Year 8 science · Chemical sciences · AC9S8U06
Element, compound or mixture?
1Look
Element, compound or mixture?
How can you tell an element, a compound and a mixture apart by their particles?
Everything around us is made of atoms, on their own or joined together. An element is made up of only one type of atom. A compound is made of two or more different elements chemically bonded together. A mixture has two or more elements or compounds that are not chemically combined. A molecule is two or more atoms bonded together, so a molecule can be part of an element or of a compound.
How this lesson works. Chemists think about a substance in three ways at once: what you can see, the particles it is made of, and the symbols they write for it. The simulations show what you can see next to the particles. This screen uses a few formulas, such as O₂ and H₂O, and screen 3 explains them. The tasks ask you to link them, for example to say what the particles in a sample are and which name or formula goes with them.
On this screen
- Choose a sample and look at its particles through the lens.
- Sort the eight samples into elements, compounds and mixtures.
- Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
Look closely
Everything around you is made of atoms. Look at eight samples through the lens, and find out what makes a substance an element, a compound or a mixture.
Choose a sample. The picture on the left shows it as you would see it, and the lens shows its particles. Count the types of atom, and look at whether they are joined together. Then press Element, Compound or Mixture.
Eight samples through the lens
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Use your results
Do these three tasks with the simulation, the table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Sort all eight samples into elements, compounds and mixtures.
Need a hint?
Choose a sample and look at the lens. Count the types of atom, and check whether they are joined together. Then press Element, Compound or Mixture.
Decide whether oxygen gas, with two atoms joined in each molecule, is an element or a compound.
Need a hint?
Look at oxygen gas through the lens, then answer the first question under the table.
Explain why air is a mixture, though it has oxygen molecules in it.
Need a hint?
Look at air through the lens, then answer the second question under the table.
Talk about it. Oxygen and water are both made of molecules. Why is oxygen an element and water a compound?
Elements, compounds and mixtures
Copper, oxygen and argon are elements. Each one has only one type of atom. An element’s atoms can be on their own, like argon’s, joined in molecules, like oxygen’s, or packed together, like copper’s.
Water, carbon dioxide and salt are compounds. Each has two or more types of atom, chemically bonded together. Every water molecule has two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom.
Air and the 20 cent coin are mixtures. Air is mostly nitrogen and oxygen molecules, with argon atoms and a little carbon dioxide, mixed but not joined to each other. In the coin, copper and nickel atoms are mixed at random, not joined in a fixed ratio. Each substance in a mixture keeps its own chemical properties.
A molecule is not always a compound. An oxygen molecule, O₂, has two atoms joined together, but both are oxygen, so oxygen is an element.
Practical
Element, compound or mixture?
Do this in the laboratory, when your teacher says.
You need
- Samples your teacher sets out in labelled containers: copper wire, water, table salt, an Australian 20 cent coin and a sealed jar of air
- A magnifying glass
What to do
- Look at each sample closely with the magnifying glass, and write down what you see.
- Find the same sample in the simulation, and draw its particles next to your notes.
- Write element, compound or mixture next to each sample, and give your reason.
Take care. Do not taste or eat any of the samples. Hold the copper wire by its middle, because its cut ends can be sharp. Never look at the Sun through the magnifying glass. Wash your hands after handling the samples. Never eat or drink anything in the laboratory.
My notebook
Which of these is a compound?
Copper and nickel atoms are mixed together in a 20 cent coin. What is the coin made of?
2Model
Build it in 3D
How do models show the difference between an element and a compound?
Atoms are far too small to see, so chemists use models of them. In a model kit, hydrogen atoms have one hole, oxygen atoms two, nitrogen atoms three and carbon atoms four. These are the numbers of bonds each type of atom usually forms, so the kit builds molecules with the right numbers of atoms.
On this screen
- Add atoms from the kit to build a molecule.
- Turn the model to see its shape from every side.
- Build an element, then a compound.
- Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
Model
Atoms are far too small to see, so chemists build models of them. Use the model kit to build molecules of elements and compounds, and turn them to see their shapes.
Press an atom to add it to the model. Each new atom joins on where there is a free hole. When every hole is filled, the molecule is finished, and you see its name and formula. Drag the model, or press Turn, to see it from another side. Press Start again to clear it.
A molecular model kit
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Use your results
Do these three tasks with the simulation and the table under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Build a molecule of an element.
Need a hint?
Use atoms of only one type. Two hydrogen atoms make a molecule of hydrogen.
Build a molecule of a compound.
Need a hint?
Use two types of atom. One oxygen atom and two hydrogen atoms make a molecule of water.
Build two different compounds from the same two elements.
Need a hint?
Build water from one oxygen and two hydrogen atoms. Then press Start again and build hydrogen peroxide: add the atoms in the order oxygen, hydrogen, oxygen, hydrogen.
Talk about it. What does a model show well, and what does it leave out?
Models of elements and compounds
A molecule of an element has only one type of atom. Hydrogen, H₂, oxygen, O₂, and nitrogen, N₂, are each made of molecules of two atoms of the same type.
A molecule of a compound has two or more types of atom joined together, like water, H₂O, carbon dioxide, CO₂, methane, CH₄, and ammonia, NH₃.
Water, H₂O, and hydrogen peroxide, H₂O₂, are made of the same two elements in a different ratio, so they are different compounds.
A model is not a copy of the real thing. Real atoms have no colours and are not joined by sticks. The balls, colours and sticks show which atoms are joined, and the shape of the molecule.
Practical
Build them for real
Do this in the laboratory, when your teacher says.
