of five mixtures, graphed as they happen.
Choose a mixture and your prediction, then press Mix. The thermometer stands in a polystyrene cup, and the graph draws the temperature for 3 minutes as it changes. The table records the start, the highest or lowest temperature, and the change. Earlier runs stay on the graph in grey.
Five mixtures and a thermometer
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Use your results
Do these three tasks with the simulation, its graph and the table under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Measure the temperature change of all five mixtures.
Need a hint?
Choose a mixture, predict whether it will get warmer or colder, and press Mix. The table fills in when the run ends.
Sort the five mixtures into exothermic and endothermic.
Need a hint?
After a run, press Exothermic if the temperature went up, or Endothermic if it went down.
Find the two mixtures that change temperature without a chemical change.
Need a hint?
Look at what happens in each mixture. Dissolving is usually classed as a physical change. Answer the question under the table.
Talk about it. A cold pack and a chemical reaction can both get colder. What else would you need to know to tell them apart?
Exothermic and endothermic changes
When hydrochloric acid and sodium hydroxide react, the temperature rises from 22.0 °C to 28.9 °C. The reaction gives out energy, so it is exothermic. Copper(II) sulfate and magnesium are exothermic too.
When sodium hydrogencarbonate and citric acid react, the temperature falls. The reaction takes in energy, so it is endothermic.
Dissolving can change the temperature too. When ammonium nitrate dissolves in water, the temperature falls from 24.9 °C to 20.3 °C. When calcium chloride dissolves, it rises from 22.4 °C to 25.8 °C. A temperature change is a sign of an energy change, not proof of a chemical change.
Afterwards, the cup slowly warms or cools back towards room temperature, as energy passes between it and the room. A polystyrene cup makes a simple calorimeter, but some energy still passes between it and the room.
Practical
Hotter or colder?
Do this in the laboratory, when your teacher says.
You need
- Polystyrene cups standing in a 250 cm³ beaker, a thermometer, a 10 cm³ measuring cylinder and a spatula
- 0.4 M sodium hydroxide solution and 0.4 M hydrochloric acid
- 0.4 M sodium hydrogencarbonate solution and citric acid
- Anhydrous calcium chloride and water
- A stopclock, or a temperature sensor and data logger
- Safety glasses
What to do
- Put 10 cm³ of sodium hydroxide solution in a cup and record its temperature.
- Add 10 cm³ of hydrochloric acid, stir with the thermometer, and record the temperature every 30 seconds for 3 minutes.
- Repeat with 10 cm³ of sodium hydrogencarbonate solution and four small spatula measures of citric acid, then with 10 cm³ of water and one spatula measure of anhydrous calcium chloride.
- Draw a temperature-time graph for each mixture, and decide whether each one is exothermic or endothermic.
Take care. Wear safety glasses throughout, because sodium hydroxide, citric acid and calcium chloride irritate the eyes and skin. If a solution splashes on your skin, wash it at once with lots of water and tell your teacher. Wipe up small spills, and tell your teacher about bigger ones or any breakage. Wash your hands afterwards. Never eat or drink anything in the laboratory.
My notebook
The temperature of a mixture rises from 22 °C to 29 °C. What does this show?
An instant cold pack gets cold when ammonium nitrate dissolves in its water. Which describes this change?
5Apply
Properties at work
How do the properties of a substance decide what it is used for?
A substance’s physical and chemical properties decide what it is good for. Whether it gives out energy, takes energy in, gives off a gas or sets hard when it meets water are all properties. A chemical property is about what a substance can change into, such as whether it reacts with oxygen.
On this screen
- Choose a job.
- Test at least two of the contents, and watch the graph.
- Choose the best one for the job.
- Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
Apply
Whether a substance gives out energy, takes it in or gives off a gas decides what it can be used for. Test the contents for three jobs, and choose the best one for each.
Choose a job, then choose some contents and press Test it. The graph shows how the temperature, or the gas given off, changes over minutes or hours. Earlier tests for the same job stay on the graph in grey. When you have found the best contents, press Use this one.
Cold packs, hand warmers and baking
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Use your results
Do these three tasks with the simulation and its graph. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Choose the best contents for a cold pack.
Need a hint?
Choose A cold pack, test at least two contents, and press Use this one for the best.
Choose the best contents for a hand warmer that lasts all morning.
Need a hint?
Choose A hand warmer, test at least two contents, and press Use this one for the best.
Choose what makes a cake rise.
Need a hint?
Choose A cake, test at least two, and press Use this one for the best.
Talk about it. Which job used a chemical change, and which used a physical change?