You need
- A molecular model kit, or plasticine in four colours and toothpicks
- Paper and a pencil
What to do
- Choose a colour for each type of atom, and write a key.
- Build a molecule of hydrogen, H₂, and a molecule of oxygen, O₂.
- Build water, H₂O, carbon dioxide, CO₂, and methane, CH₄.
- For each model, count the atoms of each type and write its formula. Write element or compound next to each one.
Take care. Toothpicks are sharp, so hold them by the middle and keep them away from faces. Do not use sweets as atoms in the laboratory. Never eat or drink anything in the laboratory.
My notebook
You build two oxygen atoms joined together. What have you made?
In the kit, oxygen has two holes and hydrogen has one. Why does a water molecule have two hydrogen atoms?
3Symbols
Symbols and formulas
Why do elements have symbols, compounds have formulas, and mixtures have percentages?
A chemical symbol is one or two letters for an element, and its first letter is always a capital: O for oxygen and Cu for copper. A chemical formula shows the symbols of the elements in a substance, with a small number called a subscript for how many atoms of each type there are. H₂O means two hydrogen atoms and one oxygen atom. A subscript is used only when there is more than one atom of that type.
On this screen
- Write the formula for each model.
- Compare water with hydrogen and oxygen mixed.
- Mix copper and nickel atoms to make a coin.
- Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
Symbols
Chemists write substances in symbols, so that anyone, in any country, can read what they are made of. Find out how symbols, formulas and percentages each do their job.
Choose what to do. In Write the formula, count the atoms in the model, set a slider for each element, and press Check. In Fixed ratio, change the amount of water, and the amounts in a mixture of hydrogen and oxygen, and compare the ratios. In Mixture, slide the amount of nickel and watch the coin’s atoms change.
Formulas, ratios and percentages
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Use your results
Do these three tasks with the simulation. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Write the formulas of all four models.
Need a hint?
In Write the formula, count each type of atom in the model, and set the slider for each element. Then press Check.
Find out which keeps a fixed ratio: water, or hydrogen and oxygen mixed.
Need a hint?
In Fixed ratio, move both sliders, and watch the ratio of hydrogen atoms to oxygen atoms under each picture.
Make the mixture of copper and nickel in an Australian 20 cent coin.
Need a hint?
In Mixture, move the slider until the coin is 75% copper and 25% nickel.
Talk about it. Why do you think chemists everywhere use the same symbols, whatever language they speak?
Symbols, formulas and percentages
Symbols give each element a short code that chemists everywhere can read, a common language for what things are made of. In articles published in 1813 and 1814, the Swedish scientist Jöns Jacob Berzelius proposed letters in place of drawn symbols, because letters are easier to write and do not spoil the look of a printed book. His letters came from the Latin names of the elements, which is why copper is Cu, from cuprum, and tin is Sn, from stannum.
A compound always has the same elements in the same ratio, so it can have a formula. However much water there is, it has two hydrogen atoms for every oxygen atom: H₂O.
The amounts in a mixture can vary, so it has no formula. Its make-up is given as percentages instead. Dry air is about 78% nitrogen, 21% oxygen and 1% argon. An Australian 20 cent coin is 75% copper and 25% nickel, and a $1 coin is 92% copper, 6% aluminium and 2% nickel.
Subscripts are written small and low, as in CO₂. A raised number means something else in maths, so CO² is wrong.
My notebook
What does the formula NH₃ tell you?
Why is a 20 cent coin described as 75% copper and 25% nickel, not with a formula?
4Find out
Solutions, colloids and suspensions
How can a torch and a wait tell three kinds of mixture apart?
Mixtures come in different kinds. In a solution, such as salt water, the dissolved particles are too small to see: it is see-through, though it can be coloured, and nothing settles out. In a suspension, such as muddy water, the particles are much larger: it is cloudy, and they settle out. A colloid, such as milk, has particles larger than most simple molecules but small enough not to settle out, and they scatter light. This is the Tyndall effect.
On this screen
- Choose a mixture and look at its particles through the lens.
- Shine the torch through it.
- Leave it to stand.
- Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
Find out
Some mixtures look clear and some look cloudy. Use a torch and a wait to sort three mixtures into a solution, a colloid and a suspension.
Choose a mixture. Press Shine the torch to send a beam of light through the side of the beaker, and look for its path inside. Press Leave it to stand to see what happens over time, and Stir it to mix it again. The lens shows the particles, drawn much bigger than they are.
Three mixtures, a torch and time
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Use your results
Do these three tasks with the simulation and the table under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Shine the torch through all three mixtures.
Need a hint?
Press Shine the torch, then choose each mixture in turn. The torch stays on.
Leave all three mixtures to stand, and find out which one settles.
Need a hint?
Choose each mixture in turn and press Leave it to stand.
Sort the three mixtures into a solution, a colloid and a suspension.
Need a hint?
Test each mixture with the torch and by leaving it to stand first. Then press Solution, Colloid or Suspension.
Talk about it. Why do you think the torch beam shows up in some mixtures and not in others?
Three kinds of mixture
Salt water is a solution. Its dissolved particles are too small to see, and they are spread among the water molecules. The torch beam passes straight through, its path inside can’t be seen, and nothing settles out.
Milky water is a colloid. Its milk particles are larger than water molecules, but small enough that they do not settle out. They scatter the torch light, so the beam shows up inside it. This is the Tyndall effect.
Muddy water is a suspension. Its particles are much larger again. It is cloudy, and the particles settle to the bottom when it stands.
Solutions, colloids and suspensions are all mixtures. Elements and compounds are pure substances.
Practical
The torch test
Do this in the laboratory, when your teacher says.
You need
- Two clear straight-sided glasses or jars, or 250 cm³ beakers
- Water
- Milk, and an eye dropper or plastic pipette
- A small torch
What to do
- Fill both glasses with water.
- Add drops of milk to one glass until it looks cloudy, about 10 drops.
- With the glasses side by side, shine the torch through both of them, and look at the path of the beam in each.
- Leave both glasses to stand for 10 minutes, and look again.
Take care. Do not shine the torch into anyone’s eyes, and use a torch, not a laser pointer. Tell your teacher about any breakage, and wipe up spills. Wash your hands afterwards. Never eat or drink anything in the laboratory.
My notebook
You shine a torch through a cloudy mixture. The beam shows up inside it, and nothing settles out, even after a week. What kind of mixture is it?
Which of these settles out when it is left to stand?
5Compare
Six ways to show a molecule
What does each representation show, and when is each one useful?
The same substance can be shown in different ways. Its name and its formula say what it is. A structural formula also shows how the atoms are connected. A particle diagram draws the atoms flat on the page. A ball-and-stick model shows how the atoms are arranged in 3D, with sizes not to scale, and a space-filling model shows the relative sizes of the atoms.
On this screen
- Choose a substance.
- Look at all six representations, and turn the 3D models.
- Find out what each one shows.
- Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
Compare
Chemists show the same molecule in different ways, and each way shows some things and leaves others out. Compare six representations of the same substance.
Choose a substance, then choose a representation to see it large. The small pictures show all six at once. Drag a 3D model, or press Turn, to look at it from another side. The table under the simulation fills in as you go.
One molecule, six representations
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Use your results
Do these three tasks with the simulation, the table and the questions under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Look at all six representations of one substance.
Need a hint?
Choose a substance, then choose each of the six representations in turn.
Turn both 3D models of methane, and compare them with its structural formula.
Need a hint?
Choose Methane. Choose Ball-and-stick model and press Turn, then Space-filling model and press Turn. Then choose Structural formula.
Decide which representation shows the relative sizes of the atoms.
Need a hint?
Answer the question under the table.
Talk about it. If you could use only one representation of water, which would you choose, and what would you lose?
Choosing a representation
A name and a formula are the quickest to write. A formula is a short form of a substance’s name that shows the types and numbers of atoms, and chemists in every country write it the same way.
A structural formula shows which atoms are joined, but it is drawn flat. Methane’s structural formula has its bonds at right angles, but in a 3D model its four hydrogen atoms point to the corners of a tetrahedron, with angles of 109.5°.
A ball-and-stick model shows the shape and the angles between the bonds, with the atoms drawn smaller than they are. A space-filling model shows the relative sizes of the atoms, but its shape is harder to see. Each representation leaves something out, so chemists choose the one that shows what they need.
My notebook
Which representations show the 3D shape of a molecule?
You want to show how big an oxygen atom is compared with a hydrogen atom. Which representation would you use?
6History
Mendeleev’s periodic table
How did Mendeleev arrange the elements, and how is his table different from today’s?
In 1869 Dmitri Mendeleev wrote the properties of the elements on cards and put the cards in order of increasing atomic weight. Certain types of element came up again and again, so he lined up the elements of each type together. Where an element seemed to be missing, he left a gap. In 1869 he predicted that elements like aluminium and silicon would be found, and in 1871 he predicted the properties of some of the missing elements in detail. His table grew into today’s periodic table, which is in order of atomic number.
On this screen
- Place the cards in order of atomic weight.
- Decide where each tricky card goes.
- Predict the missing element below silicon.
- Compare Mendeleev’s arrangement with today’s table.
- Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
History
In 1869 Dmitri Mendeleev put the elements in order and found a pattern that let him predict elements nobody had found. Build part of a table his way, card by card.
Press Next card to place the next element, in order of atomic weight. Some cards ask you to choose where they go. When the table is built, predict the missing element, then press Today’s table to see how the arrangement has changed. The cards show today’s atomic weights, rounded.
Building part of a table, Mendeleev’s way
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Use your results
Do these three tasks with the simulation and the cards in it. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Place every card, and decide where the tricky ones go.
Need a hint?
Press Next card, or Place cards to the next choice. When a card asks where it goes, look at the column it would join.
Predict the atomic weight of the missing element below silicon, and compare it with germanium.
Need a hint?
Place all the cards first. Then choose your prediction under Predict.
Compare Mendeleev’s arrangement with today’s table.
Need a hint?
Press Today’s table, and look at where tellurium and iodine are, and at the new column.
Talk about it. Mendeleev predicted elements that nobody had found. Why was that a strong test of his table?
Mendeleev’s table and today’s
Mendeleev put the elements in order of atomic weight, and started a new row where their properties began to repeat, so that elements with similar properties lined up together. The simulation draws each family as a column, as his 1871 table did. In his 1869 table the families ran across the page.
He left gaps for elements nobody had discovered, and in 1871 he predicted the properties of some of them. For the gap below silicon he predicted an atomic weight of 72 and a density of about 5.5 g/cm³. Germanium, discovered in 1886, has an atomic weight of 72.63 and a density of 5.32 g/cm³.
By atomic weight, iodine comes before tellurium. Mendeleev swapped them, because iodine is very similar to the other halogens. He also thought tellurium’s atomic weight had been measured wrongly, and in 1869 he wrote that it should be 123 to 126, not 128. Today it is 127.6.