Properties decide uses
An instant cold pack holds solid ammonium nitrate and a separate bag of water. When the water bag is broken, the ammonium nitrate dissolves and takes in energy, so the pack gets cold. Citric acid and sodium hydrogencarbonate get cold too, but they give off carbon dioxide gas, so they can’t be used in cold packs.
One kind of hand warmer starts when its packet is opened, because iron and water inside it react with oxygen from the air and give out energy. Salt in it makes the reaction faster. Another kind holds a supersaturated sodium acetate solution. Bending a metal disc in it makes the sodium acetate crystallise, which gives out energy, and heating it dissolves the crystals again, so it can be used again.
Baking powder makes a cake rise. It holds sodium hydrogencarbonate and an acid, which react when they meet the water in the batter and give off bubbles of carbon dioxide.
The same property can be useful in one job and a problem in another. A gas is no good in a cold pack, but it is what makes a cake rise.
My notebook
Citric acid and sodium hydrogencarbonate get cold when they react. Why are they not used in cold packs?
What starts a hand warmer that has iron and water inside it?
6Use
Test kits
How do test kits use a chemical change to find a substance?
A test kit uses a chemical change that gives a colour. In a soil pH kit, an indicator colours a white powder, and the colour depends on the soil’s pH. In a pool kit, a chemical called DPD turns the water pink when it reacts with chlorine, and the more chlorine, the darker the pink. A medical test strip has pads of chemicals that change colour when a particular substance, such as glucose, is there.
On this screen
- Choose a kit and a sample.
- Press Test it and watch the colour develop on the graph.
- Match the colour with the chart.
- Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
- Answer the last two questions and look at your results.
Use
Test kits use a chemical change with a colour that you can see. Use three kits, and read each colour against its chart.
Choose a kit and a sample, then press Test it. The graph shows the colour getting stronger. Each kit is read at a set time, given in its instructions, and here the reading time is the end of the graph. Then choose the square on the chart that matches the colour best. The table under the simulation records each result.
Three test kits
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Use your results
Do these three tasks with the simulation and the table under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Find the pH of all three soil samples.
Need a hint?
Choose Soil pH kit and a sample, press Test it, wait for the colour, then choose the matching square on the chart.
Find the pool water with the most chlorine.
Need a hint?
Choose Pool chlorine kit, test all three pools, and read each one against the chart.
Find the sample with glucose in it.
Need a hint?
Choose Glucose test strip, test all three samples, and read each strip against the chart.
Talk about it. Why does a test kit come with a colour chart, and not only a list of numbers?
Colours that measure
Each kit uses a chemical change that gives a colour. The colour shows whether a substance is there and how much of it, or how acidic or alkaline the sample is.
The colour takes time to develop, so each kit is read at the time its instructions give. A colour that goes on changing after the reading time can give a wrong result.
A colour chart turns a colour into a result. Matching by eye is not as precise as a laboratory test, and kits deteriorate with age: Agriculture Victoria advises throwing out soil pH kits after 12 to 18 months.
Test strips are used in medicine. A urine test strip has pads that change colour if certain substances, such as glucose, are there, and doctors use urinalysis to help find problems such as diabetes.
Practical
Test some soil
Do this in the laboratory, when your teacher says.
You need
- A garden soil pH test kit, with its indicator, white powder and colour chart
- Small samples of soil dug from three different places in the ground, not potting mix or bagged soil
- A white tile or the kit’s tray, and gloves
- Safety glasses
What to do
- Put a small amount of each soil on the tile, well apart.
- Add drops of the indicator to each soil to make a paste.
- Dust each paste with the white powder, and wait for its colour to change.
- Match each colour with the chart, and record each soil’s pH.
Take care. Wear gloves and safety glasses while you use the kit, because the indicator can irritate eyes and skin. Do not eat or taste anything. Wash your hands afterwards.
My notebook
In a soil pH kit, why does the white powder change colour?
In a pool test with DPD, one sample turns dark pink and another pale pink. What does this show?
Hotter or colder? A temperature record and graph
Two pages. Page 1 is a record sheet for measuring the temperature of three mixtures every 30 seconds. Page 2 has a grid to graph them and questions about energy and new substances.