Today’s table is in order of atomic number, and in that order tellurium does come before iodine. It also has a column Mendeleev did not have at first: the noble gases, discovered in the 1890s, which fitted in as a new group.
My notebook
Why did Mendeleev leave gaps in his table?
What order are the elements in on today’s periodic table?
7History
From Democritus to Dalton
How has the idea of an element changed over time?
People have argued about what everything is made of for thousands of years, and the idea of an element changed as they did. This timeline has five stops, from Democritus in ancient Greece to John Dalton in 1808.
On this screen
- Visit each stop on the timeline.
- At Democritus and Aristotle, cut a lump in half again and again.
- Sort ten of Lavoisier’s simple substances.
- Build water with Dalton’s symbols.
- Do the three tasks, and read the key idea.
- Answer the last two questions and look at your results.
History
The idea of an element changed over more than two thousand years. Travel along the timeline from Democritus to John Dalton.
Press a stop on the timeline, or Next stop. Each stop shows one idea as a model, and some stops have something to try.
A timeline of the idea of an element
SimulationThe simulation loads here.
Use your results
Do these three tasks with the simulation, its timeline and the table under it. If you get stuck, open a hint.
Visit all five stops on the timeline.
Need a hint?
Press each stop, or Next stop.
Sort ten of Lavoisier’s simple substances into elements today and not elements today.
Need a hint?
Go to the Lavoisier stop. Choose each substance, then press Element today or Not an element today.
Build water with Dalton’s symbols, and compare it with today’s formula.
Need a hint?
Go to the Dalton stop and press Join Dalton’s symbols, then Show today’s water.
Talk about it. Which idea on the timeline is closest to today’s, and which is furthest away?
How the idea changed
In the fifth century BC, Leucippus and Democritus argued that matter is made of tiny particles called atomos, from the Greek for indivisible. Later, Aristotle and others decided that matter is made of four elements, fire, earth, air and water, and could be divided for ever.
In 1661 Robert Boyle described elements as simple bodies, not made of any other bodies, that mixed bodies are made from and can be broken down into. He was probably thinking of tiny particles, not the substances later chemists called elements. He supported corpuscularism, an idea about particles and their motion that was slowly taking the place of older ideas, such as the four elements.
In 1789 Antoine Lavoisier listed 33 simple substances, things the experiments of his time could not break down. His list included light and heat, which are not matter, and earths that are now known to be compounds.
Dalton’s theory, first published in 1807 and set out in his New System of Chemical Philosophy from 1808, said that each element has only one type of atom, with a mass of its own, and that in a compound the atoms of two or more elements are joined in a small, whole-number ratio. He drew a symbol for each atom, but he thought water was HO. Today’s formula is H₂O.
My notebook
What did Democritus’s word atomos mean?
What did Dalton say about the atoms of one element?
Elements, compounds and mixtures: particle drawings and the torch test
Two pages. Page 1 has boxes to draw the particles of elements, compounds and mixtures. Page 2 is a record sheet for the torch test on water and milky water.
For teachers
Curriculum
Australian Curriculum: Science, Version 9, Year 8, Science understanding, Chemical sciences. The lesson teaches this content description:
AC9S8U06 classify matter as elements, compounds or mixtures and compare different representations of these, including 2-dimensional and 3-dimensional models, symbols for elements and formulas for molecules and compounds
- using virtual and physical models to distinguish between elements and compounds in terms of types of atoms
- examining how Dmitri Mendeleev arranged the elements in the first version of the periodic table and comparing his arrangement with the current version
- explaining why elements are represented by symbols, compounds and molecules by formulas and mixtures by percentages
- using representations to show the classification of matter as elements, compounds and different types of mixtures such as solutions, suspensions and colloids
- examining the information conveyed by different types of representations of elements and compounds and identifying where and why these different representations are used
- creating a timeline or models to show how the concept of an element has changed over time from Democritus to John Dalton
The second quote gives ACARA’s six elaborations for it, which are examples, not requirements. Each one has a screen of its own, and two of them are met only in part:
- Virtual and physical models to tell elements and compounds apart by their types of atom: screen 2’s 3D model kit, with a real model kit or plasticine and toothpicks in its practical, and the particle lens on screen 1; q-element, q-o2 and q-holes.
- Mendeleev’s first periodic table compared with today’s: met in part. Screen 6 builds part of a table from the families in his first table of 1869, drawn as columns as in his table of 1871 and with today’s atomic weights, and then moves the same cards into today’s order; q-gaps and q-order. Students do not see the 1869 layout itself, and About the models says what else is left out.
- Why elements have symbols, compounds and molecules have formulas, and mixtures have percentages: screen 3; q-sub and q-percent.
- Representations of the classification of matter, including solutions, suspensions and colloids: screen 1 sorts eight samples into elements, compounds and mixtures, and screen 4 tests three mixtures with a torch and by leaving them to stand, then draws the whole classification as a tree; q-mixture, q-tyndall and q-settle.
- What different representations show, and where and why each is used: screen 5 shows five substances in six ways; q-3d and q-sizes.
- A timeline or models of the idea of an element from Democritus to John Dalton: met in part. Screen 7 gives students a timeline with a model at each of its five stops to explore, and its notebook prompt asks them to explain a change between two stops, but they do not make a timeline of their own; q-atomos and q-dalton.
The lesson also works on parts of these content descriptions. Students sort their results into tables and a classification tree and use models to show what they find, a step towards AC9S8I04, though the representations are chosen for them. On screens 6 and 7 they see scientific knowledge change: the periodic table took a new column when the noble gases were found, and Lavoisier expected his earths to stop being counted as simple substances, as they did once they turned out to be compounds (AC9S8H01).
AC9S8I04 select and construct appropriate representations, including tables, graphs, models and mathematical relationships, to organise and process data and information
AC9S8H01 explain how new evidence or different perspectives can lead to changes in scientific knowledge
The lesson builds on two Year 7 lessons, on the particle model (AC9S7U05, the site’s lesson How does particle theory explain the properties of substances?) and on pure substances and mixtures (AC9S7U06, the site’s lesson How can we get pure water and salt from muddy seawater?). It does not teach chemical reactions, which come with AC9S8U07, or how atoms are rearranged in them, which is AC9S9U07. Protons appear only in the word list, to explain atomic number.
How the lesson is taught
The method is linking the three levels of chemistry. Johnstone (2000) described chemistry as working on three levels at once: what can be seen and handled, the atoms and molecules, and the symbols and mathematics used to represent them. He argued that a trained chemist can keep the three in balance but a learner cannot, and he traced many misconceptions to teaching all three together: “It is psychological folly to introduce learners to ideas at all three levels simultaneously.” He also put element and compound among the concepts that can’t be formed directly from examples, as the idea of a metal can.
The lesson brings the levels in by steps and keeps linking them. Screen 1 shows each sample as it looks next to its particles in a lens, with names and a few formulas, which screen 3 explains. Screen 2 puts formulas on 3D models, screen 3 teaches symbols and formulas, screen 4 goes back to what can be seen, with the lens beside it, and screen 5 sets six representations side by side. Screens 6 and 7 follow the history of the ideas. The tasks and the questions under each simulation ask students to match one level to another: which particles belong to a sample, which formula belongs to a model, and what a picture shows and leaves out. Before the class opens the lens on screen 1, ask what they expect copper, water and air to look like inside. You can teach one or two screens in a session.
The research. Ardac and Akaygun (2004) taught chemical change to 49 eighth graders: 16 had a multimedia unit that showed molecular pictures together with what they observed and the symbols, and 33 had their regular teaching. The multimedia group scored higher, and found it easier to represent matter at the molecular level. The abstract does not say that this advantage lasted: from the long-term results the authors suggest adding prompts that make students attend to how different representations of the same thing match up, and the tasks on each screen are prompts of that kind. In their second study (2005), 52 eighth graders aged 14 to 15 learnt chemical change with moving pictures used on their own, moving pictures shown to the whole class, or still pictures shown to the whole class. Students with moving pictures did significantly better than those with still ones, and those who used the moving pictures on their own were more consistent in using molecular representations. The authors also suggest that teachers question contradictions between what students say and the molecular pictures that go with it, and the Talk about it prompts are a place to do that. The simulations here move, and students can use them on their own or in pairs. Both studies were about chemical change, not classifying matter, the groups were small, and in 2004 they were very different in size, so treat the studies as support for the approach rather than proof that it will work in your class.
Students’ ideas
- The Royal Society of Chemistry’s page on students’ ideas about elements, compounds and mixtures describes a study by Briggs and Holding (1986). They gave 15-year-olds coloured-dot diagrams of an element, a compound and a mixture of two elements, and about 30% chose all three correctly. About half took any diagram with different atoms in it for a mixture. Screen 1 puts water, with different atoms joined in every molecule, beside air, with different molecules moving separately, and the hints after a wrong sort ask students to look at the joins. The same page reports that students do not readily move between the particles and what they can see without strong cues, and the lesson’s tasks are meant to give those cues.
- The same page describes Ben-Zvi and colleagues’ finding (1986) that nearly half of the 15-year-olds they studied gave single atoms of copper the bulk physical properties of copper. The note under screen 1’s simulation says real atoms have no colour, and the lens draws copper atoms teal, not copper-coloured, so that the colour of the wire is not taken for the colour of its atoms.
- Oak National Academy’s Key Stage 4 lesson on atoms, elements and compounds warns that students often take a diatomic element such as hydrogen for a compound, because they see two atoms joined, and it tells teachers to stress the definition of a compound: “Molecules are not the same as compounds”. Screen 1’s second task asks about oxygen gas, q-o2 on screen 2 asks the same thing about a model, and the kit builds H₂, O₂ and N₂ as well as compounds.
- The Royal Society of Chemistry’s worksheets on elements, compounds and mixtures, from Chemical misconceptions, note that some students in the pilot objected to single atoms being called molecules, so the lesson calls argon’s particles atoms on their own. They also note that some students saw bonds as solid things and expected them to be drawn as solid lines, and screen 2’s key idea says that real atoms are not joined by sticks.
- The Royal Society of Chemistry’s article on crafting molecular models names a common misconception, that a scientific model is a replica of the real thing, and says few students understand why scientists use more than one model. Screen 2’s key idea says a model is not a copy, and screen 5 asks what each of six representations shows and what it leaves out.
- Oak’s Year 8 lesson on chemical formulae lists writing subscripts as superscripts, and explains that a raised number in maths squares a value. Screen 3’s key idea says CO² is wrong, and every formula in the lesson has its numbers written low.
- Oak’s Year 8 lesson on compounds and their formation lists the idea that a compound has the same properties as the elements it is made from. This lesson does not compare properties. Oak suggests sodium chloride as an example: sodium metal and chlorine gas are both dangerous, but salt is added to food. Salt is one of the compounds on screen 1, and you could raise the point there.