For teachers
Curriculum
Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 8, Science understanding, Chemical sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:
AC9S8U07 compare physical and chemical changes and identify indicators of energy change in chemical reactions
- performing simple chemical reactions to identify the indicators of chemical change such as gas production, solid production, colour change and temperature change
- analysing and interpreting data on the properties of substances before and after the substances interact to determine if a chemical or physical change has occurred
- investigating and identifying energy changes in different chemical reactions such as differences in temperature
- examining how the physical and chemical properties of a substance will affect its production or use
- discussing where indicators of chemical change are used for identifying the presence of particular substances, such as in soil, water and medical testing kits
The second quote gives ACARA’s five elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each one has at least one screen, and one of them is met only in part:
- Performing simple chemical reactions to identify the indicators of chemical change: screen 2 runs four reactions with sensors for temperature, gas, cloudiness and colour, and screen 4’s practical, Hotter or colder?, has students carry out two reactions themselves. Screen 3’s practical is a teacher demonstration of iron and sulfur. q-signs and q-cloudy.
- Analysing data on the properties of substances before and after they interact, to decide whether a change is chemical or physical: screen 3 compares pairs of changes that give the same sign and then tests what is there afterwards, and its practical compares the colour of iron and sulfur, and what a magnet does, before and after heating. Screen 1’s graph is a model of the number of molecules of each substance before, during and after six changes. q-new, q-flat, q-boil and q-evidence.
- Investigating and identifying energy changes in chemical reactions, such as differences in temperature: screen 4 and its practical, with the temperature graph on screen 2. q-exo and q-pack.
- How the physical and chemical properties of a substance affect its production or use: met in part. Screen 5 is about use, in cold packs, hand warmers and baking, and the lesson does not look at production. q-why and q-warmer.
- Where indicators of chemical change are used to identify substances, in soil, water and medical testing kits: screen 6 uses a soil pH kit, a pool chlorine kit and a glucose test strip, and its practical tests real soil. q-kit and q-pink.
The lesson also works on two inquiry content descriptions. On screens 1, 2 and 4 students make a prediction before each change and then compare it with the graph, a step towards the reasoned predictions of AC9S8I01, though they choose their predictions from a short list. AC9S8I04 is met in part: every screen has graphs drawn over time, and the printable has students draw their own temperature–time graph with a title and labelled axes.
AC9S8I01 develop investigable questions, reasoned predictions and hypotheses to explore scientific models, identify patterns and test relationships
AC9S8I04 select and construct appropriate representations, including tables, graphs, models and mathematical relationships, to organise and process data and information
The lesson builds on three of the site’s lessons: reversible and irreversible changes in Year 6 (AC9S6U04, the site’s lesson Can you get it back?), the particle model in Year 7 (AC9S7U05, the site’s lesson How does particle theory explain the properties of substances?) and elements, compounds and mixtures in Year 8 (AC9S8U06, the site’s lesson Element, compound or mixture?). It does not write chemical equations or teach the conservation of mass, which come with AC9S9U07 (the site’s lesson Where does the mass go?), though Count the atoms on screen 1 shows the same atoms before and after a reaction.
How the lesson is taught
The method is real-time graphing. It comes from microcomputer-based laboratories (MBL), in which a sensor and a data logger draw a graph while an experiment runs. Krajcik and Layman’s summary of MBL research for NARST says real-time graphing may help students build science concepts and graphing skills, that making predictions before an MBL activity appears to help, and that students then need a chance to compare their results with their predictions. It also says a temperature probe helps students come to understand temperature and heat energy. The same summary warns that classroom research finds this kind of teaching difficult, and that MBL tools by themselves will not give students an environment for exploring concepts: a skilful teacher has to build them into the teaching.
In this lesson every simulation draws its graph while the change happens. On screens 1, 2 and 4 a change can’t start until the student has chosen a prediction, and when it ends the words under the simulation say whether the graph agreed with it. That line only reports the match. Students reconcile a prediction with a result when they explain a mismatch, so use the notebook prompts and the Talk about it questions for that. Screen 3 has students compare two graphs that look alike and then test what is left, screen 5 compares the graphs of different contents for the same job, and screen 6 graphs a colour as it develops. Screen 1’s graph counts molecules, which no real sensor can do. Most of the other graphs show things a sensor could measure, such as temperature, gas given off and colour, though screen 3’s graphs of bubbles and of the solid formed are the lesson’s own.
Before the class starts screen 1, ask what they expect to happen to the water molecules when ice melts and when water is split by electricity, and come back to their answers after both have run. You can teach one or two screens in a session.