About the models
- The particles. Each type of atom has its own colour. Carbon is black, hydrogen white and oxygen red, as in OpenStax’s ball-and-stick models, and nitrogen is blue, as in Northern Arizona University’s model kit lesson. The colours of copper, nickel, aluminium, argon, sodium and chlorine are the lesson’s own, and copper is teal, not copper-coloured (see Students’ ideas). Atoms are drawn far bigger than they are, and they move far more slowly than real particles do. In every lens except those of the liquids on screens 1 and 4, all the particles are drawn inside the circle, so that they can be counted.
- Screen 1. Argon is drawn as single atoms, as Chemguide says the noble gases are, oxygen as pairs of joined atoms, as OpenStax says, and copper as atoms packed closely, as Chemguide says most metals are. NOAA gives dry air as 78.084% nitrogen, 20.946% oxygen, 0.934% argon and 0.042% carbon dioxide. The lens shows more argon than that, so that it can be seen, and leaves out carbon dioxide and water vapour. Salt is drawn as a square pattern of two types of particle, one sodium to each chlorine, as the University of Sydney’s School of Chemistry gives it. The particles in real salt are ions, which the lesson does not teach. The 20 cent coin is drawn as copper and nickel atoms packed in a regular pattern and mixed at random. The Royal Australian Mint gives the coin as 75% copper and 25% nickel, but does not say whether these are percentages by mass or by number of atoms. NIST gives the same alloy, used for United States coins, as 0.75 copper and 0.25 nickel by mass, so the lesson takes all the Mint’s percentages to be by mass, and draws the matching numbers of atoms, worked out with CIAAW’s atomic weights: about 74 copper atoms to every 26 nickel atoms. Chemguide says metals are giant structures of atoms held together by metallic bonds, so the coin’s atoms are drawn packed together like copper’s. Oak defines an alloy as a mixture of two or more elements, at least one of them a metal, and the lesson gives the coin’s reason as its copper and nickel atoms being mixed, not joined in a fixed ratio.
- Screen 2. The kit follows Northern Arizona University’s lesson: hydrogen has one hole, oxygen two, nitrogen three and carbon four, and every hole must be filled, so O₂ has two sticks between its atoms and N₂ has three. Water, ammonia and methane have the bond angles in Gonzaga University’s notes on molecular structure (104.5°, 107.3° and 109.5°), and carbon dioxide is straight. Hydrogen peroxide is drawn roughly. A finished molecule takes no more atoms, so two oxygen atoms in a row make O₂. To build hydrogen peroxide, students add oxygen, hydrogen, oxygen and hydrogen in that order, as the task’s hint says.
- Screen 3. Both lenses in Fixed ratio are the lesson’s own. Changing the amount of water never changes its ratio of two hydrogen atoms to one oxygen atom, and the ratio in the mixture of hydrogen and oxygen follows the slider, which runs from 10% to 90% oxygen so that the right-hand lens always holds a mixture. The coin is a grid of atoms that changes with the nickel slider, from 5% to 95% of the mass in steps of 5%. The $1 coin’s 92% copper, 6% aluminium and 2% nickel are from the Royal Australian Mint. Taken by mass, they are about 85% copper, 13% aluminium and 2% nickel by number of atoms, because aluminium atoms are much lighter than copper atoms (CIAAW gives copper 63.546, aluminium 26.982 and nickel 58.693), and the lens draws them that way. With so few atoms the grid can show the shares only roughly, and the words under the simulation give the counts. The $1 coin is drawn gold-coloured and the 20 cent coin silver-coloured.
- Screen 4. A solution is clear and nothing settles out of it, the particles in a colloid scatter light and do not settle, and a suspension is cloudy and settles, all as OpenStax describes them. OpenStax lists milk as a colloid, an emulsion. The Royal Society of Chemistry’s torch practical says the milk particles are suspended in the water; the lesson follows OpenStax and calls milky water a colloid. In salt water the beam is drawn passing through unseen to a spot on a card behind the beaker. The Royal Society of Chemistry’s practical says the beam can’t be seen in plain water, and the lesson takes salt water to behave the same way. In muddy water the beam is drawn fading as it goes in, and the mud takes six seconds to settle. Both are the lesson’s own, and the milk particles and grains of mud are drawn far smaller than they would be next to the water molecules. In salt water the purple and green particles stand for sodium ions and chloride ions spread among the water molecules, as the University of Sydney’s page describes seawater; they are not sodium metal or chlorine gas, and the lesson does not teach ions. OpenStax calls air a gaseous solution and many alloys solid solutions, so the tree’s three kinds of mixture are examples, not a complete list.
- Screen 5. OpenStax shows methane as a molecular formula, a structural formula, a ball-and-stick model and a space-filling model, and the lesson adds the name and a flat particle diagram. A ball-and-stick model shows how the atoms are arranged, with their sizes not to scale, and a space-filling model shows their relative sizes, as OpenStax says. The shapes are from Gonzaga University’s notes: methane is tetrahedral, ammonia a trigonal pyramid, water bent and carbon dioxide linear. The structural formulas are drawn flat, with methane’s bonds at right angles. Molecules of two or three atoms, such as water, carbon dioxide and oxygen, lie flat, so their flat drawings show their shapes, and the words say so; methane and ammonia do not. The sizes of the atoms in the space-filling model are only roughly in proportion, and the table under the simulation is the lesson’s own.