The research. Linn and Songer (1991) changed the demands of a 13-week thermodynamics course over four versions, each taken by 100 to 200 eighth graders, and kept the same experiments and real-time data collection software. Understanding rose two- to fourfold when students predicted outcomes and reconciled them with their results, and when they used a heat-flow model to bring their results together. Since the software stayed the same, the study shows the value of predicting and reconciling, not of the real-time graphs themselves. Beichner (1990) reports Brasell’s finding (1987) that delaying the graph by only 20 seconds reduced the effect of MBL exercises, and the graphs in this lesson are drawn while each change runs. Beichner’s own study of 237 high school and college students is the closest to these simulations: students watched a replayed motion while its graph was drawn, and could replay it, slow it down or stop it, but could not control the motion itself. That gave no substantial advantage over traditional instruction. None of his students produced the motions themselves, and he suggested that students’ own control of the event and its graph might be what makes MBL effective. Pressing Start in a simulation is not that kind of control, so the practicals on screens 1, 3, 4 and 6 matter, and screen 4’s practical can use a real temperature sensor. Brungardt and Zollman (1995), with 31 high school physics students, found no significant difference in learning between graphing a recorded motion at the same time as it played and graphing it afterwards, though their results suggested graphing at the same time may help in some areas. Newton (2000) notes that data logging appeared to be under-used despite research identifying its benefits, and found from interviews that using it in classrooms is not straightforward. Most of these studies were about graphs of motion or heat, not chemical change, so treat them as support for the approach rather than proof that it will work in your class.
Students’ ideas
- The Victorian Department of Education’s Science Continuum page on identifying physical and chemical changes says research shows students often call changes of state chemical changes, taking freezing and boiling to be chemical reactions. Kind’s review of students’ ideas for the Royal Society of Chemistry, Beyond appearances, reports Ahtee and Varjola’s finding (1998) that about a fifth of 13 to 14-year-olds thought dissolving and changes of state were chemical reactions. Screen 1 runs three changes of state beside three chemical changes, and its graph shows the difference: in a change of state the line for each substance stays level. Screen 3 pairs boiling and freezing with chemical changes that give the same signs.
- Kind also describes de Vos and Verdonk’s finding (1987) that most students give a molecule an identity that it keeps through a chemical reaction. Screen 1’s lens shows the molecules coming apart and their atoms joining in new molecules.
- The Continuum page says students commonly believe that physical changes are reversible and chemical changes are not. In Year 6 the curriculum compares reversible and irreversible changes (AC9S6U04). This lesson decides by whether a new substance forms, and screen 3’s tests look for one. The last step of screen 1’s practical asks both questions, which change can be undone and which made a new substance, so the class can compare the two ideas.
- The Continuum page also says students often believe that the substance at the start of a chemical reaction vanishes completely and for ever. Count the atoms on screen 1 counts every atom before and after methane burns, and the key idea says that no atoms are made or lost.
- The page notes that students may take potassium permanganate (Condy’s crystals) dissolving in water to be a chemical change. Screen 3 pairs it with copper wire in silver nitrate, which also colours the solution, and the test is to look for a new solid.
- Sources differ on dissolving. The Continuum page says salt dissolving is usually considered a physical change, but that the particles in salt solution are different from those in solid salt, and that dissolving usually comes with an energy change and is probably better thought of as a chemical process, even though what dissolved can be got back by physical means. Taber, in the Royal Society of Chemistry’s Chemical misconceptions, writes that “The distinction between chemical and physical change is not absolute”, and that breaking up the ionic bonds in a crystal lattice may suggest dissolving could count as a chemical change. The lesson follows the usual school classification and calls dissolving a physical change, in the glossary and on screens 3, 4 and 5, and screen 3’s key idea gives the other view. Screen 4’s third task asks students to find the two mixtures whose temperature changed without a chemical change.
About the models
- The graphs. Every curve is the lesson’s own, drawn smooth to show each change clearly. Where a source gives a starting temperature, or the highest or lowest one, the curve starts there or reaches it, as the screens below say. Real sensor readings are noisy and vary from run to run. A line stays flat when the sources describe no such sign for that change, so the flat lines on screen 2 do not mean that a real sensor would read exactly nothing.
- Screen 1. Carbon is black, hydrogen white and oxygen red, the colours in the site’s lesson Element, compound or mixture?, and the molecules are drawn far bigger than they are and moving far more slowly. The numbers of molecules in each lens are the lesson’s own, but each chemical change keeps the ratio in its balanced equation. OpenStax gives one methane molecule and two oxygen molecules making one carbon dioxide molecule and two water molecules, and two water molecules making one oxygen molecule and two hydrogen molecules, with the energy from a battery or power supply. It says hydrogen peroxide is used as a dilute solution in water and breaks down into water and oxygen, very slowly unless something speeds it up, and that the solution foams as the oxygen comes off. The lens shows the solution’s water from the start, so its blue line rises as more water forms, and oxygen is the only new substance; the lesson balances the change as two water molecules and one oxygen molecule from every two hydrogen peroxide molecules. OpenStax also says dry ice sublimes without forming any liquid, and gives steam condensing inside a cooking pot as a physical change. The Science Learning Hub says complete combustion gives only water and carbon dioxide, with a flame that is typically blue. In a real change there are so many molecules that the graph would rise and fall smoothly; the lesson’s molecules react in three groups, so its lines rise and fall in steps.
- Screen 1 leaves some things out, and the note under the simulation says so. The lens has no nitrogen from the air round the flame, no catalyst in the hydrogen peroxide, and no substance to make the water conduct: the Royal Society of Chemistry’s demonstration of splitting water adds sodium sulfate for that. It also says hydrogen forms at the cathode (the negative electrode) and oxygen at the anode, with twice the volume of hydrogen. The drawing gives the plate joined to the negative terminal about twice as many bubbles, and puts hydrogen on the left, as OpenStax’s figure does, but the lens shows the gases from both plates together. The American Chemical Society’s Cloud bubble activity says the cloudy look over dry ice comes from water vapour condensing, and that water vapour and carbon dioxide are invisible, so the white fog round the dry ice and the cloud above the pot are drops of liquid water.
- Screen 2. OpenStax gives the temperatures for hydrochloric acid and sodium hydroxide (both at 22.0 °C, reaching 28.9 °C) and for sodium chloride and silver nitrate (21.9 °C, rising to 23.5 °C as solid silver chloride forms), and describes the grey silver and blue solution from copper wire in silver nitrate. Taber’s worksheet on precipitation for the Royal Society of Chemistry says the solid from sodium chloride and silver nitrate is white silver chloride. The Royal Society of Chemistry’s Cold reactions resources say that sodium hydrogencarbonate and citric acid react in an endothermic reaction and give off carbon dioxide. The fall from 22.0 °C to 16.0 °C, the 60 cm³ of gas, the cloudiness of 85% and the colour strip are the lesson’s own. The cloudiness sensor is drawn as a lamp shining through the flask onto a light sensor.
- Screen 3. The temperatures for calcium chloride dissolving (22.4 °C to 25.8 °C) and for hydrochloric acid and sodium hydroxide come from OpenStax. The other curves, and the results of the tests, are the lesson’s own simple versions. The Royal Society of Chemistry says limewater turns from colourless to cloudy if carbon dioxide is there, and in the lesson the gas from boiling water is cooled first, which turns it back into water. OpenStax gives silver chloride as insoluble and the blue colour as coming from dissolved copper ions. For Condy’s crystals the evidence is that evaporating the water would give back the same crystals: finding no new solid would not show on its own that no new substance formed. In the temperature pair both dishes are left with white crystals, so they look alike. The words say which is which, from the equation in the Nuffield practical Exothermic or endothermic?, which gives sodium chloride and water as the products of sodium hydroxide and hydrochloric acid.
- Screen 4. OpenStax gives three of the five temperature changes: hydrochloric acid and sodium hydroxide (50.0 mL of each at 1.00 M, from 22.0 °C to 28.9 °C) and ammonium nitrate dissolving (3.21 g in 50.0 g of water, from 24.9 °C to 20.3 °C) in section 5.2, and calcium chloride dissolving (3.0 g in 150.0 g of water, from 22.4 °C to 25.8 °C) in an exercise for that section. The other two are the lesson’s own: sodium hydrogencarbonate and citric acid falling from 22.0 °C to 16.0 °C, and copper(II) sulfate and magnesium rising from 22.0 °C to 42.0 °C. The mixtures are different amounts, so the sizes of their changes can’t be compared fairly, and the note under the simulation says so. The Nuffield practical Displacement reactions between metals and their salts says metals more reactive than copper react exothermically with copper sulfate, that the blue colour fades and that a reddish-brown or orange deposit of copper forms, and the cup is drawn that way; preproom.org’s page on the Nuffield temperature practical says all four of its reactions are exothermic apart from sodium hydrogencarbonate with citric acid. The time each mixture takes to reach its highest or lowest temperature, and the slow drift back towards a room temperature of 22 °C afterwards, are the lesson’s own. OpenStax says general chemistry students often use simple calorimeters made from polystyrene cups, which let more heat pass to and from the surroundings than well-insulated calorimeters do, and so give less accurate values.