- Screen 6. Mendeleev wrote the properties of the elements on cards, put them in order of increasing atomic weight and left gaps, as the Royal Society of Chemistry’s page on the development of the periodic table describes. The cards come from six families in his 1869 table, in Carmen Giunta’s translation at Le Moyne College: beryllium to cadmium, boron to the gap below aluminium, carbon to tin, nitrogen to antimony, oxygen to tellurium, and fluorine to iodine, which the 1869 table writes as J. The cards show today’s atomic weights from CIAAW, rounded to one decimal place, not Mendeleev’s own; his table gives tellurium as 128, with a question mark, and point 7 of the paper says tellurium’s atomic weight should be 123 to 126, not 128. They leave out the family of lithium and sodium, and the elements between chlorine and zinc and between bromine and cadmium. Indium is placed under the gap below aluminium. In the 1869 table that place holds uranium (Ur=116), and indium is listed elsewhere with a weight of 75.6 and a question mark; the Royal Society of Chemistry’s article on Mendeleev’s periodic tables says he corrected the atomic weights of indium and uranium for his table of 1871. The families are drawn as columns headed groups II to VII, as in the 1871 table, where the same article gives beryllium, magnesium, zinc and cadmium in Group II. In 1869 the families ran across the page. For the gap below silicon the 1869 table has ?=70, and point 6 of the 1869 paper predicts analogues of aluminium and silicon with atomic weights of 65 to 75. In 1871 Mendeleev predicted an atomic weight of 72 and a specific gravity of 5.5 for eka-silicon, in his paper of that year in Farber’s translation at Le Moyne College; the Royal Society of Chemistry’s page on germanium gives the prediction as about 71, with a density of about 5.5 g/cm³. The Royal Society of Chemistry says he predicted the properties of five of the missing elements, and Britannica that his 1871 table predicted three, scandium, gallium and germanium. Today’s table puts the same cards in order of CIAAW’s atomic numbers, in the groups of the Royal Society of Chemistry’s periodic table, and adds helium, neon, argon, krypton and xenon as the final column.
- Screen 7. Each stop is the lesson’s own model of one idea. Democritus’s atoms are simple shapes of different sizes that move about, from OpenStax’s description. The last piece is drawn after four cuts, with a lens on its atoms; the number of cuts is the lesson’s own, and the note under the simulation says a real lump would take far more. Aristotle’s four elements are words around a diamond. Boyle’s mixed body coming apart into simple bodies is drawn from his definition as the Science History Institute quotes it. The four elements are crossed out because in The Sceptical Chymist Boyle’s speaker Carneades objects to them, in the annotated excerpt at Le Moyne College, whose notes describe Carneades as agnostic about whether any elements exist. The Science History Institute says corpuscularism was slowly displacing the older views of Aristotle and Paracelsus. The ten substances at Lavoisier’s stop come from his Table of simple substances, in Robert Kerr’s translation at Le Moyne College, which lists 33. Frostburg State University’s page says light and heat are not considered matter at all, and gives magnesia as magnesium oxide and silica, which Lavoisier’s table calls silex, as silicon dioxide. Dalton’s symbols follow the Linda Hall Library’s description: oxygen a white circle, carbon a black circle, and hydrogen a white circle with a dot in the centre.
Practical work and safety
- Do your school’s own risk assessment for each practical, following your state or territory’s requirements.
- Every practical says never to eat or drink anything in the laboratory, as in the Royal Society of Chemistry’s Nuffield practical on tap water and seawater. Screen 1’s practical has students look at samples you set out in labelled containers, with the air in a sealed jar. Its care line adds that none of them is to be tasted, the salt included, and that students wash their hands after handling the samples, as CLEAPSS’s laboratory rules ask after handling chemicals. Holding the copper wire by its middle, because cut ends can be sharp, and never looking at the Sun through the magnifying glass are the lesson’s own care lines.
- Screen 2’s practical uses a model kit, or plasticine and toothpicks. The Royal Society of Chemistry’s article on crafting molecular models suggests home-made materials, sweets among them, and names hygiene issues with sweets in labs and safety issues with sharp pipe cleaners. The care line asks for no sweets in the laboratory. It also treats toothpicks as sharp: the article names pipe cleaners, and toothpicks are the lesson’s own addition. ASCIA’s risk minimisation table for schools asks for care with play dough, including a check that it was not made with nut oils, and for options to be discussed with the parents of children allergic to wheat, so check what the plasticine is made of.
- Screen 4’s torch test follows the Royal Society of Chemistry’s practical Tyndall effect: why the sky is blue, with two glasses of water (or jars, or 250 cm³ beakers), about 10 drops of milk in one, and a small torch. Its safety notes say not to shine bright lights into anyone’s eyes and not to use laser pointers for experiments, and the care line says both. Leaving the glasses to stand for 10 minutes is the lesson’s own step, so that students can compare the result with the simulation; OpenStax says the particles in a colloid do not settle out on standing. ASCIA’s table asks schools to talk with parents before experiments that use foods, so check for students with a milk allergy first. The care line adds CLEAPSS’s rules on reporting breakages and wiping up spills, and washing hands, since milk is animal material.
Answers at a glance
- Screen 1: copper, oxygen and argon are elements, water, carbon dioxide and salt are compounds, and air and the 20 cent coin are mixtures. Oxygen gas is an element because both atoms in each molecule are oxygen. Air is a mixture because its nitrogen, oxygen and argon are mixed, not joined to each other, and the coin because its copper and nickel atoms are mixed, not joined in a fixed ratio. q-element water; q-mixture a mixture.
- Screen 2: H₂, O₂ and N₂ are molecules of elements, and H₂O, CO₂, CH₄, NH₃ and H₂O₂ are molecules of compounds. Water and hydrogen peroxide are two different compounds of hydrogen and oxygen. q-o2 a molecule of an element; q-holes each hydrogen atom fills one of the oxygen atom’s two holes.