- Screen 5. OpenStax describes the instant cold pack (a bag of solid ammonium nitrate and a second bag of water), the hand warmer that gives out heat when it is ripped open, exposing its iron and water to oxygen in the air, with salt to speed the reaction up, and the reusable hand warmer of a supersaturated sodium acetate solution and a metal disc, which can be reheated and used again. It also says baking powder holds sodium bicarbonate and one or more acid salts, which react when they meet the water in a batter. The Royal Society of Chemistry’s Cold reactions resources say that ammonium nitrate is used in commercial cold packs, that sodium hydrogencarbonate and citric acid can’t be used in cold packs because they give off carbon dioxide, that sodium chloride has almost no effect on the temperature, and that plaster of Paris (calcium sulfate) gives out heat and may start to set. NSEAD, the art and design teachers’ society, warns that setting plaster slowly becomes hot, can reach 60 °C and can damage skin at temperatures as low as 45 °C if contact is long, and that hands should never be put into wet plaster. Every temperature, time and volume of gas on screen 5 is the lesson’s own, chosen to show the differences between the contents. The lesson takes the packs to hold more solid for their water than the cups on screen 4, so its packs change temperature much more. OpenStax calls what happens when the sodium acetate warmer’s disc is flexed a precipitation reaction, and the lesson does not call it physical or chemical.
- Screen 6. Agriculture Victoria describes the field soil pH kit: an indicator solution is added to the soil to make a paste, the paste is coated with barium sulfate powder, and the colour of the powder is compared with a chart. It says the method is not as precise as laboratory methods, and that kits should be thrown out after 12 to 18 months. The Queensland Department of Environment, Science and Innovation describes the DPD test, in which the intensity of the pink from DPD reacting with chlorine is measured, in simple kits by comparing it by eye with a calibrated chart. Pathology Tests Explained describes a urine dipstick as a strip with bands of chemicals that change colour if certain substances are present, and Patient.info says the glucose test relies on glucose oxidase making hydrogen peroxide, which causes the colour change. Kits are read at a set time. The Washington State Department of Health says to read a free chlorine test within a minute of adding the indicator, and that if the colour darkens over several minutes the result may not be accurate. The Johns Hopkins Hospital’s instructions for one urine strip give each pad a reading time (30 seconds for glucose) and say that colour changes after it are wrong. The lesson reads each kit at the end of its graph, with the glucose strip at 30 seconds. The other times, the colours of the three charts and the samples’ values are the lesson’s own; real kits come with their own charts and instructions. The glucose strip is tested on water, a glucose solution and a salt solution, not on urine.
Practical work and safety
- Do your school’s own risk assessment for each practical, following your state or territory’s requirements.
- Screen 1’s practical, heating chocolate and egg white, follows the Nuffield practical Heating chocolate and egg: a few grams of chocolate and about 4 cm³ of egg white in test tubes, in a beaker of water that boils gently for about 5 minutes. Its safety notes ask for safety glasses, long hair tied up, no sitting down while heating the beaker or handling hot tubes, and no tasting of food in the laboratory, because the food or the apparatus may be contaminated. Its slides warn that the tripod, gauze and beaker get hot, and its method has students turn off the Bunsen burner before moving the tubes. The steps and care line say all of these, and add CLEAPSS’s hand washing after handling animal and plant material. CLEAPSS also says never to put waste solids in the sink, so the cooked egg and chocolate go in the bin. The risk minimisation table from Allergy & Anaphylaxis Australia and ASCIA asks schools to talk with parents before experiments that use foods, and to have a strategy to reduce the risk of children with an egg allergy coming into contact with raw egg, so check for allergies to egg and to anything in the chocolate first.
- Screen 3’s practical is the Nuffield practical Iron and sulfur reaction, which can be a demonstration or a class experiment in a well-ventilated laboratory. Its safety notes say the sulfur may boil or burn and give off sulfur dioxide, a toxic and corrosive gas that may trigger an asthma attack, that eye protection is worn throughout, and that the reaction must not be done on tin lids in the open laboratory. The lesson makes it a teacher demonstration, and the care line asks students with asthma to tell you. To get the product out, Nuffield has the teacher break the cooled tube open in a pestle and mortar, wearing protective gloves. It says showing that the product is non-magnetic is not always successful and advises a very weak magnet, so warn the class that the test may not work. Follow the Nuffield instructions for the method, the amounts and disposal.