- Screen 3: H₂O, CO₂, NH₃ and CH₄. Water keeps two hydrogen atoms to each oxygen atom however much there is, and the ratio in the mixture changes with the slider. The 20 cent coin is 25% nickel. q-sub one nitrogen atom and three hydrogen atoms; q-percent it is a mixture, and the amounts in a mixture can vary.
- Screen 4: salt water is a solution (the beam can’t be seen in it, and nothing settles), milky water is a colloid (the beam shows up, and nothing settles), and muddy water is a suspension (it is cloudy, and it settles), and all three go under mixtures in the tree. q-tyndall a colloid; q-settle muddy water.
- Screen 5: only the two 3D models show the shape, and only the space-filling model shows the relative sizes. Methane’s structural formula is drawn flat, but its 3D models are tetrahedral. q-3d ball-and-stick and space-filling models; q-sizes a space-filling model.
- Screen 6: magnesium goes under beryllium, starting a new row; arsenic goes under phosphorus, leaving two gaps; tellurium goes under selenium and iodine under bromine. The best prediction is about 72, between zinc and arsenic; Mendeleev predicted 72 in 1871, and germanium’s atomic weight is 72.63. Today’s table is in order of atomic number, so tellurium (52) comes before iodine (53), zinc and cadmium move to group 12, and the noble gases make a new column. q-gaps he thought those elements had not been discovered yet; q-order atomic number.
- Screen 7: six of the ten substances are elements today, and the other four are not: light and caloric are not matter, and magnesia and silex are compounds. Azote is nitrogen. Dalton’s water is HO, and today’s formula is H₂O. q-atomos indivisible; q-dalton they are all one type, with their own mass.
- The printable: the drawings vary. Oxygen gas has pairs of joined oxygen atoms, water has molecules of one oxygen atom and two hydrogen atoms, carbon dioxide has molecules of one carbon atom and two oxygen atoms, air has separate molecules of nitrogen and oxygen with a few argon atoms, copper has one type of atom packed closely, and the coin has copper and nickel atoms mixed. In the torch test the beam shows up in the milky water but not in the plain water.
Saved progress
Answers, notes, results tables and settings are saved only in this browser on this device. Nothing is sent anywhere. If students share devices, clear the saved answers between them.
Sources by screen
- Screen 1: Oak National Academy, Atoms, elements and compounds (Key Stage 4), Compounds and their formation, Compounds (teacher lesson page), Separating mixtures (Key Stage 4) and Alloys and their properties; OpenStax, Chemistry 2e (diatomic molecules); Chemguide, Group 0, the noble gases, and Metal structures; NOAA, The Atmosphere; the Royal Australian Mint, About our coins; NIST (cupronickel by mass); CIAAW (atomic weights); the University of Sydney, School of Chemistry, and the University of Wisconsin-Madison, Formulas (sodium chloride).
- Screen 2: Northern Arizona University, Molecular models; OpenStax, Chemistry 2e (formulas and the colours of models); Mississippi State University and the University of Wisconsin-Madison (hydrogen peroxide); Oak National Academy, Chemical formulae (the same elements in a different ratio); Gonzaga University, Molecular structure; the Royal Society of Chemistry, Reasons to craft your own molecular models.
- Screen 3: Oak National Academy, Chemical formulae and Atoms, elements and compounds (Key Stage 4); OpenStax, Chemistry 2e; Berzelius (1813 and 1814), at Le Moyne College; the Linda Hall Library, Jakob Berzelius (1813 and 1814); Britannica, Chemical symbol; NOAA; the Royal Australian Mint; NIST; CIAAW.
- Screen 4: OpenStax, Chemistry, Colloids, and Chemistry 2e, The dissolution process; the Royal Society of Chemistry, Tyndall effect: why the sky is blue; the University of Sydney, School of Chemistry (ions in seawater).
- Screen 5: OpenStax, Chemistry 2e (formulas, structural formulas and models); Gonzaga University, Molecular structure; Oak National Academy, Atoms, elements and compounds (a common language).
- Screen 6: the Royal Society of Chemistry, Development of the periodic table, Germanium, Zinc and The periodic tables of Mendeleev; OpenStax, Chemistry 2e, The periodic table; Britannica, When was the periodic table invented?; Mendeleev (1869) and (1871), at Le Moyne College; CIAAW, Abridged standard atomic weights.
- Screen 7: OpenStax, Chemistry, Early ideas in atomic theory; the Science History Institute, Robert Boyle and John Dalton; Boyle (1661), The Sceptical Chymist, at Le Moyne College; Lavoisier’s Traité élémentaire de chimie (1789), at the Smithsonian Libraries, and his Table of simple substances, at Le Moyne College; Frostburg State University, How did Lavoisier classify elements known in his time?; the Linda Hall Library, Jakob Berzelius (Dalton’s symbols).
- The method: Johnstone (2000); Ardac and Akaygun (2004, 2005).
- Students’ ideas: the Royal Society of Chemistry, Students’ ideas about the differences between elements, compounds and mixtures, Chemical misconceptions: elements, compounds and mixtures, and Reasons to craft your own molecular models; Oak National Academy’s lessons above.
- Safety: the Royal Society of Chemistry, Tyndall effect: why the sky is blue, Reasons to craft your own molecular models, and Dissolved substances in tap water and seawater; CLEAPSS, Student safety sheet 101: Laboratory rules; ASCIA, Examples of risk minimisation strategies for schools.
- Printable: the same sources as screens 1 and 4.