- Screen 4’s practical, Hotter or colder?, follows the Nuffield practical Exothermic or endothermic?: 10 cm³ of each solution in a polystyrene cup, with solutions of about 0.4 M, and sodium hydrogencarbonate solution with four small (not heaped) spatula measures of citric acid. Standing the cup in a beaker keeps it steady. Calcium chloride dissolving comes from the Royal Society of Chemistry’s Cold reactions practical, whose technician notes give 5 g portions; one spatula measure in 10 cm³ of water is the lesson’s own amount, and the practical asks for anhydrous calcium chloride, the CaCl₂ of OpenStax’s figures. The simulation’s figures are OpenStax’s, for 1.00 M solutions and for 3.0 g of calcium chloride in 150.0 g of water, so expect the class’s changes to be different sizes from screen 4’s, and the two warm mixtures may come out in either order.
- Nuffield asks for eye protection throughout and labels sodium hydroxide an irritant, and the Cold reactions technician notes say calcium chloride and citric acid cause serious eye irritation and skin irritation. The care line asks for safety glasses throughout and gives CLEAPSS’s rules on splashes on the skin, spills, breakages and washing hands. The Cold reactions activity measures the temperature over three minutes. Recording it every 30 seconds is the lesson’s own, so that students can draw a graph like the ones on screen 4, and a temperature sensor and data logger can do the recording instead. For disposal, the Cold reactions teacher notes say calcium chloride and sodium chloride solutions go down a foul-water drain after dilution, and the technician notes say to neutralise and dilute the citric acid and sodium hydrogencarbonate solutions, then pour them down a foul-water drain with more water.
- Two of screen 4’s mixtures are in the simulation only. Nuffield says ammonium nitrate, an oxidiser, is for post-16 students or a teacher demonstration only. In South Australia, SafeWork SA says ammonium nitrate blends with more than 45% ammonium nitrate (security sensitive ammonium nitrate) need a licence to store or use, and that licences are granted only for mining and agriculture. Check your own state or territory’s rules. Nuffield calls magnesium powder highly flammable and says the teacher may prefer to dispense it, so the practical leaves out copper(II) sulfate and magnesium.
- Other changes on the screens are in the simulations only, and the notes under them say why. The American Chemical Society says dry ice will harm bare skin, that only the facilitator handles it, and that carbon dioxide can displace oxygen in an enclosed space such as a car. The Royal Society of Chemistry calls the hydrogen from splitting water extremely flammable. CLEAPSS says concentrated hydrogen peroxide (about 8% to 30%) causes serious eye damage. The Royal Society of Chemistry says 0.1 M silver nitrate is an eye irritant.
- Screen 6’s practical uses a garden soil pH test kit like the one Agriculture Victoria describes. The safety data sheet for one such kit, Manutec’s, says both parts of the kit are non-hazardous, that the indicator may irritate the eyes and skin, and that the kit is non-hazardous waste. It suggests gloves while using the kit and safety glasses while dusting the barium sulfate; the care line asks for both throughout. That sheet was valid until 15 August 2026, so check the safety data sheet for the kit you use. The Western Australian Department of Health says packaged potting mixes and other commercial garden soils have been linked with cases of Legionnaires’ disease, and gives precautions: a face mask, gloves, not breathing in dust and washing hands afterwards. The practical uses soil dug from the ground, not potting mix or bagged soil.
Answers at a glance
- Screen 1: ice melting, steam condensing and dry ice turning to gas are physical changes, and methane burning, splitting water and hydrogen peroxide breaking down are chemical changes. Melting leaves the same 12 water molecules, but splitting turns 6 water molecules into 6 hydrogen molecules and 3 oxygen molecules. Hydrogen peroxide breaking down makes oxygen, a new substance, and more water. There are 3 carbon, 12 hydrogen and 12 oxygen atoms before and after methane burns. q-new methane burning; q-flat they stay level.
- Screen 2: sodium hydrogencarbonate and citric acid give off a gas and get colder, sodium chloride and silver nitrate form a white solid and warm a little, copper wire in silver nitrate turns the liquid blue and grows grey silver, and hydrochloric acid and sodium hydroxide warm from 22.0 °C to 28.9 °C with nothing to see. The reaction that gives off a gas is sodium hydrogencarbonate and citric acid, and the one whose only sign shows on a graph is hydrochloric acid and sodium hydroxide. q-signs a solid forms when two clear solutions are mixed; q-cloudy a solid has formed.
- Screen 3: boiling water, freezing water, Condy’s crystals dissolving and calcium chloride dissolving are physical changes, and the four reactions paired with them are chemical changes. Cooled, the gas from boiling water turns back into water and leaves the limewater clear, and carbon dioxide turns it cloudy. Warming melts the ice, but the silver chloride stays solid. Condy’s crystals leave no new solid and would come back if the water evaporated, but grey silver forms on the copper wire. Evaporating leaves the calcium chloride that was added, but after the acid and alkali react it leaves salt, a new substance. q-boil the gas is water vapour, which turns back into water when it cools; q-evidence a new substance with different properties has formed.
- Screen 4: hydrochloric acid and sodium hydroxide (+6.9 °C), copper(II) sulfate and magnesium (+20.0 °C) and calcium chloride dissolving (+3.4 °C) are exothermic, and sodium hydrogencarbonate and citric acid (−6.0 °C) and ammonium nitrate dissolving (−4.6 °C) are endothermic. Ammonium nitrate and calcium chloride change temperature without a chemical change. q-exo energy was given out, so the change is exothermic; q-pack endothermic, and usually classed as physical.
- Screen 5: the cold pack needs ammonium nitrate and water, which works by dissolving, usually classed as a physical change. The hand warmer needs iron, water and salt, opened to the air, and the cake needs baking powder; both are chemical changes. q-why they give off carbon dioxide gas; q-warmer opening the packet, so that oxygen from the air reaches the iron.
- Screen 6: soils A, B and C are pH 5, 7 and 9. Pool C has the most chlorine (3 mg/L, with 1 mg/L in pool B and none in pool A), and only the glucose solution has glucose in it. q-kit the indicator colours it, and its colour depends on the soil’s pH; q-pink the dark pink sample has more chlorine.
- The printable: results vary. Sodium hydroxide and hydrochloric acid, and anhydrous calcium chloride in water, should get warmer, so they are exothermic, and sodium hydrogencarbonate and citric acid should get colder, so it is endothermic. The fizzing is carbon dioxide, which turns limewater cloudy. Calcium chloride’s temperature change does not prove a chemical change, because dissolving is usually classed as physical. After the highest or lowest point the temperature drifts back towards room temperature, as heat passes between the cup and the room.
Saved progress
Answers, notes, results tables and settings are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere. If students share devices, clear the saved answers between them.
Sources by screen
- Screen 1: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e (physical and chemical changes, splitting water, methane burning, dry ice, hydrogen peroxide and catalysts); the Science Learning Hub, What is fire?; the Royal Society of Chemistry, the demonstration of splitting water; the American Chemical Society, Cloud bubble; CLEAPSS, Student safety sheet 57: Hydrogen peroxide; the Victorian Department of Education, Identifying physical and chemical changes.
- Screen 2: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e (calorimetry, precipitation, copper in silver nitrate and combustion); the Royal Society of Chemistry, Cold reactions, Precipitation and The chemistry of silver.
- Screen 3: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e; the Royal Society of Chemistry, Particles in motion? (limewater) and Taber’s Changes in chemistry; the Nuffield practical Exothermic or endothermic?; the Victorian Department of Education, Identifying physical and chemical changes.
- Screen 4: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e (energy basics, calorimetry and its exercises); the Nuffield practicals Exothermic or endothermic? and Displacement reactions between metals and their salts; preproom.org, Exothermic and endothermic reactions; the Royal Society of Chemistry, Cold reactions.
- Screen 5: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e (the cold pack, hand warmers and baking powder); the Royal Society of Chemistry, Cold reactions; NSEAD, Plaster of Paris.
- Screen 6: Agriculture Victoria, Measuring and interpreting soil pH; the Queensland Department of Environment, Science and Innovation, Physical and chemical assessment: test kits for water sampling; Pathology Tests Explained, Urinalysis; Patient.info, Urine dipstick analysis; the Washington State Department of Health, Measuring free chlorine; the Johns Hopkins Hospital, Urine Dipstick: Multistix 10SG; Manutec, Soil pH test kit safety data sheet; the Western Australian Department of Health, Legionella and garden soils.
- The method: Krajcik and Layman (n.d.); Linn and Songer (1991); Beichner (1990), with Brasell (1987); Brungardt and Zollman (1995); Newton (2000).
- Students’ ideas: the Victorian Department of Education, Identifying physical and chemical changes; Kind (2004), Beyond appearances; Taber, Changes in chemistry.
- Safety: the Nuffield practicals Heating chocolate and egg, Iron and sulfur reaction and Exothermic or endothermic?; the Royal Society of Chemistry, Cold reactions; SafeWork SA, Ammonium nitrate licences; Manutec, Soil pH test kit safety data sheet; CLEAPSS, Student safety sheet 101: Laboratory rules; Allergy & Anaphylaxis Australia and ASCIA, Examples of risk minimisation strategies for schools; the sources for screens 1 and 6 above.
- Printable: the same sources as screen 4 and its practical.